ipl-logo

The Hobbit And A Dog's Life Comparison

1014 Words5 Pages

The hero 's journey is everywhere, in the books you read to in your own life. In every book it’s a little different due to the author 's style. This can be seen between the two books The Hobbit and A Dog’s life. The Hobbit is about a Hobbit named Bilbo Baggins who goes on a quest to get treasure back from a dragon. A Dog’s Life is about a dog who had to learn how to survive on her own from a very young age and is trying to find a place to live. The hero 's journey is shown in many different ways in these two books. There are many differences and similarities in the texts but more differences between both books.

The differences start to show very early in the books. To start the trials show very different in both books.For one one of the …show more content…

For one they are both pushed into doing this journey. This is one of the first chapters in The Hobbit where Gandalf shows up up at Bilbo’s hobbit hole and when he goes inside he put a mark on the door. This mark lets the dwarves’ where to go. Then in A Dog’s Life she follows her brother away from the house after their mom dies. They also both get help from a character in the book who will keep helping them
This is one of the most noticeable points to find in any book or movie. In The Hobbit he has Gandalf witch is one of the fist characters the book mentions. He also has all of the dwarves’. In A Dog’s Life she has Bone, Moon, and her mother are the main dogs that help her. The humans in the story most of them are mean to the dog’s. They both at some point in the story they get into really bad fights or accidents. In one in A Dog’s Life moon lost her life. In The Hobbit Bilbo first is dropped off a cliff, then he is tormented my gollum. After he escapes him he is knocked out and wakes up with a spider trying to eat him he then kills the spider. While trying to find his friends he ends up fighting a clan of the same spiders. Then in A Dog’s Life she first gets a broken shoulder from being thrown out of a car. After that she is then attacked by a ban of wild dogs while always being chased to be taken to the pound. One of the biggest accidents happened as she was hit by a truck and could have died. They are not all that similar but they do have a few similarities between them

Show More
Related
867 Words | 4 Pages

Dogs may not be able to be educated, but they can be trained to put on a show or help people to get through any type of struggle. By setting up her story, with short anecdotes about different dogs that flow into one another, Sedgwick makes it clear that her argument is that animal cruelty is wrong, and that goodness trumps genius. Ultimately, Sedgwick wants children to understand that hurting animals is wrong, and that goodness, as well as fidelity, are much more important

Read More
787 Words | 4 Pages

Even though this part of the hero’s journey was portrayed pretty similarly, there is still a bit of a difference. They both used their instincts, but Bilbo was influenced a bit by the dwarves. His Took side had shown while the dwarves were contemplating whether he was fit for the adventure or not. This made him want to prove himself to them. Instincts aren’t normally the cause of the call to adventure, but for some reason, these two very different novels are similar this way.

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

Author’s show the Hero’s Journey in many different and similar ways. In The Hobbit wrote by JRR Tolkien the Hero Bilbo Baggins leaves his home to go on a adventure with the dwarves’. They run into goblins, elves’, and spiders and are heading to Smaug to fight a dragon to get their gold back. In A Dog’s Life wrote by Ann M Martin the Hero Squirrel leaves her home to follow her brother and runs into another home. The person of the home drives them and drops them off at the mall; Squirrel loses her brother named Bone and is left in the mall to find food and shelter.

Read More
393 Words | 2 Pages

Ponyboy is an interesting character. He and his group of buddies were greasers. In the outsiders the greasers have a rivalry with the socs. Ponyboy was one of the only people that had a positive interaction with the socs so the question is while he was a senior was he still a greaser or did he turn into a socs. I am convinced that ponyboy stayed a greaser.

Read More
265 Words | 2 Pages

Furthermore I think the dog changes her, her mom, and her dad’s life. I say this because when the dog first came into the house the parents didn’t want to keep the dog, and then when the dad was taking the dog to the pound he didn’t leave the dog there, and the mom didn’t want to

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

Joseph Campbell, a renowned mythologist and professor studied mythology and traditional stories. He defined a hero as “someone who has given his or her life for something bigger than oneself.” His creation of the Hero’s Journey structured the storyline for so many stories to come, including The Hobbit. J.R.R. Tolkien’s novel follows the adventure of Bilbo Baggins, an ordinary hobbit turned hero. Gandalf, a wizard forces Bilbo on an adventure to regain treasure with thirteen dwarves.

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

This novel, written by Garth Stein, explains the answers to questions like these through a dog’s interpretation of human life. The main character and narrator, Enzo, compares living a balanced human life in the midst of challenges and struggles to racing a car in the rain. Although he is not able to become directly involved with the main plot of the story, Enzo witnesses the lives of his owners and tries to analyze and understand what they are going through. He believes that he will be reincarnated as a man at the end of his life as a dog and wants to learn as much as he can. Enzo’s perspective on human life gives the reader a better understanding of what it

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

Gollum gets three chances and loses, and since Gollum was supposed to get Bilbo out he tries to find his ring to kill Bilbo, but when he realizes it’s gone he gets mad and starts accusing Bilbo and then hunts for him, but Bilbo slips on his ring without realizes he is invisible and he goes and follows Gollum as Gollum doesn’t realize he is leading Bilbo to the exit. Then Bilbo realizes he is invisible when he crashes into Gollum and Gollum

Read More
842 Words | 4 Pages

“Books and movies are like apples and oranges. They both are fruit, but taste completely different” (Stephen King). The Hobbit, originally written by JRR Tolkien and directed in film by Peter Jackson, is a story about Bilbo Baggins, a Hobbit used to the sedentary lifestyle who also owns a magic ring that turns him invisible, pursuing an adventure with Thorin and Company, a group of dwarves seeking to reclaim their lost treasure from Smaug, a dragon who conquered the lost kingdom of Dale, ruled by Thorin’s ancestors. The stories themselves of both film and novel are very similar in structure. The chapter “Barrels out of Bond” contains the Wood-elves imprisoning the dwarves, with Bilbo barely slipping out.

Read More
1260 Words | 6 Pages

Hero’s Journey Essay Literary Analysis of The Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien What happens when one day a cloaked figure asks you to join a group of heavily bearded men in search for treasure in a dragon’s lair? Bilbo is fortunate enough to experience such a peculiar invitation, but the Baggins side of him is quick in refusal. Yet off he still goes from his warm and fuzzy hobbit hole in the Shire to the desolate land of Dain, where he learns to prove his worth amongst his hot-tempered Dwarf companions. Along the way, allies are made, secrets kept and human desires put into play, eventually culminating in the concluding battles where Bilbo plays a pivotal role in the management of order in the fellowship.

Read More
465 Words | 2 Pages

He begins by falling into a fit when he feels he is being forced to join Gandalf and the dwarves, and later he must be carried by Dori when they are escaping the Goblins. In the face of difficulties, he is often afraid and constantly daydreams of bacon and eggs and wishes himself back home. Bilbo is also shows signs of being fastidious. He does not like the mess the dwarves create in his home and he thinks multiple times that places they stay are unorganized

Read More
704 Words | 3 Pages

The book, A Dog’s Purpose, follows a dog who searches for his unique purpose in life. The canine experiences reincarnation four times, and in every one of his different lives, he tries to accomplish making his human happy. In his first life, he is Toby and lives in the Yard with a woman called Señora. Toby adjusts to his life in the Yard and assumes his purpose is to make Señora smile. He comforts her and takes pride in being her favorite.

Read More
1270 Words | 6 Pages

Bilbo escapes being captured by killing the spider that was attacking him. Bilbo kills the spider with a sword and says, “I will give you a name, and I shall call you Sting” (154). With Sting and his ring, Bilbo sets off to save his friends. Bilbo slips on his ring when he became close to the spiders. He decides to try and lure them away from where they had the dwarves hanging from a tree branch.

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

Mark Twain believes that dogs are superior to man because out of all animals, man is the only one that is cruel enough to inflict pain on others just for the pleasure of doing it. Twain’s short story “A Dog’s Tale”, written in 1903, displays these beliefs and is done so from a dog’s point of view. This unusual take on the story is used to help convey the theme that one shouldn’t assume the others will do the same for them. The story includes literary elements such as characterisation, structural irony and a plot and conflict. It is a story of a loyal and heroic dog which unfortunately ends in an ironic twist of fate.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

He believes that the dog made him appreciate the little things in life and now that he is gone, he is left alone in the world. The dog gives the owner a sense of hope and optimism until it reaches the end of its life. The author no longer has the same happiness and excitement that he used to have. He lost the one thing that he shared

Read More

More about The Hobbit And A Dog's Life Comparison

Related Topics

Open Document