ipl-logo

Why Do We Need A Risky Environmental Policy In 2267

1050 Words5 Pages

This paper will examine the potential harm caused by the Canadian government implementing a risky environmental policy that gives subsidies to coal producers while taxing producers of renewable energy. The policy will cause an environmental disaster in 2267 if implemented, and thousands will die because of this policy. This paper examines the key arguments of both sides, in order to understand the cases for and against the policy based on how much harm both sides believe will be caused. If a risky environmental policy is chosen that would benefit people now, but would directly cause the deaths of thousands in 2267 then one may view the policy as harmful. One might believe this harm comes from the direct impact the policy has on future persons. If these future persons are going to exist no matter what the choice is in …show more content…

If the policy allowing the current people to live at a higher standard of living did not exist, then these future people may not have accordingly existed. As they have been allowed to exist in the first place, the risky policy is effectively better for the future people. Denying these people life is denying them any sort of happiness, even if they are to eventually die in a manner directly attributed to the policy in question. If the amount of happiness these people experience amounts to a life worth living then the policy is worth it. Another point the opposing view would raise is that the concern with the risky policy is tied to people who may not exist in the future. If these people were never going to exist then there is no danger associated with the policy implementation in the first place. Someone has to exist in order to be harmed. No victims therefore means no harm. The policy debate then becomes a question of what will bring the most benefit in the present rather than in the

Show More
Related

Keystone XL Pipeline Research Paper

628 Words | 3 Pages

The US is going to use some source of energy and that will always have some negative effects on the environment. The alternative sources for the energy we need have negative effects on the environment as well. “In 2011 U.S. coal-fired power plants emitted nearly two billion metric tons of greenhouse gases -- roughly eight times the amount produced by mining, refining and burning tar sands”(Biello). Canada is going to develop a pipeline system to export oil whether it’s to the US or other countries, like China, that are trying to get access to this resource.

Read More

The Devil Is In The Generalities Summary

655 Words | 3 Pages

The title of the article is The Environmental Crisis: The Devil is in the Generalities, written by Ross McKitrick. It appears in the April 2008 edition of the Academic Matters journal. The author is an associate professor and director of graduate studies at the Department of Economics at the University of Guelph. In discussing the environment, the author argues that the topic is rather wide to use vague terms to define or understand it. The issue is further complicated by politicians who use it as a campaign scapegoat, in which they paint it as a crisis.

Read More

The Similarities Between Avatar And The Alberta Oil Sand

1577 Words | 7 Pages

Environmentalists see the movie Avatar as a close depiction of our society's reality with the Alberta oil sands. James Cameron, the director of Avatar, created this blockbuster to bring awareness to a growing issue of Alberta’s oil sands. Undoubtedly, he has achieved this task as this movie shows numerous similarities, but also some differences regarding the current situation with the oil sands. Both show similarities when it comes to cultural and environmental sustainabilities. One environmental sustainabilities that both Avatar and the Alberta oil sands share is that in both situations mining companies decrease biodiversity.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography On Keystone Pipeline

903 Words | 4 Pages

Wilder’s essay introduces every possible issue that can arise from Keystone XL pipeline, but my focus is towards climate change. She argues that the construction and refining the dirty oil will increases climates change effect. Why should Americans shoot an arrow that will be a harm to them? We risk reaching higher atmospheric temperature, serious droughts, and floods due to the changing climate. That is not the only way climate change will affect communities, but it will also have an impact on oil spills near communities.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Keystone Pipeline

435 Words | 2 Pages

One of the most controversial projects for the United States to decide on was whether or not to build the Keystone pipeline. This topic forces the government to decide if economic development is worth the cost of endangering the environment. Though this pipeline will allow the United States to rely less on foreign oil, the pipeline’s lasting effects prove to be a factor that cannot be easily overlooked. The Keystone pipeline should not be built because it endangers the environment and has the ability to create catastrophic damages through pollution and habitat desecration. Pollution is a major factor that has to be considered when referring to the Keystone pipeline.

Read More

Argument Against Polymet

2010 Words | 9 Pages

There is a controversial and intimidating proposal that looms over the heads of not only the many inhabitants of the northwestern area of Minnesota, but as well as the entirety of the state. Polymet wishes to invest a large chunk of money into the construction of a sulfide mine. Upon first consideration, this seems like a fantastic idea. As it would provide jobs, give Minnesota new opportunities, and boost the economy of the towns and cities surrounding the mine site. However, when digging deeper, it is easily said that the negative effects outweigh the positive ones.

Read More

Michael Pollan Case Study

495 Words | 2 Pages

Discuss the role cheap fossil fuel plays in determining the way American farmers grow corn. Explain why Pollan might characterize the availability of cheap corn as a “plague”. The cheap fossil fuels are killing the economy, killing the chances for corn. Pollan characterizes the availability of cheap corn as a plague because a plague is an infectious disease that harms a lot of people.

Read More

Ontario's Long-Term Energy Plan 2015: Revision To LTEP 2013

1734 Words | 7 Pages

(Climate Change Action Plan) to ensure the directives government take are transparent and in line with COP 21 GHG emissions (see appendix) (see Figure 3)standards and provincial targets. (Environmental Commissioner of Ontario, 2016) Present Scenario Despite ON’s low-carbon electricity supply, 80% (see Figure 1)of total energy source is still fossil fuel based and that accounts for 70% of total GHG emissions (see Figure 2)in the province (see appendix). The retraction of coal fired refineries backed by presence of nuclear energy helped bring down the GHG emissions of electricity sector to 7%(of total 171 Mt, 2013) yet transportation, industry and building sectors

Read More

Review Of Senator Jay Rockefeller's Inhofe Resolution

1198 Words | 5 Pages

He believes there are other ways to end Obama’s war on coal than to put the lives of coal miners and their families at risk. Using clean coal is one alternative Rockefeller presents instead of blocking the EPA’s rules on the pollutant gases. The safety of West Virginians is in his best interest. This speech reflects his ideas and beliefs about the past, present, and future use of coal. He supports the EPA’s rules on limiting mercury, acid gases, and other toxic pollution from power plants.

Read More

Keystone Pipeline Project Research Paper

2089 Words | 9 Pages

Rachele Liba Professor Whitehead POSC 100 22 July 2016 Placing a Price on a Green Nation Having lived a nomadic lifestyle across the United States, I have had the opportunity to witness the wonders of our flourishing society and the everyday turmoils that we face. Rigorous innovation has helped Americans fulfill countless dreams, however with every gift there is a usually a price-tag or opportunity cost. Now in the midst of the general presidential election, platforms that represent our beliefs can undergo much needed reform to address the opportunity costs that were surpassed in the process of success. Among the various problems found in our society, a key movement that has raised necessary controversy has to do with environmental policy.

Read More

Non Identity Headache

1635 Words | 7 Pages

If the choice causes them to be worse off, it is still better than not existing at all. Lastly, even if the action is considered morally wrong and harms the future person, it is still morally better to choose this action as opposed to denying this future person the right to live. The choice you are worried about will not affect the existence of these future people, but rather, it will only benefit or damage them but not violate them existing. (Serada, class notes). As Parfit states, “Since these two choices will be worse for no one, we need to explain why we have a moral reason not to make these choices.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Is Universal Healthcare Good For America?

693 Words | 3 Pages

Instead of defending one’s right to live, government would decide if one ought to live. And even if universal healthcare permits one to live, that one would find himself living in a less free and entrepreneurial society; a society that is supposedly good for everyone

Read More

Polluter Dilemma Case Study

927 Words | 4 Pages

A Case Study on Polluter’s Dilemma I. Background/Point of View On a small plastic manufacturing, Jonica Gunson works as an environmental compliance manager. The company where she is working with is now facing a serious situation that needs to have a fast and decisive decision, decision whether to invest or not to invest money on new technology that will help decrease or as possible eliminate the level of toxic in the water which is flowing from the back of the factory up to lake. Though the company is compliant with the levels of emissions set by the Environmental Management board, the manager sees that environmental procedures for this specific toxic are sheathing behind logical evidence, particularly that there is a protest from a certain scientist that is publish in the newspaper.

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Government Intervention

1195 Words | 5 Pages

Thus, an unpopular tax on a product that produces negative externalities, such as car use that creates environmental damage, may be avoided due to the fact that the government is afraid of losing support from the

Read More

Plastic Bag Levy: A Case Study

1713 Words | 7 Pages

These are some for the barriers and competitiveness issues which environmental regulation, taxes and policies encounter with the respective stakeholders during policy making and during policy implementation. Therefore, a balanced approach has to be achieved; and not to focus on avoiding environment damage only, while destroying industries and forgoing the opportunity of economic growth which creates tax base for government’s revenues. The policy or package will also have to guarantee that the polluter is charged or taxed accordingly and not the affected society at large to be bore the environmental damaging costs. According to Green Fiscal Commission 2009, there are two criteria’s which can be used to assess the effectiveness of environment taxes.

Read More

More about Why Do We Need A Risky Environmental Policy In 2267

Related Topics

Open Document