ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Offender Profiling

1011 Words5 Pages

To start with, do you know that what is offender profiling? Different authors have defined offender profiling by using different terms such as specific profile analysis, psychological profiling, criminal profiling and criminal personality profiling. However, the basic concept of definitions remains the same (Jackson and Bekerian, 1997). Beauregard, Lussier and Proulx (2005) state that offender profiling provides some descriptive information on the behaviors and individuality of an offender. Number of suspects can be narrowed and finally solve the cases by analyzing the crime scene features. Muller (2000) describes the information which the criminal profile uses is often taken from the scene of crime, profilers will take into consideration with …show more content…

Third, there are many ways that crime analysis benefits law enforcement. But, there isn’t any offender profiling can be correct completely. Take a medical doctor as an example. What is a doctor’s job? Doctors can help treating patients. So, what is the doctor’s role? Doctor practice medicine. No doctor can guarantee that he can help you cure your disease. In addition, doctors cannot even guarantee that they will not make you worse. Why? If the medicine is a science, why the doctors do not write out the agreement, stating that you will be one hundred percentages cured in the treatment of a certain process? This is because, although the medicine is a science, doctors according to their specialty practice. By the same token, offender profiling may not always be one completely true, but based on the experts under thousands of cases, with their many years of experience and use their expertise to work. Offender profiling is only one of many tools for the police criminal investigation. Sometimes, it can help police to reduce time to narrow the focus in the investigation. In many cases, it can also help the police to reiterate what detectives has already known. Research done by the analyzer has helped the police to focus on the rights of the murder suspects. In addition, the analyzer provides specifically for the interview with the detective suspects were questioned design skills. These will help to stimulate the information may not be brought in other ways. Offenders profile does …show more content…

Importantly, criminal profile maybe misleads police. It maybe allow the criminal to escape detection, police cannot arrest the offender as soon as possible. It will let an innocent person may be dead as a result. One of the case in Hong Kong in 2006, the offender Tsui Po Ko, he was a police constable in the Hong Kong Police Force. He was commit bank robbery and murder. During the investigation, police are narrowing down an area of suspects that the offender was a left-handed person. It is because the CCTV displayed that the person who commit the bank robbery is holding a gun with the left-hand. Then, police narrowed down the area of suspects, Tsui Po was not a suspect in the crime area so that police cannot arrest the offender as soon as possible. But, this does not imply that profiles should be ignored or should never be used by police again, but that profiling should be approached with caution. Criminal profiling should not be blindly accepted or should not be relied on because it may be something that may not have any relationship to the real

Show More
Related
426 Words | 2 Pages

In the article, “Beware the Biomarkers for Criminal Behavior,” Kira Peikoff analyzes the expanding use of brain imaging and biomarkers to predict criminal behavior. She describes the expansion of these technological advancements as a possible violation to an individual’s basic civil rights of innocent until proven guilty. Piekoff expresses that with these growing advancements in this technology a fine line between science and morality should be explored with caution. Our society today may consist of individuals with mental defects, but where is the line drawn in depicting a future crime without infringing on an individual 's basic civil rights. Peikoff provides three distinguishable premises in her article.

Read More
1085 Words | 5 Pages

"Racial Profiling and Criminal Justice." The Journal of Ethics, vol. 15, no. 1-2, 2011. , pp. 79-88. Nclive, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10892-010-9098-3.

Read More
626 Words | 3 Pages

David Canter’s intriguing novel conveys the psychology deeply rooted within these criminals that link them to the crimes they committed. Criminal shadows entails the distinctive “shadows” remaining from each crime that helps lead police straight to the criminals. The wide array of criminal offenders and their unique crime style gave way to psychologists and police officers to piece together bits of significant information to profile a criminal. These miscreants look like ordinary people, like you and me, the only difference is that they perform heinous acts of violence. The techniques and evaluations discussed in this novel eventually helped the future of taking down the criminals.

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

They use an ability called crime analysis. Crime analysis is a law enforcement technique that involves systematic analysis. They use it to find patterns and trends in criminals. When a criminal kills people that all look the same that would be a pattern. If someone kills people that all look alike it usually means someone that looks like that hurt the

Read More
352 Words | 2 Pages

How they use the technique is misleading. Profiling “blends law enforcement with psychology to develop a better understanding or description of offenders (Huet, 2012, p. 1)”. Profiling is a central part of the show’s plot. The team works together to discuss cases, quickly determines crucial identifying factors about the suspects with incredible accuracy, and catch the killers quite easily. That’s just not how it works.

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

Basic scientists are individuals who prefer to study occurrences in order to gather a better understanding to satisfy their curiosity. This process doesn’t resolve in answering the question but rather gaining the knowledge (Greene & Heilbrun, 2014). The basic scientists’ role in law enforcement is to conduct “research on the relationship between social attitudes and behavior can clarify why people obey or disobey the law” (Greene & Heilbrun, 2014). This predation is transferred to the courtroom through testimony and

Read More
586 Words | 3 Pages

I determined these questions by thinking about what professional profilers might ask if they were studying this crime as

Read More
1309 Words | 6 Pages

With a plethora of movies, shows, and books about crime scene profiling these days, one might believe that F.B.I. criminal profiling is an exact science. These dramatic stories lead their audience to view F.B.I. profilers as scientific experts who are able to make pin point predictions of a killer’s entire life, leading to an arrest. The reality, however, is that crime scene profiling is not quite as dramatic or accurate as depicted on the big screen or in best-selling books about the topic. More importantly, it is not a scientific approach to solving crimes. This paper explores the notion of criminal profiling as contextualized in the article; "Dangerous Minds: Criminal Profiling Made Easy" written by Malcolm Gladwell and aims to show how

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

Recently, law enforcement agencies have returned to using profiling, even if the definition of a serial killer has never been made specific. Since then many methods of profiling have been put in play. Von Krafft-Ebing's book is still used as the basis of modern criminal profiling. This old book “ Psychopathia sexualis” describes different characteristics of serial killers. Since then profiling has expanded but how has it been modified?

Read More
883 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction: • Offender profiles are extremely useful in all types of police investigations. • Offender profiles narrow down potential suspects leading to quicker arrests, they can be applied in virtually all types of crime and can give another avenue into finding the offender if there is a lack of physical evidence at a crime scene. Grounds I: Narrow down potential suspects in a crime Evidence/Reason: • As evidenced in the case study “State of California v. Louis J. Peoples.” , offender profiling was conducted in a serial killer investigation in which the profile showed that the suspect knew the area. After a spree of murders, it took only one day from when the profile was provided, to lead to an arrest of the murderer who was a local

Read More
266 Words | 2 Pages

Racial Profiling is when a certain ethnicity is categorized into police and society. This is important because people are prone to judge and label a person for their race. “Since the terrorist attacks in the United States on September 11, 2001, security profiling has targeted people of Arab descent or those who are believed to be Muslims. ”(Racial Profiling). Recently racial profiling has been an issue in the media and local facilities.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

n.d.). Even though, in 1997 in the United Kingdom profiling assisted investigators in furthering their understanding of the case. There was only a small percentage of cases reported that profiling had assisted the police in solving the actual case and there was even a smaller percentage of reporting that the usage of profiling helped police in identifying the criminal in a case. Yet, 82.6% of those interviewed had said that profiling was operationally useful and 60.9% stated that profiling enhanced their understanding of the case they were handling (abrbradozier.wordpress.com. n.d.). Profiling has seemed to work best for serial crimes such as rape and murder.

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

Racial profiling has become a national issue starting in 2015 (“Racial”). Judging someone for their race has been a problem ever since a minority group has been noticed. Racial profiling has spread over all over the world. Racial profiling has been a problem through the years, if the human race can learn what racial profiling is, advantages of the profiling, and the disadvantages.

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

Profiling serial killers has proven to be a difficult task because despite the fact that serial murders have been recorded since the 1400’s, there are multiple definitions of what a serial killer actually is. In the article, “The Use of Criminal Profilers in the Prosecution of Serial Killers” by Chelsea van Aken, she explains the different definitions of what make a serial killer, a serial killer. According to Van Aken, “The FBI characterizes a serial killer as an individual who has various degrees of a personality disorder and unlawfully kills two or more individuals at different times.” The FBI’s behavioral unit, also known as the National Center for the Analysis of Violent Crime, is currently the leading organization in profiling serial

Read More
164 Words | 1 Pages

Criminal profiling is defined as an investigative and behavioral tool that is aimed at assisting those in the investigative field in profiling criminal offenders who are in most cases unknown. Criminal profiling goes by many names, such as: offender profiling, criminological profiling, criminal investigative analysis, criminal personality profiling and behavioral profiling. Criminal profilers are agents that study and analyze the behavior of an unknown criminal based on information that is gathered by his or her kills. The Federal Bareau of Investigation, or the Behavioral Analysis Unit rely on criminal profilers to provide psychological profiles of the offender. Technically, there is no official job title in the F.B.I called “criminal profiler.”

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Offender Profiling

Related Topics

Open Document