ipl-logo

Truth Through Confession Analysis

1530 Words7 Pages

Truth through Confession: An analysis on Rousseau and Foucault How do we know the truth about ourselves and how do we communicate it? Foucault explores these questions in The History of Sexuality where he poses the “repressive hypothesis” that repressing sex in society caused the opposite effect. There occurred a proliferation of sexual discourse where sex became part of every sector of society entering spaces such as education and medicine. The confession is the primary means of discourse, in other words how information and power are disseminated in society. To Foucault the confession is a mechanism that produces truth; through confession we are creating a truth about ourselves. When considering Rousseau’s autobiography The Confessions of …show more content…

His egoism is shown in his assertion of writing the first and most truthful autobiography begins by stating that a written project had not been undertaken before and that he will be the first to show himself as a man in “all the truth of nature”. This idea of creating truth with confession is consistent with Foucault. Foucault states that “the confession became one of the West 's most highly valued techniques for producing truth”. Yet Rousseau’s truth through his autobiography contains inconsistencies. In his introduction, it is clear that he is well aware of his critics and the fact that the autobiographical project may not be fully accurate or truthful. He states that he has “concealed nothing that was ill, added nothing that was good” and “indifferent ornamentation” to fill in the gaps in his memory. While “indifferent” creates a sense that Rousseau is objective and fair in his portrayal of himself by not caring for the parts that are not truthful, it is important to keep a critical view of his writing. The act of writing allows the confession to be analyzed and reflected upon by the author and society as a whole once it is published. While it is honest to acknowledge the possibility of untruths in the text, it is difficult to reconcile that with the claim of truth that an autobiographical text holds. In regards to truth, Foucault states that “confession frees, but power reduces one to silence; truth does not belong to the order of power but shares an original affinity with freedom”. This ties into Rousseau’s confession being a source of liberation for him, yet the underlying power in society is not something he addresses. For Rousseau truth is subjective and reliant on unreliable memory but still frees him from shame and

Show More
Related
1137 Words | 5 Pages

Rousseau’s main idea is that everyone should feel safe, happy, and equal even if it means sacrificing personal joy for the good of society. If these things are not present then the community does not work. The contract

Read More
1384 Words | 6 Pages

Rousseau took advantage of his freedom by writing about is confessions. Writing about his confessions was equivalent to a girl writing in her diary, but he published his confessions for everyone to view and make their own opinions about his situations . Since he had so much freedom he was not worried about the consequences he could face if he published them or what help thought of it. “Let the trumpet of judgement sound when it will, I will present myself with this book in my hand before the Supreme Judge” (586 Rousseau). Rousseau was absolutely confident that he would not face any consequences and people would understand why he was doing this.

Read More
1631 Words | 7 Pages

At the time of its publication, Rousseau had withdrawn from Paris and was living with a noblewoman. His location allowed him to write with little concern for the controversy surrounding his two previous Discourses, and the period was one of the most productive of his life (Delaney). He wrote as a way to address the ideas he had been accumulating from years traveling around Europe. His observations led him to argue that the rights of the people are violated in a civil society, and this should be changed under a social contract. After observing numerous governments, he concludes that people should only be governed by the Sovereign, a body with one collective will.

Read More
2790 Words | 12 Pages

It also requires the ability and willingness to collaborate with the storyteller and tolerated his capriciousness. Even I Diderot, as written by Robert Alter (1975, p. 82), does not publish a fatalist Jacques knowing that his work deserves an audience that will appreciate it more than it did his contemporaries and leaves it for

Read More
769 Words | 4 Pages

This is a fatal event in Rousseau’s mind as unlike ‘the savage’ who ‘lives in himself’, an individual in society ‘is always outside himself and knows how to live only in the opinion of others’. Very unlike the Hobbesian war-like state of nature where ‘vainglory’ cause people to act like barbarous beasts, Rousseau argues that egocentrism derives solely from social interaction believing that his predecessors were projecting ideas of modern corruption onto the state of nature. Therefore, Rousseau’s analysis of moral psychology reveals how humans have become duplicitous and false through socialisation as the foundations of competition and bettering people are laid and consequently, a ‘desire for inequality’ governs the

Read More
1695 Words | 7 Pages

Young Foucault was educated in his early years in Poitiers, during the same time as Germany’s occupation. Foucault excelled very quickly in subjects like philosophy and, from a young age devoted his aims to pursue

Read More
777 Words | 4 Pages

According to Foucault, confession is “a ritual that unfolds within a power relationship, for one does not confess without the presence, or virtual presence, of a partner who is not simply the interlocutor but the authority who requires the confession, prescribes and appreciates it, and intervenes in order to judge, punish, forgive, console, and reconcile.” Confession, therefore, is a truth creating mechanism that creates rather than simply state an irrepressible truth. In most circumstances, this truth is constructed under coercion, rather than a free expression of self. Thus, confession is “poietic not mimetic, it constructs rather than reflects some pre-textual truth.”

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

MICHEL FOUCAULT ON SEXUALITY Michel Foucault was a French philosopher, philologist and social theorist. He made discourses on the relationship between power and knowledge and about how they are utilized as a form of social control through social establishments. This essay talks about Michel Foucault’s discourse on sexuality. He put forward his theory of the history of sexuality.

Read More
2357 Words | 10 Pages

The themes of sexuality, power, repression, knowledge and the mergence of religion and science have been thoroughly addressed, presented and exchanged between the movie Augustine and the writings of Foucault in the History of Sexuality. This notion presented by Foucault that sexuality is almost everything and anything is strongly conveyed through the movie. Throughout the movie, we can almost see that sexual desire is the good and the bad, the trap and the escape and last but not least, it is the problem and the solution. Having read between the lines that the sexual relationship between Dr. Charcot and his wife is quite anemic, it seemed as if his search towards knowing the truth behind sexuality is what substitutes what he is missing in terms

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

Foucault came up with propositions regarding sexuality. He consistently argued that it is of the essence to comprehend passion in what he defined as power rather than just understanding sexuality regarding the law, countering the repressive hypothesis. In trying to analyze the existing relationship between history, energy, and knowledge, Foucault came up with four rules that were consequently applied in the comprehension of sexuality including the provision of immanence, the state of continual variations, the practice of double conditioning and the rule of tactical polyvalence of the discourses. In analyzing the rules, a question arises; why does Foucault believe that these rules are vital in understanding sexuality?

Read More
960 Words | 4 Pages

However, his true morals are revealed when the narrator shows signs of guilt like “My head ached, and I fancied a ringing in my ears.” The narrator’s transition from superiority to guilt represents the reality that the acknowledgement of wrongdoings can either be done consciously or unconsciously, and that the latter has considerable negative

Read More
1434 Words | 6 Pages

Instead of reconciling the gap between reality and fiction, the narrator attempts to reinforce it. The narrator similarly includes himself as a character of his text, as mentioned previously during his encounter with Charles on the train. Despite also employing the method of metalepsis, the narrator’s intentions for and effect of doing so is the opposite of the narrator of Slaughterhouse Five. Compared to Slaughterhouse Five that has a testimonial function, the “narrative function” of the narrator in The French Lieutenant ’s

Read More
1355 Words | 6 Pages

The autobiography, The Confessions of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, provides a vivid insight into the complicated, yet exhilarating, life of Rousseau. The beginning of his life was filled with misfortunes, such as the death of his mother which was quickly followed by a distraught and self-sabotaging attitude which his father adopted. This led to his father’s involvement in illegal behaviors and the subsequent abandonment of Rousseau. His mother’s death was the catalyst for his journey to meet multiple women who would later affect his life greatly. The Influence of Miss Lamberciers, Madame Basile, Countess de Vercellis, and Madam de Warens on the impressionable adolescent mind of Rousseau led to the positive cultivation of self-discovery and the creation of new experiences, as well as the development of inappropriate sexual desires and attachments towards women.

Read More
2352 Words | 10 Pages

Paul- Michel Foucault was a French philosopher also known as a historian of systems of thoughts whose influence extended across a broad array of disciplines especially in the humanities and social sciences and a social critic. He created his own title when he was promoted to professorship at one of the most prestigious colleges in France “College de France” in 1970. He is perhaps best known for his ruminations on power, self identity, epistemology, and the evolution of systems of thought and meaning. He is often described as post-structuralist or post modernist, however Foucault himself rejected such titles, preferring to analyse their significance rather than identifying with them.

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

Guilt A few days ago, something _____happened. My girlfriend and I went to a local haunted area for a scare and to kill an evening. It was midnight and we were arriving at the location when it started to get extremely foggy to the point where we could hardly see in front of us. We started to slow down to park, and I saw a look of terror on my girl’s face that definitely looked real.

Read More

More about Truth Through Confession Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document