ipl-logo

The Responsibility Of Odysseus Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

662 Words3 Pages

Will Cho
Period 7
October 19, 2015
In Book 1, Telemachus replies to his mother, “Poets are not to blame, but Zeus who gives / what fate he pleases to adventures men” (12). Telemachus is implying that humans do not have a say in their life (free will), and fate is responsible for human actions. However, free will is supported by evidences suggested by the book. Despite the fact that fate may have a minimal role, free will and the individual themselves is ultimately responsible for their actions. In the epic of The Odyssey, the individual has a free will and is responsible for human beings’ actions because although fate may give the chance, the person has to chose to utilize the chance and fulfill the destiny. Zeus mentioned exasperatedly in Book 1, “My word, how mortals take the gods to task! All their affliction come …show more content…

Odysseus’ crew raided the land of the Cyclopes and waited for the inhabitants to come back. Polyphemus came back, ate 2 of the Akhaians, and left the others to groan and wait for the morning (154). Odysseus, in the morning, gave Polyphemus alcohol to become drunk, stabbed him in the eye with a scalding hot hand spike, and escaped underneath Polyphemus’ handsome, fat, dark violet rams. Odysseus says his name is “Nobody” at first, but then he foolishly screams his true name after his ship was out of Polyphemus’ throwing range. Polyphemus prayed to his father Poseidon to curse Odysseus with loneliness and bitter days at home (160-161). Poseidon blocked Odysseus' attempts to return to Ithaca as punishment for him blinding Poseidon's son Polyphemus. Although Poseidon did curse Odysseus’ destiny, the Great Tactician used his wits and still found his way back to Ithaca. This is an example of how free will is responsible. Fate is a guide or more like an obstacle in this case, not the main lead. Odysseus’ choice to go home is the ultimate responsible for his

Show More
Related
813 Words | 4 Pages

Sometimes Odysseus’s emotional need for rest and relaxation got the best of him, but that was only on one occasion. Odysseus made the selection to use his motives and emotions to choose the right way of path and ultimately save him from what could've been a deadly consequence. One trial where is occurred is when the crew was getting caught up in the moment with the Cicones, Odysseus made the choice not to get caught up in victory, but to continue going on his journey. If Odysseus were to of been in that mindset, all of the crew could’ve possibly gotten killed. “Then I urged them to cut and run, set sail, / but

Read More
1666 Words | 7 Pages

Depending on Others, Can Teach Self-dependence From a young age people are often told, contradictory things. People are told that they should try to do things on their own, but are also told that, if they need help they should ask for it. These conflicting messages are exceptionally difficult for soldiers trying to assimilate back into society after the war. As soldiers return home, they often try to live self-dependently, but sometimes they need help and have to depend on others. This effects Odysseus because when he needs help, he has to rely on the gods to lead him the right way.

Read More
544 Words | 3 Pages

But the most dangerous action that was a barrier towards his motives of going home was with the Cyclopes. This was when his mens were killed from the Cyclopes. This is an example of the danger that Odysseus faces when returning back to his kingdom that also affected the lives of his fellow mens. But this danger we know that fate is also on Odysseus side. We know this because when Odysseus want his four men's to draw the shortest straw, those four mens that was with Odysseus, just happen to draw the shortest straw.

Read More
1189 Words | 5 Pages

In Homer’s The Odyssey, Odysseus experiences a powerful craving on his journey home. He must pass the island of the Sirens in order to return home but also must avoid landing there; doing so would mean certain death for him and his crew. Although he cannot control his impulses in the moment, Circe’s keen advice beforehand and his crew’s steadfastness save Odysseus from his own desire. In looking at The Odyssey, we will consider Circe’s directions to Odysseus and the way the Sirens and Odysseus act at their meeting to find that Odysseus cannot control his appetite and needs specific guidelines, in this case from Circe, to survive a life-or-death situation.

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

These stories prove that Odysseus made all of his own decisions and he is the one to blame for many of the deaths of his men. In conclusion, there are many more times in The Odyssey where Odysseus sacrificed more and more of his men because of his own choices and

Read More
815 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine being were swept away from home, away from everything that was dear, to fight a war that was not your own. Odysseus, King of Ithica, was sent into battle soon after his son was born. The great warrior he is, allowed him to win, but due to his overwhelming, vainglorious shouts of victory turned the god Poseidon against him. Poseidon vowed to not let him return to his homeland and set him keep him at sea forever. In his journey to find his way home, Odysseus and his crew encounter many obstacles that hindered his success which leads to the transferring of responsibility.

Read More
274 Words | 2 Pages

In Homer’s Odyssey, Zeus, in utter exasperation and discontent, condemns one of the grave follies of mortals—shedding blame on the gods for all their misfortunes. Continuing his expression of disdain, Zeus implies that humans beings only suffer calamity and sorrow because they are foolish and disregard the bad omens and prophecies which are given to them by the gods. Zeus, to support his argument, gives the example of Aegisthus, who was killed for committing crimes against his kinsmen after he was thoroughly forewarned by the gods to not plot such a thing. Certainly, Zeus, or even perhaps Homer, is wholly under the impression that humans are the cause of their own trials and tribulations because of their callous decisions. Indeed, this is a

Read More
1092 Words | 5 Pages

This portrays the fate of the suitor’s that was emanating from the gods due to the suitor’s choices. This confirms the free will representing the actions that were acceptable in the myth. Odyssey represented the free will as it allowed choices to be made by the people. For example, the choice made by Odysseus in disguising himself rather than going direct to tell his wife that he had come home.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

Fate and destiny are very important parts in The Odyssey. Many gods and goddesses find their fate and destiny through the choices they make. For example, in Book 9, the Cyclopes predicts Odysseus’ destiny. “...Grant that Odysseus, raider of cities, never see his home… Should destiny intend that he shall see his roof again among his family and his father

Read More
1197 Words | 5 Pages

Surya Govindaswaami Vidya Madavan English A HL 3 May 2016 The Influence of Divine Intervention on the Portrayal of Fate and Free Will in The Odyssey by Homer The Odyssey is not only considered one of the most prolific mythological epics of all time, but one of the greatest texts written by man. It recounts the arduous journey of the war hero Odysseus, in which he faced a multitude of adversities and obstacles that he had to overcome, as well as numerous challenges upon his arrival.

Read More
1262 Words | 6 Pages

Should destiny intend he shall see his roof again among his family in his fatherland, far be that day, and dark the years between. Let him lose all companions, and return under strange sail to bitter days at home.’ In these words he prayed, and the god heard him” (161, 176-186). Polyphemus prayed that Odysseus would have a hard voyage home, and his father heard his request and went through with it. This shows that Poseidon loves Polyphemus and cares for him; he is avenging

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

The Odyssey In Homer’s epic, The Odyssey, Odysseus is bestowed with great abilities. But along with this potential, he is cursed with great arrogance. Conveying that even the labeled ‘perfect’ among us have fatal flaws that causes pain and suffering among the ones closest to them. The author, Homer, uses Odysseus’ arrogance to create a melancholic atmosphere to convey the idea that arrogance is a fatal flaw that will lead those around them to pain and suffering.

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

Poseidon, Apollo, Athena, Zeus, and Hermes are all Greek Gods that appear in the epic poem The Odyssey by Homer. These gods all play a significant role in The Odyssey by both helping and hindering Odysseus on his 10-year journey home. Homer illustrates the theme of divine intervention in The Odyssey using Poseidon’s wrath, Athena’s providence, and Hermes’ guidance. Poseidon is one of the main gods that appears throughout The Odyssey, Homer shows Poseidon's divine intervention through his wrath on Odysseus during his journey home.

Read More
155 Words | 1 Pages

So it may be that the gods have some control over fate and destiny, but there is also the chance that the actions of men can also affect their own fate and destiny. This epic poem allows both the audience and the ancient Greeks to ruminate about the place of mortals in the entire universe as well as attempt to comprehend how much free will mortals are actually given. Without this topic, there would be no conversation on how the Greek religion

Read More
1217 Words | 5 Pages

It has been noticed that the actions taken place in the Iliad could become impregnated without any intervention of the gods. On the other hand, others disagree with the fact that nothing happens in the poem without the inducing of the gods. The role of fate and the of gods in the Iliad both play a major part. The actions of the god can affect the men fighting in the battle but regardless what the gods do they still cannot change or stop the fate, if it is prearranged that one must die, the gods only play part in how the person will die. Even though they play a role in how fate runs its course, even the gods are bound by fate, the extent to which Zeus is “bound” by fate—as oppose to the understandable “binding” of only mortals that is left arguable.

Read More

More about The Responsibility Of Odysseus Free Will In Homer's Odyssey

Related Topics

Open Document