ipl-logo

Summary Of Fundamental Principle Of A Republic By Anna Howard Shaw

450 Words2 Pages

In the text sample of Anna Howard Shaw’s speech about women's suffrage, “The Fundamental Principle of a Republic” she highlights the importance of equality within a republic. Anna believes that if there is no equality amongst a republic, how can it be called a republic? Anna states,”Whenever the government says that a citizen, in order to vote, must be a resident of a community a certain length of time, and of the state a certain length of time and of the nation a certain length of time, that applies to all equally. There is no discrimination”(Lines 47-50). If there are rules established by a republic that are meant for all people, why can only a majority of the population vote? She additionally acknowledges that men and women can be very ignorant …show more content…

Anna attempts to understand how ignorant women prevent women from voting, yet ignorant men don’t prevent men from voting. If the rules of a republic are to be applied to all, why not this one? Anna uses irony to further prove her point that women should have the freedom to vote. In the second paragraph of the speech she states,”If a woman’s suffrage1 is wrong, it is a great wrong; if it is right, it is a profound and fundamental principle, and we all know, if we know what a Republic is, that it is the fundamental principle upon which a Republic must rise. Let us see where we are as a people; how we act here and what we think we are”(Lines 14-17). It is ironic how we called ourselves a republic at the time when we restricted most of our population from voting, knowing that a republic is a primary power that is sustained by the people and the electors that they voted for. Anna used this irony to construct her claim about women's

Show More
Related

Angela Grimke's Bearing Witness Against Slavery

1510 Words | 7 Pages

Because of sexist opinions of the time, many people believed that a woman had no power to create change, especially in government since she could not vote. Women themselves believed this societal expectation, and although Grimke does not reject society’s idea of femininity and womanhood entirely, she specifically rejects their supposed political incompetence in a rebuttal. Using evidence from general and specific political movements in England, all of which were greatly aided by the support of women petitioning the government, Grimke assured her audience that “When the women of these States send up to Congress such a petition our legislators will arise, as did those of England, and say: ‘When all the maids and matrons of the land are knocking at our doors we must legislate.’” (Grimke, 192) This summary of her somewhat vague past points is similarly nonspecific; however, this is still effective since simply alluding to historical events rather than explaining them was sufficient for an audience that knew more about England and its history than contemporary Americans do today.

Read More

Carrie Chapman Catt Thesis Statement

164 Words | 1 Pages

In addition she points out that half of the country has already granted suffrage to women. Lastly, she feels women have the right because of “American principles” (Chapman, 1917). American is known as a political leader to other countries, yet they have yet to give women rights. Even though she is a woman, she does a great job of articulating the facts.

Read More

Elizabeth Macdonald's Role In Canadian Politics

1219 Words | 5 Pages

Historically, women have been excluded from political institutions and they remain the group with the most marked inequality between demographic weight and representation on decision-making bodies. While it is correct to argue that women have been and continue to be excluded from political institutions, it is less valid to assume that they have refrained from political

Read More

How Did Susan B Anthony Get The Right To Vote

470 Words | 2 Pages

The rights that all citizens have were ensured by the constitution and therefore they cannot be denied by a law pass by the state. Anthony assured that a law that takes away women’s rights to vote because of their gender is a “violation to the supreme law of the land” (19). If their rights were to be revoke half of the country would become superior to the other causing the rights of liberty and equality to disappear. Denying the rights of a woman based on her gender makes the country less of a democracy and more of an aristocracy (Anthony 19). The country was built upon equality for all but if women were not included than equality would never be

Read More

The Fundamental Principle Of A Republic Summary

807 Words | 4 Pages

She states that men and women are equal and should have the same rights and should not be treated differently than each other. This quote by Anna from the speech backs this point up, “Now I want to make this proposition, and I believe every man will accept it. Of course, he will if he is intelligent. Whenever a Republic prescribes the qualifications as applying equally to all the citizens of the Republic, when the Republic says in order to vote, a citizen must be twenty-one years of age, it applies to all alike, there is no discrimination against any race or sex”. (Shaw,4)

Read More

Summary Of Address To Congress On Women's Suffrage By Carrie Chapman Catt

387 Words | 2 Pages

A Suffragette, Carrie Chapman Catt, wrote a speech called “Address to Congress on Women’s Suffrage” which argues for women's right to vote. Catt supports their thesis through explanation of America’s History, explanation of the inevitability of women’s suffrage, and stating how America has already supported women’s suffrage in some states. The author speaks in order to pursue her purpose of allowing women the right to vote. The author speaks to an audience of fellow women, those who believe in the suffrage of women, because she sympathizes with them. Catt applies logos to aid in persuading the audience as to why women deserve the right to vote.

Read More

Anna Howard Shaw's Speech

420 Words | 2 Pages

She does not find it fair that only men are given the right opportunity to vote. Shaw’s tone is persuasive when she gives the definition of a republic to prove

Read More

Susan B Anthony Women's Right To Suffrage Rhetorical Analysis

1200 Words | 5 Pages

She cites the fact that women make up half of the population, and that they are responsible for much of the nation's work and education. Despite this, she notes, women are excluded from the political process and denied a say in matters that directly affect their lives. By using these statistics, Susan B. Anthony effectively demonstrates the illogical and unjust nature of women's disenfranchisement and creates a compelling case for suffrage. Furthermore, Susan B.

Read More

Anna Shaw On Women's Rights

2556 Words | 11 Pages

In Anna Howard Shaw 's speech to the suffragists and anti-suffragists of America, she is easily identifiable as a skilled orator and it makes sense that Susan B. Anthony sought her out. She easily handles the bias against anything she says as a woman by dissecting opposing arguments and pointing out their flaws. Her use of clean cut logic and ability to sway a crowd enabled her to create the persona of a man in the eyes of anti-suffragists. Through her speech at New York and its recanting at other locations in the U.S., her efforts and the efforts of others were not in vain when women gained the right to vote in 1920, five years after her speech. The main factors that contribute to this goal were her well thought out uses of ethos through emphasizing the most important or thought provoking point, and her establishing her credibility by proving her gender does not define her intelligence.

Read More

Susan B Anthony Persuasive Speech

1975 Words | 8 Pages

By using the countries’ own governmental document, Anthony masterfully poses, “In this very first paragraph of the declaration, is the assertion of the natural right of all to the ballot; for, how can “the consent of the governed” be given, if the right to vote be denied. Again: ‘That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute a new government, laying its foundations on such principles’” (Anthony par. 4-5). Women are citizens of the United States who are governed, yet they have no say in their government.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Susan B. Anthony's Speech

991 Words | 4 Pages

For a very long time, the voting rights of the citizens have been a problem in the US. It started out with only men with land being able to vote, and then expanded to white men, and then to all men. However, women were never in the situation, they were disregarded and believed to not be worthy enough to have the same rights as men. They were essentially being treated as property, therefore having no rights. But, in Susan B. Anthony’s speech, she hits upon the point that women are just as righteous as men.

Read More

Address To Congress On Women's Suffrage Speech Analysis

715 Words | 3 Pages

Carrie Chapman Catt uses a lot of ideas about democracy in her speech that was logical. Catt uses logic to appeal to her audience from the first reason of women suffrage inevitability to the end of the speech. Catt uses the Declaration of independence, which turn out to be the basic rule of government (Catt, 1917). This is because it states that all men (women) are created equal and Catt used that along with the quote from Woodrow Wilson that states “we are fighting for the things which we have always carried nearest to our hearts: for democracy, for the right of those who submit to authority to have a voice in their own government” (Catt, 1917). The logic in Wilson’s quote as it relates to women’s suffrage is if democracy is the right of those who submit to authority to have a voice in their own government than why do women not allow to vote because they too submit to authority as men do.

Read More

Susan B Anthony Women's Right To Vote Essay

632 Words | 3 Pages

How they couldn’t vote and how they didn’t have the rights that white men had. But throughout the whole speech, she is trying to convince people to start a big ordeal on how white men are not the only ones able to vote. In conclusion, the author is speaking to her fellow women and the to the wrong white men of the United States. Her purpose of making this speech is that woman have just as much right to vote as white men do.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Women's Rights To Suffrage By Susan B Anthony

1137 Words | 5 Pages

In her speech she continues to say, “And it is a downright mockery to talk to women of their enjoyment of the blessings of liberty while they are denied the use of the only means of securing them provided by this democratic-republic government -- the ballot.” (Anthony,1)

Read More

Susan B Anthony On Women's Right To Vote Analysis

814 Words | 4 Pages

Susan B. Anthony, a woman who was arrested for illegally voting in the president election of 1872, in her “On Women's Right to Vote” speech, argues that women deserve to be treated as citizens of America and be able to vote and have all the rights that white males in America have. She begins by introducing her purpose, then provides evidence of how women are citizens of America, not just males by using the preamble of the Constitution, then goes on about the how this problem has became a big problem and occurs in every home in the nation, and finally states that women deserve rights because the discrimination against them is not valid because the laws and constitutions give rights to every CITIZEN in America. Anthony purpose is to make the woman of America realize that the treatment and limitations that hold them back are not correct because they are citizens and they deserve to be treated like one. She adopts a expressive and confident tone to encourage and light the hearts of American woman. To make her speech effective, she incorporates ethos in her speech to support her claims and reasons.

Read More

More about Summary Of Fundamental Principle Of A Republic By Anna Howard Shaw

Open Document