ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Keeping DNA Database

537 Words3 Pages

Law enforcement agencies should not be permitted to maintain DNA databases on the population. Yes, I understand the governments purpose of wanting a database to help with investigations and catching criminals, however, investigators could easily misuse the information and suspect an innocent person. If a database were to be created, the government would hold a large amount of power in their hands, which would contain private information on all citizens. The government would have control over its citizens. Collecting DNA from everyone and using it to convict both the innocent and criminals is unethical. The Las Vegas case in 2002 is one example which proves why it is unethical to keep DNA samples of innocent people. Keeping DNA of innocent people allows them to be suspects for any case. …show more content…

It’s one thing for police to have to have access to the database, but for it to be in access to all citizens is just wrong. It would be greatly misused, abused, and people would be convicted for the wrong crime. With the DNA database being open to all citizens, more harm would be done than good. Since the government would be in charge of the database, they would have access to information on every single citizen. There will always be people against the government, and now with their DNA in a government database, the government can trace any information they need about certain individuals. We don’t need to question whether or not the government would abuse the database because we already know they would. We know this because the UK currently has a DNA database of its people, and it constantly gets misused and is not left secure. DNA information is extremely personal and valuable whether it gets into the hands of criminals or insurance companies and should not be

Show More
Related

Penal Code 1405 Research Paper

1964 Words | 8 Pages

The Department of Justice says, "States began passing laws requiring offenders convicted of certain offenses to provide DNA samples. " That DNA evidence can help convict someone of a crime and it helps to uncover more things about the crime itself. Investigators have been using forensic science to help them solve cases since before the 90 's, mostly fingerprints that were found at the crime scenes and on the victims (O 'Brien). DNA evidence has solved countless cases including ones that happened over a prolonged period of time because of the technological advancements there is

Read More

Todd Willingham Corsicana Case

559 Words | 3 Pages

Before the advancements in science and DNA discovery, there have been many men and woman executed for a crime he/ she did not commite. After DNA was discovered there have been cases where DNA has exonerated date row inmates. If DNA wasn't discovered many men and women would have been executed and if DNA testing was available earlier it would have easily proven that Cameron Todd Willingham, Corsicana, Texas was innocent.

Read More

Summary: Texan Who Died In Prison Cleared Of Rape

744 Words | 3 Pages

It is a great technological innovation that can help bring evidences and fact faster. In the article The DNA Wars Are Over, “Forensic use of DNA technology in criminal cases began in 1986… In one of the first uses of DNA in a criminal case in the United States, in November 1987.” Sadly in 1985, DNA testing was not popular in the U.S. investigation and was not available in Cole’s case. I believe the U.S. court system is improving and yes there are a lot mistrials and wrongful conviction cases, but you cannot avoid the fact that DNA testing can bring better truth than just relying on statements of both

Read More

Podcast Of Serial: Sarah Koenig's Case

1460 Words | 6 Pages

It can refute a claim of self-defense and put a weapon in the suspect's hand. It can change a story from an alibi to one of consent. The more officers know how to use DNA, the more powerful a tool it becomes.” This proves that DNA evidence is very reliable and is hard evidence that cannot be argued upon. DNA is either found at the scene of the crime or isn’t.

Read More

Why Is Gary Ridgway Called The Green River Killer?

657 Words | 3 Pages

Without the help of DNA, connecting offenders to their victims and the scene of the crime, so many cases would be left unsolved. Shockingly enough, it wasn’t until 1984 where DNA was used for biological identification. Once DNA started to play such a big role in criminal justice, many cases where they didn’t have enough evidence to prosecute, were brought to court and finally solved. Even though there was such a large gap in when the offenses were first committed and when they were solved, there was still justice for the victims and their families. An important case where DNA changes everything would be that of Gary Ridgway, otherwise known as the green river killer.

Read More

Analysis Of The Supreme Court Case Of Maryland V. King

980 Words | 4 Pages

For example, Maryland believed that DNA analysis helps to identify suspects more accurately and reduce future crimes, which would boost the public's confidence in law enforcement. The State even claimed that without the DNA Collection Act, which enabled the police to cheek swab from King, they would not have connected King to the sexual assault that he was ultimately accused of. Nevertheless, there is a risk in allowing Maryland to enforce its DNA Act for the purpose of only removing violent offenders. King actually acknowledges that DNA collection is beneficial because arrestees are more likely to have committed other crimes but hypothesizes that this logic can also be applied for other subgroups as well. For instance, young men, residents of particular neighborhoods, individuals from particular socioeconomic or educational backgrounds, or any other group that has a high incidence of criminal activity can be accused.

Read More

Comparison Of Ancestrydna And Atlas Biomed

1740 Words | 7 Pages

The main issue people have with DNA tests is privacy. An individual's DNA is immensely more exclusive than a social security number and in the wrong hands, your life could be at risk. If a database filled with millions of DNA samples from people all around the world; it takes only one person to breach the “security” and peoples DNA would then be readily available to anyone in the public. People can potentially analyze your DNA and see what bacteria or viruses your DNA is most vulnerable to, and use it against you. Additionally insurance companies could potentially obtain the results of a DNA test and see that you have an incredibly high probability of developing breast cancer.

Read More

Phyllis Hennem Investigative Genetic Genealogy

1159 Words | 5 Pages

Today, the FBI has DNA records of more than 5 million convicted offenders in the database CODIS, or Combined DNA Index System. However, DNA fingerprinting has limitations: it is limited to directly connecting crimes to felons already in CODIS, has high risk of contamination, does not look at familial records, and only analyzes short pieces of DNA. With the advent of more affordable and high resolution genetic technologies after The Human Genome Project, over 35 million people have submitted their DNA to the largest direct-to-consumer genetic companies. Two companies, FamilyTreeDNA and GEDmatch, also allow law enforcement access to their databases. Thus, beginning investigative genetic genealogy, a new method of forensic investigation not only with higher resolution DNA information than DNA fingerprinting but also the capability of finding a suspect from distant relatives.

Read More

The Case Of Timothy Cole

2295 Words | 10 Pages

The impact of Tim’s case was also felt on a national and even international level, as it shed light on the importance of using accurate and scientific evidence in the legal system and the need to reform the criminal justice system to prevent wrongful convictions. Tim’s story has inspired many other cases to be re-opened and re-examined, leading to the exoneration of several other innocent individuals. Overall, the case of Tim Cole has had a profound impact on the criminal justice system and has helped to bring about important changes in the use of DNA

Read More

Arguments Against The 4th Amendment

1073 Words | 5 Pages

In 2009, Alonzo King, Jr. was arrested for violent assault charges and while in custody, the police took his DNA and logged into the Maryland DNA Database. His DNA was matched to the DNA in an unsolved rape case. The Maryland DNA Collection Act (MDCA) allows police officers to collect DNA samples of people under arrest for violent crimes or attempted violent crimes. However, in court, King appealed to have the conviction because the MDCA was against his IV amendment rights because his DNA was taken without a search warrant. The Maryland Court of Appeals reversed the conviction stating that the MDCA was infact unconstitutional, because King’s expectation of privacy was greater than the interest of Maryland in using DNA samples for the purpose of identification.

Read More

Fourth Amendment Essay Examples

630 Words | 3 Pages

In King, Justice Kennedy referred to the invention of DNA technology as “one of the most significant scientific advancements of our era.” This statement has been criticized, but the impact of DNA technology has been significant. Currently, forensic analysts can use “junk” DNA to identify a person with near certainty. Law enforcement can collect a person’s DNA through saliva. The sample is then uploaded to CODIS, a national network of DNA databases.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of GINA

573 Words | 3 Pages

For instance, in the event in which law enforcement needs to investigate criminal acts to prove someone innocent or guilty. For example Maryland vs King which states that when a police officer arrest someone because they have a suspect of a serious offence , they make need a cheek swab to rove that the suspect is innocent or guilty because of DNA left at the crime scene. Another positive outcome is that your doctors will be able to detect genetic diseases or cancer and treat it before it becomes a problem or takes effect. Although there are many positive outcomes there is a law that does protect you genome. The Genetic Information and Nondiscrimination Act or GINA protects the genetic privacy of the public.

Read More

Post Conviction Dna Testing Essay

957 Words | 4 Pages

All state justice systems should allow post-conviction DNA testing and the collection of DNA from suspects. This will help the wrongly convicted to prove their innocence and avoid the death penalty, and also have the chance at exoneration. Law enforcement should collect DNA from suspects to prove if suspects truly are innocent or guilty. As well as require state officials to properly catalogue and preserve biological evidence for as long as the suspect is incarcerated. DNA testing is an important way for those who have been wrongly convicted to prove their innocence.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Misdemeanor Convicts

661 Words | 3 Pages

While there are many arguments out there as to why an individual who has been convicted of a misdemeanor crime should have his or her DNA collected, we must not only look at the practicality of this, but also the facts. A law of this magnitude could open the flood gates to a massive invasion of privacy. Many supporters of this law claim oftentimes misdemeanor convicts go on to commit more serious crimes, so having their DNA in the system will help identify them sooner if they commit a crime. This invasion of privacy not only assumes that a misdemeanor convict will become a serious convict in the future,

Read More

Forensic Testing Essay

1095 Words | 5 Pages

This could be fatal because then a person could be wrongly convicted of a crime or even let free if he committed the crime and who knows if he won’t do it again? ● The equipment used in forensic testing can be very expensive and will cost a lot of money. ● Misleading or false DNA can easily be placed at the crime scene. As a result the wrong person will be arrested and the people who actually committed is still running around free. ● The DNA information is on a computer and can be vulnerable to exploitation from hackers.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Keeping DNA Database

Related Topics

Open Document