ipl-logo

Summary: The Differential Effect Of Numeracy

994 Words4 Pages

The Differential Effect of Numeracy and Anecdotes on the Perceived Fallibility of Forensic Science: An Analysis
Shelbey Bissot
Grand Canyon University: BIO-201L
Rakhad Alrawi
November 19, 2017

Abstract An article written by Nicholas Scurich examines how forensic science may not be as flawless as the general public has thought it to be. The research tested two theories for why jurors ignore the flaws of forensic science. The overall results showed that both theories did affect participants’ verdicts (Scurich, 2015, p. 616).
Hypothesis
In “The Differential Effect of Numeracy and Anecdotes on the Perceived Fallibility of Forensic Science” by Nicholas Scurich, there are two hypotheses. The first states that “jurors neglect laboratory …show more content…

Because of this, it is a common assumption that forensic science is infallible, or incapable of being incorrect. He states that this belief is a myth and shares evidence that forensic science was used in over half of exoneration cases. Currently, it is unknown how often forensic science techniques are incorrect, however studies from the 1980s and 1990s estimate the error rate to be anywhere from 1 in 100 to 1 in 1000 (Scurich, 2015, p. 617). However, in real life situations the error rates are likely to be higher because this study was performed under the most favorable conditions. Scurich then goes into detail on the ways a false-positive DNA match can occur. These situations include coincidence and laboratory error. Genetic profiles are not extremely unique and it is not impossible for multiple DNA profiles to match. Laboratory error could occur from cross contamination, mislabeling, or misinterpretation (Scurich, 2015, p. 617). How frequently these errors occur is referred to as the laboratory error rate. Research has shown that jurors disregard laboratory error rates when giving the verdict. The purpose of Scurich’s experiment is to find why jurors do not take the laboratory error rates into consideration when making a …show more content…

They were also asked to indicate how likely it was that the defendant committed the crime on a scale of 0-100% (Scurich, 2015, p. 619). Other questions concerning the case were also asked, such as how believable the prosecution’s case is, as well as how trustworthy the laboratory technician is. A reading comprehension question was asked to ensure the participants were paying attention to the details. Only the participants who answered the comprehension question correctly were included in the final data analysis. The participants were told that a sexual assault had occurred and a DNA sample had been extracted from the victim. The main suspect was a man who worked nearby the scene of the crime. He reluctantly gave a blood sample, and was charged with sexual assault. During the trial, a geneticist testified that the suspect’s genetic profile matched 1 in 200,000,000 Hispanics and admitted to a laboratory error rate of 1 in 10 or 1 in 100, depending on the test group (Scurich, 2015, p.

Show More
Related

Lindy Chamberlain Case Essay

978 Words | 4 Pages

The Azaria Chamberlain case is a reminder that the criminal justice system does get it wrong, with each error bearing its own human cost. Lindy Chamberlain’s conviction was based largely on the use of unreliable or improper forensic science during the

Read More

Second Trial Of Ronald Cotton V.

797 Words | 4 Pages

The samples from one victim were too deteriorated to be conclusive, but the samples from the other victim’s vaginal swab and underwear were subjected to PCR based DNA testing and it showed no match to Richard Cotton. At the request of the defense, the results were sent to the State Bureau of Investigation’s DNA database, containing the DNA patterns of convicted felons in North Carolina prisons. The DNA proved to be a match for the convict who earlier confessed that he was the one who actually committed the

Read More

Deconstructing The CSI Effect: Forensic Science And The Media

1731 Words | 7 Pages

Sometimes it’s difficult as well to have jurors who know about the case through social media so if they’ve seen similar cases on television or in reality they will quickly use that case to evaluate their verdict. At the same time this causes bias preconception throughout jurors mind during the case. According to two different sources, one believes that forensic technology is not the case of why jurors believe in forensic evidence, and the other believes is it true that jurors believe in forensic technology. According to Judge Donald Shelton, he says that these CSI Effect articles are primarily based off of lawyers opinions, they are not facts. The reason jurors expect carts aspects in courtrooms is because of the technology they carry in

Read More

Dale Woodall Double Rape Case

852 Words | 4 Pages

In 1996, Peter Neufeld the cofounder of the Innocence Project remarked that there is no rational as why crime laboratories, which habitually make decisions that have life and death outcome for an indicted individual, should be less managed than a clinical laboratory operating alike tests. In addition to this The NAS Report commented on the lack of standards for lab management and administration. For example, it argues that ‘There is no uniformity in the certification of forensic practitioners, or in the accreditation of crime laboratories. Indeed, most jurisdictions do not require forensic practitioners to be certified, and most forensic science disciplines have no mandatory certification programs. Moreover, accreditation of crime laboratories is not required in most jurisdictions.

Read More

Biases In The Cosby Case Steven T. O Neil

1737 Words | 7 Pages

The possible biases in jury decision-making will be discussed, including those related to having a celebrity on trial. In addition, this paper will examine the taboo nature of sexual assault cases, the problems that often arise in such cases, and the psychological toll on the victim. One issue with this case is the prosecution’s lack forensic evidence. In a “he said, she said” case that lacks the evidence that jurors expect in order to make their decision, it comes down to whether they believe the defendant or the prosecution. When DNA is not available, other types of physical evidence are examined (LaPorte, G., Nguyen, M., Schwarting, D., Scott, F., Waltke, H., Weiss, D., 2017).

Read More

Was Bennett Barbour An Innocent Or Inhumane?

1990 Words | 8 Pages

We know that DNA testing is giving hope to the hopeless in prison. Margret Berger (2006) comments, “Even though the number of inmates released as a consequence of DNA testing is minuscule in contrast to the two million persons incarcerated in the United States, the DNA exonerations have had an enormous impact on the fundamental assumptions about the American criminal justice system and how it operates.” Changes like the desirability of the death penalty, the growing concerns on how forensic laboratories operate alongside the increasing interest in forensic science overall. For instance, as the number of exonerations continues to rise, the number of people being placed on death row is decreasing thanks to Supreme Court rulings that juveniles under the age of 18 and the mentally ill cannot be sentenced to death. The death penalty is overall losing its appeal to society, not just because of the DNA testing, but people become aware of the wrongful convictions of other crimes as well.

Read More

The Case Of Timothy Cole

2295 Words | 10 Pages

The impact of Tim’s case was also felt on a national and even international level, as it shed light on the importance of using accurate and scientific evidence in the legal system and the need to reform the criminal justice system to prevent wrongful convictions. Tim’s story has inspired many other cases to be re-opened and re-examined, leading to the exoneration of several other innocent individuals. Overall, the case of Tim Cole has had a profound impact on the criminal justice system and has helped to bring about important changes in the use of DNA

Read More

United States V. Bonds: A Case Study

120 Words | 1 Pages

In the case of United States v. Bonds, 12 F.3d 540 (6th Cir. 1993), defendant John Ray Bonds was accused of killing a man during a late night shooting. The basis for his appeal was to suppress the DNA evidence because “at that time the FBI test results had not yet been published in a peer review journal explaining the FBI 's methods and offering data to support the results” (United States v. Bonds, 1993). The defendant also believed different methods for DNA analysis could have provided accurate results rather than a 1 in 35000 probability for the DNA match. The purpose of the case was to determine whether the court made a mistake in admitting DNA evidence in the trial.

Read More

Research Paper On The Central Park Five

2014 Words | 9 Pages

Every day people are wrongfully convicted and imprisoned due to untested/false DNA, misconduct

Read More

A Comprehensive Overview Of The Forensic Science Community And The Legal System

1502 Words | 7 Pages

Forensic practitioners must adhere to established protocols and quality assurance measures to ensure the credibility of their findings. Additionally, ongoing training and proficiency testing are essential for maintaining the competence of firearm examiners and upholding the integrity of forensic analysis. Forensic experts who conduct firearm examinations often testify in court as expert witnesses. Their testimony regarding the analysis, findings, and interpretation of firearm

Read More

Dna Fingerprinting Lab Report

1726 Words | 7 Pages

In the lab report three students are tested along with one suspect. Student number two’s DNA matched the suspects DNA. The student’s DNA’s are cut with five different enzymes as well as the suspects DNA. Student two’s DNA matched exactly with the suspects DNA; the other two student’s DNA did not resemble the suspects DNA at all. (Choi, et al, 2008) DNA fingerprinting is used a lot in determining who committed a crime.

Read More

Forensic Analysis: The Real CSI

819 Words | 4 Pages

The CSI effect is common among jurors and other people because they assume everything they see on tv shows like Law and Order and Criminal Minds is what really happens in real life cases. The juries who believe in this misconception can cause a problem in the courtroom because they would question why everything isn’t being subject to forensic analysis. Also some jurors may believe that forensic science is a perfect science thats always accurate however they ignoring the possibility of human or technical error. In the movie “The Real CSI”, it is stated that someone can be considered an expert based on knowledge, skill, experience, training or education, the real issue is that once a judge says they can testify they are considered and expert.

Read More

Examples Of Wrongful Conviction

969 Words | 4 Pages

Wrongful conviction has been an emerging and tremendous dilemma in our society since the discovery of DNA analysis. This is a very recent study that has presented another form of evidence that can prove an individual's innocence in ways never before. Forensic scientist collect DNA evidence and run tests to see if there is a match to DNA samples collected at the crime scenes. However, the justice system has not taken this new science into consideration because many influential individuals, such as judges, prosecutor, jurors, and attorneys, do not understand this new science. This leaves the burden to forensic scientist to explain DNA testing to representatives of the court system.

Read More

True Crime Research Paper

1469 Words | 6 Pages

The most obvious symptom of this effect is that jurors believe that they have enough knowledge of science they have

Read More

Examples Of Circumstantial Evidence

1033 Words | 5 Pages

Circumstantial evidence has proven to be powerful where there is little or no direct evidence, and is also more credible in relation to error rates of wrongfully convicted crimes. However, the use of

Read More

More about Summary: The Differential Effect Of Numeracy

Related Topics

Open Document