ipl-logo

Summary Of Indomitable Will Lbj In The Presidency

713 Words3 Pages

The decision of Lyndon B Johnson in refusing to call his troops during the Vietnam war even though he certainly has the power to do so was really controversial. Different scholars have different opinions and theories on why president Johnson decided to let the war continued and escalated it. The two scholarly sources that will be evaluated and examined during this paper is Indomitable Will: LBJ In The Presidency by Mark K. Updegrove (2012) and Dereliction of Duty by H. R. McMaster (1997). The origin of Indomitable Will: LBJ In The Presidency is 2012 and its author Mark K. Updegrove is an historian, an American author and the Lyndon Baines Johnson library and museum director. The purpose of his book is to redefine Lyndon B Johnson’s personality …show more content…

R. McMaster is an American soldier and a career officer in the U.S army. The purpose of McMaster’s book is to analyze how and why the United States becomes involved in the Vietnam War. During this, the author also explains on what he thinks why the president decided to keep the war going instead and escalate it. McMaster came to a conclusion that Johnson made the mess himself and he chose to escalate the war. The author presents the war as a consequence of specific decisions made by specific men, Lyndon B. Johnson. McMaster also talked about how president Johnson believed that he would be able to control the U.S involvement in vietnam and part of that belief is based of of McNamara's confident assurance. (McMaster 333) Because of Lyndon B John secret decision made in Washington between November 1963 to July 1965, he got the United States deeper and deeper into the war. President Johnson also believed that it would be possible to preserve American credibility even if the U.S armed force withdrew from Vietnam (McMaster 332). He was totally wrong. “After the United States become committed to the war, however, more American soldiers, airmen,... had died in the conflict, it would become impossible simply to disengage and declare America’s credibility intact…” (McMaster 332). So in the end, LBJ couldn’t just recall his troops so he just followed his personal interests and escalated the war. The value of this book is that it is based on recently released transcripts and personal accounts of crucial meetings, confrontations and decisions. Dereliction of Duty is one of the few book that fully re-creates what happened and why it happened. The background of the author also enhances the value of this book ( H. R. McMaster served in the U.S military). The limits of this book is that it does not provide much information on why LBJ decided to escalate the war since this book is mainly about specific

Show More
Related

Summary Of No More Vietnam By Richard Milhous Nixon

528 Words | 3 Pages

The thesis that I took from his writing was that the we entered the war because allowing North Vietnam to obtain a communist victory would lead to massive human suffering for the people of Vietnam, damage American strategic interests and pose a threat to non-communist allies and friends. One interesting topic I learned from Nixon’s book was that he did not want to fully cut all ties with the Vietnam War even though he pushed for the policy to pull out our troops. He still wanted to support the South Vietnamese units because he thought we could still win the war. He then goes on to blame Congress for the loss of the war because they initiated a “total retreat from our commitments to the South Vietnamese people.” The book was great because it provided a lot of factually information through the lens of not just any historian or writer, but through the lens of America’s commander in-chief during the war’s most difficult stage.

Read More

How Did Lyndon Bailnes Johnson Impact The Vietnam War

642 Words | 3 Pages

Lyndon Baines Johnson, who reigned as president from 1963 to 1968 in the US, sparked a profound impact on the Vietnam War by escalating the involvement of the United States through The Gulf of Tonkin Resolution and implementing the controversial strategy of Operation Ranch Hand. As a result of the passing of the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, Johnson obtained the authority to utilise a range of defensive measures that he considered essential in promoting international peace and securing Southeast Asia. This discussion will encompass how the interaction between the measures that Johnson enforced and the logic surrounding them ultimately transformed the Vietnam War in 1955. Lyndon Baines Johnson significantly impacted the Vietnam War by utilising the Gulf of Tonkin

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Robert S. Mcnamara's Legacy

190 Words | 1 Pages

Robert S. McNamara’s legacy is undoubtedly how he redefined the Secretary of Defense's role in the White House, but I am interested in his thoughts on the war afterward. From my research, I have found that McNamara heavily regretted the Vietnam War as a whole. In his memoir, “In Retrospect”, he writes about how he believed the communist threat was truly not that large of a threat, and he questioned if Soviet and Chinese behavior would have been different if the United States had not ever been involved in the Vietnam War. He also pinpointed eleven different “failures” of the war, like how there was a failure to involve Congress and the American people in a pros-and-cons-Esque discussion of entering Vietnam. McNamara retained the idea of how

Read More

Dereliction Of Duty Summary

101 Words | 1 Pages

H.R. Mcmaster, author of Dereliction of Duty: Lyndon Johnson, Robert McNamara, The Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Lies That Led to Vietnam. McMaster explains who was responsible for the Vietnam war and why. H.R. McMaster wrote Dereliction of Duty to provide information to the public on what really happened during Vietnam, wanting others to know what the military leaders did. Also believing that if you go into the military you should know about previous issues and happenings that occurred to provide the best work. McMaster began digging deeper into the Vietnam war and the people behind it all in America.

Read More

American Reckoning The Vietnam War And Our National Identity Summary

657 Words | 3 Pages

“American Reckoning: The Vietnam War and our National Identity” is a book that takes us through 20 years of the War in Vietnam from about 1955 to 1975. The Vietnam War is the second longest war in US history encompassing 5 presidents which include Dwight D. Eisenhower, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Gerald Ford. Appy’s book gives a unique American perspective on incredible, horrifying, and inspiring stories in Vietnam as well as American. Through Apps book readers learn about different communism containment methods that America used. Readers also learn about different methods of attack on Vietnam from an American standpoint and how the different failures of the US army and US politicians turned many heads into hard truths about the war.

Read More

Essay On Johnson's Loss To The Vietnam War

706 Words | 3 Pages

Johnson’s Loss to the War Lyndon Johnson, as he was admitted to office, had a very strong idea about what he wanted his presidency to be like. He had to come after one of the nation’s most recognized presidents, and tried to retain that image in his own as a ploy in his political campaign. Plans to reshape the economy and revitalize it, make the domestic front more stable, and bring an end to most unemployment. The unfortunate case with his presidency though was that the Vietnam War had prevented any of his measures to improve America, and his decisions in it broke his future campaigns for office.

Read More

How Did President Johnson Influence The Vietnam War

177 Words | 1 Pages

President Johnson made the Vietnam War his own by manipulating information, and the media to get congress to help support him in fighting the war. He didn’t want to go to war with Vietnam, but he felt that if the U.S. did not help South Vietnam, it would be a failure on him to have let Vietnam become a communist country. He was determined to keep the North Vietnamese communists from taking control over the government of South Vietnam. He feared that if America did not do anything to help contain communism, that it would spread throughout the world. This was also known as the “Domino Theory,” in which President Johnson strongly believed in.

Read More

Summary Of The Great Silent Majority

1575 Words | 7 Pages

To illustrate, Nixon sent a message to those opposing America by stating,” If I conclude that increased enemy action jeopardizes our remaining forces in Vietnam, I shall not hesitate to take strong and effective measures to deal with that situation. This is not a threat. This is a statement of policy which as Commander-in-Chief of our armed forces I am making and meeting my responsibility for the protection of American fighting men wherever they may be '' (Nixon). This quote both delivers historical significance and perfectly exemplifies the leadership Nixon displayed, which caused the other nations and Americans to realize that the consequences of a precipitous withdrawal of American power would be devastating to the spirits of Americans in the long term. this specific quote demonstrates the dominance President Nixon showed to those who are supporting the Communist campaign of the North Vietnamese government.

Read More

Vandemark Secondary Sources

494 Words | 2 Pages

VanDeMark uses primary source and secondary sources to find information from Lyndon Bines Johnson library in Austin, Texas (VanDeMark, 1995). VanDeMark uses Vietnam documents, National Security File (NSF), Pentagon Papers, government publication, newspaper/ Periodicals, contemporary books. For the secondary sources, VanDeMark use Richard Dean Burns and Milton Leitenberg, The Wars in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos, 1945-1982: A Bibliographic Guide (Santa Barbara: ABC-Clio, 1983) and Richard Dean Burns, Guide to American Foreign Relations since 1700 (Santa Barbara: ABC- Clio, 1983) (VanDeMark, 1995). The author document the book well because he arranges the event in chronological order from the beginning to the end of the Vietnam War.

Read More

Lyndon B Johnson Political Courage

892 Words | 4 Pages

Johnson “suffered from a deep-rooted neediness, a desire to be liked by everyone, to outdo his predecessors, and to be known as the best president in American history.” To do so he used deception, charm and persuasion in order to gain support from the mass amounts of people with differing opinions. Achieving political consensus was something Johnson did well, utilizing his term as Senator to sharpen these skills. He always wanted the approval of his advisers and the American public, and he viewed criticisms of his policies as personal attacks which led him to double his resolve and intensify his efforts. A truly tenacious man Johnson’s modest

Read More

Lyndon B Johnson's Issues In The 1960 Essay

1511 Words | 7 Pages

The US first started getting involved with Vietnam in 1960 under President Truman to prevent communism taking over all of Vietnam and would not end its involvement until 1973 under President Nixon. In the beginning of his term, Johnson approved NSAM 273 “which directed the U.S. government to assist the people and Government of South Vietnam to win their contest against the externally directed and supported Communist conspiracy" and NSAM 288 which increased US involvement (Germany, “Lyndon B. Johnson”). Johnson officially authorized the US entering the Vietnam war in 1965 where “its legacy was 58,220 American soldiers dead, a huge drain on the nation’s finances, social polarisation and the tarnishing of the reputation of the United States” (White, “Why did Lyndon”). Towards the end of the term he reflected “I knew from the start that I was bound to be crucified either way I moved” saying that he was torn between leaving the Great Society or letting communism take over Vietnam (White, “ Why did Lyndon”).

Read More

Peter Braestrup's Big Story

1428 Words | 6 Pages

first report from Saigon, Cronkite told his audience that “first and simplest, the Viet Cong suffered a military defeat.” Walter Cronkite, declared that they could not see in all of this fighting any quick end to the burden of this war. Cronkite’s well known statement, concluded the feelings of the Vietnam War, “We have been too often disappointed by the optimism of the American leaders, both in Vietnam and Washington, to have faith any longer in the silver linings they find in the darkest clouds… For it seems now more certain than ever that the bloody experience in Vietnam is to end in stalemate. Today that we are mired in stalemate seems the only realistic, yet unsatisfactory, conclusion.”

Read More

Why Lyndon Johnson Won The Vietnam War

998 Words | 4 Pages

Johnson’s decision to escalate the situation was based on America’s initial understanding of the war, combined with poor war tactics and a terribly unreliable security counsel apparatus, which resulted in the

Read More

Lyndon Baines Johnson's Presidency

1200 Words | 5 Pages

In the beginning, historians focused on the Vietnam War and how that conflict derailed liberalism, tarnished the nation's reputation, and wasted lives. Each stage of his political climb was marked by the manifestation of pragmatism in politics in a democracy. (Caro 8) More recently, Johnson has been excoriated in more personal terms: as a player of political hardball, as the product of machine-style corruption, as an opportunist, as a cruel husband and boss. Johnson was a man possessed by inner demons. From early in his childhood he manifested character traits that shaped his behavior throughout his life.

Read More

Was Martin Luther King Jr Justified In The Vietnam War

2107 Words | 9 Pages

Section One: Identification and Evaluation of Sources The topic of this investigation is: To what extent was Martin Luther King Junior justified in his disapproval of the Vietnam War? The first source that was critical to this investigation was “A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin Luther King Jr,” It contained All of the speeches and some other writing that were written by Martin Luther King Jr. who was arguably one of the most famous Civil Rights Leaders in the 60’s. His peaceful work against racial prejudice in the United States earned him the Nobel Peace Prize in October 1964. He worked as Civil Rights Leader and humanitarian until he was assassinated on April 4th 1968.

Read More

More about Summary Of Indomitable Will Lbj In The Presidency

Open Document