ipl-logo

Summary Parting At The Crossroads The Development Of Health Insurance In Canada

1050 Words5 Pages

The United States and Canada have similar welfare states, meaning their objective is to promote and protect the economic and social well-being of their citizens. As well, health care was the same until 1940 (Maioni, 1997). The article “Parting at the Crossroads: The Development of Health Insurance in Canada and the United States 1940 -1965” by Antonia Maioni, explains how, in these two countries, health insurance was implemented and why it became divergent over time. The one assumption that could explain this was a social democratic third party that started as Cooperative Commonwealth Federation (CCF) in Canada in 1932. It was form by independent labour representatives in the House of Commons. The CCF formed in postwar and proposed universal …show more content…

As we know, after the 1940s, the two countries developed different health care systems. In the article, Maioni argues that completely different health care systems caused by diverse political systems in these two countries. The major point that the author makes to support her arguments was impact of the third party. The third party could only form in Canada, but not in the United States. This can be explained by the following two reasons. First, the rules of parliamentary government in Canada give the right for the formation of a third party and give it potency. Second, federalism in Canada is decentralized which means a lack of equal representatives who could represent regions and provinces at the federal level. Therefore, provinces have more liberty and more authority that could lead to the formation of the third party. In contrast, the United States third party has less independence because of the complicated rules of the committee system and control by two antagonistic parties (Maioni, 1997). Therefore, due to these facts, two different health policies were developed as universal health insurance in Canada, and private health insurance in the United …show more content…

To me, the most important message is that governments should make changes in health care reform based on an average person’s needs and health, and not just to satisfy politicians. This is the difference between the United States and Canada health care insurance plans. It is connected to the idea of the third party. This was the key idea in the article. The third party played a huge role in implementing universal health care insurance in Canada. In contrast, in the United States, a third party had potential to form, who supported the idea of the universal health insurance in the first place. Nevertheless, due to the limitation of other parties, it subsequently merged with Democratic Party and was obliged to adhere the party’s agenda. Therefore, the United States had a chance to implement better universal health insurance than in Canada, but the antagonistic parties denied it in

Show More
Related
826 Words | 4 Pages

Thomas Clement “Tommy” Douglas (20 October 1904 – 24 February 1986) known as “The Father of Medicare”, had done extraordinary work to make Canada a unique country. The problems he faced with short term helped to greatly benefit Canadians in the long term. The experience Douglas had from when he was a child to when he finishes his studies, influenced him to join politics and help millions of Canadians. In 1944, Tommy Douglas became the premier of Saskatchewan and helped raise Canada’s reputation in front of the whole world by introducing new laws and regulations. Tommy Douglas’s own childhood experience led him to join politics and help millions of Canadians by introducing Medicare system in Canada.

Read More
1127 Words | 5 Pages

Both Pennington and Baker deal with the issues surrounding Canadian trade agreements with the United States during the latter half of the nineteenth century and early twentieth century. However Pennington and Baker take vastly different viewpoints on the issue. Whereas Pennington takes the view that Laurier's Liberals were hoping for some sort of moderate trade agreement with the United States and support for a commercial Union, Baker deals with reciprocity and its ties to anti-Americanism. In addition, both authors tend to imply that the greater underlying question resulted into which economic orbit Canada would tie itself. MacDonald's Conservatives favouring to maintain the traditional economic alignment to Great Britain while the Liberals

Read More
1626 Words | 7 Pages

Canada’s economy has undergone continuous changes throughout the years. Many of these developments include newly established acts, economical, and political reforms; the core of what has shaped the country into what it is today. More prominently, since the 1950s, Canada’s identity as a nation is stronger and more defined due to many of these growths. One can clearly see this from the following examples; the welfare state, the St. Lawrence Seaway, and NAFTA.

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

“Courage, my friends; ’tis not too late to build a better world. ”-Tommy Douglas or better known as the Father of Medicare. Douglas won “The Greatest Canadian of all Time” on April 5th, 2004. This man has certainly brought many benefits to all Canadians. Universal Healthcare started with a belief that every Canadian deserves free healthcare regardless of their economic or social status.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Motivated by the difficulties he saw, and consistent with his religious beliefs, “eventually he came to believe that he could do more for people from a political platform than from a pulpit.” (Weyburn Review) And so began his journey into political life, and the influencing of Canadian Government(s) arguably for the good of the whole Canadian society. Well known for his main achievements, and while ‘he was at times labelled a “Red” and a “Communist” by his political opponents — he won honour largely for his belief that every Canadian deserved the right to have quality health care, regardless of their economic or social situation… and so is frequently called “father of universal healthcare”’

Read More
926 Words | 4 Pages

Have you ever been sick, or so they particularly thought. The chances mostly are that you have in a kind of major way. Medical care particularly is very expensive; a checkup could cost hundreds of dollars, which actually is fairly significant. If it for the most part was not for Tommy Douglas and his idea of free universal health care, it mostly is pretty possible that pretty many people would actually be fairly bankrupt or very ill; he for the most part had also re-organized the for all intents and purposes public-school system and made fluctuations to very social welfare in a particularly big way. Although overlooked, Tommy Douglas definitely has evolved Canada as a nation and actually has really had an important effect on the lives of pretty

Read More
940 Words | 4 Pages

Ever wonder why you have free health care? Well Tommy Douglas is the answer. In this speech I’m going to tell you about his childhood, what lead him to be named the greatest Canadian in CBC poll, The Greatest Canadian of all time by voters across Canada and the Father of Medicare, his achievements and failures and some of his other jobs and the education he needed. Firstly, his childhood was very normal.

Read More
1074 Words | 5 Pages

“Saskatchewan’s favourite politician, ‘father of the Medicare’ Tommy Douglas, is among 11 Canadians who were recently inducted into the Canadian Medical Hall of Fame”(Wharry,1998,p.211). Tommy Douglas, who was known for his creation of Medicare, devoted himself into creating a promising future for Canada. There is no doubt that he is the greatest Canadian. Michael Shevell stated in his article(2012) that Tommy Douglas was born in Scotland in 1904.

Read More
832 Words | 4 Pages

The one major difference between the Canadian health care system and the American health care system is that is that they have a privatized health care system. A documentary such as “Sicko directed by Michael Moore” demonstrates the crisis of American citizens without health care coverage. Canada’s universal health care system ensures those who cannot pay for health to not suffer, contrary to the Sicko

Read More
693 Words | 3 Pages

The nature of the current debate surrounding the implementation of universal healthcare in America is troubling because it is comprised almost entirely of pragmatic arguments void of concern for the principles behind the project. Before one asks how much a thing will cost, how it will be organized, or whether “the uninsured” will benefit, one should ask whether enacting universal healthcare is in keeping with the values and principles of the American experiment. In other words, is universal healthcare good for America? Universal healthcare is not good for America.

Read More
741 Words | 3 Pages

The real debate is how can we accomplish the goal of universal healthcare in the most affordable and sustainable way. The United States is evaluated as a wealthy country, yet there are more penurious countries who provide health maintenance, paid through higher taxes. “In the United Kingdom and other European countries, payroll taxes average 37% - much higher than the 15.3% payroll taxes paid by the average US worker” (Gregory). With this data, the only reform would be to end the private health insurance companies of dominant health services, and incorporate a single payer system. Conversely, it is factual that taxes will rise, but the implementation of universal healthcare will better the health of American citizens.

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Canada enjoys the benefits of a “universal” insurance plan funded by the federal government. The idea of having a publicly administered, accessible hospital and medical services with comprehensive coverage, universality and portability has its own complex history, more so, than the many challenges in trying to accommodate the responsibility of a shared-cost agreement between federal and provincial governments. (Tiedemann, 2008) Canada’s health care system has gone through many reforms, always with the intent to deliver the most adequate health care to Canadians. The British North American Act, Hospital Insurance and Diagnostic Services Act, Saskatchewan’s Medical Care Act, and the Canada Health Act are four Acts that have played an important

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

Social Welfare Policy and Child Protection – Strength and Limitations Since last two decades Canada being experienced softer and harder forms of neo-liberal economic impetus (McKeen, 2006). Many of these reforms targeted social benefits and divided marginalized people into deserved and undeserved category (McKeen, 2006). At a large level, social policies are shaped by the exploration of dominant ideas about a social issue. Existing political views and the interest of the dominant policy community are predominantly influencing policy making (McKeen, 2006). The mainstream discourses for solutions of social problems and policy outcomes are increasingly underrepresented and narrow down the focus of social welfare in Canada (McKeen, 2006).

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

Health care should not be considered a political argument in America; it is a matter of basic human rights. Something that many people seem to forget is that the US is the only industrialized western nation that lacks a universal health care system. The National Health Care Disparities Report, as well as author and health care worker Nicholas Conley and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), strongly suggest that the US needs a universal health care system. The most secure solution for many problems in America, such as wasted spending on a flawed non-universal health care system and 46.8 million Americans being uninsured, is to organize a national health care program in the US that covers all citizens for medical necessities.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

Health Care is a huge and important part of Canada and what it is. Canadian citizens all have access to Canada 's healthcare system known as `Medicare`. Medicare is managed by the federal government delivered through a publicly funded health care system, in cooperation with the 10 provinces and 3 territories. Under the health care system, individual citizens are provided preventative care and medical treatments from primary care physicians as well as access to hospitals, dental surgery, and additional medical services. With a few exceptions, all citizens qualify for health coverage regardless of medical history, personal income, or standard of living.

Read More

More about Summary Parting At The Crossroads The Development Of Health Insurance In Canada

Related Topics

Open Document