ipl-logo

The Soul Substance Experiment: Bad Science

494 Words2 Pages

The Soul Substance experiment was bad science because many errors were made and it greatly affected the results and the credibility of the experiment. Scientist Duncan MacDougall's results were inconsistent, the sample size was too small and he tried to prove his argument instead of disproving it, this demonstrates how the soul substance experiment was bad science. The results from this experiment were very inconsistent, therefore it is very hard to create a solid conclusion from this experiment. On lines 70, 71, 81, 82, 83 and 84 The article talks about results from his experiment. The results vary greatly, one person's soul went immediately from the body and others came out in pieces. There is no explanation for it and that makes the results very hard to understand. On lines 113 and 114, the scientist talks about how we did the same experiment with dogs and he got very different results. He found that none of the dogs weights changed after they died. This is poor science because he doesn't have enough consistent evidence to make a valid point. All of his results were very different from each other and this shows that the results were not consistent to prove a point. …show more content…

According to lines 85 and 95, only six people were tested on and two out of the six people tested did not count because there was an error made while experimenting. Only four people were used to prove his point that is not enough for he's beliefs to become a common, Predictable and provable result. This is poor science because the sample size is too small, maybe these results are specific to only these four people and you would get different results if you tested it on

Show More
Related
1124 Words | 5 Pages

He utilizes a study from New York about inappropriate teacher-student behavior in the state, but fails to specify what exactly it says or who did the study. Not only that, but he lacks to name the study, who studied it, and what exactly the numbers are. This leads the reader to believe that his claim of the study may be insubstantial and possibly false or misleading. His claim fails here because he just assumes that his audience will just take his word for it. Giving a paraphrase of a graph can be easily biased towards one side, as one can say that the rates went up, and the audience will misconstrue that as a drastic change, rather than a possibly normal spike that occurs with nature.

Read More
913 Words | 4 Pages

B 9). He based his claim on common knowledge of the makeup

Read More
383 Words | 2 Pages

The data obtained (energy content) in the experiment was significantly inaccurate compared to the actual energy content of the marshmallows. Even though the result was inaccurate it still agreed with the hypothesis, the white/original marshmallows have slightly lower calories (energy content) compare to the coloured marshmallows. In my opinion, this slight change in calories occurred because one of ingredient, food colouring. Though food colouring doesn’t have much effect on the calories yet, it still affects the overall calories to a certain extent. Therefore the investigation agreed to the hypothesis to a certain extent.

Read More
985 Words | 4 Pages

The book "Soul by Soul" talks about one of the largest antebellum slave market that has happened in the South, specifically, in New Orleans. The author, Walter Johnson, describes the slave "pens" of New Orleans to establish a full understanding on how the American slave system worked. While in the pens, slaves were locked in cages or cells. A tight jail for hundreds of slaves with poor sanitary conditions, smells, and noise from all the slaves living together inside the Crammed quarters. Basically, a life as cattle living packed in a stable.

Read More
1241 Words | 5 Pages

For many years, the creation of man-made medicine has gone through many trial and error, progress and complication. One major way in which medicine has thrived was through the form of experiments, some on animals, plants and humans. Unfortunately, certain medical experiments have had drastic consequences. The Tuskegee Experiment was a medical experiment used to study the long-term effects of syphilis of not treated. In 1932, the Public Health Service together with the Tuskegee Institute, began an experiment to record the long-term effects of syphilis which also became a strict medical treatment programs for blacks.

Read More
1205 Words | 5 Pages

He does not bring statistics into the article until it is almost completed, and he only cites two statistics that pertain to his argument. He references that, “[h]igh

Read More
1890 Words | 8 Pages

In many ways Quieting a Noisy Soul is closely related to concepts like 'pray your weight away ', particularly in regards to how religious elements become a tool to combat a profane problem. The religious context itself is taken from Evangelical as well as Baptist traditions. Jim Berg, the Author, has studied at the Bob Jones University himself, and received an honorary doctor of divinity degree from the Tabernacle Baptist Theological Seminary ("Jim Berg"). The University itself was founded by an evangelist named Bob Jones Sr. in 1927 and created as a "thoroughly Christian college" supposed to follow a program which would follow the "absolute authority of the Bible" to shape American students ("History of BJU").

Read More
426 Words | 2 Pages

In which he found that test retest reliability after 48 days wad lower than desirable. This is this is

Read More
1694 Words | 7 Pages

He didn’t care to admit that the inference had any validity.” (Matheson, 49-50) he discusses with

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

The author’s claim could be true but he has a lack of evidence to support, which makes it hard for readers to agree with that

Read More
251 Words | 2 Pages

The researcher agree with the reasoning given by the chairman

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

In the movie, there are 24 students chosen to participate in the experiment. The researchers conducted series of interviews to eliminate applicants that have psychological

Read More
1015 Words | 5 Pages

In fact, although science creates a feeling of uncertainty in our existence, humans do everything possible to discover more in order to innovate, evolve, and possess even a greater knowledge of the universe. Actually, a group of scientist and scholars predicted that after the fall and decline of the Roman Empire, with the increase of scientific development, the descent of religious and spiritual beliefs would be inevitable, but as time evolved, faith increased in the same rate as science increased in a global scale. This correlation expresses how as humanity obtains more knowledge of the universe, it needs to also have a strong sense of belonging in order to tolerate all the discoveries and still possess a purpose of living and continue innovating

Read More
708 Words | 3 Pages

His experiment was all a hoax. The shock machine was fake. All he wanted was to know how many people would be obedient and how many would be defiant. Much to Milgram’s surprise sixty-five percent of people did what were told of them, and only thirty-five percent were

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

He first took a poll on how his experiment would turn out. He asked residents of New Haven, Yale undergraduates, and a group of psychiatrists how they thought a group of people would behave in this situation he wanted to enact. They all told him the same answer, and predicted that every person who was to be involved in this experiment would not go all the way and shock someone all the way up to 450 volts (Slater, 40). He ended up with the result of 65% were obedient, and the other 35% were defiant. Why didn’t the 35% carry out the experiment?

Read More

More about The Soul Substance Experiment: Bad Science

Related Topics

Open Document