ipl-logo

The Mcmartin Daycare Case Of The 1980s

717 Words3 Pages

Throughout time, fear has been the number one thing that keeps people alive. Because people are scared, they run from predators in order to survive. The process of natural selection has ensured that those who are scared will live. The people who realize this can take advantage of it. Two prime examples are Abigail Williams and Judy Johnson. The McMartin Daycare Case of the 1980s shares similar themes with the Salem Witch Trials, as seen in Arthur Miller’s The Crucible.
Without a doubt, there is plenty of hysteria leading to impulsive decision making featured in the McMartin Daycare Case. To recap, in 1983 a woman named Judy Johnson accused Ray Buckley of molesting her two-year-old son. Letters were sent out to parents and word spread quickly …show more content…

After accusing Ray Buckely, she pursued more allegations against the school using weak evidence. According to information about the trial compiled by law Professor Douglas O. Linder, “[Judy Johnson] claimed that Peggy Buckey, Ray’s mother, was involved in satanic practices … most prosecutors would come to recognize Johnson's allegations as the delusions of a paranoid schizophrenic, but the snowball of suspicion had started rolling.'' (Linder). Professor Linder demonstrates that Judy is responsible for the controversy at McMartin Preschool. He illustrates how Judy’s lies led to an unnecessary investigation and wrongful imprisonment. By starting several rumors about rape and satanic practices in the preschool, Johnson was able to manipulate the court into believing her because they were scared. This connects back to the theme of hysteria leading to impulsive decision making, as found in The Crucible and The McMartin Daycare …show more content…

In John Miller’s play, the extremely Christian town’s fear of the devil pushes innocent people to be needlessly killed when they are accused of witchcraft. In act II Reverend Hale warns Proctor and Elizabeth, “‘We dare not quail to follow wherever the accusing finger points!’” (Miller 201). The theme of hysteria leading to impulsive decision making is present in The Crucible. In this passage, Hale is saying that he cannot let fear guide his accusations. He knows that fear will inevitably lead to poor decisions. When the court fails to listen, those who are innocent face horrendous punishments. This is comparable to the McMartin Case. According to an article by the History Channel “The McMartin prosecutions represented the height of the hysteria over sexual abuse of children in America. Despite a complete lack of reputable evidence … [procecuters] proceeded against Ray Buckey for more than six years" (“Teachers”). This article reinforces the theme of hysteria leading to impulsive decision making. Although there wasn’t evidence, the lawsuit proceeded for six years because the people were scared. That fear of abuse and satanic practices pushed this case forward more than it should have. The unorthodox decisions from the courts in both instances were clearly driven by fear. Unquestionably, both the McMartin Preschool Case and The Crucible share the theme of mass

Show More
Related
1756 Words | 8 Pages

In KOVR-TV, the children were subjected to the media bombarding them and revealing sensitive information. The three children, all under twelve and without adult supervision, were “interrogated” by Saxenmyer. (Id. at 432) Saxenmeyer, then, informed three kids that Mrs. Weber murdered the Weber children. He does not stop there; he went on to tell the children that the mother committed suicide. (Id. at 433).

Read More
389 Words | 2 Pages

This proves the claim of Madam having “more than her share” of evil because Ruth, who is 5 years old, is having a seizure and Madam began to beat her with a broom, while the toddler had no sort of self-defense. On page 265, it exclaims,

Read More
1742 Words | 7 Pages

Peggy goes on to state “we’re all so surprised when they come back on another charge. Or when they turn into Ronald Duncan. The system is stupid. Completely stupid” (44). This is why she is frustrated with the juvenile court, for protecting defendants like Ronald Duncan, who come from non abusive households and have too many privileges handed to him.

Read More
387 Words | 2 Pages

In Act I of the Crucible, by Arthur Miller, we are introduced to Reverend Hale, a “spiritual doctor” who comes to Salem as an authoritative figure on the science of demonology to try and assess whether the presence of witchcraft in Salem is true or false. However, as the play proceeds, we see Hale deviating from his original purpose and ideas. His intentions shift from figuring out whether or not witchcraft is afoot in Salem to the desire of making the accused confess to save themselves from being hanged. In Act II, after Hale has seen all of the girls confessing to seeing others with the Devil, such as Elizabeth Proctor, he goes to John Proctor’s house to find out more.

Read More
773 Words | 4 Pages

Innocent people who are incriminated under improper evidence are hanged. Parallel in the McMartin day care abuse case, the McMartin family, who administrate the establishment, and other members are accused illegally of having abused sexually numerously of the children under their vigilance. The accusations used against the McMartin

Read More
530 Words | 3 Pages

Human Nature has always been about survival and self-preservation. We see this repeated over and over in history, literature, and even in our own lives. “The Crucible”, written by Arthur Miller, is a web spun on deceit, lies, fear, and the strong will to preserve one’s self. Set in the late 1600’s, a witch hunt grips the small town of Salem throwing its residents into a state of constant hysteria. Many characters if not all, have been the spider and the fly, some more obvious to one side than others.

Read More
968 Words | 4 Pages

In Arthur Miller’s play “the Crucible”, Rev. Hale changes from narrow minded to regretful through Miller’s use of Rev. Hale’s actions, other characters reactions of him and his stage directions. Hale strictly follows the law to maintain order, and contributes to the beginning of the witch trials. As Hale arrives in Salem he shows that he is very serious about what he does. As Hale enters “He appears loaded down with half a dozen heavy books”(36). Hale seems to want to impress the others with his amazing knowledge on the subject of witchcraft.

Read More
801 Words | 4 Pages

The scapegoats of this trial were Ray Buckey, and several teachers at the preschool. Ray Buckey did have power, as the owner of the school, but he was accused of molesting a child, which then influenced every other parent's opinion on him. As people started to become suspicious of Buckey, the police took action; "the police conducted searches of Buckey's home, confiscating such 'evidence' as a rubber duck, a graduation robe, and Playboy magazines. Detective Hoag arrested Buckey on September 7, 1983. (Linder 1)

Read More
1446 Words | 6 Pages

Linda Sterling, her husband Ron, and their son Travis Sterling were accused of sexually abusing children at the Preschool. One day a little girl came home from daycare and her mother found redness and broken skin on her bottom, so she asked her about it and she replied “a stranger had been poking me with a pink rope, lives at Linda’s” (Pasiuk “Satanic Panic”). From there Martensville police was called and an investigation was opened up to investigate the incident and to take up statements. Soon after the Sterling’s were accused of ritual abuse, another teacher, Ray Buckey was accused of performing ritual abuse on his students in the underground tunnels of cemeteries near his Preschool.

Read More
1404 Words | 6 Pages

Injustice and hysteria are all too frequent in Arthur Miller’s The Crucible, as people become convinced that false statements and accusations with insufficient evidence are truthful. The people in Salem fall victim to false preconceptions of guilt about those accused, making it almost impossible for the accused to defend themself. Now, they have to prove innocence on top of already having to defend themselves from further accusations. In The Crucible, Miller conveys the idea that people tried in court should be seen as innocent until proven guilty to prevent hysteria and preconceptions ruin a fair trial through the actions of Abigail Williams, Judge Danforth, and Reverend Hale. Abigail Williams, the main accuser in The Crucible, plays a big

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

The witches are on the hunt for the innocent souls of Salem with Hale stating, “The Devil is alive in Salem, and we dare not quail to follow wherever the accusing finger points” (Miller 1251). Hale is determined to use God’s mighty hand against the “evil witches”. This shows that Hale is faithful to Abigail’s accusations against the common people of Salem. At first, Reverend Hale is eager to prosecute, but as more innocent people are condemned, his compliance turns into distaste. His dissatisfaction eventually turns into rage when Hale shouts, “I denounce these proceedings!”

Read More
419 Words | 2 Pages

I have seen too many frightful proofs in court - the Devil is alive in Salem, and we dare not quail to follow wherever the accusing finger points!” (Hale, Act 2) Hale proves the mindset of the characters affected by hysteria and fear. In his arguments it's more hysteria than

Read More
1158 Words | 5 Pages

The play illustrates how hysteria can lead to the breakdown of social order and how individuals can be swept up in the madness, losing sight of reality. The abuse of power is also demonstrated through the actions of characters such as Judge Danforth, who use their positions of authority to manipulate and control others. The concept of truth is also explored, as the characters grapple with the difficulty of discerning what is true in a world where lies and deception abound. Miller's play serves as a warning against the dangers of unchecked hysteria and the corrupting influence of power. By examining the Salem Witch Trials, Miller highlights the potential for individuals and societies to succumb to irrationality and the devastating consequences that can result.

Read More
1161 Words | 5 Pages

The drama demonstrates how hysteria may cause societal order to disintegrate and how people can become engulfed in the chaos and lose sight of reality. Characters like Judge Danforth, who abuse their positions of authority to manipulate and dominate others, provide more examples of how power may be abused. The idea of reality is also investigated, as the protagonists struggle to determine what is real in a setting where lies and deception are commonplace. The play by Miller serves as a warning about the dangers of unchecked fear and the skewed effects of power. By focusing on the Salem Witch Trials, Miller draws attention to the dangers of irrationality for both individuals and civilizations, as well as the devastation it may cause.

Read More
1122 Words | 5 Pages

The discretion of the case was significant in the regard of the defense, which countered some contradicted evidences. The evidences from the trial and the hearing preliminaries have revealed that the children were coached. The testimony showed lack of credibility on the issues and showing the significance of the discretion on the defense. McMartin told his attorney that he did not do it and his attorney used his discretion and believed him.

Read More

More about The Mcmartin Daycare Case Of The 1980s

Related Topics

Open Document