ipl-logo

Why Facts Don T Change Our Minds, By Elizabeth Kolbert

826 Words4 Pages

In today’s hyperpolarized political climate where the controversial public figure, President Donald Trump won the 2016 presidential election, Americans have become transfixed upon something that should in theory be nonnegotiable: the truth. The “truth”, defined by the Oxford Dictionary as “the quality or state of something being true”, or “in accordance with fact or reality”, is something that, by definition, is black and white. However, many individuals on all areas of the political spectrum today, fail to see the what is true even when “fact or reality” is readily accessible and present, raising questions as to whether the truth is a concept as plain as it once was viewed to be. In the article, “Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds” (2017), written in The New Yorker by Elizabeth Kolbert, an award-winning columnist who has also written for the New York Times and …show more content…

In “Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds”, through describing different studies and discussing modern-day connections, Kolbert asserts that the general public’s misunderstanding of what is fact and what is fiction stems from an evolutionary adaptation for survival that has now backfired onto society as it surges forward into a world of new technologies, innovations, and ideas. Kolbert cites scientific studies to confirm her point that society has lost its ability to determine the truth. However, not only does she reference studies done about the current day human psyche, confirming society’s lack of understanding regarding the truth, but also, she describes evolutionary studies to confirm a more intrinsic reality of her idea—she references scientific examples of people

Show More
Related

Yertle The Turtle Analysis

1120 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the course of the last year, the political climate around the citizens of the United States – as well others around the world who were affected – became exceedingly politically charged. The country and its people were faced with a deep and complicated partition. Directly derived from the 2016 United States presidential election, political messages had become common place throughout all forms of media. From television shows, music, and the most apparent being news outlets, the population was continuously exposed to political ideals of different groups, as well as debates against their own. Even so, there have been countless times when political messages are not as apparent or as direct.

Read More

Essay On Trump's Argument Culture

868 Words | 4 Pages

Since the beginning of his campaign, President Trump has often portrayed himself as the victim of the liberal media and “fake news.” While every person should make a habit of checking their sources, it is my assertion that the media’s attitudes towards Trump have benefited him greatly. A common comparison somewhat alike to the chicken and the egg, is whether the media accurately represents events or creates them in their depiction. In my view both instances are present and valid in one’s attempt to analyse the media.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis On Trump And Cruz

673 Words | 3 Pages

As these statistics serve as evidence, they help validate the logic behind Bruni’s wish to educate the reader on the reality of Trump and Cruz. In this reality, a significant number of voters approve of Cruz, despite members of his own party disapproving. Thus, Bruni uses evidence to show that most Republicans themselves appose Cruz, and then statistics to prove the frightening fact that this doesn’t matter to certain voters, while simultaneously appealing to ethos by establishing

Read More

How Facts Backfire

1091 Words | 5 Pages

Humanity is in a perpetual state of trying to make living in the world an easier place. In just a few seconds, people can access information at their disposal, instead of having to look through different books to find what you need. But the question arises; does this boundless place for information honestly make us more informed than before we had the internet? Joe Keohane, the author of the article “How Facts Backfire,” is a political journalist who has also written articles on technology and culture.  

Read More

Summary Of A Minority President Lakoff

588 Words | 3 Pages

In the commentary, “A Minority President: Why the Polls Failed And What The Majority Can Do”, George Lakoff (2016) offers a refreshing analysis of the rudimentary divisiveness between America’s progressives and conservatives to explain the American zeitgeist. He presents a framework to explain Donald Trump’s unexpected win at the United States Presidential Elections 2016. By explaining Trump’s tactics, Lakoff attempts to transform his readers into critical listeners, well-versed in political rhetoric to readily oppose acts of Trump which contradict “American values”. This mirrors the fear ancient philosophers had of possible repercussions arising from an unassuming audience facing a masterful speaker (Beasley, 2012). In this essay, I seek to challenge Lakoff’s argument that Trump’s success at the elections is largely contributed to the oratorical tactics pointed out by Lakoff.

Read More

Analysis Of Can We End The Division By Cherome Clemente

738 Words | 3 Pages

Although the nation’s motto may mean “one from many,” two of the greatest and earliest presidential figures were insulting each other in becoming president, and stating ideas that ruined the other’s credibility from things that did not matter as a political figure. This showed although the two were competing for politics, they were dividing each other even further by going to their personal life and insulting. Lastly as seen in society, “An honest disagreement about principles or issues seems to be increasingly hard to find. Instead, what we have are ‘facts’ that are nothing more than lies that fit with preconceived prejudices” (Clemente 6). With the Jefferson versus Adams case as an example to fit the above statement, this is showing that a lot of what we believe is lies than truths in hopes of allowing the public to take a stance.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Daubert Standard

1404 Words | 6 Pages

Framing Truths How do we know what is true? How do we know if a man sentenced to death was truly a murderer? A question echoed by thousands of people revolting against the death penalty as the story of Todd Willingham made it to the headlines. In The New Yorker, under the title of Trial by Fire, came the terrifying enigma: “Did Texas execute an innocent man?” followed by a thorough listing of the evidence that was used to convict Willingham of setting his house on fire and resulting in the death of his three children, and how they were later disproved. There is a great misconception about the source of controversy in issues like these.

Read More

The Great Gatsby Wooden Headedness Analysis

1171 Words | 5 Pages

In everyday actions and decisions, human nature dictates that ignorance is very common. Barbara Tuchman’s theory of “wooden-headedness”, can be applied to real life on many different levels. Wooden headedness consists of assessing a situation in terms of preconceived fixed notions while ignoring or rejecting any contrary signs. This is when a person acts according to a wish while not allowing oneself to be deflected by the facts. Ignorance plays a substantial role in human affairs, although some may think it is just how kids are raised by their parents.

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Richard Cohen's The Washington

1531 Words | 7 Pages

Cohen first places President Donald Trump and his counselor Kellyanne Conway under an examination of credibility. Constantly, Cohen attacks both of these credible people to try and manipulate his audience. Cohen presents these expressions, “fake news” and “alternative facts” to show the audience how President Trump and Conway have, “increased the talk of ‘real’ or ‘fact-based’ journalism.” These details, though small, manipulates Cohen’s intended audience into thinking that Trump and Conway are the sole reason that journalists are continuously attacked for their statements. Thus, creating another dichotomy, as seen in Sullivan’s article, between those manipulated into joining Cohen’s stance and those who believe that some journalists act upon releasing fake or exaggerated news stories.

Read More

'Game Of Trump' By Maureen Dowd

144 Words | 1 Pages

Maureen Dowd’s article, “Game of Trump” (July 15, 2017), examines the “chaos” that consumes the current situation in American Politics, in which Dowd argues that the “chaos” results from Donald Trump becoming the president. Dowd uses a play on words to compare Washington to the fictional tv show, Game of Thrones. Dowd points out the critical flaws made by the president and his family in order to show Americans that if they pay close attention to the White House, they will see that Trump’s presidency is not beneficial to the country. Because the article’s content goes into politics and current events, in this case, criticizing Donald Trump’s presidency, Dowd writes for an educated audience that has a similar political bias. This article is significant

Read More

Voting Bias In America

254 Words | 2 Pages

Today’s political arena is so tremendous that few voters can fully understand it. Policies of jobs, foreign relations and gay marriage are great factors that forge party lines and get out the vote. However, when forced to choose, voters must make sense of their vote by using very limited information and tangles of misperceptions guided by politically biased newscasts . With so many factors beyond comprehension often voters are hindered due to a limited number of sources to receive unbiased information from (Lenz, 2012) .

Read More

9: 45 Worship Service Paper

876 Words | 4 Pages

When I was 20 years old, I decided to attend church services for the first time. King Street Church was the first church I went to and it is in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. There were three different types of worship services for different groups of people. One service was very traditional and most older people attended that one. I chose the 9:45 worship service because it was open to all age groups and the younger people attended.

Read More

Truth In Shirley Jackson's The Lottery

1386 Words | 6 Pages

The struggle for truth has arguably inspired and produced the greatest achievements in human history. Truth is only attainable through change, and to change is to be open to truth. History's overwhelming presence of biases and dogmatism has contributed to stifled progress and deprived men from pursuing the truth. To oppose a viewpoint contrary to one that is strongly believed in, is characteristic of humans; however, few are open to change, even when confronted by the status quo. If observed, further, it is found that views which substitute the consensus for an objective standard have certain consequences which few would accept.

Read More

Informatio Information Is A Persuasive Speech On Bruce Jenner

436 Words | 2 Pages

Raw information much like crude oil, has to be refined so it can be used as the gasoline to give put into motion specific ideologies. Looking at Donald Trump's campaign for President of the United States, facts are meaningless. His campaign is built upon the dissemination of viscerally divisive ideologies. Trump has been afforded and unrelenting media coverage which many other candidates have not been afforded. Sadly most of us are all too familiar with the 'never-ending media cycle: coverage leads to better performance in polls, which leads to more

Read More

The Negative Effects Of Media Bias

1501 Words | 7 Pages

Public trust in the media has been declining continuously over the past five years. In a Gallup study, it was reported that, “Americans' trust and confidence in the mass media "to report the news fully, accurately and fairly" has dropped to its lowest level in Gallup polling history, with 32% saying they have a great deal or fair amount of trust in the media” (Swift). This type of mistrust is because of the bias in the new forms of media today. Bias may have been easier to keep in check when there were fewer news sources. However, with the ease of access to the internet and the rise of citizen journalists and fake news sites, the public is finding more and more stories they most see shared are false.

Read More

More about Why Facts Don T Change Our Minds, By Elizabeth Kolbert

Related Topics

Open Document