ipl-logo

What Means Switch Short Story

1131 Words5 Pages

The story picked is What Means Switch written by Gish Jen. It revolves around the life of Mona Chang, an 8th grade American-born Chinese girl in New York during the 1960s. She meets Sherman Matsumoto, a new Japanese student who becomes her boyfriend. She battles Japanese, traditional and modern Chinese influences, in a western environment. The concepts derived from this short story are as follows. Pull & Push Factors of Acculturation, Acculturation Process, Family models, Freudian Psychoanalysts, Discrimination, Socialization and Sex vs. Gender.
Pull & Push Factors of acculturation refers to factors either attract individuals to or pressure them to leave a society. Pull factors (Positive) refers to “greener pastures”, like employment opportunities, allowing one have a better life. Push …show more content…

Seen from, “Scarsdale ... Whitman Road Gang used to throw crab apple mash at my sister Callie and me and tell us it would make our eyes stick shut.” (What Means Switch, 1998, p1). This occurred when foreigners were not welcomed, shown in: “civil rights on TV, we 're not so much accepted” (What Means Switch, 1998, p1). Their actions portrayed racist degrading views of the Asian people and their integration.
Sex vs. Gender. Concentrating on gender, it refers how society or culture defines as masculine or feminine. It is social constructions of what it is like to be a male or female in society referring to roles (Females only cook), identity (I’m a man, I’m strong) and stereotypes (Only men work) stemming from learned beliefs.
From the story, “Later she tells me if I don 't like school, I don 't have to go every day. ... "No good for a girl be too smart anyway."” (What Means Switch, 1998, p9). This portrays Mona’s mother’s biased perception on the social standing of females, viewing education as unimportant and irrelevant to females. This illustrates a perception that importance is inclined to males than females in

Show More
Related
1303 Words | 6 Pages

People are able to interpret things differently and don’t have to simply follow the dominant meaning of something. She states, “how at every moment, the world presents us with a composition in which a multitude of meanings and realities are available, and you are able to swim, lucid and self-contained, in that turbulent sea of multiplicity” (311). When presented with something, someone is able to create multiple meanings and definitions by what they choose. This relates to Susan Faludi’s essay “The Naked Citadel” where the Cadets go to the Treehouse due to their gender confusion. At the Treehouse, the Cadets have sexual relationships with the Drag Queens there which creates a stereotype that they are actually feminine and not a “Whole Man”.

Read More
950 Words | 4 Pages

Grimke proclaimed in her letters, girls should be educated to cultivate their minds, to allow time for reading, to be constantly inculcated, and to improve their intellectual capacities rather than exclusively worrying about culinary and manual operations. In other words, Grimke longed for an education where women didn’t spend so much time on domestic duties, such as, “furnishing a well spread table.” Grimke not only wanted a change in women’s education, but a change in their husbands mindset as well. That the husbands would need to encourage their wives and help out around the house in order for Grimke’s vision on education to work out. On the other hand, Grimke still believed that the “knowledge of housewifery” was “an indispensable requisite in woman’s education.”

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

Trujillo advises Minerva that she is unfit to attend law school when he says that “The university is no place for a woman these days” (99). Although it is false, the more superior sex is considered to be males as they are viewed as being both smarter and stronger over females. Defying this misconception of women not deserving an education because the main role of a lady is presumably housework, Minerva agitates to go to law school. With all the limitations of women, Minerva restates how without education there is even fewer options for girls as she expresses, “You know as well as I do that without schooling we women have fewer choices open to us” (105). Without school, females have fewer opportunities to become successful in life despite that they are fully competent for greatness.

Read More
1462 Words | 6 Pages

In the beginning of the story, the narrator believes she is free to become who she wants. As the story advances, her female role models, quickly ignore what she wants –for example working with the foxes– and set expectations for her to ‘act like a lady’, thus forcing the narrator to become a new highly feminized version of herself. Since the story is written in the 1950s, the mistreatment of women is permitted. The narrator’s society is extremely sexist. When

Read More
396 Words | 2 Pages

Rosemary Okumu PSYC 1113 – Section 11/18 /2016 Gender Gender is the state of being male or female. Male are thought to be adventurous, aggressive, strong whereas females are to be affectionate, attractive, shy and sexy. While I highly identify with my feminine gender characteristics, at times l possess masculine characteristics like confidence, ambition, and sometimes aggression.

Read More
499 Words | 2 Pages

She employs many literary devices that support her specific claim in this passage as well as she provides many clear examples of how stereotypes have shaped young girls’ lives throughout the book. Through these examples she succeeds to use them as evidence so the audience does not conform to

Read More
1022 Words | 5 Pages

Although it was common for girls to receive an education no higher than reading for knowing more was seen as unfit for marriage (Archives: Part One, Women’s Education), she accomplished both reading and writing at home while having access to her family’s large

Read More
1441 Words | 6 Pages

Betty mentions that more than style preferences, the girl’s behavior represented group membership for them. In other words, each group was aware that their style was in opposition and try to maintain their symbolic boundaries as an important tool for distinction. Most important, Bettie points out that their style preferences became to represent a categorical definition for the school personal. This category being the assumption that the preps were innocent and pure, while las chicas mature and low class. Thus, Betty claims that rather of seeing their style as markers of class distinction, the school personal saw las chicas’s performance as evidence of their heterosexual interest.

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

The Talk-Funny Girl by Roland Merullo has many critical approaches within it, but the gender approach was one consistent approach with its three concepts of gender roles, masculinity and femininity, and patriarchy and matriarchy. From the beginning of this reading, the gender roles concept was frequently used to compare characters and their roles in the story. As a punishment, Marjorie would be forced to act like a boy by her parents, who referred to it as “boying” days. “On boying days there would always be a job to do, a house repair project usually…it was almost as if he really did want a son there to help him” (Merullo 74). As a female, it was as uncommon for one to participate in house repairs and outdoor work, so the roles of gender were altered in this setting.

Read More
176 Words | 1 Pages

At tthe start, the Director gave a tour of the Hatchery to only male students. This shows how the book shows that men and women are not equal in Brave New World. Throughout the book there were restrictions placed on women. Since the government attempts to control reproduction, they sterilize the fetuses of women, but the males are not sterilized.

Read More
1686 Words | 7 Pages

Assimilation is usually meant to indicate what happens to immigrants in a new land. However, “rejection, loneliness, discrimination—these were the byproducts of living in the United States” (Ghymn 37). In Marilyn Chin’s essay on assimilation “How I Got That Name,” the speaker acquaints the readers how she got the American name “Marilyn.” The tension between the two cultures is evident, for the speaker is treated as “Model Minority.” Her race and ethnicity define her; in fact, the stereotypes inscribed with her race restricted and cage her significance in the society.

Read More
1130 Words | 5 Pages

It is also through Kincaid 's use of her setting, constructive atmosphere, and one sentence structure that some readers can better understand the mother 's belief of how productivity will lead to a respected life. After reading "Girl" readers are now made more aware of the direct relation between domestic knowledge and strict gender roles being forced onto

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

“Doing Gender” by West and Zimmerman is similar to Butler’s “Performative Acts and Gender Constitution.” However, West and Zimmerman build upon the ideas that Butler puts forth. Butler focuses on gender as performance and how gender is made up by specific actions. While West and Zimmerman take the concept of performance and constitution and applies it to a new concept, the sex category and how sex categories and gender are intertwined in society. Sex categories and gender, according to West and Zimmerman, are different and interconnected.

Read More
1091 Words | 5 Pages

The time when this story took place was a time when women were viewed as second class citizens. Mothers had traditional roles, which usually left them in the house, while men also had their roles, outside of the

Read More
1762 Words | 8 Pages

The focus of this essay will be on push and pull factors that causes or influence people to migrate.

Read More

More about What Means Switch Short Story

Related Topics

Open Document