ipl-logo

To What Extent Was Captain Edward Smith To Blame For The Titanic

704 Words3 Pages

Titanic
1500 people died on the catastrophic night of April 14th, riding the Titanic. The ship had around 2240 people on it and over half perished. Captain Edward Smith was to drive the ship from England to New York. Smith went to school as a child, but dropped out at age 12 to be a sailor. He had sailed a lot of cargo ships, but not many passenger ships. Smith sailed a vessel similar to the Titanic, called the Olympic, but a British Royal Navy cruiser crashed into the side of it. Captain Edward Smith was responsible for sinking the Titanic because of his experience, the warnings he was given, and the speed he put the ship at.
Captain Edward Smith is responsible for sinking the Titanic partly because of his education and experience. Growing up, he didn’t have much schooling or navy training.“Smith finished school at 12 years old and took to the sea as a teenager... He did work his way up the ranks and earn certifications in handling cargo vessels, but that had nothing to do with the enormous responsibility that goes …show more content…

They were trying to beat out the speed of other ships coming across the Atlantic to get more customers.“Bruce Ismay, the managing director of the White Star Line, put pressure on Smith to maintain the ship's speed.” (Kasey Butcher Santana, 2022) However, Captain Smith didn’t have to listen to him. A captain is always responsible for its passengers, and if they were in danger he should have done something. “Instead, a captain would have been expected to be responsible for the vessel and its crew.” (Ian Fortey, 2022). The safety of his passengers is more important than trying to make it across the Atlantic the fastest. Captain Smith should have ignored the pressure from the White Star Line, and slowed down for the safety of himself and his passengers. This is why it is Captain Edward Smith’s fault that the Titanic

Show More
Related
919 Words | 4 Pages

Passengers scrambled back to rooms for life jackets. Then, a second explosion shook the ship, believed to be a steam pressure drop. With the ship moving at 18 knots the water flooding in caused the bow to sink and the stern to lift, and a list towards the starboard, as a result of the empty coal bunker filling up. The men in the forward baggage holds, where the torpedo hit, were all killed or trapped, and they knew how to launch a life boat. The deck was in chaos, the starboard boats were too far for a person to get in them off the deck and the port ones were not over the water.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

“Walter lord brings up during the novel that the reason why most passengers aboard the ship died was due to them not having access to the lifeboats on the Titanic. It mentions, “Especially when everyone realized there weren't enough boats for everyone.” If the Titanic never took this “risk” and experimented with not adding enough lifeboats, we wouldn't know nowadays that boats would need so many lifeboats in case of emergencies. With this, Walter Lord describes the cause and effect of this risk that led to a tragedy. He mentions, “Third officer Pitman…heard the cries…pitman was toned by the dilemma.”

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Causes: When the titanic sank to the bottom of the ocean; it was 70 years until the wreckage was found by an expedition that was run by a famous oceanographer. Course: The unsinkable ship was out at sea for 3 days and hit an iceberg and 2 ½ hours to sink everyone was not able to be saved. The lifeboats could have held around 1000 people but only 705 people were saved. 1,500 people died that night.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

The Titanic, most definitely man’s greatest accomplishment, is made in Belfast, Ireland, where it is then set off into the open ocean, and set for Southampton, England. From there, on April 11, 1912, 2:00 p.m., the Titanic sets sail for New York. All seems well, and it looks for the first time, that man has built the “unsinkable ship.” However, the hopes, lives, ship and all are cut down by an iceberg and now rest at the bottom of the Atlantic. This horrendous fact was shown in both the book and the movie, “A Night to Remember,” along with many other facts and stories.

Read More
1798 Words | 8 Pages

In some instances, “the captain got his command from a merchant or group of merchants who own the ship and financed the voyage” (Rediker 190). Merchants would instruct captains which slaves to purchase, what goods to exchange, and how to ultimately treat and discipline the African captives and sailors. Additionally, merchants would instruct slave ship captains to “treat the slaves kindly, but not too kindly” (Rediker 197). These slave voyages were performed in order to advance profits.

Read More
1147 Words | 5 Pages

He would have no idea what awaited for himself and the other was colored people that were put on the ship. On the journey over, Smith was very nearly killed by some fellow African Americans on the ship, with them shouting that they wanted to “throw him overboard!” (Sparks, 1975.). If it wasn’t for the ship’s captain and a person that Smith referred to as “L”, then he would have been thrown overboard while he was still in chains. Once the ship had docked Smith recalls that it docked in New Orleans,

Read More
400 Words | 2 Pages

The Titanic’s maiden voyage was a disaster because the people didn’t prepare for things like this. Most ships go over a safety procedures, but the Titanic didn’t do such a thing. They only rescued wealthy people, which I felt was wrong. Some passengers jumped off the ship in desperation. Whoever drove the ship couldn’t have been paying attention.

Read More
2566 Words | 11 Pages

Despite being deemed unsinkable, the ship sank on its maiden voyage, even though “It was a luxurious passenger liner, which was considered to be unsinkable, due to its double-bottomed hull with sixteen watertight compartments'' (Kaufman, 2002, p. 898). One of the theories suggests that the Titanic never sank, and someone switched it with another White Star Line ship, the R.M.S. Olympic, to reap insurance money. However, there are a lot of holes in this theory, one of the biggest is that the Titanic’s insurance wasn’t enough to cover the Olympics loss. As J. Kent Layton writes in Conspiracies at Sea, “the switch conspiracy founders—quite literally—on its financial merits alone” (Little, 2018, para. 10).

Read More
359 Words | 2 Pages

The Titanic, made on the 31st of March 1909, was the biggest ship in American history. Weighing approximately 52,310 tons, it could carry almost 4,000 people. It measured 46,328 gross register tons and with a draught of 34 feet 7 inches. 2,228 people boarded the titanic, being as big as it was, and of course they had their space. The ship was said to be unsinkable, but is that as true as it seems…?

Read More
457 Words | 2 Pages

On April 15 the unsinkable ship went down into the North Atlantic Ocean. I Survived the Sinking of the Titanic by Lauren Tarshis is about the tragedy of the Titanic. I Survived the Sinking of the Titanic is about a 10 year old boy named George. Living in New York, George and his sister, Phoebe, went to England with their Aunt Daisy. They sail home on the ship of the Titanic.

Read More
2885 Words | 12 Pages

1- Introduction. It was the night between the 14th and the 15th of April 1912. The British ocean liner Titanic, described as " unsinkable " by the builders and the ship-owners, sank due to a collision with an iceberg in the Atlantic ocean , ending with a tragedy that cost the lives of 1517 people ( 2223 in total ) [1]. What went wrong ?

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

This means that no matter what the captain did, the ship would have still been sunk by the bulkheads being too short and the water overflowing outside of the

Read More
1099 Words | 5 Pages

Titanic was deemed unsinkable because it had 15 watertight bulkheads and a double bottom. The problem with this though was that “the watertight compartment design contained a flaw that was a critical factor in Titanic’s sinking: While the individual bulkheads were indeed watertight, the walls separating the bulkheads extended only a few feet above the waterline, so water could pour from one compartment into another, especially if the ship began to list or pitch forward.” Many people say that the ship was doomed from the start. On April 10th 1912, The Titanic set sail for Cherbourg, France and then to Queenstown, Ireland.

Read More
594 Words | 3 Pages

I believe J. Bruce Ismay is responsible for the sinking of the Titanic because he rushed through testings and had the ship low on equipment they needed and just preceded to set sail. All though you think that Captain Smith was responsible because he ignored multiple iceberg warnings. He also left the ship wheel when he knew there was iceberg warnings. He went to a dinner party when left the wheel and got drunk. I think J. Bruce Ismay is responsible for the sinking of the Titanic because he skipped of a good crew he also speeded up when told not to.

Read More
1331 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction Most people thought that the Titanic was unsinkable, but they couldn’t have been any further from the truth. The Titanic’s maiden voyage in the early 1900s was cut short due to a collision with an iceberg. The sinking of the Titanic was a tragic event that helped change sailing for years to come because of the massive casualties and the sinking of an unsinkable ship. Features

Read More

More about To What Extent Was Captain Edward Smith To Blame For The Titanic

Related Topics

Open Document