ipl-logo

The Monkey's Paw Movie And Book Comparison Essay

731 Words3 Pages

Many people watch movie versions of books they like. More often than not, there are slight alterations from the books in movie versions. This would be the case if one read “ The Monkey’s Paw” and then watched the short film rendition of it afterwards. There are a few similarities and differences between the two versions. The movie and book versions share both similarities and differences because the dialogue in the movie has been slightly altered from the dialogue in the book, the point of view stayed the same, and some characters’ reactions changed. One example of how “The Monkey’s Paw” is similar to the movie version, is that the theme is still the same . The theme of both versions is to be careful what you wish for. …show more content…

For example, in the book, Herbert asks his father to wish for 200 pounds, while in the film Herbert requests for his dad to wish for 300 pounds (The Monkey’s Paw 4). This is only one example of an instance in which the movie has different dialogue from the book. Another example is that while in the story, Mrs. White screams at hearing about her son's death, Mrs. White doesn’t scream, but faints in the film. Based on this, one can infer that the movie version of “The Monkey’s Paw” has different dialogue than the book …show more content…

In the text, the speaker refers to the characters as if they are on the outside looking in. One example of such language is when the speaker states, “Mr.White dropped his wife’s hand, and rising to his feet, stared with a look of horror at his visitor”(The Monkey’s Paw 6). The way that the narrator describes the characters is as if their experiences are a movie that they are watching. The narrator does not know their inner thoughts and feelings, much like the viewer does not know the characters’ inner thoughts and feelings while watching the movie. The viewer is simply on the outside looking in, similarly to the narrator. Based on this information, one can conclude that both the book version and the movie version of “The Monkey’s Paw”share a third person point of

Show More
Related
640 Words | 3 Pages

The movie gives her character the same temperament as in the text. The movie does the same for Herbert, for example, in both the text and movie Herbert is presented as a light-hearted character who does not believe in the monkey’s paw, but instead makes humourous jokes about the tales behind it. The movie does make his character seem a little older than what the text does, but his personality is the same as the text. Another character that is true to his role is Sergeant-Major Morris. His character in the text and movie is very dark and mysterious.

Read More
588 Words | 3 Pages

What would you do if someone questioned your every thought or action without even providing evidence why? In the story Doubt written by John Patrick Shanley, Father Flynn is accused of seducing a student by Sister Aloysius. I believe that Father Flynn is innocent of the accused acquisitions. Father Flynn continually sticks to his story. He claims that he only tired to help Donald as he was troubled and needed a friend to talk with.

Read More
619 Words | 3 Pages

Comparing the movie to the book, the reader realizes that many scenes were added to the television episode. Although the book and movie were alike in some ways, the book was less complicated and easier to understand. In my opinion, the movie differences were most likely due to the adaptation of the story to television. Ray Bradbury Published and presented an intriguing

Read More
314 Words | 2 Pages

For example, in the book, only one person drowns Pony, but in the movie, three people drowned him. This is different because in the book Pony is being drowned at the water fountain by only one person. On the other hand in the movie Pony is getting drowned by three people instead of one like it is in the story. Another comparison between the book and the movie would be when Ponyboy goes to court and doesn’t testify in the book, but in the movie he does. These are different because in the book when Pony has to go to court for the murder of Bob he doesn’t testify in the movie when he goes to court he does testify.

Read More
255 Words | 2 Pages

Although the book and movie are very similar, they also have many differences.

Read More
310 Words | 2 Pages

One scene that was altered that stood out the most was when Simon saw the pig’s head. In the book, the pig’s head talks to Simon as the lord of the flies, while in the movie the pig says nothing. Without the dialogue between Simon and the lord of the flies, the watcher is confused. The pig speaking to him symbolizes temptation and evil trying to take over, but Simon is the only one who knows what is going on with the boys and can save them from further depression. It takes away from the overarching theme of good versus evil.

Read More
606 Words | 3 Pages

In both the book and the movie, there are a lot of similarities but also some differences we see. The characters from the book act mostly the same in the movie. Lennie still has a mental disability and George is strict, but still loves Lennie.

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

Thesis: In The Monkey's Paw by W.W Jacobs, the realistic essence of the monkey's paw made it fundamentally creepy. Point 1: The monkey's paw is a symbol for inclination for greed, exposing our superior wants as people, even the most humble. Point 2: Consequences for the actions of those using the paw develops the image of regret and fear. Point 3:

Read More
435 Words | 2 Pages

In the monkey’s paw was supernatural events. The suspense in the monkey’s paw was that sergeant major Morris goes to tell the people in the house about the monkey’s paw, and shows the paw , and tells them

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever read a book and then watched a movie and noticed that some things were missing or gone when you looked back in the book to compare what was there and what was not? There are many differences, like how the movie changed a lot of the theme then, how the book described it, and how the film is more faithful than the book. The book is better because it tells a great story and explains what would happen to dogs if they were sled dogs. There is also a huge difference because they published the book in 1903 and made the movie in 2020. 1 Instincts.

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

The “Monkey’s Paw" is a short story and movie that are different in many ways. The "Monkey's Paw, " story and movie are being compared and contrasted. These pieces from the movie and the story state how the two share similarities and how they differ. The reading of the story and the watching of the movie have led me to know what happens throughout the story and movie. The reading of the story and the watching of the movie have led me to know what happens throughout the story and movie.

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

The message from the two passages are relatively the same based on the characters, events and plot. The main connections between the two articles are characters, theme, plot and authors point of view. The author of each story writes to entertain their audience. In the Monkeys Paw, the story starts off “Without, the night was cold and wet, but in the small parlor of Laburnum villa the blinds were drawn and the fire burned brightly”.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

The conflict in the story is not only the monkey’s paw but was somewhat Mr. White’s attitude. If he never was that greedy the story would have changed he would have agreed with Morris and burned the monkey’s paw but he didn’t want to do that creating the plot. Any change in the plot could have/ would have altered the course of the story but also altering the theme. In “The Monkey’s Paw,” the downfall of the White family is when they receive the two hundred pounds as a compensation for the son’s death which was actually caused by messing with fate.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

In my opinion there are a lot of comparisons between the film and the book, but there are also differences between them too, but also they have impacted the audience in both the film and the

Read More
825 Words | 4 Pages

In the short story, The Monkey 's Paw we are first introduced to the White, the Mrs.White, Mr.White, and their son, Herbert White. Later in the story, we are introduced to Sergeant Major Morris who brought the mummy-like monkey’s paw to the Whites house. The theme of the Monkey 's paw is to never interfere with fate. The theme is shown through many forms in the short story. The forms are the events, the foreshadowing, and the actions.

Read More

More about The Monkey's Paw Movie And Book Comparison Essay

Related Topics

Open Document