ipl-logo

What Is The Legal Battle Between The Western Shoshone And Ruby Valley Treaty

1494 Words6 Pages

The legal battle that has been happening between the Western Shoshone and Ruby Valley Treaty has been ongoing for decades. The Ruby Valley treaty was a treaty of friendship and peace signed between the Western Shoshone people and the United States Government. This treaty granted the United States government safe passage, and the right to mine gold and other valuable minerals that were found in their territory. Since this treaty was signed in 1863, the U.S. had been regularly breaking this treaty, which has resulted in decades long battle between the Western Shoshone and the United States Government.
The Newe, which means “the people” are the extensive tribal ancestors or the Western Shoshone Native Americans. Their traditional territory expanded …show more content…

These small groups covered allocated areas and in such areas were given jobs to perform. These jobs could include hunting, fishing, or gathering. In the 1820’s once white colonization began, white people renamed the Newe Shoshone, which is how they got their current name. Then Immigrants began to flood America because of the gold mines in California, and of those immigrants, many settled in the territory of the Newe people, claiming their most fertile …show more content…

Mary and Carrie Dann, who’s ranch is in Crescent Valley in the heart of Western Shoshone territory, were approached in 1973 by the Bureau of Land Management and were told to apply for grazing permits and were told to pay grazing fees for their livestock. The coming year the Dann sisters were sued for trespassing, but the year before argued that their cattle were grazing on Western Shoshone Territory. The Dann sisters have since been struggling to maintain their way of life after the Bureau of Land Management has repeatedly tried to impound their livestock. Ever since, the Dann sisters have been struggling to maintain their way of life against the repeated attempts by the Bureau of Land Management to impound their livestock.
The word “encroachment” insinuates that the activity happened against one’s will. The activities that are included in the treaty are not encroachments, the Western Shoshone Nation never relinquished its territory through a ratified treaty with the United States. Such a ratified treaty is required by the organic act. The organic act established the territory of Nevada. The treaty of Ruby Valley never renounced land

Show More
Related

Uneven Ground Case Analysis

1104 Words | 5 Pages

This was a case that led to a statement by Justice Swayne in which he declared that “A treaty may supersede a prior act of Congress and an act of Congress may supersede a prior treaty.” (157). However, two months earlier an act had just been passed that terminated all Indian treaty processes. Thus Congress could pass laws that changed treaties, but no more treaties could be made that supersede the law. The tribes could no longer negotiate with the government as they used to, had they been viewed as sovereign (157).

Read More

Treaty Of New Echota Pros And Cons

554 Words | 3 Pages

To the United States Senate and House of Representatives, I am a member of the Cherokee nation currently residing in the state of Georgia. Over the past several years, I have watched as the citizens of Georgia have begun coming onto Cherokee land and slowly attempting to take over. Although I do know that a cause of this sudden disruption was the discovery of gold on our land, this does not change the fact that our fathers, yours and mine, have taken part in multiple agreements over the years which established these land boundaries. However, it has recently become aware to me that it seems we have entered into a Treaty of New Echota, which promises us land in the West, money, and compensation for our lands lost, given that we remove ourselves from our native land within two years time. I have several grievances regarding this agreement, the first of which being that the treaty is not a true binding settlement.

Read More

Punk Island Research Paper

1635 Words | 7 Pages

They burned their capital to the ground. This was probably the first time and American flag was seen at Rock Island. A treaty was signed in 1783 between Great Britain and the United States pacing the U.S. in possession of the land on Arsenal Island. The U.S. recognized that the land belonged to the Indians but they either bought the land from them or eventually forced them out. In 1804 Rock Island was bought in a treaty formed from six chiefs from the Sauk and Foxes.

Read More

Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee Analysis

1036 Words | 5 Pages

What would it be like to have everything common and normal in life taken away within a moments notice? The film Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee explores this question through the historical events that took place during the Indian removal era. Furthermore, the film reveals the motives of the U.S. government through the many scenes in which they attempt to negotiate for land with the Sioux Indians. The Sioux refuse to sell their land, so the United States forces the Sioux to pay for the western expansion with life, land, and freedom.

Read More

Comparison Of Andrew Jackson, John Marshall And The Trail Of Tears

813 Words | 4 Pages

Andrew Jackson, John Marshall, and The Trail of Tears There have been many dark times in our History as Americans. Among them is the Trail of Tears,brought upon by Andrew Jackson, which exiled the Indians from the American south and resulted in the death of thousands on the way to Oklahoma. Before this trying time there was speculation within the supreme court whether to treat the Native tribes as a sovereign foreign nation or as a dependent entity within the United States. I will discuss how these decisions came to be, the reactions to said decisions, and the aftermath of these rulings which inevitably leads to the Trail of Tears.

Read More

Imperialism, Colonization And The Haudenosaunee

1500 Words | 6 Pages

Imperialism/Colonization and the Haudenosaunee The year of 1142 marked the formation of the Haudenosaunee; A year when the group of alliances was exempt of all the tangible social, political and economic legacies that historical globalization would later impose on them. Centuries before Europeans arrived, the area now called upper New York State was occupied by five First Nation tribes, the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, Prior to the proposal of creating a confederacy, these nations had their own separate territories, and were often at war with each other. After the collective establishment of the confederacy they called the Haudenosaunee, their political alliance and unity were destined to indestructible. The Europeans called them

Read More

How Did The Fur Trade Affect The Culture Of Native Americans?

395 Words | 2 Pages

One of the main ways in which the US Government obtained Native American lands was to offer them terms within treaties. Congress declared that the only treaties ratified by them would result in the legal seizure of native land. These treaties frequently offered some sort of payment or guarantee to “compensate” the native for land forfeitures. Federal regulation of the fur trade was an attempt at obtaining control of the Native Americans. The Fur Trade was prevalent for both settlers and the natives.

Read More

Dawes Act Research Paper

1127 Words | 5 Pages

Dawes Severalty Act De Juan Evans-Taylor Humboldt State University Abstract The Dawes Act of 1887, some of the time alluded to as the Dawes Severalty Act of 1887 or the General Allotment Act, was marked into law on January 8, 1887, by US President Grover Cleveland. This was approved by the president to appropriate and redistribute tribal grounds in the American West. It expressly tried to crush the social union of Indian tribes and to along these lines dispose of the rest of the remnants of Indian culture and society. Just by repudiating their own customs, it was accepted, could the Indians at any point turn out to be genuinely "American."

Read More

Manifest Destiny Dbq

498 Words | 2 Pages

Manifest Destiny was the 19th-century doctrine or belief that the expansion of the US throughout the American continents was both justified and inevitable. Of course there were already Native Americans living in the area. The new people in the U.S. wanted to push the Native Americans out and make room for their new settlements. Not all of the Native Americans were very happy about being pushed out of their homes. The Native Americans were affected greatly by Manifest Destiny.

Read More

The Bannock Tribe

704 Words | 3 Pages

“The attack was led by volunteer soldiers from California, and it was one of the first and largest massacres of Native peoples west of the Mississippi River” (History of the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes). A year later, “[i]n 1864 the government attempted to confine the tribes to a reservation with the Treaty of Soda Springs, but it failed to gain ratification” (History of the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes) Springs, but it failed to gain ratification” (History of the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes). Now the Bannock tribe has a reservation and bit of the land they once

Read More

American Expansion In Sioux By D. L. Birchfield

383 Words | 2 Pages

Because of all these people moving west, some wanted to settle on their land, leading to treaties forcing the Sioux into small reserved

Read More

The Impact Of Westward Expansion On Native Americans

847 Words | 4 Pages

The treaty the US government signed with the Indians in 1851 granted the Indians to have an extensive territory, which means the Indians can get more land, but eventually that did not last(doc 3,4). One of the most important and well-known wars was the Sand Creek Massacre. On November 29, 1864, John Chivington led 700 troops in an unprovoked attack on the Arapaho and Cheyenne villagers. There they killed over 200 women, children, and older men. US Indian Commissioner admitted that :We have substantially taken possession of the country and deprived the Indians of their accustomed means of support.”

Read More

Wild West Research Paper

627 Words | 3 Pages

The mesmerizing images of cowboys, Indians, and saloons conjures a pictorial view of, as we all know, the "Wild West". The Industrial Age changed the West in many ways. In times before the West, there had always been farmers. Farming, mining, and cattle were the life of the West. A great variety of Native American cultures ruled most parts of the area.

Read More

Push And Pull Factors Of Indian Trail Of Tears

1189 Words | 5 Pages

The Treaty of New Echota was soon created that allowed the Indians

Read More

Concept Of Deculturalization

2113 Words | 9 Pages

The lands that the Native Americans were previously calling their homelands were immediately sold and used for their resources (timber, mining, gold etc.) I like the quote under the Treaty Timeline portion that highlights this best as quoted by Ohiyesa, “The greatest object of their lives seems to be to acquire possessions-to be rich. They desire to possess the whole world” (Why Treaties Matter, How Treaties Changed Lands and Lifeways) I think that this another example of how we have been socialized to believe the Eurocentric perspective that is taught in textbooks.

Read More

More about What Is The Legal Battle Between The Western Shoshone And Ruby Valley Treaty

Related Topics

Open Document