ipl-logo

Two Key Assumptions Of The Field Of Anthropology

1132 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay on critical analysis on qualitative research

1.What seems to be some of the assumptions of the field of anthropology (based on evidence from you book)
This linguistic turn makes problematic two key assumptions of qualitative research. The first is that qualitative researchers can directly capture lived experience. Such experience, it is now argued, is created in the social text written by the researcher. This is the representational crisis…. The second assumption makes the traditional criteria for evaluating and interpreting qualitative research problematic. This is the legitimation crisis. It involves a serious rethinking of such terms as validity, generalizability, and reliability. … This crisis asks, how are qualitative studies to be evaluated in the poststructural moment?
2.What Material is studied (based on book evidence)
Focusing on a particular area of the U.S.-Mexico border, Ciudad Juarez-El Paso, Ethnography at the Border brings out the complexity of the border experience through the voices of the diverse people who inhabit the region. In a series of ethnographic essays that investigate specific aspects of border existence, the contributors provide rich and detailed insights into such topics …show more content…

4 were sociology students (Leslie Salzinger, Tim Dunn, David Spener, and I), 1 a communications graduate (Eduardo Barrera), 1 a human geography graduate student (Melissa Wright), and the final 1 a literature student (Socorro Tabuenca). It is important to remember this diversity and above all the prominence of sociologists among the “non anthropologists” in the group, because much of the debate about “natives” and “non natives,” the West and the rest, was much more important for those contributors who were part of anthropology departments than for the rest of us. →

Show More
Related
1022 Words | 5 Pages

In Rachel St. John’s book, “Line in the Sand: A History of the Western U.S.-Mexico Border,” the author offers up “a history of how and why the border changed” (St. John 1). This is her central thesis that she presents, providing evidence and historical context concerning the border and its changes over the course of the late 1800s to the mid-1900s. In seven chapters plus and introduction providing more general information and a conclusion that brings the U.S.-Mexico border situation into the present day, Rachel St. John’s focus is both periodical and geographical. St. John moves across both space and time in her book, looking at how region and era affected the border situation and how these effects differed in significance. St. John takes

Read More
874 Words | 4 Pages

In “Stephen F. Austin, Empresario and Borderlander”, Gregg Cantrell’s main argument is that the borderland native had a cultural identity of their own that made them very unique. Cantrell uses selected readings from original sources on narratives extensively to explain in detail what happened during U.S-Mexico War.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

Urrea endeavors to show the complex and dynamic factors that make the interplay, which leads to the problem of immigration. As such, the work highlights more than just immigration. Above all, Urrea focuses more on drawing attention guides or Coyotes that work in a gang-like manner to ferry immigrants for a pay. The groups immigrants or walkers put their fate in the hands of the guides after paying a fee that will guarantee their safe transit, but as they later realize the transit is never any safe, but a rather a journey of many challenges. In the case highlighted by Urrea, the Coyotes lead the group of walkers to a trail

Read More
1267 Words | 6 Pages

According to Hernandez, “ Mexicans in the borderlands, regardless of immigration of citizenship status, were subject to high levels of suspicion, surveillance, and state violence as border patrol officers aggressively policed not only the U.S and Mexico border but also Mexican communities and work sites” (Hernandez Pg. 2). In her book, Hernandez tells the story of how Mexican immigrant workers became

Read More
562 Words | 3 Pages

Taking the protagonists’ experiences as portrayed in El Norte and Maria Full of Grace as a first step in understanding a singular word border, I aim to compose a literature review and investigate how border develops into a wider issue concerning borderland, border crossing and border theory. Having knowledge of the plethora of the term border such as border theory is believed to be beneficial for people look critically at issues on wider topics such as identity. Collecting and reading literatures on borders and border crossing will be the next step to do to understand better the context embedded in those terms. Many scholars such as Gloria Anzaldúa has initially started defining border and its complexity. In addition, by looking at what the protagonists in EL Norte and Maria Full of Grace have undergone, the concept of the physical and abstract border is in line with what Anzaldúa argued in her book, Borderlands/La Frontera, where she contends that border connotes both concrete and nonconcrete

Read More
2165 Words | 9 Pages

Brock Baldwin November 18, 2014 Mexican Borderlands Reflection Historians have tried piecing together as much as they can about the history on the Mexican Borderlands for centuries. The only evidence and knowledge they have to base off their work is from documents like Martha Summerhayes’ diary, which she published in the late 1800s. Martha Summerhayes was an American female during this time on a journey through Arizona. In this document she explains life in the Borderlands from a first person point of view and explains many first hand encounters from her daily life.

Read More
1279 Words | 6 Pages

Ruth Gomberg-Munoz's Labor and Legaility: An Ethnography of a Mexican Immigrant Network, describes the lives of undocumented immigrants from Mexico who work as busboys In a Chicago restaurant. Gomberg-Munoz gives insight into the new lives of the boys, through her compilation of their experiences both before crossing the border and after moving away from home into an unknown world. As an ethnography, the book gives information and details of the workers without arguing or taking a stance on immigration itself; it is instead presented in a manner that attempts to give readers a full understanding of the undocumented life through the revelation of the ones living it. She provides readers with a perspective on the daily struggles faced when living

Read More
1430 Words | 6 Pages

and Mexico by providing a wealth of information on many different aspects on it. This book was written to cater to a wide and differing audience by providing so much information for different people to pick up on. This information can make it difficult to read the full book, but the author’s purpose is not for everyone to read the full book and comprehend everything. Her book allows for very detailed information to be available on everything imaginable that a person could want to know about the border. This lets people pick and choose the important information to them that they would like to read about and retain.

Read More
1619 Words | 7 Pages

Divided not By Choice “The U.S- Mexican border es una herida abierta where the Third World grates against the first and bleeds. And before a scab forms it hemorrhages again, the lifeblood of two worlds merging to for a third country- a border culture. Border are set up to define the places that are safe and unsafe, to distinguish us from them.” (Gloria Anzaldua/Borderlands La Frontera: The New Mestiza 2nd Edition (Page 25) Gloria Anzaldua wrote Borderlands La Frontera: The New Mestiza and was originally published in 1987. Even though this book was written long ago, this book is a great example of what most Mexican-Americans struggle with on a day-by-day basis especially to those that do not follow Mexican customs and traditions.

Read More
1318 Words | 6 Pages

Analytical Book Critique “On the Edge”,” written by Char Miller, is an absolutely great book which harps on the public issues which took place in the southern region of the United States, specifically in the State of Texas, the State of California, and the border of which lies between Texas and Mexico. Char Miller did a great job with this book and did not fail to exclude his own opinions. By doing so, Miller took full advantage of the reader’s capability to interpret his views and has portrayed himself as a viable source, worthy of his own opinions. Miller gained his credibility by these three simple aspects: major/minor events, religion, and quotes used by political leaders. Char Miller was born on November 23rd, in 1951 in St. Louis, Missouri.

Read More
1143 Words | 5 Pages

CRA: Anzaldua Borderlands In her poem “Borderlands,” Gloria Anzaldua strategically exposes readers to the true form of the Borderlands region as she conveys the internal incongruity that is rife with this state. As she characterizes the nature of the Borderlands, extending the idea of the Borderlands from a geographical region to an extensive social phenomenon, Anzaldua emulates an experience that is shared by many; conquered by fear. Anzaldua cogently employs the use of distinct structural elements within her poem as a form of illustrative depiction in order to express to readers the strenuous relationship between the inhabitants and their environment.

Read More
586 Words | 3 Pages

Anthropology Questions: 1. Was this crime indicative of the beliefs, morals, and culture of the two aggressors? 2. Were there any scratch marks found on the victim? Were there any fingernails found at the scene of the crime?

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

In class last week, we discussed how a border is defined not merely as a political line dividing nations, but an undefined barrier that exists between different cultures. A borderland in Texas, I thought, was just cities or towns that just happen to reside along the border after the U.S. acquisition of Texas in 1848. I never thought much of the community within the borderland areas other than believing that most communities there had a deep-rooted Mexican culture. However, Gloria Anzaldúa best defined the border as, “a vague and undetermined place created by the emotional residue of an unnatural boundary.” The community within the borderlands is not as simply defined as a borderline.

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

The beginning of conflict between Native Americans and anthropologists is hard to determine, though we know that it is tied to the early creation of American anthropology in the United States. According to Native American authors such as Vine Deloria, the conflict is also tied to the history of gruesome collections and expeditions of past grave-robbing. In these cases anthropologists claimed to be saving pieces of information and history, while the Indians claimed they were being treated like pieces of history that needed to be saved. The relationship between the two parties is one filled with distrust, as very few members on either side appear to understand and recognize the rights of the other. Into each life, it is said, some rain must fall.

Read More
1054 Words | 5 Pages

In the poem “To live in the Borderlands means you”, the borderlands become a place of change, such as changing from just one culture or race into a diverse culture or race and not-belonging. (Singh, A., & Schmidt, P. 2000). The poem describes how the author’s own background ethnicity people, mixicanas, identifies people like her, chicanas, as “split or mixture that means to betray your word and they deny “Anlo inside you.” (Anzaldua, F. 1987). The poem describes that the borderland is a place of contradiction, such as of home not being a home.

Read More

More about Two Key Assumptions Of The Field Of Anthropology

Related Topics

Open Document