ipl-logo

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

1314 Words6 Pages

To what extent do you think the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture?
I think that to some extent there was a true concern with Canadian culture but I would say that the reason for the dispute was also economic. The American culture and its products are spread over Canada in all areas an not only in the magazines business. If this was a 100% culture concern, it would have affected more sectors of the economy and not only magazines. Radio, cinema, TV would all be examples, but it happened only with the magazines. For instance: "Canada is one of the best examples of a country where U.S. cultural products dominate despite the Canadian government's efforts to preserve local culture. Canadian films account for just 2.1 percent of Canadian film ticket sales, and the vast majority of the remaining 98 percent are American. Moreover, three-quarters of the television watched, four out of five magazines sold on newsstands, and 70 percent of the content on radio, are of foreign origin. The vast majority of foreign products in all of these categories are American."

To what extent do you think the government of Canada was pressured to seek to protect its market because of the financial interests of the Canadian magazine industry?
I think that a very strong lobby for the magazine …show more content…

And to be able to convince them, that in a globalized world, putting up such pressure would be sustainable and not give the motto to start a conflict in other areas of trading. Taxing foreign products has the same effect as subsidizing national ones and creates abnormal fluctuations in the consumption and in the production padrons that might be difficult to correct afterwards. The "retaliation" from the United States of America regarding doing the same on Canadian product was not a

Show More
Related

Little Sisters Vs. Canadian Charter: Case Summary

689 Words | 3 Pages

Charter Case Analysis Censorship: Little Sisters vs. Canada Little Sisters vs. Canada was a case that involved a bookstore in Vancouver that serves to mainly gay and lesbian clients. Little Sisters fought against the unfair, discriminatory treatment from Canada Customs. For years, Canada Customs had repeatedly confiscated books and magazines being shipped to Little Sisters from the United States because they deemed them “obscene”. The items were often seized, detained and then prohibited although they had previously been approved for shipment to either Little Sisters or other bookstores and many “obscene” pieces could be found in the Public Library.

Read More

Summary Of Bored With USA By Brendon O Connor

390 Words | 2 Pages

Now there are McDonald’s restaurants all over the world. The American movie and television industry dominates the world. Through television, the world sees American fashions, customs, scenery and way of life. O’Connor

Read More

Sauve V Canada Case Study

434 Words | 2 Pages

Sauvé v Canada (Chief Electoral Officer) (2002) Plaintiff - Richard Sauvé Defendant - Attorney General of Canada, Chief Electoral Officer of Canada & the Solicitor General of Canada FACTS The Plaintiff: Richard Sauvé is a former member of the biker gang ‘Satan’s Choice’. In 1975, Sauvé was sentenced to 25 years in federal prison for the murder of an opposing gang member. In 1993, Sauvé started a long journey fighting an injustice that denied all inmates the right to vote.

Read More

Moore V British Columbia Case Study

327 Words | 2 Pages

Facts: In Moore v. British Columbia (2012), Jeffrey is a student suffered from severe dyslexia, which is a learning disabilities defined in difficulties in reading but it does not affect general inelegance. He was denied remedial help at the school but referred to a Diagnostic Centre, which was later closed due to financial issues. Jeffrey’s father transferred him to a private school and filed a complaint against the Province and the school district stating that his son was not allow to have an access to a service entitled to him under s.8 of the B.C. Human Rights Code. As such, the Province and District were found to have discriminated the student by the Tribunal. However, the Supreme Court of British Columbia overturned the decision of

Read More

Brief Analysis Of R Vs. Oakes Case In Canada

507 Words | 3 Pages

Describe Topic: R v. Oakes is the most important charter case in Canada. The main reason for it being so important is that it led to the creation of the Oakes test, but also for it being a case concerned with section 11 of the charter and the fact that David Oakes was told to prove himself innocent. The main legal conflict in the case is whether section 1 justifies the fact that he has to prove himself innocent, based on the laws applied in the case. Main Issue to be researched further: Was the “reverse onus” applied on David Oakes lawful under Canadian Law? Legal Issues: 1.

Read More

Boston Tea Party Essay

753 Words | 4 Pages

This is similar with what colonials were facing in the 17th century. They were not allowed to import Black Tea from India or China but only from Great Britain since the British government gave the East India Company a monopoly on the importation of tea. The increased tax, however, was the tip of the story. The causes of the Boston Tea Party were more

Read More

How Did The Roaring Twenties Affect Canada

1210 Words | 5 Pages

After the Great War, it was noticeable that Canadians were beginning to entertain themselves the same way Americans were. Arguably the most popular American entertainment breakthrough was the radio. The radio was huge in the United States, it was the main way American people would entertain themselves. Eventually, the radio began to spread up to Canada, with Canadians wanting to use radios as well. The Canadians faced a big problem, there were no Canadian stations, therefore making it very difficult for Canadians to use this form of entertainment.

Read More

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

857 Words | 4 Pages

To what extent do you think the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture? Through reading the passage on the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute, I find it hard to believe that the conflict truly revolved around protecting Canadian culture. For a country that produced a mere eleven percent of the magazine market domestically, it is evident that the force behind this dispute was financially motivated. I would have been more inclined to side on the cultural integrity if the dispute was not created with the use of a split run edition. My understanding of the use of the split run edition was to allow tax breaks for Canadian companies who chose to advertise in this periodical.

Read More

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

740 Words | 3 Pages

Canadian government have a genuine desire to protect their culture by implement a law that will favour and promote their culture without such law Canadian might loss their heritage especially the new generation will not be able to continue and aware of their culture, almost 89% of magazine that being sold in Canada are all foreign magazine which contain most information about other culture which cannot benefit to local people in Canada especially other people that is not speaking English, is not all Canadian citizen that is speaking English some are speaking only French only, by impose law will benefit both the government and their citizen. Q2: To what extent do you think the government of Canada was pressured to seek to protect its market because of the financial interests of the Canadian magazine industry? The Canadian government was pressure to seek to protect their market because of so many reason starting from their financial interest which will benefit the country as well and also to protect their

Read More

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

1276 Words | 6 Pages

To what extent do you think the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture? I imagine that initially the dispute was motivated by Canadian nationalism and eventually evolved into a standalone conflict. It began fueled “by a desire to promote Canadian cultural uniqueness in magazine production had therefore escalated to the brink of inciting a wide-ranging trade war” (The Levin Institute, n.d.). Canadian attempts to preserve their national identity through their magazine production prompted American magazine producers to circumvent the prohibitory measures imposed on foreign magazines. This in turn inspired the Canadian government to establish further sanctions and the entire dispute

Read More

Canadian Government's Contribution Of Cultures To Protect Canadian Culture

733 Words | 3 Pages

The Canadian government believed that domestic production of magazines was linked to national identity and they have to protect it. Canadian publishers and the Canadian government feared many Canadian magazines would be forced out of business. The Canadian government placed restrictions on foreign magazines and in 1965 prohibited the importation of “split-run magazines. Due to the huge success of US books, magazines and film in Canada, the nation has begun to feel that its individual

Read More

How Does Globalization Affect Canada

1639 Words | 7 Pages

Globalization is a many-faceted process which has benefits and repercussions in many areas. It has led to great developments through exchanges of ideas and technologies and has also caused deep conflicts within and among nations in different ways. While often conflicts arise economically, politically, or in the realm of intellectual rights, these are easier to understand and resolve than the varied and nuanced conflicts that arise between Globalization and Culture. Due to a long history of such conflicts, sometimes groups or governments take it upon themselves to initiate preventative measures in order to reduce the risk of damage or loss of cultural identity. One specific example of this preventative action began almost 100 years ago as Canada started issuing a tax on foreign produced magazines in the

Read More

Essay On Canadian Identity

1033 Words | 5 Pages

The events in American history have also affected Canada from a political perspective, which lead to the Democracy that is present today. Another way the U.S. has affected Canada is from a military perspective because Americans are quick to jump to war and Canada has had to help control them which lead to them being peacekeepers. The United States helped mold the Canadian identity by being both a threat and support to the nation; this will continue into the 21st century but Canada will keep it’s unique identity. A country 's culture can be seen as interchangeable with identity; in Canada there is evidence of American culture everywhere.

Read More

The Three Main Causes Of World War One

1271 Words | 6 Pages

Thirty-seven million casualties, thirty-two countries, four years, two alliance systems, and one assassination. the Great War, which lasted from 1914 to 1918, was perhaps one of the most important and destructive wars of all times. All major industrialized countries including Britain, the United States of America, Germany, France, Italy, Austria-Hungary and Russia were reeled into the Western front in France and the eastern front near Russia to fight. Although there were multiple causes to the strife known as World War one; the main three were the greed of imperialism, the pride of nationalism, and the threat of militarism. Sidney Fay Bradshaw once said, “Intense rivalry for prestige, markets resources and colonies led to confrontations…these

Read More

Do Hollywood Movies Affect National Culture Around The World Essay

848 Words | 4 Pages

Hollywood movies affect national culture in various ways. In one sense, movies could be characterized as America’s storytellers. Hollywood movies „Americanize“ global values and beliefs ,therefore they in a way diminish national culture traits and adapt and reinforce American customs. People tend to copy the ideas,customs and culture of American people or in other words they tend to acculturate. So called „Americanization“ is

Read More

More about Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document