ipl-logo

Summary Of Love Medicine By Louise Erdrich

1869 Words8 Pages

In Love Medicine Louise Erdrich shows the efforts of assimilation. Many characters tried assimilation, with varying degrees of success and failure. Assimilation could be considered another form of “nature vs. nurture.” In theory, assimilation sounds like a good idea, of lets all fit in together, but it has the condion of as long as you fit in with us. However, when forced, the results of assimilation are not optimal. Erdrich shows us that assimilation forced the parent’s choice and there was compliance but no character in Love Medicine truly assimiliated.
According to Michael Friscolanti, assimilation is, “If the Department of Indian Affairs came calling, parents had little choice but to surrender their children to residential schools. …show more content…

Lulu liked to live her life as she wanted, it was not the punishment that was a problem for Lulu it was the lack of personal freedom, or the ability to be herself. Erdrich shows that the school's attempts at disciplining Lulu were not sufficient, as she was constantly in the orange shame dress. Corporal punishment was not enough to force the assimilation of Lulu. Corporal punishment according to Stout is;
Corporal punishment was one commonly accepted method of discipline in American Child-rearing practice, which was transplanted into the governments Indian boarding schools. The educators did not know, and many did not care, that corporal punishment was never used to discipline Native American children in their various native cultures (93)
Native Americans were thought to be savages, and corporal punishment was believed to be a way to get the savage out of them. As in the case of Lulu's repeated incidences of running away, it could be thought of in two ways. She was either running away from the corporal punishment or, the corporal punishment had no effect on her. To point this out Chavkin says in his analysis of Erdrich, “Lulu’s repudiation of her government school values and her embracing the Pillager spirit also results in her rejection of a white goal oriented lifestyle” (Chavkin 98). Lulu shows that you can not force an idea on …show more content…

There is the underlying current that those years in boarding school may have contributed to his dementia when he got older. This shows that the childhood was forced out of him, and he stole it back as he aged. Eli, on the other hand, who was not sent to boarding school was taught by the “nature” route. Eli became one of the best hunters and fishermen, although he lacked the social skills to leave the reservation, and lived more like a recluse. Lulu fought assimilation the entire way; she was constantly in trouble at boarding school. The boarding school was unable to beat the savage out of her. There may have been good intentions with the idea of assimilation. When one is forced into something, it does not work. Assimilation required that they leave their heritage, and adapt. Adaptation in such an environment leaves out the facts of biology and nature. Again Erdrich shows the theory of assimilation in Love Medicine was to chose red, act white, and it offered no shades of pink. If the shades of pink were offered, then assimilation could have been successful. The attempts at assimilation in Love Medicine, even those that responded well such as Nector, no one truly assimilated or left the

Show More
Related
281 Words | 2 Pages

In "Love Medicine" by Lousie Erdrich, the main character Lipsha Morrissey tells a few different stories, also is trying to help his Grandpa find the faithfulness he once had with Grandma. During the story Lipsha learns a few different lessons. Lipsha learns two important lessons while in the slough. The first lesson Lipsha learns is to be grateful for life. Lipsha says to himself "Lipsha Morrissey, you're a happy S.O.B who could be covered up with weeds by now down at the bottom of this slough, but instead you're alive to tell the tale."

Read More
208 Words | 1 Pages

1. Pratt opposed reservations because Jefferson’s treaty agreement meant the Great River would be the border between them and the whites. Indians would be isolated and not a part of the American life. 2. Schools would “kill the Indian and save the man” by introducing them to the life of an American.

Read More
172 Words | 1 Pages

In “St. Lucy’s” and the Native Americans one and the other were forced into a new culture, but had no say in this event. In some cases Native American children were kidnapped and taken to boarding schools far away from their family 's. Likewise “St. Lucy 's” had basically the same issue as the Native American children people came and took them away to a new culture they did not particularly like. Presented to Brenda J. Child author of “Boarding School Seasons: American Indian Families, 1900-1940””American Indian children who often went to school quite a distance away from home, often suffered homesickness and their parents loneliness.”.similarly the girls were also homesick and desired to see their parents. Guy B. Senese claims that “Many

Read More
158 Words | 1 Pages

The students in “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls” nor the Native Americans had a choice to be forced out of their homes and assigned a new home, which resulted in learning a new language and to learn how to change their attitudes towards other people, how

Read More
1518 Words | 7 Pages

Theda Perdue`s Cherokee Women: Gender and Culture Change, 1700-1835, is a book that greatly depicts what life had been like for many Native Americans as they were under European Conquering. This book was published in 1998, Perdue was influenced by a Cherokee Stomp Dance in northeastern Oklahoma. She had admired the Cherokee society construction of gender which she used as the subject of this book. Though the title Cherokee Women infers that the book focuses on the lives of only Cherokee women, Perdue actually shines light upon the way women 's roles affected the Native cultures and Cherokee-American relations. In the book, there is a focus on the way that gender roles affected the way different tribes were run in the 1700 and 1800`s.

Read More
930 Words | 4 Pages

The Evolution of Lipsha Morrissey In the novel, Love Medicine, the reader gets to read about what it’s like to live a life as an Ojibwe Indian. The reader follows a family through the struggles of their everyday lives and witnesses how the individual characters develop through this story. Louise Erdrich created a character that’s development during these 60 years stood out significantly, Lipsha Morrissey.

Read More
203 Words | 1 Pages

Many Native children were taken by forced from their families and were submitted for a long time into residential schools. It was

Read More
186 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout assimilation, there was a cultural barrier between the Indians and the teachers. At the core of this barrier was the idea that one culture was more civilized than the other. This idea can be seen in both Native American boarding schools and at St. Lucy’s. As stated in Sarah E. Stone’s dissertation, the teachers at Native American boarding schools were not “culturally familiar” (57) with the students and, as a result, treated them differently. Similarly, at St. Lucy’s the nuns saw the wolf girls as barbaric people and treated them accordingly.

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

How is your feeling when you are falling in love? Most of the people say “it is awesome” because they “fall in love with the most unexpected person at the most unexpected time.” How do show your love? Every person has his or her own ways to show his or her love; therefore, Erdrich’s character – Grandma Kashpaw in Love Medicine also has her own ways.

Read More
1246 Words | 5 Pages

Questioning Tradition Typically, the phrase higher power is associated with that of a god-like figure. When thought of as such, this power is not directly accessible to an individual character within a story. The phrase ‘higher power’, however, could be used to refer to many different forms of power. Throughout the short story, Love Medicine, by Louise Erdrich, higher power becomes a term associated with selected types of power.

Read More
714 Words | 3 Pages

The award winning novel Love Medicine by Louise Erdrich contains various viewpoints from Native Americans of the Chippewa tribe. Many of the stories in this book contain some sort of heartache or struggle due to an affair or some external source, but interestingly there is one relationship that is not strained in that way. Instead, it is the conflicting ideas of a mother-daughter relationship. Even though Zelda Kashpaw and her daughter Albertine Johnson at first seem to be a living dichotomy, they realize the need for each other. Zelda Kashpaw is a Chippewa and aligns herself to the traditions of her family and tribe, except for one major decision.

Read More
174 Words | 1 Pages

The Bureau of Indian Affairs removed tens of thousands of American Indian children from their homes in the late 19th and early 20th centuries to assimilate the youth into the dominant Euro-American culture. Although the schools provided education and vocational training, their primary intention was to deprive Indian children of their tribal culture, language, and appearance. There was a significant amount of abuse in the boarding schools with administrators, teachers, and staff often treating students harshly, including physical and sexual abuse and neglect. Moreover, children suffered serious illnesses and disease. Due to these harsh conditions many Indian youth returned home with mental and physical health problems that transcended for

Read More
992 Words | 4 Pages

The Allotment and Assimilation Era brought about many policies to make Native Americans act “americanized.” Two extremely impactful policies were boarding schools and the allotting of American Indian land. These both affected Native Americans and their culture by splitting up families and tribes and forcing them to assimilate into American culture. Although both policies are extremely devastating for their culture, allotment and boarding schools had slightly different impacts and legacies on the culture. Allotment had a bigger impact on Native American communities at the time, whereas boarding schools had a more significant lasting legacy.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

Captivity is defined as the state of being imprisoned or confined. A tragic experience is given a whole new perspective from Louise Erdrich 's poem, “Captivity”. Through descriptive imagery and a melancholic tone, we can see the poem and theme develop in her words. Erdrich takes a quote from Mary Rowlandson’s narrative about her imprisonment by the Native Americans and her response to this brings readers a different story based off of the epigraph. Louise Erdrich compiles various literary devices to convey her theme of sympathy, and her poem “Captivity” through specific and descriptive language brings a whole new meaning to Mary Rowlandson’s narrative.

Read More
1142 Words | 5 Pages

In different instances, this would come up in conversations and the reactions were for the majority “that’s awful” or “poor thing” or “I can’t understand how anyone could do such a thing” and I never fully understood why. My mother was raised with an abusive father and a compromising mother (who too was dealing with the abuse), so I have seen how a negative experience can have a positive impact/result (message) on a person/child. I have now grown a curiosity to understand the different limits of child abuse and believe what my parents did benefitted me and any other children who received this discipline. With that in mind, I am going to define, and explore different aspects of child abuse with some modern examples.     Some people believe that physical punishments can be degrading and negatively affect the mental health of the child compared to those who think it teaches discipline and how to respect others without any significant damage to the child 's psyche.

Read More

More about Summary Of Love Medicine By Louise Erdrich

Related Topics

Open Document