ipl-logo

Technological Determinism Analysis

1187 Words5 Pages

Since the advent of stone tools 2.5 million years ago, technology has played a crucial role in the way humans interact with one another and with the world around them. In the modern academic landscape, many historians and philosophers have attempted to explain the significance technology has played throughout the course of history. This has led to the emergence of several differing theories; all of these competing ideas agree that technology has been an integral factor in shaping the current landscape, but there are many conflicting viewpoints concerning the degree to which technology directly impacted society. Most recent thinkers argue that technology was but one variable in a mix of social, economic and political motives that shaped the …show more content…

Thorstein Veblen (1857-1929) argued that the social and cultural values of a society are determined by its technology (https://www.communicationtheory.org). Determinism still has its proponents today, long after its initial inception. Phillip Scranton puts forth a localized theory of determinism in his work Determinism and Indeterminacy in the History of Technology (1995), arguing that if an idea or artefact can gain enough technological momentum then it should be "sufficiently powerful to overcome the constraints offered by other factors in the situational context" (1995, p. S36). If there are specific locations or time periods where technological determinism can reign supreme then what is stopping it from influencing society on a larger scale? Scranton stresses bureaucracy as the main limiting factor especially concerning governments and large corporations. He addresses a startling case of local determinism in the same journal article about how Cincinnati became "the nation 's most respected machine-tool district well before the First World War" (1995, S39). While other surrounding cities offered comparable environments with well-established industry, workers in Cincinnati turned their attention to machine-tool manufactories with networks between veterans and novices and a marketing scheme that involved many firms filling separate parts of a single, large order. This locally determined momentum can be attributed as much to engineering refinements as it is to the social interactions occurring throughout the community, according to Scranton. Even in this local, technology-driven change to the society, social aspects are front and center beside

Show More
Related
454 Words | 2 Pages

A. Morgan spent attending school in his early life.” “In 1895 he moved to cleveland, later when he was a grown up he became a sewing machine mechanic.” He repaired sewing machines, “Then he opened a shop in 1907.” Later he sold his sewing shop and bought several others through the years. After he opened many sewing machine shops, “He became an independent businessman.”

Read More
1907 Words | 8 Pages

Many workers, not far from Thomas O’Donnell, got laid off during business slumps by being replaced with handy machinery, or a worker with a lower wage. This was cheaper and more efficient. This left numerous workers without a job, especially when being replaced by a machine. Thomas O’Donnell, an ex-mule spinner, located in mills in Fall River, Massachusetts, testified before the U.S Senate about the relationship between labor and capital. In this document, O’Donnell reenacts his trial on the labor market.

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

Class and Community by Alan Dawley is a book written about the impact that factories and industrialization had on little towns such as that of Lynn, Massachusetts. This book goes into strong detail about how the lives of factory shoemakers were forever changed when the industrial revolution came about. The industrial revolution was such a game changer for these shoemakers mainly due to the factory system it introduced and the hardships that came with that. This book was originally written to show how many hardships these shoemakers had to go through and the massive difference they made in the path of the industrial revolution so the little man was not overlooked.

Read More
533 Words | 3 Pages

The pursuit of equal rights by the shoemakers of Lynn made them a microcosm of the industrial revolution because shoemaking was a small step for the inventing of new things for American culture and was not seen as an issue to the public until the townspeople began strikes against their employers. The careers of Ebenezer Breed, Micajah Pratt and Benjamin Newhall reflect the capitalist transformation of shoe manufacturing in Lynn from their very promising beginnings and their strive to increase their social status but utterly failed after their attempts.

Read More
347 Words | 2 Pages

Urban/political machines played a major role in late nineteenth-century American cities. These machines were powerful political organizations that controlled local government and politics in many cities. They were often led by a single powerful leader, known as a “boss”, who had the ability to influence elections and appointments to public office. The machines were able to control the city’s resources and patronage, and they used these resources to reward their supporters and punish their opponents. The machines were able to gain power by providing services to the city’s residents.

Read More
612 Words | 3 Pages

During the years of 1870-1916 the U.S. went through an industrial boom that manifested the country we live in today. At the time, the nation was rebuilding it’s connections back up once again making the south and the north together as one union. In between all of the changes happening nationally, there were major developments in booming cities like inventions including new forms of industrial idealization, transportation, and the uprising of electricity and along with these inventions came users who would take advantage. As for transportation, one of the major effects of industrialization in the U.S. was the creation of the steamboat.

Read More
1276 Words | 6 Pages

Between 1810’s and 1860’s, American capitalists and workers had turned towards the innovations of the steam engine, power loom, and other new technologies

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

Isaac Shaw October 9, 2014 Hist 2020 Dr. Paulauskas Paper #1 In the 1890’s, America was starting to experience changes leading to new revelations in the way it functioned in mass communication, mass transportation, and urbanization. In Erik Larson’s The Devil in the White City, he brings the seemingly different stories of two men in this time period, one a mass murder, H.H. Holmes and, the other a grand architect, Daniel Burnham to explain how America was changing into a more modern era. First, both Burnham and Holmes used the popularity of urbanization to achieve their individual goals.

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout history, technology was created

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

Along with slaves, most whites formed a huge majority of Southerners who had minimal ties to the market and who bought few manufactured goods.” Unlike the north who Factories are an example of new technology started in mainly the north in America. according to the American Nation,”it was not until Samuel Slater installed his machines in Pawtucket,Rhode Island,that a successful factory was constructed. ”(p.224). After the first factory more were coming into business.

Read More
1473 Words | 6 Pages

Particularly, in his study of industrial tycoons’ contributions to the American super economy, Charles Morris details that “The cheaper, better, steel flowing out of Andrew Carnegie’s new steel plants made possible mass-produced tools and consumer products that cost less, lasted longer, and worked better than anything that had gone before” (Morris 108). Mechanization and efficient manufacturing techniques not only enabled mass production, it levitated cost-effectiveness since consumers can access cheaper but

Read More
748 Words | 3 Pages

The Civil War may have set over 4 million slaves free, but the Reconstruction Era brought a whole new set of problems. The Reconstruction Era was the period of time after the Civil War, in which the Confederacy was supposed to rebuild itself into a new and improved country, but that didn’t happen. Former President, Abraham Lincoln, had come up with new ideas to bring together the country. Those ideas included things, such as finding aid former slaves in funding education, healthcare, and employment, but before that could happen, on April 14th, 1865, John Wilkes Booth assassinated President Lincoln. The Reconstruction Era made America the way it is today by providing former Americans with the tools to use for success.

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

(p 320). Another example that Davidson uses to show the change is Luke, also one of the workers at the machinery. “In many ways, Luke personifies the dramatic shift in the U.S. industrial labor market.” (p 323). Here the author explains how the machinery Luke works with and how it has progressed, as well as he has, to help show the change in the manufacturing

Read More
128 Words | 1 Pages

In the article “Where Are the Missing Masses? The Sociology of a Few Mundane Artifacts”, Bruno Latour explores how artifacts can be designed to shape human action and that technology mostly rely on human interaction to function. He argues that technologies shape the decisions we make, the effects our actions have, and the way we move through this world. Providing examples from the door closers, and engineers among others, Latour emphasize the importance of the interaction between humans and technology. He studies the relationship between humans (the creator) and machines (the creation) and shows how the use of technology can help achieve certain goals and values.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

Technology can be defined as “the branch of knowledge that deals with the creation and use of technical means and their interrelation with life, society, and the environment”. (n.d.) Therefore, when we speak of technological evolution we can say that it is an “innovation and technology related hypothesis that describes the fundamental change of society through technical development”. Different theorists have their own perspective on the evolution of technology but, although each of their views differs from another, they shared certain common features, mechanism, and incidence in technology. Some theorists have developed distinct approaches to understanding the nature of the technological process and the relationship between technological development and the social world.

Read More

More about Technological Determinism Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document