ipl-logo

Who Was Responsible For Victor's Death In Frankenstein

584 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Victor's downfall in frankenstein

4. The blame for the events that had occurred in the book can go both ways. Victor could be the one responsible for creating the creature in chapter 5. He could also be responsible because according to book 3 chapters 1 he didn’t give the creature what it wanted; which was a female creature, which angered it enough to kill Elizabeth in chapter 6 of book 3. The creature had become more developed throughout the book, in book 2 chapters 5 when it was eavesdropping on the cottagers. It states, “I observed that the countenance of Felix was melancholy beyond expression” (Chapter 13). The creature is technically responsible for the murders; example would be killing Victor’s brother William in chapter 8 of book 2. It states, “Frankenstein! You belong then to my enemy—to him towards whom I have sworn eternal revenge; you shall be my first victim (Chapter 16).” Some of the blame could also shift to the cottagers that kicked it out of the cottage just because of it’s looks which angered it enough to question his existence and make him want to kill Victor. The creature did develop more throughout the story, which made him mature enough to sort of regret making Victor’s life horrible as it states when Walton was continuing, “he cried, with sad and solemn enthusiasm, "I shall die, and …show more content…

It was hard to tell in close detail how Mary Shelley was trying to define the term, “monster”, the creature may be generalized as a monster based off of his actions, not what he looks like. When Victor learned that he could create life, that wouldn’t exactly make him more monstrous because it may have been his curiosity that drove him to create the creature. One thing that Victor did do which was “monstrous” was allowing Justine to be committed of a crime and killed in chapter 8. Victor only does seem to care for his revenge against his own creation stating, “allow me the rest I so much desire; or must I die, and he yet live? If I do, swear to me, Walton, that he shall not escape” (Chapter

Show More
Related
168 Words | 1 Pages

After the death of William, Elizabeth express her feelings in this quote, “But now misery has come home, and men appear to me as monsters thirsting for each other’s blood” ( Shelley Pg. 63). Victor can be consider a monster by making the life of others sad and miserable, but especially Elizabeth’s life. Yes, the creature is the responsible of William’s death. But, who brought the creature to life? VICTOR, so who is the responsible of William’s death and the pain, misery, and suffer, generated on William’s family?

Read More
576 Words | 3 Pages

In Mary Shelley's novel Frankenstein, one of the main characters Victor Frankenstein creates a creature in an uncertain process from his eagerness to bring death back to life. Victor worked intensely for approximately two years to accomplish his desire of creating a human being. However, after bringing the creature to life, Victor felt guilty that he had given life to a "monster". Many people may believe that the creature is not human but based on the evidence the creature is human. Two reasons the creature is human is that he has a conscious and he committed crimes out of envy and revenge.

Read More
960 Words | 4 Pages

After the creature is finished explaining its story to Victor, there is a turning point in the novel. Victor realizes that he needs to take on some responsibility for his creation: “did I not as his maker, owe him all the portion of happiness that it was in my power to bestow?”(Shelley 148). Victor also thinks, “…the justice due both to him and my fellow creatures demanded of me that I should comply with his request. ”(Shelley 150). Victor is finally understanding that he needs to take on some responsibility for this creature.

Read More
685 Words | 3 Pages

Victor is one of the characters who is greatly affected by revenge. To start, the death of William and Justine started Victor’s hate for the creature. Victor started misunderstanding the creature from that moment. “Could he be the murderer of my brother? He was the murderer!”(60)

Read More
363 Words | 2 Pages

The Creation In Mary Shelly’s gothic novel Frankenstein a major problem that runs through the minds of both characters is that who was actually to blame for the horrible incidents that took place. I believe that both Victor Frankenstein and his monster were to blame for the death and destruction that occurred. Victor actions were a strong cause of all the chaos by causing his monster to feel alone and abandoned and never having someone there for him. With Victor shutting out his creation from the beginning his monster had to endure the harsh struggle of surving on your own in the wilderness.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

The fact that Victor sees the creature as such a vile thing shows us that Victor doesn’t have any respect whatsoever for it. The creature states that he was ‘dependent on none and related to none’ which also

Read More
629 Words | 3 Pages

Victor gave the creature life, and the creature took the lives of those Victor loved. The creature took these lives as revenge for Victor abandoning it and Victor breaking his oath to the creature. Victor is guilty of all of the murders through his creation of the creature, after all, if the creature was not created, all four victims of the creature would still be alive. “That poor victim, who on the morrow was to pass the awful boundary between life and death…” (Shelly 70).

Read More
1090 Words | 5 Pages

On the contrary, there are plenty of counter arguments in support of Victor Frankesntin being more responsible than the creature due to the creature not having a true moral compass or being taught right from wrong, hence Victor being a “bad” creator/father figure towards his own creation. “Unable to endure the aspect of the being I had created, I rushed out the room” or when it was stated “One hand was stretched out, seemingly to detain me, but I escaped, and rushed down stairs” (45-46). People can argue on the other hand that Victor being the creator of this creature that he had a father-like presence and abandoning that innocence can put some blame on victor. For the creature's side, others can state that he himself even understood he was once benevolent, hinting towards the blame of victor for his misery. “But I am rather the fallen angel…

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

Although the question of “who is to blame” Is up in the air, it’s quite obvious that the monster was directly to blame for the murders. But, when you think about the fact that he was merely created and not born, so he wasn’t able to differentiate right from wrong, or how to control his feelings. His anger was stemmed from his hate of his creator Victor. The wrongs that Victor did unto the creature is what caused the creature’s anger to overtake whatever bit of logical thinking and ability to reason and in a way, throw it out it out the window. So, physically speaking, the creature was to blame.

Read More
551 Words | 3 Pages

Now, Victor and we as readers know that this monster has some kind of thought process or instinct that has urged it to kill. While it appears as though the creature knew that it was killing Victor’s beloved brother when it was happening, it is also difficult to determine at this point whether or not it can think like a human. As such, it is almost impossible for anyone to know what it will do next now that it has already killed once to Victor’s knowledge, and what Victor has done

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

Over the past century, Frankenstein has been analyzed and interpreted in seemingly infinite different forms of literature, film, and television shows. Once solely recognized as the story about a brilliant scientist who creates a creature in whom he regrets making after the creature turns out ugly, Frankenstein now represents an internationally recognized and commercialized pop culture symbol for Halloween decorations and costumes. When analyzing and appreciating the true literary essence behind Mary Shelley’s original Frankenstein, one of the most important comparisons to consider remains the underlying influences behind the Creature’s immoral actions and whether or not the blame for these actions belong to Victor or the Creature. When exploring the dichotomy of the Creature versus Victor Frankenstein, one of the biggest and most widely debated questions remains whether Victor should be blamed for the Creature’s destructive actions or if the Creature should be considered guilty for his actions based off of his own free will. Many consider Victor Frankenstein the villain of the story due to his repetitive decisions to abandon and avoid his own “mistake,” the irresponsible choice of creating the monster in the first place, and his obvious negligence of the Creature’s feelings.

Read More
1511 Words | 7 Pages

In life there are many evils that will try to defeat a person but the key to living a happy, fulfilling life is learning to have empathy for others who are facing their own evils. Empathy is hard to have if a person has not endured any real struggles in their life. Being able to know firsthand how it feels to go through difficulties helps create a level of empathy that leads to compassion for one another. Victor Frankenstein is a prime example of someone who has faced evils in their own life but in the end did not find compassion for others, instead he found his own hell. In the novel Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, Victor’s lack of empathy opens the door into his world of selfishness, cruelty, and unhappiness.

Read More
1990 Words | 8 Pages

I have murdered the lovely and the helpless; I have strangled the innocent as they slept, and grasped to death his throat who never injured me or any other living thing. I have devoted my creator, the select specimen of all that is worthy of love and admiration among men, to misery.” (Shelley 274). Victor created life, but he is not responsible for the creation’s actions. The monster has

Read More
193 Words | 1 Pages

In Mary Shelley's book Frankenstein Dr. Frankenstein is more of a monster than the literal monster he has created. He spent all of his time in his laboratory trying to create something that he would not be able to take care of, without even thinking of the consequences. He was not aware what he is doing is hurtful to others. A lot of Victors’ problems stem from his early childhood and what appears to me to be mental illness. My theory is that he might have been schizophrenic and the monster coming to get him was his own paranoia and in fact, there was no real monster.

Read More
456 Words | 2 Pages

Victor was correct that “[the Creature reproaches him] with [his] behavior” (97), but he fails to realize that it is rightly so. The Creature would never have been so obscene if it weren’t for Victor’s abandoning him. Still, Victor places all blame onto his creation, because when you’re an “innocent and helpless creature bestowed [from] Heaven” (29), you can do no wrong. It is much later that Victor truly begins to take responsibility for the deaths of “William, Justine, and Henry” he

Read More

More about Who Was Responsible For Victor's Death In Frankenstein

Related Topics

Open Document