The movie, The Village, and the novel 1984 provides new insight and connections on a “utopian” society. Both are very similar to each other in a way that their utopian society has many flaws. 1984 is about a rebellion against an iron-fisted totalitarian government while The Village is about an attempt to protect the innocence of people. In these societies, the leaders lie in order to try and achieve a utopian world. Both societies have different purposes to control the people through fear, but despite their attempts to create a utopian society, they were only successful to a certain extent.
Through his lessons with The Giver, Jonas learns about past human society, and he begins to view his world with color. Society in the Anthem is also described as utopian. When children reach the age of five, they are placed in a hall called, Home of the Infants. These children then do not have contact with their parents as the state is responsible for their care. At the ages of five and fifteen, they become placed in Home of the Students and later in the Home of the Street Sweeper.
Kyla Buchanan Reading 12-15-16 Period:8 Compare and Contrast Jonas”s dystopian society was irregular and judgemental. In this essay I’m going to compare and contrast his dystopian society with modern day. There are many ways they were alike and different in the text. In the first paragraph, I’m going to contrast Jonas’s society with modern day. Then, In the second paragraph I’m going to contrast modern day with Jonas’s.
The Giver Compare/Contrast Essay When some people hear the words ‘perfect society’ what do they think of? Take a look at our society, then take a look at Jonas’s society, between our two societies there are some comparisons and a vast amount of differences. For instance, the rules are different, as well as their family units and their individuality. While our society is more on the modern side, Jonas’s society is plainer. When it comes to the rules in our society, we don’t normally think of rules that are very extreme.
Lois Lowry’s The Giver revolves around the story of twelve years old boy named, Jonas, who lives in a community where all human disturbances are banned; no wars, no crimes, no hunger or sorrow and not even the binary of rich and poor. In this community, all citizens are comfortable and equal. In terms of equality, the community’s maxim is “sameness”, where everything seems utopian, flawless as claimed by Erika Gotllieb, “each dystopian society contains within its seeds of a utopian dream” (8). However, to achieve this idealistic state of social stability, there must be a price to pay in which people of the community are deprived from their memories, emotions and choices.
The Giver Literature essay I have read the dystopian novel “The Giver” (1993) which is written by the beloved American author Lois Lowry. “The Giver” is about a twelve-year-old boy with the name Jonas. Jonas lives a similar life as all the others in the community, until the Ceremony of Twelve when he got assigned the task as the Receiver of Memory. As The Receiver of Memory it is Jonas’ task to keep all the memories of the past so not everyone needs to keep this burden. Although Jonas received beautiful memories with a lot of colors and happiness he also felt grief, pain and anger.
“The old of the community did not ever leave their special place, the house of the old, where they were so well cared for and respected.” (Lowry 123) In modern day society The leaders of our society do not care about the problems that we have and the things that they don’t ever ask about our feelings on the problem. In Jonas’ society The leaders of their society do not know what to do about some problems and so they sometimes make the community all messed up.
On the other hand a utopia is an imaginary place where everyone and everything is perfect and it is very wanted and desired by many. While some differences between Jonas’s society and our society are noticeable, the similarities are striking. First there are many similarities in Jonas’s society and modern society. In both modern society and Jonas’s society there are jobs. For example, in the text it says “I hope I get assigned to be a birthmother” (Lowry, 27).
“Dystopia, by definition, promises a darker story” (Lauren DeStefano). This means that a dream doesn’t become reality through magic. In the novel, The Giver , by Luis Lowry, Jonas is part of a dystopia. A Dystopia is the complete opposite of a perfect world, a dystopian society would be like a world full of hate, racism, etc. A Utopia is a perfect world.
Despite the fact that we endeavor for a utopia, the inability to do so results in our dystopian society. Envision a utopia where famine and war does not exist. This expectation costs multiple inflexible sacrifices to maintain such an infallible society. In The Giver by Lois Lowry, the community is synchronized to sameness daily to maintain humbleness or peace. In spite of that, society's ignorance of the truth keeps them from experiencing life itself.
In the novel The Giver by Lois Lowry, Jonas’s community is definitely a dystopia for multiple reason. First of all, the society Jonas lives in. People are not allowed to choose who their spouse is. ”What if they were allowed to choose their mate. And choose wrong, it 's not safe.”
He is under sameness and the influence of the community. Jonas is chosen to receive feelings, colors, and emotions from memories. As time goes by Jonas sees the community not as a utopia but a horrible place. Jonas wants to change
Imagine living in a perfect society. No pain, everyone is equal, and perfect laws that every person follows. Now imagine being exactly like every other person with all your daily choices being made by someone else for you. In the book The Giver by Lois Lowry, this is exactly how they are living. The author writes about how Jonas’ perfect society is not so perfect after all.
When Jonas experiences both painful and pleasurable memories, he becomes willing to accept pain and suffering in order to experience the fullness of life. He decides to leave, that he will no longer live within the constraints of his community, and that security is not worth the absence of freedom. The line between public safety and personal freedoms should be drawn where extreme harm can occur, and most freedoms are more essential than an orderly society. These freedoms include color and diversity, personal freedoms such as dress code, speech, and religion, and love and marriage.
In Lois Lowry’s award-winning novel, The Giver, Jonas’s society is considered to be utopian because the society has an overall sense of sameness, organization, and minimal problems. To begin, the society is utopian because of sameness. In Lois Lowry 's, The Giver, Jonas is selected to be the Receiver of Memories and he comes to learn that when his community decided to go to sameness they were getting rid of color, emotion, and choice. At first the Giver tells him it 's to "protect" them from making the wrong choices. As stated in the text “Our people made that choice the choice to go to sameness”.(Lois Lowry pg 95)
