ipl-logo

Why Is Aias Defeated Instead Of The Atreidai

1003 Words5 Pages

In Aias, the most profound enemies Aias has are the Atreidai. The Atreidai are comprised of the brothers, Menelaus and Agamemnon, who rule their lands and army during the Trojan War. Aias has conflicts with them because of their different levels of commitment to heroic ethic, which ultimately leads to Aias’ suicide. If Aias is supposed to be the protagonist of the story, why is he the one defeated instead of the Atreidai? I will argue that in Aias the Atreidai’s corrupt rule persists while Aias dies because Aias’ overvalued perception of the heroic ethic makes him unable to rise up against the Atreidai. The enemies fall on either end of the spectrum when it comes to the heroic ethic. While Aias believes in the heroic ethic wholeheartedly, the …show more content…

This same heroic ethic instills fear in the Atreidai because it threatens their power. This is why the Atreidai do not want to give Aias a proper burial. A proper burial implies the warrior is an ally and not an enemy, which the Atreidai do not see Aias as (line 1267). To give him a proper burial encourages Aias’ example “to deny the need for obedience” (line 1195) in the Atreidai’s eyes. The Atreidai instead want to present Aias as a “dangerous enemy” and “traitor” as they see him (lines 1172-1173). However, the rejection of a proper burial for Aias evokes the opposite effect in part of the army as seen when the chorus tells Menelaus to “not outrage the dead” (line 1220), defending Aias rather than condemning him. With the chorus as his first wave of support, Aias could have rallied more of the troops when alive to overthrow the Atreidai he loathed so much. However, the dedication to the heroic ethic that makes Aias a hero ultimately causes his downfall. While he is honorable in his battles and sees the corruption and shamelessness of the Atreidai, Aias is blinded by his own shame, unable to see the potential for change he could have brought about if he had lived. He is supposed to be the hero but instead falls short, thus revealing how overvaluing the heroic ethic can cause more harm than

Show More
Related
146 Words | 1 Pages

In conclusion, the Iliad presents readers a mystical world with double duality through the god's intervention in the Trojan War. The inner layer is the conflicts between Achaians and Trojans, while the outer layer is the opposition between mortals and immortals. The duality of gods and humans gives the readers a new perspective of considering the world of the Iliad, in which human beings, regardless their nationality, can be seen as an entity. The new perspective places mortal's value system in an equivalent position with god's will when mortal decides their active movement. The intervention also transforms the reader's attitudes towards heroes, especially Achilles, Hektor, and Diomedes, who reveal their persistence in either moral value or

Read More
445 Words | 2 Pages

Another aspect that hinders the Achaians is that Achilleus, their best fighter, refuses to fight. With this, the Achaians go into a sort go loosing slump, as the Trojans gain speed and more success. In book two, Zeus’, in order to fulfill Achilleus’ request, sends a treacherous dream to Agamemnon that says, “He might take the wide-eyed city of the Trojans” (92). In the dream Nestor tells Agamemnon that if he attacks Troy immediately at full strength, then it will fall.

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

“Aspire rather to be a hero than merely appear as one,” said Baltasar Gracian. Not all heros wear capes or can fly. Nor do they look as imagined, they just look like ordinary people who do not always want to be cherished for their daring acts. The author of the first novel The Enemy of the seven book series is Charlie Higson who is not only an author but an english actor, comedian, screenwriter, producer and a former singer. Many characters in the book The Enemy show heroism but one character that stands out above all is Achilleus who demonstrates three of the many character traits of a hero; Altruism, being caring and being tenacious.

Read More
1169 Words | 5 Pages

Patroklos is willing to die, as long as it is for and beside his friends. Whereas, Achilleus has the wrong intentions for fighting in battle. In his fury, his emotions take action, primitively speaking, “ Now I shall go, to overtake that killer of a dear life, Hektor.” (XVIII 114). Having anger in general and furthermore acting upon his anger makes him less heroic.

Read More
425 Words | 2 Pages

Both of those instances show that being a hero and doing what's right is more important than their personal

Read More
1119 Words | 5 Pages

The story of the death of Agamemnon is told in both the Homeric epic Odyssey and in Aeschylus’ tragic trilogy the Oresteia. Although the basic plot remains the same, differences in presentation, emphasis, and details show how myth is fluid and can be adapted to suit a particular author, performance, and audience. This myth serves in the Odyssey as an example of failed nostos caused by the breakdown of the hero’s household, and so it provides a foil for the successful return home of the epic hero Odysseus to his intact household. On the other hand, in the Oresteia, the myth illustrates the overarching theme of the nature of justice. Here the death of Agamemnon both illustrates the curse on his household and also provides the necessary background for Orestes’ important role in the transformation of justice from oikos-based revenge to polis-based trial by jury.

Read More
1051 Words | 5 Pages

Agamemnon’s taking of Briseis enrages Achilles and spurs him to remove himself from the war, leading to a massive death toll in the Achaean forces. In stealing Briseis from Achilles, he is not only robbing of him of a material prize, but also a symbol of honor, his geras, in Greek culture. In retaliation, Achilles removes himself from the war and prays to his mother, Thetis, that she will ask Zeus to damage the Achaean forces. Achilles’ only goal is that “even mighty Atrides can see how mad he was to disgrace Achilles” (1.488-490). Despite having no true grievance against the Achaean army as a whole, Achilles’ rage blinds him from the potential harm that may befall his troops.

Read More
1381 Words | 6 Pages

If I stay here and fight before the city of Troy, there will be no home- coming for me but my fame shall never die; if I go home to my native land, there will be no great fame for me, but I shall live long and not die an early death.” (Homer 110) This shows that he is selfishness and fearful at the same time of losing and dying in the war. In the very beginning of the Iliad, King Agamemnon and Achilles have an argument for a couple of different reasons. After, the Achians won a battle against a city that was allied with the Trojans each of them received a prize consisted of a young woman from the war.

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

Odysseus shows considerable hubris when he brags to King Alconis about slaughtering the small village of Ismarus. Odysseus claims that he and his men “stormed that place,” enslaved the women, and slaughtered those who fought. (Homer 43). Due to Odysseus’ arrogant decision to assault Ismarus, a few of his men died. This demonstrates how arrogance and the hunger for victory will lead to certain death.

Read More
1143 Words | 5 Pages

Bernard Evslin’s Heroes, Gods and Monsters of the Greek Myths and Burton Raffel’s Beowulf provide the reader with heroes who are morally questionable. In a typical myth, the hero of the story often makes many ambiguous choices that seem admirable on the surface, but develop in an unsettling manner. The hero is generally guided to an adventure and along the way commits many sins of goodness. Oftentimes, these heroes will never be able to overcome their obstacles; and therefore become fundamentally flawed. They are often looked up to as role models, but in essence these “heros” are representations of evil.

Read More
1570 Words | 7 Pages

In the epic poem, the Iliad written by Homer, several characters taking part in the warfare between the Achaeans and the Trojans are portrayed as embodying the heroic code of courage, physical strength, leadership, arete of value of honour, and the acceptance of fate. The heroic code is illustrated by the actions of the Trojan prince, Hector and the Achaeans strongest warrior, Achilles. Both of these characters display the Greek’s image of a hero, and can also let the reader discern what the society admires, looks up to and aspires to in its heroes. There are also characters who fail to be heroic, such as the Trojan “vivid and beautiful” prince, Paris. These characters in the Iliad illustrate the qualities that Ancient Greek society values.

Read More
1254 Words | 6 Pages

When in modern day society, we would see him as a blood-thirsty lunatic. Achilles was not a hero, simply because he was selfish, distrustful, and he acted upon his own instinct without thought of the repercussions he would cause for those around him. The Iliad is a novel about the Trojan War. Previous to the war, three goddesses, Hera, Athena and Aphrodite are competing to see who is the best.

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

More a warrior than a king Imagine the biggest bully you know. He 's big and strong, but not so smart. He picks on those smaller or weaker than himself, throws his weight around, and basically acts like a huge jerk just because he can. Now give that bully a kingdom and soldiers at his command, and you 're pretty close to the character of Agamemnon in The Iliad. Though he is a great warrior, he is not much of a king.

Read More
396 Words | 2 Pages

Some people want to know if myths,folktales, and fairy tales. Are relevant to our society and the answer is yes. Why well there many reasons why they are relevant. So if people are asking these question, is because they don 't know. In a matter of fact let 's jump into the first reason why they are relevant to our everyday society.

Read More
1512 Words | 7 Pages

Iliad is recognized as one of the most famous ancient monuments of literature. The full understanding of this epic poem is hardly possible without thorough analysis of its main characters. Among all the episodes of the Trojan War, Homer chooses the moment of Achilles’ wrath and thus creates a poem in which he becomes the central figure. From the Ancient Greeks’ point of view, Achilles represents the ideal of manliness and pure heroism, for he is brave and fights for heroics, not profits. Today, one can agree with this interpretation, yet Achilles is probably the most controversial character because he combines various personality traits and acts in accordance with his ambiguous nature.

Read More

More about Why Is Aias Defeated Instead Of The Atreidai

Related Topics

Open Document