ipl-logo

Susan Sontag's 'Watching Suffering From A Distance'

1116 Words5 Pages

Susan Sontag’s “Watching Suffering From A Distance” discusses why people need to see photographs that contain disturbing imagery. According to Sontag, seeing such images is important to enhancing general awareness of the suffering of others. The failure to do so or to not acknowledge the unpleasant aspects of human nature is tantamount to ethical decay.
Her words are academic and her tone acerbic. The claims Sontag makes are supported on hearsay and vague statements. She insults those who do not agree with her and belittles them often. “Watching Suffering from a Distance” is fueled by bias, by passion and it still works, according to the author’s intentions.
Sontag’s arguments are sound enough, reasonably discussing the merits and drawbacks …show more content…

Sontag uses this metaphor, of Hell, to convey deep and continuous suffering, to draw the reader in. She uses a great deal of metaphor and exaggeration throughout, especially when it comes to detractors of her position. She calls their point of view “...this moral depravity...” (437) and repeatedly refers to them as childish, a reaction at odds from the logical and intellectual person she presents herself as. Later in the narrative, even as she is examining the reasons that people shy away from graphic images, she insinuates that people unwilling to confront such images are consumerist and unduly insular: “...an accusation of the indecency of regarding such images... flanked... by advertising for emollients... and SUVs” (439).
This ties into the larger emphasis on ethics and emotion that Sontag uses. While she seems to be basing her points in a learned sensibility, she appeals to emotion often. The aforementioned insults turn her own opinion into the moral high ground. Her vocabulary integrates terms such as ‘impugn’, ‘ethical’, ‘atrocity’, ‘accusation’, and ’superficiality’. If she is not attacking with her words, then she is being attacked by others. The essay that first seemed like a reasoned debate has been turned into a battlefield. The reader must be with her or against her; there is no middle

Show More
Related

Imagining The Post Antibiotics Future Summary

963 Words | 4 Pages

This happened only five years before the antibiotic that could have treated him and prevented his death came to be. In illustrating this story, she describes the event as one that “scarred his family with a grief they never recovered from.” (188) Through this story, as a reader, it is almost impossible not to imagine yourself in her shoes. That, along with the use of these very emotionally provoking words, she captures the audience from the beginning with this pathetic appeal that carries on throughout the essay. She goes on to appeal to logics as well.

Read More

Examples Of Irony In Fallen Angels

509 Words | 3 Pages

In the book Fallen Angels Walter Dean Myers tells the story of soldiers who struggles with a problem involving what is right and wrong in war. Fallen Angels set in Vietnam during the Vietnam war, the story introduces the main character Perry, who faces obstacles, including death and killing. The author’s use of literary devices, specifically imagery, irony, and metaphors convey the theme warfare often forces soldiers to reconsider their traditional notions of right and wrong. The author employs imagery to express the theme that warfare often forces soldiers to reconsider their traditional notions of right and wrong.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Photojournalism

1074 Words | 5 Pages

There are instances where these photographs cross an ethical boundary. Instances in which it becomes unclear whether they should tell the story. Sometimes described as disaster pornography, these photographs depict brutal moments of human suffering. Often with a level of objectivity that may seem callous or exploitative. These moments prompt the question: is this necessary to tell the story?

Read More

Donald Murray The Stranger In The Photo Is Me

304 Words | 2 Pages

Polizer Prize-winning journalist, Donald M. Murray, in his essay for The Boston Globe, “The Stranger in the Photo Is Me”, argues that innocence changes overtime through photos. He supports this claim by first alluding to an artist’s painting. Then he speaks on himself in third-person, and finally reflect on the loss of innocence. Murray’s purpose is to describe his experiences in order to inform people. He adopts a nostalgic tone for people over the age of sixty.

Read More

The War Photo No One Would Publish Summary

1503 Words | 7 Pages

Sometimes though, omitting an image means shielding the public from the messy, imprecise consequences of war- making the coverage incomplete and even deceptive.” (Daghett 2) This reflection shows that Daghett does not want graphic imagery to be shown merely for shock value, but rather that she believes it has an instrumental role in keeping the public informed and aware. While a noble thought, there are many questions that can be raised from this sentiment. For example, what would factor into determining what photos are necessary or unnecessary for the public to see?

Read More

Nora Ephron Boston Photographs Analysis

948 Words | 4 Pages

The picture of the dead bodies of the Syrians shows loved ones dealing with a particular tragic; photographers are invading privacy when they photographed dozens of dead bodies. Additionally, showing the world an image of people intensely bawling gives off a discourteous persona of the photographer to the mass audience. Similarly, a lot of people disagree with Ephron, and one point repeats continuously: “Invading the privacy of death” (731). Although this point is valid, it is also important to show people the exact portrayal of life to prevent similar situations in the future. The Boston photos, according to Ephron, does much more than show two people falling off a fire escape.

Read More

Maggie Nelson's 'Great To Watch'

1829 Words | 8 Pages

The American obsession with spectatorship is a phenomenon created by the inaccessibility of timely and relevant knowledge. This oddly leads to an increase in the demand and likeability of terror. In her piece “Great to Watch”, Maggie Nelson explores the origins of this fascination with horror and gives an

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Night By Elie Wiesel

759 Words | 4 Pages

Human suffering anywhere concerns men and women everywhere”. There is so much bad form and enduring, shouting out for attention victims of yearning, of racism and political abuse in Chile, for occasion, or in the occasion journalists and artists, prisoners in such a large number of terrains administered by the left and by the

Read More

All Quiet On The Western Front Dehumanization Analysis

834 Words | 4 Pages

The theme dehumanization can be seen in different types of forms for example novel, poetry, art, etc. I will be using the novel, All Quiet on the Western Front, poetry, The Rear-Guard and I will be using a painting, Bathers with a Turtle that was painted by Matisse in 1907. The dehumanizing art is mostly used to trigger familiar emotions and feelings, and this is really the abiding subject of the viewer’s delight. This art is used as a narcotic way that allows us to enjoy what we are most familiar with, our own emotions.

Read More

Gloria Steinem A Balance Between Nature And Nurture

408 Words | 2 Pages

In the essay “A Balance Between Nature and Nurture,” Gloria Steinem gives the audience an insight into her beliefs on this controversial topic. Gloria has a belief that both nature and nurture impact us throughout our lives. In her article she writes about how her parents thought that traveling was just as “enlightening as sitting in a classroom.” Beside her parents, Gloria saw the world through a different perspective compared to other kids her age. However, once she got to school things changed- she was exposed to gender obsessions, race and class complexities, and the idea that war and male leadership were part of human nature.

Read More

Living Like Weasels Analysis

880 Words | 4 Pages

Having your hair braided by local girls, exploring the forest, and seeing a tarantula are experiences that bring us closer to nature and lead us to desire simpler things. In Dillard’s next essay, The Deer at Providencia, she makes the point that suffering is unavoidable, we are all going to suffer at one point in our lives just as the man and the deer did. Pain is unavoidable, whether one is a human or an

Read More

Punctum In Dorothea Lange's Migrant Mother

754 Words | 4 Pages

As a photographer myself, the theory of punctum is not unknown to me; however, the application of the concept of punctum towards the perfomativity of a photograph is unchartered territory. The photograph I chose to analyze is Dorothea Lange’s renowned portrait Migrant Mother, which is a Great Depression-era photograph featuring a migrant farmer, and is among the most famous photographs from this turbulent chapter of American history. The raw emotion in the mother’s face, paired with her body language and grimy appearance, captivates viewers; however, it is not the mother that makes this image so powerful to me, but rather, the turned away children framing their mother. This detail adds a new dimension to the portrait for me.

Read More

Donald Murray The Stranger In The Photo Is Me Analysis

694 Words | 3 Pages

Professor, Pulitzer Prize-winning author, Donald M. Murray, in his article, “The Stranger in the Photo Is Me”, suggests that innocence cannot be regained once it is lost, and he supports this claim by first reflecting on who he was before the photograph. Then, he detaches himself from the photograph because of his personal development throughout the war he fought in, and finally concluding that one cannot regain innocence after something as traumatic as war. Murray’s purpose is to argue in order to prove that war changes a person, adopting a nostalgic tone for the elder, over sixty, generation that is his audience. Murray admits that he used to never care to look at photographs, an example of his past self, but now, he gives them “a second glance” even “a third” (8).

Read More

Nancy Mairs On Being A Cripple Essay

807 Words | 4 Pages

This quote shows that even though Mairs sometimes has difficulty accepting her illness, she knows that there is a growing acceptance of people who must deal with the difficulties that she faces. This ultimately lends a hopeful and positive tone to an otherwise serious and depressing section of her essay. This contrast in tone, but general feeling of hope is key to the type of emotions that Nancy Mairs is trying to educate her readers about. Mair is successful in using multiple rhetorical strategies to connect with the reader.

Read More

Similarities Between A Doll's House And Never Let Me Go

1565 Words | 7 Pages

To Suffer or Not to Suffer As human beings, we try to eschew from the suffering and adversities that plague human morality. Nonetheless, society remains drawn to the surplus of tragedies in plays, movies, and literary works. Not only do these works provide an escape from our own hardships, but suffering and tragedy is a significant aspect to the development of human society. Personally, I have experienced my own share of sorrow, trauma, and difficulties in life. While they may not be as severe as those faced by the characters in A Doll’s House and Never Let Me Go, a pervasive theme still manifests in the presence of suffering.

Read More

More about Susan Sontag's 'Watching Suffering From A Distance'

Related Topics

Open Document