ipl-logo

Why Americans Won T Do Dirty Jobs Analysis

616 Words3 Pages

America is at an impasse with itself over the current unemployment rate and questions about where all the jobs are going. According to Elizabeth Dwoskin, most of these job positions, considered dirty, are being filled by immigrants and not Americans. Americans have found themselves in an uproar about migrant workers taking jobs away from them, but it seems they are hypocritical as they refuse to fill these jobs themselves. In her article “Why Americans Won 't Do Dirty Jobs,” Dwoskin implies that Americans are too lazy to do hard work but complain when immigrants fill these positions. It seems that even when Americans are faced with the threat of homelessness they claim they cannot find any jobs, or rather, they refuse to do the dirty ones. Even though the jobs suggested are not ideal, they still need to be filled. According to Dwoskin 's article, 211,000 people are unemployed in the state of Alabama, not because there is no work available, but because they choose not to apply for the jobs available. Americans claim to have higher standards, regarding hourly wages and working conditions and would rather leave it to someone else. But because of certain laws that have been enacted in America, these immigrants are unable to fill these jobs. …show more content…

The reason why many Americans refuse to take these jobs is that they are low paying and tedious. They would rather do minimal amounts of work for higher pay in the comfort of an office space rather than pick fruits, packaging food, or work at a steel mill. To quote Dwoskins article “Why Americans Won 't do Dirty Jobs,” Dwoskin states “Americans won’t fill them, thus, Americans are too soft.” This may not be entirely true, but according to unemployment rates and desperate employers, it might

Show More
Related
568 Words | 3 Pages

Fast food jobs is the classic stereotype for high school students, while field work is the classic stereotype for immigrants. " A Gringo in the Lettuce Fields" written by Gabriel Thomson talks about "doing a job that most Americans won't do" (89). In Amitai Etzioni's "Working at McDonald's" essay, he argues how holding part-time jobs while still attending high school "undermine school attendance and involvement" (249). While both Thomson and Etzioni describe what it is to work in a specific type of environment, Thompson immerses himself in the job and Etzioni argues that working while still in high school should be avoided. Despite their differences in their type of work, these two essays have many similarities.

Read More
417 Words | 2 Pages

We live in a fast paced, self-service and capitalist world. In this sense, people will be exploited in the work force especially if they are people of color from low-income background. This is how America function in order to make progress and profit. There are a lot of topics that was brought up while reading Food Nation by Eric Schlosser, an investigative and American journalist, that speaks a lot on the society we live in. Immigrants are getting paid below the minimum wage without any medical insurance.

Read More
1644 Words | 7 Pages

So where are the jobs the American people are losing? Immigration has a very positive effect in the US economy as a whole. Latino immigrants, especially those in the country undocumented, have actually improved local economies for whites, according to several studies, because their willingness to work for lower wages has rejuvenated the profitability of ailing industries and thus presented further their job

Read More
1388 Words | 6 Pages

In the formal essay “Making it in America,” Adam Davidson brings up what other people tend to ignore. He discusses the injustice the low income factory workers are receiving, even though productivity has grown. Humanity

Read More
1061 Words | 5 Pages

The jobs they believe they’ll have are such as hair dressing, jobs in factories, or as a seamstress all because they believe to be ghetto. In the essay “Still Separate, Still Unequal,”, after a student said she wanted to take AP college classes, one student named Fortino, said, “Listen to me, the owners of the sewing factories need laborers” (216). Fortino was implying that his classmates don’t belong in colleges, he believes such thing because he repeatedly said that they were ghetto. Working class students believe that they aren’t good enough to actually earn a college degree. They believe such thing because of what they have been surrounded by, and the courses they take due to the lack of AP classes, or any sort of ROP classes.

Read More
698 Words | 3 Pages

Consequently, millions undocumented workers have entered the American workforce. Most of the blame for the steady rise of undocumented workers goes to U.S. employers, not those seeking a better life. It is due to the demand for low-paid workers, especially in certain

Read More
1565 Words | 7 Pages

One of the reasons there is so much immigrant population in this country is because of the economy. In the past, immigration was helpful to the economy when people encouraged it so that the it could become prosperous and bring in diversity and help needed. Today, many people are afraid of losing their jobs. Immigration is currently flooding the labor market, primarily in the low-skill, low-wage sectors, and driving down wages and working conditions for many Americans because our immigration policies do not take economic conditions into account. Illegal immigration probably has its greatest impact on the United States’

Read More
1315 Words | 6 Pages

( Unemployment rate) This means that over 243 million people have jobs in America. This means that 80 million people in America don't have jobs. With the rate being the lowest of the decade, many Americans have jobs and are able to provide many items for their families. Furthermore, Bob Miglani and his family moved from India to America in 1979.

Read More
881 Words | 4 Pages

It also demonstrates how, alongside students, Janitors organize within their labor union to fight for the protection of their hard-earned contract with their contractors. This Op-Ed also sheds light on the systematic ways in which administration pacifies Janitors by acquiring to their demands while simultaneously increasing their workload and assignments in the workplace. This Op-Ed is a good resource for my own research because it helps me feel comfortable to have an example on how I could possibly structure my Op-Ed. At the same time, the argument in this piece is crucial to my investigation relating to how labor is discussed in the U.S, specifically in a college campus, today.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Due to the large income of unskilled workers has allowed employers to give out low wages and actually allow there to be horrible working conditions. There seems to be a solution to this. By reducing low-skill immigration, we can strengthen the labor market and as well as increase wages along with them for the American people. Among being a burden on the work force, they are also harming

Read More
1733 Words | 7 Pages

The issue of homelessness in America is controversial because Americans have different views on the causes, conditions, and solutions to homelessness. Advocates for the homeless cite economic problems, a limited supply of affordable housing, and domestic violence as the main causes of homelessness, while opponents vehemently contend that homelessness in America is due solely to a lack of personal industry. Nevertheless opponents and advocates for the homeless are in agreement on the conditions of homelessness, but the solutions to homelessness are vigorously debated by both groups. Opponents cite personal responsibility (a steady job) as the main solution to homelessness, while advocates for the homeless cite a steady, well-paying job, and

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

They don’t have to take our jobs, it would benefit their country if they had done something productive there. Now that they came to the United States, there will be a significant job decrease at the immigrant's country. La 2 When Illegal Immigrants come to the United States,

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

And, unfortunately, it’s more prevalent in America than many may believe. When defining what exactly a sweatshop is and what it consists of, there are many forms that it has taken over the many decades of America’s existence. The basic definition of a sweatshop is a factory in which its employees, many being children, are exploited; working long hours in extreme cases of hazardous and unhealthful conditions for little pay. Despite the fact this is a

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

Senator Jeff Sussions said, “I’m also dubious about the idea that there are jobs Americans won’t do. I worked construction in the Alabama sun, hauling lumber, and stuff. I know Americans do that every single day, tough work that is done every single day.” There are many Americans that do hard work everyday to support their families. Legalizing these immigrants would take away American jobs and not allow Americans to work hard to support their families.

Read More
695 Words | 3 Pages

is because immigrant workers are willing to do most of the jobs Americans do not want to do. Most of these jobs are manual labor like building houses, construction or other things that fall under that category. I think that people who have made it here and done the whole process legally deserve to be here but the ones who are here illegally need to go back to where they came from. It makes it possible for people to be able to improve their living conditions because if they have their own company or business they can hire immigrants and they will work for much cheaper than the normal American. This also hurts a lot of Americans because they get fired when immigrants are willing to work for wages way lower than what these people are normally used to.

Read More

More about Why Americans Won T Do Dirty Jobs Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document