ipl-logo

The Feminist Lens In Alice Munro's The Shining House

1209 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Boys and girls by alice munro feminist critical lens

In many stories, the characters are what define the narrative; they separate the engaging stories from the monotonous, the humourous from the somber, and the good from the great. Often, a reader’s understanding of a character changes as a story progresses and new perspectives emerge, allowing for characters to be shaped into three-dimensional, dynamic personas that resonate with the audience. In Alice Munro’s short story, “The Shining Houses”, the application of the feminist lens allows for a more profound understanding of both Mary and Mrs. Fullerton; bringing insightful perspectives on the traits both characters possess. More specifically, Mary is seen to be both self conscious and courageous when analyzing the need for masculine protection …show more content…

Mary’s reactions to the struggles she is faced with provide readers with a deeper comprehension of her character, and reveal her to be someone who is self conscious and courageous. Firstly, Mary’s character demonstrates her self-consciousness through the internal monologue she has during the birthday party. Mary is unsure of herself, her thoughts, and her opinions, pausing before speaking as she needs to “think of other words, words more sound and reasonable than these; she could not expose to this positive tide any notion that they might think flimsy or romantic, or she would destroy her argument” (Munro 70). As supported by the preceding example, Mary feels incertitude within herself as a result of the societally enforced idea that women are unable to make sound decisions. Mary is dismissive of her own opinion, as she (along with many other women) is often perceived as hysterical or illogical when expressing an idea. Mary is conscious of the societal bias imposed upon women, and her own self confidence and assuredness as a character has consequently been shaped by societal beliefs and values. In addition, a better understanding of Mary and the courageousness her character possesses is acquired when observing her reaction to the masculine protection that is pressed upon her. When departing from the birthday party, Mary is urged to sign a petition to help orchestrate the demolition of Mrs Fullerton’s house. Despite having the knowledge that refusing to sign the petition could result in being alienated from the group and criticized by others, Mary declines the offer, with “her face flush[ing] up at once, her voice… trembling” (Munro 71). In this instance, Mary rebels against the protection that the men are offering; she refuses to

Show More
Related
631 Words | 3 Pages

What Mary lacks to see is that her parents love her with all their heart, but her viewpoint is her parents don’t understand her. The reason being is since Hana knows very little english Mary and her can not have quality talks with her and Taro spends most a his days at the shop so he is never home. In this case Hana and Taro are the people who will do anything for another person. Sadly, Mary feels like her parents could care less about her and starts thinking it would be better if she lived her life and they lived their life separate. She truly believed that if this change was made then everyone will be joyful in the long run.

Read More
1908 Words | 8 Pages

She writes many different examples showcasing the equality between the two genders. Mary then ends the second speech by incorporating biblical aspects. The main idea of speech one was to bring attention to the power of money. That it has the power to take over even

Read More
2461 Words | 10 Pages

Mary and her mother were fortunately sold to quite a kind family who did not treat their slaves as much like garbage but instead were treated more of as they were, humans. Although she was a slave, she was treated very well in the William’s and Pruden’s household. Mary had a very positive experience as a child and believes it to be the happiest time in her life. Thus, leading her childhood being the happiest

Read More
215 Words | 1 Pages

She knew they didn’t treat people right because of past times, making it hard to not trust the people you support to trust like; the police and doctors. Feels like he has no choice in further education, as Mary had no

Read More
1143 Words | 5 Pages

She resists conforming to societal norms and wants to live a free spirited life with no requirements. Moreover, Mary is unwilling to follow through with her priorities and is upset about

Read More
1235 Words | 5 Pages

But the sexualization within the document is not only applied to Mary. When describing the two-year old traveling with John and Mary, she is described as a ‘woman child’. This was another conscious decision that depicts a young Indigenous girl as being ‘mature’ for her age, suggesting that unlike English girls, this child is closer to the age of majority. This also implies that she is closer to the age of sexual availability, ignoring that she is still a toddler. Lastly, when describing Mary, the choice was made to describe

Read More
589 Words | 3 Pages

Mary just didn’t know how to cope with everything and she was depressed about all the deaths in her life and all the loves she had lost. her surviving son, Robert Todd Lincoln, had her temporarily committed. “Mary was judged insane” . She attempted suicide through an overdose of laudanum, but the pharmacist gave her a placebo. After many weeks her sister, Elizabeth Edwards had secured her release and took Mary to live with her and Ninian.

Read More
1239 Words | 5 Pages

“Identity cannot be found or fabricated, but emerges from within when one has the courage to let go”- by Doug Cooper. Circumstances, experiences and society are factors in an individual’s life which contribute to the formation of their identity. Identity is not found, instead, it’s made by conflicts, hurdles, societal pressures and obstacles in one’s life which come together in harmony to create one’s identity in its purest form. How individuals act and respond to challenging circumstances determines their values, goals and beliefs, thus, forms them as a whole. In the text name “The Shining Houses” by Alice Munro, a character named Mary experiences stresses in her life which attribute to not only her individuality but to her development as a character as the story progresses.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

Authors, especially female authors, have long used their writing to emphasize and analyze the feminist issues that characterize society, both in the past and the present. Kate Chopin, Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and Susan Glaspell wrote narratives that best examined feminist movements through the unreliable minds of their characters. In all three stories, “The Story of an Hour”, “The Yellow Wallpaper”, and “A Jury of Her Peers”, the authors use characterization, symbolism, and foreshadowing to describe the characters’ apparent psychosis or unreasonable behavior to shed light on the social issues that characterized the late 19th century and early 20th century. Penning many stories that demonstrate her opinions on the social issues of the era,

Read More
498 Words | 2 Pages

In a world where the "new" outweighs the “old,” the well being of the majority tends to come before the well being of the individual. In The Shining Houses, a short story written by Alice Munro, The “new” neighbours develop this theme, throughout the story, as they conjure up a scheme to eliminate Ms. Fullerton—the “old” neighbour—from their neighbourhood. First of all, the new neighbours introduced the theme in a smooth fashion as they started complaining about Mrs. Fullerton’s and her home. They explained to one another it was an eyesore, and that it smelled quite unpleasant. The general disdain for Mrs. Fullerton’s property was emphasized as Steve, Edith’s husband, stated that “if [he] was next door to [Mrs. Fullerton’s house], [he] would send [his] kids

Read More
1465 Words | 6 Pages

[who] can’t go against his word” (294).This is conflated with the episode in which Mr. Jones, troubled by his grief on not having a son and his wife’s coldness towards him, comes looking for the prostitute at the inn. He discovers Mary to be the whore but that does not stop him from having sex with her. The superficiality and duplicity of the marriage institution is thus exposed as wives are regulated to be monogamous, whereas husbands are free to seek pleasure and comfort elsewhere. The challenge to this prejudice was clearly enunciated in the feminist stance of Mary Astell given in A Serious Proposal to Women (1668), which seeks to subvert the patriarchal institution of marriage that entraps women and the struggles and triumphs of such a stance is manifestly represented Donoghue’s characterisation of

Read More
666 Words | 3 Pages

Mary’s ambivalent identification with Africanness (her submission to Muses), and with whiteness (her domestic space) could not be resolved and thus led to her self-sacrificial death. She feels a complicated sense of in-between-ness. She cannot fully identify with England, nor is she comfortable with her British colonial identity as the colonial in exile in Africa. “In the destruction of both Mary and Dick, the novel also seems to suggest that chaos lies always on the margins of (white) civilization in colonial Africa” (Fishburn 3).

Read More
1068 Words | 5 Pages

Her mother died shortly after her birth leaving her father to care for her and her half-sister, Fanny Imlay. The dynamic of her family soon changed when her father remarried. Mary was treated poorly by her new stepmother, and her quality of life was less than satisfactory. Her step-siblings were allowed to receive an education while Mary stayed at home. She found comfort in reading, and created stories in her father’s library.

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

Mary Wollstoneraft’s partly autobiographical novel Mary, A Fiction, shows how a talented young woman learns to think and act for herself. Her first heroine, Mary, is an outspoken and autonomous woman, rather than the typical accommodating, soft and domesticated woman of her period. Wollstonecraft undoubtedly refuses to follow models of female characters or narratives of the time (romantic or sentimental fiction). This is clearly shown in the prefatory advertisement to Mary, A Fiction, where she anticipates that she will “develop a character different from those generally portrayed. This woman is neither a Clarissa, a Lady G-, nor a Sophie” (Wollstonecraft, 1788: 4).

Read More
1415 Words | 6 Pages

However, in the process of persuading upper class women in addition to the men who overhear, she constructs and perpetuates a rigid class system, in which only the moneyed listeners may achieve. Continuing to contemplate in the beginning of her essay, Mary says, “I thought how it is worse perhaps to be locked in; and, thinking of the safety and prosperity of the one sex and of the poverty and insecurity of the other and of the effect of tradition and the lack of tradition upon the mind of a writer” (24). Once again, she is addressing the few literature upper class women who didn’t meet the model Mary describes. In her cogitation, she reveals the detriment caused by poverty and lack of resources. However, she fails to acknowledge the ability of success to arise out of such adversity.

Read More

More about The Feminist Lens In Alice Munro's The Shining House

Related Topics

Open Document