ipl-logo

The Insane Cases: The Defense Of Andrea Yates

1246 Words5 Pages

When the police were called to Andrea Yates suburban Hudson Texas home in June 20th 2001 they were not prepared for what they were about to see. The police were shocked to see Andreas five children dead while Andrea acted completely calm and admitted to drowning them one by one in the family bath tub. Andrea had previous mental health issues which she had been hospitalized including suicide attempts. She had been suffering with very sever postpartum depression and post part partum psychosis, two illnesses that would make Andrea very dangerous to herself and those around her, especially her children. Andrea went to trial against the Harris County Texas District Attorney who were convicting her of capital murder and asking for the death penalty, …show more content…

Although the defences expert testimony agreed that Yates was psychotic, the law in Texas is that to be able to be considered insane you must have not known your actions were wrong which was hard to prove for Andrea since she was very capable of separating right from wrong and since she was very aware of what she had done. When asked about the murders Andrea asked very calm, she had no remorse and genuinely believed what she was going was the right thing to do. Andrea was very heavily influenced by her religion and truly thought that she was saving her children from growing up and becoming sinners to avoid hell. Since Andrea admitted to waiting for her husband to leave for work to kill her children to Dr. Michael Welner, the Prosecutors were easily able to prove this was a thought-out murder which very possibly qualifies this murder as a very possible first degree murder. Testimony from Dr. Dietz also very heavily impact the jury’s decision. He claimed he recently saw a “Law & Order” episode shortly before the killings, featuring a woman who drowned her children and was acquitted of murder because of …show more content…

Park Dietz. The fact that this testimony was false came to the courts attention when author of the show later stated on Oprah that such episode didn’t exist. This means the first Jury would have made their decision considering false facts. Therefore, a new trial would only be truly fair. Through out the new, reconsidered trial not only did yates appear more stable but her attorney introduced more witnesses to help show that she was, in fact, a fragile woman who loved her children, but delusionally believed death would save them from sin. This time around Andrea also had a new group of juror to listen. The last group he had consisted of eight women and four men. Its possible that woman, especially those who’d faced similar challenges in day to day life as mothers with small children like Andrea, might have been especially unsympathetic. The second jury was more diverse as it was evenly divided between men and women. Jurors listened to testimonies from investigators, medical experts, and people close to Andrea. Officers who reported to Andreas home after she called 911 testified that Andrea appeared wet and unemotional as she calmly confessed to the police. Andreas best friend said that Andrea was a loving mother and a very sweet friend, but after the birth of her fourth child, she became

Show More
Related
1783 Words | 8 Pages

USA TODAY published an article “Casey Anthony breaks her silence: I sleep pretty good at night.” Anthony did an interview with Associated Press speaking about the case and her daughter’s death for the first time. The Associated Press said that the interview with Anthony was “revealing, bizarre and often contradictory, and ultimately raised more question than answers about the case.” In the interview with Associated Press, Anthony admitted to lying to the police about a number of things such as her employment, leaving her child with a babysitter, and receiving a call from Caylee before she went missing. During the trial, the defense stated that Caylee had drown in the pool and then Casey Anthony’s father tried to cover up the accident.

Read More
1667 Words | 7 Pages

Even when Michael’s new defense team, through the innocence project, found a crime that was eerily similar to the method of murder and subsequent events to the one that Michael was convicted of, the new prosecutor in Williamson County fought hard to keep DNA testing from taking place, even stating that they objected to the testing now because the defense hadn’t requested it before (Morton, 2014). There was further evidence of ineffectiveness in that the coroner who’d changed his estimated time of death between the autopsy and trial, had come under scrutiny for his findings in this case, as well as several others, with claims of gross errors “including one case where he came to the conclusion that a man who’d been stabbed in the back had committed suicide” (Morton, 2014). This was only one of the many injustices that were committed against Michael Morton throughout his trial. In August of 2006, the defense was finally granted permission to perform DNA testing on the items that had been taken from his wife’s body (Morton, 2014). Although this testing did not reveal any information about the guilty party, it did at least give Michael the knowledge that Chris was not sexually violated before or after her death (Morton,

Read More
2253 Words | 10 Pages

She called Amy and asked where Casey was and Amy told her she was at Tony Lazzaro’s, Casey’s boyfriend where Cindy found Casey. Cindy asked repeatedly where Caylee was and that she wanted to see her. Casey’s replied over and over that she’s with the nanny. Cindy finally told Casey that she was calling the police. Casey then started to cry and told her family that Caylee had been kidnapped by Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez, the nanny, and Casey was searching for her daughter on her own, and had been for the last 31 days.

Read More
211 Words | 1 Pages

Two women from Texas, Andrea Yates, 37 and Darlie Routier, 27 both shocked the world when they brutally murdered their children. Both women were described as wonderful mothers who loved their children, but were also described as having post-partum issues during the last years of their children’s lives. Andrea Yates admitted to her harsh crimes and was willing to take any punishment that was given, as she believed she was saving her children’s souls. On the other hand, Darlie Routier did not admitted her crimes towards her children. Darlie Routier pleaded not guilty, but prosecutors believed differently after many conflicts appeared in her story.

Read More
390 Words | 2 Pages

After reading chapters one and two of the Psychology in Everyday Life book and learning about the four big ideas in psychology, and also while trying to figure out the contributing factors of Andrea Yates’ murder of her children. I have to focus in on and think about big idea two, the biopsychosocial approach, that integrates three levels which are biological, psychological and social/cultural; all together these factors influence and give insight into behavior and mental processes. (CITE BOOK) After reviewing these, the psychological factors that I believe to have contributed to Andrea Yates’ murder of her children are, firstly biological, Andrea had a genetic predispositions, which means Andrea had an increased likelihood of developing

Read More
365 Words | 2 Pages

In this case the only obstacle the prosecutors had was prove that Caylee Anthony was murdered by her own mother, they had to prove beyond reasonable doubt to the jury that she was behind her daughter’s death. Most of the evidence that was presented was in fact pointed to Casey Anthony as the person who was fully liable for her daughter

Read More
791 Words | 4 Pages

Cindy Anthony, Casey Anthony's mother, was called to testify. She testified in her daughter's defense and took responsibility for some of the chloroform searches. The computer searches were key to the prosecution's claims of premeditated murder, an essential element for first degree murder and the possibility of the death penalty. “Baez said in closing arguments, I told you she was a liar the first day.(abc news.2017)” Casey killed that Caylee by drugging her, but she got away with

Read More
1188 Words | 5 Pages

In the case of Judy Norman should have been acquitted based on self-defense rather than being convicted of voluntary manslaughter. According to defense psychologist, Judy had been tortured, degraded, and reduced to an animal level of existence. Since her husband had abused her for twenty years physically assaulting her, burning her with cigarettes, forcing her into prostitution, and forcing her to eat dog food off the floor. Judy’s first resort was not to kill her husband, first, she contacted police after a horrible beating, but was so deep in a cycle of fear she did not press charges on her husband. For police officers to be first responders to domestic violence calls they should be trained to know the signs of domestic abuse, and the cycle

Read More
646 Words | 3 Pages

Lead defense attorney Jose Baez suggested, at the trial, that the little girl drowned and Casey Anthony's father, George, helped cover up the incident. The former judge for the case believes the Casey Anthony killed her toddler daughter, but not own purpose. “Considering the high levels of chloroform that was found in the trunk of the car, that was my logical deduction for what happened,' Perry said. ' That’s just a theory. The only person that actually knows what happened is Casey

Read More
1451 Words | 6 Pages

During this test he couldn't control his breathing and you could tell from watching the tape that he was lying to all the questions that the lady was asking. After confessing to officials that he had murdered his wife, he decides to lie and tell them the reason for murdering Shan’ann was due to her smothering their daughters. The next day the three bodies were found at the oil site where Chris worked. That same day there was a bond hearing that Chris appeared at in Weld County which he was denied. On November 6, 2018 Chris Watts pleaded guilty to all nine criminal counts.

Read More
416 Words | 2 Pages

Not calling 911 and hiding the body was morally and criminally wrong. The lack of remorse bothered me as an utter disregard for her dead daughter and selfishness unparalleled. I believe that the prosecution’s putting the death

Read More
697 Words | 3 Pages

In June of 2001, the entire nation was deeply disturbed by the horrific acts committed by a suburban Texas housewife, and mother of five. Andrea Yates had drowned all five of her young children in the bathtub of their home. Yates called the authorities and her husband Rusty Yates to the home, where she confessed to killing her children. According to Faith McLellan of the Lancet Medical Journal, Andrea Yates’s bizarre reasoning behind this horrific act was because she believed to have been marked by Satan, and that in order to save her children from hell she needed to take their lives (McLellan, 2006). Yates pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity on the basis of mental defect due to postpartum depression and postpartum psychosis.

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, you are here because one person in this courtroom decided to take law into her own hands. The defendant, Mrs. Dominique Stephens, murdered the man that she vowed to love. This sole act by the defendant is violation of all morals and her husband’s right to live. Afterwards, she even felt guilty about this violation of justice and called the cops on herself, and she later signed a written statement stating that she is guilty of the murder of Mr. Donovan Stephens. Then the defendant later recanted this statement and said that she only killed Mr. Stephens in self defense.

Read More
1464 Words | 6 Pages

It took about a month for Rusty to start noticing Andrea was falling back into her old depressive ways. She was caught talking about suicide again and once held a knife to her neck and begged Rusty to just let her die. July 1999, Yates suffered from a nervous breakdown and tried again to commit suicide and was hospitalized. The doctors determined she suffered from postpartum psychosis. Postpartum psychosis is a rare psychiatric emergency in which symptoms of high mood and racing thoughts (mania), depression, severe confusion, loss of inhibition, paranoia, hallucinations and delusions set in, beginning suddenly in the first two weeks after delivery.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

On the morning of June 20, 2001, Andrea Yates murdered all five of her children by drowning them in her household’s bathtub while her husband was away. After the birth of her 4th child, Yates became diagnosed with postpartum depression and this carried on after the birth of her 5th. Yates indicated the killing of her children was due to the fact that she was seeing violent images and hearing voices telling her to get a knife, or even hearing a voice she believed to be the devil that told her he was after her children. Such voices can be explained by the psychodynamic perspective that Yates’ behavior of killing her children was a result of these unconscious voices that were demanding her to take such violent action. Growing obsessively religious over the years, Yates followed extreme Christian views presented by the

Read More

More about The Insane Cases: The Defense Of Andrea Yates

Related Topics

Open Document