ipl-logo

Was Queen Elizabeth An Evil Queen

874 Words4 Pages

Was Queen Elizabeth an evil queen who didn’t justify Catholics? No, Queen Elizabeth wasn’t an evil queen because she was kind to all of her subjects, as most Catholics say. Ever since Queen Elizabeth was young, she always strived to do her best since her father didn’t pay much attention to her and her mother was executed for not giving a male successor. With that small trait, she lead England for quite a long while. In 1586, Mary, Queen of Scotland was currently in house arrest. However, while Elizabeth was ruling England, many Catholics thought that Mary, Queen of Scotland was a better Queen that Elizabeth and kept saying that Mary should overthrow Elizabeth one day. They saw Elizabeth as a weak person while Mary was kind and strong, seeing how Mary tried her best with Scotland. But it wasn't just Catholics in England that thought Mary was a better suitor, most of the Catholics in Europe thought so as well. …show more content…

(See Appendix B). Babington was a young child when he first met Mary, Queen of Scotland, who was in house arrest at the time. When Babington was a young adult, he wanted to break Mary out of her prison, so he decided to create the Babington Plot. A problem Babington had was that Mary, Queen of Scotland, was prohibited from receiving or sending letters, so in order to bypass that, he snuck in letters in a brewer’s keg that would then be given to Mary to continue the planning of the plot. At this point of time, beer was an important part of a meal, so it didn’t seem

Show More
Related
1271 Words | 6 Pages

She would have been a serious threat to the queen as Mary had a claim to the English throne which was based on the fact that she was the grand-daughter of Margaret Tudor (Henry VIII’s sister). In the eyes of the Catholics, Mary's claim appeared stronger than Elizabeth's because they believed that Henry's marriage to Anne Boleyn was illegal. This would have seriously threatened Elizabeth’s security as there was a possibility that Elizabeth could lose her place on the English throne, therefore endangering her safety, royal supremacy, religious settlement. However, this threat didn’t remain as on the 19th May 1568, Elizabeth imprisoned her cousin. This shows that Mary, who was a prestigious Catholic, didn’t remain a threat to Elizabeth’s security as she was imprisoned for 19 years and was consequently unable to do anything about Elizabeth being queen.

Read More
906 Words | 4 Pages

Elizabeth I, Queen of England from 1558-1603, brought much success and political stability to England during her reign. However, the ideas about gender at the time greatly influenced her rule. With the views of the religious peoples during Elizabeth’s reign leaning towards negativity about a woman ruler, Elizabeth I responded to these challenges against her ability to rule wisely with sophisticated anger and strong leadership, while not responding to the challenges to her authority as a religious leader. One of the main challenges to Elizabeth’s right to rule came from the church. Document 1, “First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women” by John Knox, a Scottish religious reformer, shows the biased views of a Scot who

Read More
216 Words | 1 Pages

Abigail Archer also suggests that “Mary intended to return England to Catholicism, but she knew Elizabeth was a least tolerant of Protestantism, and therefore posed a risk.” (Archer n.p.) Anne Somerset in her book Elizabeth I suggests that Mary throughout

Read More
1636 Words | 7 Pages

She did make committed catholic bishops, and that was probably a surprise to others. While she was trying to get the throne she ordered her first execution at the Tower of London. Lady Jane Grey and her husband were the first to be charged with high treason. Mary was on the throne for five years and she was the main reason for so many deaths, and it didn’t solve her problems with religion. All of the people she had executed were English Protestants.

Read More
1509 Words | 7 Pages

The Catholics and the Anglicans always have had tension, and when Queen Elizabeth I came to power, she started to execute Roman Catholics. The Church of England became official once more after Queen Mary I’s decision as a Catholic. However, Queen Elizabeth I’s approach was a moderate access to the Anglican belief (Source 7). This approach did not satisfy the Puritans and later caused them to rebel against the Queen. Under Queen Elizabeth I’s rule, the Anglicans had more freedom than before and were not executed for their beliefs.

Read More
762 Words | 4 Pages

Mary was the Catholic great-granddaughter of Henry VII; therefore, she was the legitimate heir to the throne while Elizabeth was a Protestant daughter.

Read More
201 Words | 1 Pages

Elizabeth was a protestant woman and, consequently, people questioned her right to rule England. Woman were seen as inferior and unsuitable at that in time and since as ruler she would take control of the catholic church many wondered if she was fit to ruler England. Because of this concern, it was important for her to stabalize her divine right to power as it applied to religion. This was made possible by the medieval theory of two bodies. “In the theory of two bodies, there was the body natural and the body politic.

Read More
1380 Words | 6 Pages

(Sommerville) Mary was the prime Catholic candidate for the throne of England while losing popularity in her own country because she was a Catholic monarch in a country that was slowly slipping into Protestantism. (Sommerville) But from birth, they were threats to each other. “Elizabeth’s secretary, William Cecil, realised that as long as Mary lived, this quarrel now begun, is undoubtedly like to be a perpetual encumbrance of this kingdom: When the French king died in July 1559, 15-year-old Francois became King of France- with Mary, aged 16, as his queen consort. The threat to Elizabeth grew even greater.”

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

After the reign of Mary in England, Elizabeth I ascended the throne. She began a period of religious tolerance and compromise. The English Protestant population gladly accepted her over the cruel rule of Mary I. However, certain individuals did not believe in the rule of a female. Elizabeth I constantly had to bear unfair treatment and criticism from males and the church.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

While she was a Protestant, she was also known for her tolerance of other faiths, which made her vulnerable to accusations of heresy. This was especially problematic because the Catholic Church viewed Elizabeth as an illegitimate ruler, and therefore a threat to their authority. While politics and foreign affairs were undoubtedly significant challenges that Elizabeth faced, religion was arguably her most pressing concern between 1559 and 1569. Religious tension in England was a deeply ingrained issue that had been brewing for decades, and it threatened the country's stability. The split between Catholics and Protestants was not just a matter of religious beliefs, but it was also intertwined with political power and authority.

Read More
1244 Words | 5 Pages

The previous reign of Mary I, who was a devout Catholic, had brought with it widespread persecution of Protestants. The bloodshed of that period was still fresh in the minds of Elizabeth 's subjects, particularly her Protestant nobles. As such, the pressure exerted by those nobles to avoid a marriage to a Catholic suitor was great. While her marriage to a man might bring about a rightful male heir to the throne, the religion of

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

Queen Mary I persecuted Protestants by public execution such as hanging and burning alive. This is why her nickname was “Bloody Mary”. This compares to selected countries in Europe and Asia. This is represented by execution of missionaries. Queen Elizabeth was very accepting of Protestants making Protestantism the official religion of England.

Read More
1421 Words | 6 Pages

Due to the constant clashing of religious beliefs between the Catholics and the Protestant denominations, left civilization in England to be at constant war with each other over which religion was the true and honest one to follow, because of this violence had engulfed England which resulted in execution, destruction of religious artifacts, and mass-murder. Once Elizabeth came into power, she ensured that the decisions she made were in the best interests of everyone in her kingdom, and the image of being The Virgin Queen helped in the making of those decisions. Elizabeth’s Virgin Queen image helped proved her to be an powerful and great figure in society that everyone could look up to, which made the decisions Elizabeth made easier and more likely to be accepted by both Catholics and protestants due to her god-like image. Elizabeth’s image helped her secure the needs of everyone in her kingdom, which helped avoid civil unrest and provided English society with a sense of peace and

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

Queen Elizabeth I ruled England during a turbulent time in its history. She was beset on all sides by those who wished to take her throne for themselves, whether it be through marriage or outright treason. With these threats, as well as the unstable political atmosphere across much of Europe, Elizabeth I could not afford to be seen as weak. This is why she distanced herself from the stereotypes of women at the time. She painted herself as a masculine figure to give herself an aura of strength that would deter potential usurpers.

Read More
1624 Words | 7 Pages

There is one Jesus Christ,' she once said. ' The rest is a dispute over trifles.'" (Britannica School, Elizabeth I) Despite being a Catholic herself in the belief of God, many Catholics were still persecuted and some were executed under her reign. In 1570 because of these actions Pope Pius V eventually excommunicated her.

Read More

More about Was Queen Elizabeth An Evil Queen

Related Topics

Open Document