ipl-logo

Why Tom Brady Should Not Have Been Suspended Essay

1231 Words5 Pages

Why Tom Brady Should Not Have Been Suspended Researching this topic, I found a few qualified authors that discussed this topic. These authors provide information and statistics on how the NFL handles these issues poorly and why Tom Brady shouldn't have been suspended. These articles also explain how the suspension process went through with in depth facts of the events that happened over the year and a half long scandal. The authors of the articles have qualified opinions about the law and how the league should have handled it due to their policies. On Jan 18, of 2015 the NFL started looking into the Patriots use of deflated footballs used in the AFC championship game against the Colts. Two days later the NFL learned that 11 footballs had …show more content…

McCann says “from a legal perspective, are many questions on how the NFL handled the controversy.” (Leadbeater 1). Some of the questions arise because of how the NFL handled the evidence, the lack of evidence they had, and how Brady’s punishment was given out. McCann states “NFL commissioner Roger Goodell has too much power in his position, and that’s part of the reason why the league is in the position it is currently in.” (Leafbeater 2). The NFL Players Association is criticized for putting all the power into Goodell’s hands. Goodell has the power of being the judge and the juror, he decides whether or not players be punished and then he decides how long they are going to be suspended or how much they will be fined. The Players Association is blamed for this because, in their last collective bargaining agreement with league officials, they failed to gain any leverage in the sentencing of their players’ punishments. The NFL is also criticized in the handling of Tom Brady’s punishment due to the amount of time it took them to deal out his suspension. McCann said in his interview “The NBA had the story of Donald Sterling’s racial comments handled in less than 72 hours”. (Leadbeater 2). The NFL has had issues dealing with punishments. For example, the NFL has a history of making larger suspensions in small drug offenses than they do for domestic violence charges. Josh Gordon was suspended for the entire 2015 season, while Greg Hardy was only suspended 4 games even though there were graphic images proving the severity of his crime. McCann also criticizes Goodell for not actually being an attorney, and believes “he does not grasp the consistency of transparency and process” (Leadbeater 2). McCann believes the NFL needs to reevaluate its system of player discipline. For all of the injustice going on for the players of the league at this time, the Players Union will

Show More
Related
331 Words | 2 Pages

The main issue from this case was to determine whether the NFL’s eligibility rule was exempt from the antitrust law. During this case, the NFL players union and the

Read More
1775 Words | 8 Pages

In an incident in 2014, Goodell was responsible for reviewing the appropriateness of Tom Brady's actions in the Deflate Gate case. Goodell was responsible for handing down Brady’s four game suspension, listening to Brady’s appeal, and additionally denying the appeal, which is most definitely in a conflict of interest. People

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

“What the numbers Show about N.F.L. player Arrests” is an article written by Neil Irwin who analysis the amount of run ins the NFL players have with the law. Irwin compares the numbers to see if there are certain teams that get into legal trouble. The author claim is that “the numbers show a league in which drunk-driving arrests are a continuing problem and domestic violence charges are surprisingly common” (181). Irwin uses data, numbers, and other facts to support his claim. Irwin draws out specific types of arrests and he discusses the frequency of these arrests that the players have.

Read More
631 Words | 3 Pages

The deflategate is a NFL controversy about how the New England Patriots deflated 11 of the 12 game balls. The Patriots did this in the AFC Championship game against the Indianapolis Colts to win at a score of 45-7.That was a odd score don't you think how could a team go to the AFC Championship game just to lose 45-7.It turns out that the New England Patriots had deflated the balls. Bob Kratiz had said that the inflation range was under the NFL requirements of 12.5-13.5 P.S.I.Now there is proof if you Patriots fans were asking. There was a Patriots locker room attendant tried to give the NFL official in the AFC Championship game a unaproved special teams ball. A man named Sharp who focuses alot on football looked more into this conterversy by looking at the fumbles.

Read More
1576 Words | 7 Pages

While he most definitely responds to and takes care of the needs of the owners of all NFL teams, it’s a known fact the NFL Players Association has mostly disapproved of his job as commissioner. In response to Deflategate, the NFLPA stated, “that the final decision “is more smear campaign than reasoned decision,” that is it “a propaganda piece written for public consumption, at a time when the NFL believed the transcript would be sealed for public view,” and that Goodell hoped “to validate a multi-million-dollar ‘independent’ investigation” (Florio,

Read More
817 Words | 4 Pages

Why you should pull for the New England Patriots There were two minutes and eight seconds left in the third quarter and the Patriots were losing 28 to 3. It was first and goal and Tom Brady threw a touchdown pass to James White to close the deficit to 28-9. The Patriots defense made a huge stop to give their offense the ball back to start the fourth quarter. From then on it was incredible the Patriots orchestrated one of the greatest comebacks just not in Super Bowl history but in all of sports. Tom Brady the New England Patriots starting Quarterback has orchestrated over 40 fourth quarter comebacks and 51 game winning drives, why wouldn’t you want to pull for a team that has no quit.

Read More
658 Words | 3 Pages

Generally people think that the NFL should adjust the game, and its rules to increase player safety, statistics clearly show that too much adjusting has been done and the NFL is suffering because of it. Too many rules have been changed for player safety and the current changes being discussed, like getting rid of the kickoff, are going to far and the game is not like it was. Players sign contracts and are aware of the risks they put themselves at when playing the game of football at a professional level. Referees are throwing more flags and the NFL commissioner, Roger Goodell, is handing out a record high of fines. These adjustments by the National Football League are going too far and some rule changes need to be reverted back to their previous rules.

Read More
998 Words | 4 Pages

Did you know Tom brady is one of the best quarterbacks ever with the most super bowl starts ever? Tom Brady has had a super interesting life and a very interesting career playing football. Tom Brady has a very fun and eventful career. Also Tom brady has a pretty well rounded family. Another thing about Tom is that he had a good time at college.

Read More
1138 Words | 5 Pages

According to Dylan Bennett, most NFL players that know that most player that have medicine The National Football League (NFL) needs to change their policy on drug for players that have reason for them. One reason why they need to change it is so players that use prescription drugs can still play in the NFL instead of just being suspended and fine for taking their medication perceived by their doctor. This case will be shown because players have lost a large amount of time form their careers or have lost their careers due to the drug policy of the NFL. What is the NFL drug policy and when it came into effect? What are other sports drug policies?

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

Playing sports of any kind comes with associated risks, which is why pro athletes are some of the highest paid individuals in the industry. During his 3.5-year career, an average pro football player makes over $6 million, while an average professional basketball player makes over $24 million during his 4.8-year career. So why aren't student-athletes afforded the same compensation? They are still at risk every time they step inside the court or in the field, after all.

Read More
1279 Words | 6 Pages

A drug test is a biological specimen of urine, hair, blood, breath, sweat, or saliva. It is used to determine the presence of drugs or metabolism. In the Nfl drug tests are used for many reasons one of them being that they aren’t allowed and there is much information to prove that. All players are tested at least once per league year during training camp for substances of abuse including marijuana. This makes not so much sense because if there are reports that you were using any kind of drug your team could drug test you immediately.

Read More
836 Words | 4 Pages

I’m a big football fan, but I have to tell you if I had a son, I’d have think long and hard before I let him play football,” says President Obama (Fox News). The debate of whether or not football should be banned started with this speech given by President Obama. Recently, studies have shown that a large number of hits may cause more brain damage than a handful of concussions. Although people think banning football will decrease the amount of teen deaths and concussions; football should not be banned because it is just as dangerous as any other high school sports, many people would lose their job if it was banned, and football and sports help keep kids off the street. Football should not be banned because it is just as dangerous as any other

Read More
490 Words | 2 Pages

Very often the athlete is put on trial by the public before all facts have been uncovered. However, as expected the athlete’s deviant behavior elicits a response from fans (Norms & Deviance, PP) Consequently, the leagues usually exact punishment to the extent of public uproar rather the extent of the misconduct. As results some athletes may be punished unfairly or given leniency based on public opinions.

Read More
910 Words | 4 Pages

This stirred up controversy around the league on how long his suspension should be. He was

Read More
1320 Words | 6 Pages

Moreover, it might be their husband who did not want this incident to go public so that it would not risk their career, their husband's manager who also did not want to lose a job if the player was dismissed from the league, and the NFL itself who did not want its name to be stained. Based on some story by the victims, the NFL also did not reply to some of these reported violence cases by their player. NFL players have a lot of backup, and some of the big people in the NFL also did not want the player to be dismissed from the league because of this incident. There are some confessions by one of the victim that when her neighbor called the police and filed a report, the police came to her house and did not arrest her husband, and what they did was they chatted, laughed, and some of them also asked for a signature for their kids. There are a lot of possibilities about who might be the person who wants to cover up and conceal this incident, because there are many people who will be at a disadvantage to defend someone who is

Read More

More about Why Tom Brady Should Not Have Been Suspended Essay

Open Document