ipl-logo

Summary Of Smart's Identity Theory Of Mind

857 Words4 Pages

In this essay, I will offer a summary of Smart’s epistemological and logical objections to his identity theory of the mind. Further, I will argue that one of his objections is successful while the other is not.
Firstly, I will consider Smart’s epistemological objection from ignorance to the identity theory of mind. The argument goes as follows: Smart argues that sensations which are the mental states are not equivalent to brain processes. A lot can be known about sensations while being ignorant about the brain processes involved. He says ‘… the publicly observable physical object lightning is in fact the electrical discharge, not just a correlate of it.’ Regarding the sense-datum, he says ‘it is a brain state caused by the lightning.’ Smart …show more content…

The argument goes as follows: Smart argues that the after-image is not a brain process. Rather, he identifies the state, experiencing an after-image which is orangish with some brain process. He says, ‘the after-image is yellowy-orange but that surgeon looking into your brain would see nothing yellow-orange’. In this quotation, Smart asserts that after-image and brain process are not the same. This is important because it indicates that his argument on the mental state being not equivalent to the brain state relies on the fact that the brain process cannot be yellowy-orange like how the after-image appears. Thus, Smart argues that, ‘the after-image is not a brain process’.
Now I will analyze Smart’s logical objection. I believe that it is certainly possible to conceive of the after-image is actually a brain process, whereby the brain cells are working on a part of the brain, generating signals. For example, there is, I think, the eyes capture the image, which is translated into signals that are sent to the brain, causing the brain cells to work and generate the signals which are transformed into the after-image that is yellowish

Show More
Related

Comparing The Diving Patterns Of Transient And Resident Killer Whales

463 Words | 2 Pages

The two graphs shows the diving patterns of transient and resident killer whales within a three hour range after midnight. It also shows the depth of the ocean where the certain killer whale is traveling to. I believe that graph A represents resident killer whales and graph B represents transient killer whales. In graph A, the average bottom depth is from 75 to 125 meters, except for one spike at a shallow depth of around 35 meters.

Read More

Allen And Parnes's Shattered

1389 Words | 6 Pages

The book “SHATTERED” is about Hillary’s presidency campaign and the authors (Allen & Parnes) take note of that she saw herself, from the earliest starting point, as almost unsurpassable, even as she still could not seem to authoritatively run. She thought, they compose, that she had a meet with fate, and that her triumphant was practically foreordained. This state of mind, suggest the authors, would torment Hillary appropriate to the end. This is the sense in which this book “SHATTERED” is an account of brain science - the brain research of the decision class, which is exactly what the inevitable champ of the general race railed against for quite a long time.

Read More

David Fallows Ethos Pathos Logos

536 Words | 3 Pages

The effect states that “the more limited someone is in reality, the more talented the person imagines himself to be.” Fallows had previously revealed the vainness embedded in Trump’s public twitter post, and so the Dunning-Kruger effect is utilized to logically prove that Trump has limited intelligence. By associating scientific knowledge in the argument, Fallows appeals to logos, providing firm evidence to the audience that clearly explains why Trump isn’t smart. Fallows also describes Trump’s twitter post as a “flamboyant illustration of a dangerous misperception.” With the reference to the effect, the author additionally displays that Trump is self-deluding himself because his tweet is “flamboyant” and is a “misperception” that contains “self-inflated assessments.”

Read More

Comparing Christian Philosopher 'Richard Swinburne And Tim O' Connor

515 Words | 3 Pages

In this two Christian philosophers, Richard Swinburne and Tim O'Connor, discussed the concept of neuroscience and the soul. The first philosopher, Swinburne, believed in the idea of substance dualism while O’Conner supported the argument for emergent individualism. Swinburne starts off by saying one’s physical body is simply the vehicle we interact with the world while the real essence of a person lies within their soul. When it comes to Swinburne’s belief on the soul after death I am reminded of Phaedo and how death will only bring about separation of body and soul.

Read More

An Analysis Of James Elkins's 'How To Look At Nothing'

760 Words | 4 Pages

The passage first talks about the proper conditions needed to experience the effects and phenomenons described. The author then goes on to briefly explain some malfunctions in our brains and says, “Those are ‘false positives,’ reports that there is light when there isn’t. We see light when we shouldn’t and we fail to see light when, by the

Read More

Gertler's Argument Defends Naturalistic Dualism

524 Words | 3 Pages

Gertler’s argument defends naturalistic dualism. Naturalistic dualism is the idea that the mental state is existentially separate from the physical state. Dualism’s opposing ideology is physicalism. Physicalism is the idea that the mental and physical state are one in the same. Through this she rejects the identity theory which claims that mental states are ultimately identical to states of the brain and/or central nervous system.

Read More

Elijah And David Analysis

740 Words | 3 Pages

Thus, David exists because of Elijah, and therefore, the brains are

Read More

John Searle's The Chinese Room Argument

1040 Words | 5 Pages

The Chinese Room Argument was a thought experiment presented by an American philosopher by the name of John Searle. The Chinese room argument is a concept that refutes the idea of a strong artificial intelligence also known as Strong Al. Strong Ai is “the view that an appropriately programmed digital computer capable of passing the Turing test would thereby have mental states and a mind in the same sense in which human beings have mental states and a mind” (Searle, 2005). However the opposing view of weak Al is distinguished by the view that the computer is a useful tool in studying the mind, just as it is a useful tool in other disciplines ranging from molecular biology to weather prediction. In the following essay I will explain in detail

Read More

John Locke's Direct Memory View Of Personal Identity

1276 Words | 6 Pages

However, based on Locke’s direct memory view of personal identity, the general is not the same person as the boy, because the general cannot remember himself as the boy. Therefore, the general is and is not the same person as the boy at the same time. This is a manifest contradiction that results from Locke’s direct memory view of personal identity. I will present an indirect memory view of personal identity that is more align with our intuitions that does not result in a

Read More

Serial Killers: Nurture Vs. Nature

1273 Words | 6 Pages

Studies showed that there are many different things that happen after the prefrontal cortex is damaged at different conceptual levels (Raine 67). Due to the reduced prefrontal functioning, results show a lack of control

Read More

Ego Theory And Bundle Theory: Ego Theory Vs. Bundle Theory

1423 Words | 6 Pages

The argument of whether or not a human has a soul has been argued throughout centuries. Derek Parfit discusses two separate theories of personal identity, Ego Theory and Bundle Theory. The argument of which present a more accurate account of personhood is very hard to determine. The Ego Theory has some flaws such the soul is separate from the body and is a immaterialist object within us. Bundle Theory is reinforced and proven by the split-brain case, however it can lead to the argument that there is no self.

Read More

Derek Parfit's Theory Of Personal Identity

1354 Words | 6 Pages

He has three fundamental arguments; 1. He rejects both the physical and soul theories of the self. 2. He asserts that personal identity is not what matters for the survival of the self. 3.

Read More

Descartes Sixth Meditation Analysis

1919 Words | 8 Pages

Conclusion: The mind is substantively different from the body and indeed matter in general. Because in this conception the mind is substantively distinct from the body it becomes plausible for us to doubt the intuitive connection between mind and body. Indeed there are many aspects of the external world that do not appear to have minds and yet appear none the less real in spite of this for example mountains, sticks or lamps, given this we can begin to rationalize that perhaps minds can exist without bodies, and we only lack the capacity to perceive them.

Read More

Descartes Mind Body Dualism Summary

1104 Words | 5 Pages

It embodies the insight that there is a serious muddle at the centre of the whole of Descartes theory of knowledge. He says that we do not hold a clear idea of the mind to make out much. ‘He thinks that although we have knowledge through the idea of body, we know the mind “only through consciousness, and because of this, our knowledge of it is imperfect” (3–2.7, OCM 1:451; LO 237). Knowledge through ideas is superior because it involves direct access to the “blueprints” for creation in the divine understanding, whereas in consciousness we are employing our own weak cognitive resources that

Read More

Behaviourist Theory Vs Identity Theory

1104 Words | 5 Pages

In this essay I will be comparing the identity theory to the behaviorist’s theory. Both theories are similar in the sense that they are of the monists (physicalism) view but they do vary in many other ways that I will point out in the duration of my essay. I do believe that the behaviorist theory is the better argument for reasons I will outline in this essay. The identity theory The identity theory refers to the understanding that the mind and the brain are identical.

Read More

More about Summary Of Smart's Identity Theory Of Mind

Related Topics

Open Document