ipl-logo

Workplace Monitoring Case Summary

1943 Words8 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Legal and ethical issues of employee monitoring

Workplace monitoring covers the legal allegations of balancing and managing organizational needs to protect and preserve the workplace with the expectation of privacy from its employees. Employers must conduct appropriate steps to reduce the risk of misconduct and other losses by monitoring and establishing policies to protect its employees and property. In this paper, the topic for discussion will provide an analysis of the federal court’s decisions on issues concerning employees’ privacy and limits on an employer’s rights to search and seizure in four separate case studies. Additionally, the discussion will include the impact that the decisions had on an employer’s responsibility and the employee’s rights to privacy. …show more content…

UAL Corporation The plaintiff, Kevin Sporer argues that UAL breached his privacy and wrongfully fired him. Sporer was an employee with UAL for over 20 years, and ended his employment under “at will” status (Moran, 2014). In 2007, Sporer received an email that contained pornographic material through the company’s email system, in which he forwarded to his personal email account. Sporer then sent an email to the sender of the pornographic material requesting him to not send any further messages that contain inappropriate contents due to the organization’s strict policies. During a routine audit, UAL’s Information Security Department crossed the pornographic email that Sporer forwarded to his personal email. According to the organization, Sporer’s termination resulted of his company’s email policy violation. The organization’s email policy states that all message content must always be professional, and prohibits the transmission of any messages that compromise such policy (Moran, 2014). Additionally, the organization’s policy also prohibits the transmission of profane, derogatory, and obscene material. Sporer clearly understood UAL’s email policy and knew that email was regularly audited and monitored. He was repeatedly informed about the monitoring system of all activity conducted on the workplace computers, including emails. The disclosure that informed Sporer of this each time the computer was signed into could not be bypassed without selecting “OK” to clear the notice of the system monitoring (Moran, 2014). Additionally, when Sporer requested for the sender of the pornographic material to not send that type of content because of UAL’s strict policy indicates that he was completely aware of the monitoring and the policy. By forwarding the email to his personal email account was a breach of UAL’s policies and instead of deleting it (Moran, 2014). The monitoring of company systems serve to protect sensitive information

Show More
Related
625 Words | 3 Pages

One of, if not, the most provocative arguments Kerr offers in his article is that the third-party doctrine should not be framed in terms of “reasonable expectation of privacy” in which a person “waives” their reasonable expectation of privacy, but rather as a consent doctrine. In his view, what we voluntarily disclose to third parties eliminates Fourth Amendment protection because of implied consent. Specifically, a person voluntarily discloses information to a third party if they do so knowingly. Consequently, searches, if a government agent’s conduct is deemed as such, are reasonable because the person allowed the government to do so. Kerr’s example for his principle is problematic.

Read More
2313 Words | 10 Pages

Because technology is continually growing, new laws are being passed regarding technology and confidentiality. This article questions the “invasive” internet searches and looks for a constitutional answer. As of now, no electronic device can be confiscated and searched without a warrant. This could prove to be beneficial for Arnie. If he was to report Mr. Bowen’s suspicious data to the police, they would be able to obtain a warrant to officially search Mr. Bowen’s computer.

Read More
162 Words | 1 Pages

In “Avatars, Scarlet ‘A’s, and Adultery in the Technological Age” by an Assistant Professor of Law Sandi S. Varnado explore the new increasing twist on the age-old issue of adultery and online infidelity by using technology that causes many divorces between marriages. Nowadays people have love affairs using the Internet, specifically to communicate with others. According to Varnado, she reports that in December 2012 a survey revealed that 81% of all adults in the United States use the Internet, which has impacted our society in both positive and negative ways (372). Varnado also emphasizes that given the appearance and prevalence of online sexual satisfaction, it is not difficult to imagine that many Internet users are engaging in online. When

Read More
1604 Words | 7 Pages

After being reviewed, the Court ruled that the search was not in violation of the Fourth Amendment. They said that “the realities of the workplace” did not give him the same privacy of being in his own home. It states that an individual’s workspace can be searched because it’s the safety of the workplace and the space is property of the business, not the employee. (O'Connor v. Ortega, n.d.).

Read More
699 Words | 3 Pages

“The Fourth Amendment says that you have an expectation of privacy in your home and person (body). The government cannot search you, your home, or belongings without a good reason.” (Background Essay). But, through the years the government has invaded the protection the Fourth Amendment has given to society. For example, “Federal agents put a bug- a device that allowed them to listen to the conversations” (Doc A).

Read More
1117 Words | 5 Pages

This a negative impact on people and people need to start worrying about saving their job. Schneier use pathos, this is scary to think that we’re under surveillance 24/7, no matter where you are. People need to be aware that the companies are invading their privacy, “which means they keep you under surveillance” (Schneier 4). They offer you many free services and apps. This is their way to collect your data.

Read More
451 Words | 2 Pages

Again, the standards of use are clear and the expectation of privacy does not survive the government’s interest and already established case law. If using a personal thumb-drive in a government owned device, the employee would not have any rights under the Fourth Amendment for that thumb drive being searched and seized. Is the governments search or seizure unreasonable? It would not be once an employee introduced a device such as a thumb-drive into the government computer. The government has a vested interest in the cyber security of their network.

Read More
1202 Words | 5 Pages

Generacism Flannery O’Connor uses her profound and substantial words to unleash a deeper meaning within her writing “A Good Man Is Hard To Find.” Although there were numerous cultural conflicts amongst the story, racism is a very firmly expressed concern in the text due to the generational differences between the grandmother and the family. My grandmother, Mimi, is the most lovable woman to walk the Earth. However, due to her generational differences, it led her to believe an adopted black baby might be troubling to her family. Despite their personality variations and verbal behavior, my grandmother and the grandmother in “A Good Man Is Hard To Find” have been afflicted in tremendous ways by the surrounding society from their past.

Read More
1651 Words | 7 Pages

Nowadays, “privacy” is becoming a popular conversation topic. Many people believe that if they do not do anything wrong in the face of technology and security, then they have nothing to hide. Professor Daniel J. Solove of George Washington University Law School, an internationally known expert in privacy law, wrote the article Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have ‘Nothing to Hide’, published in The Chronicle of Higher Education in May of 2011. Solove explains what privacy is and the value of privacy, and he insists that the ‘nothing to hide’ argument is wrong in this article. In the article, “Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have ‘Nothing to Hide’”, Daniel J. Solove uses ethos, pathos, and logos effectively by using strong sources, using

Read More
186 Words | 1 Pages

In the article, Snoopers at Work author Bill Bryson, suggests that nearly every American employee is being spied on in some way by their employers. Many companies have taken advantage of the advances in technology by using it daringly to spy on their employees by intruding in medical records and monetoring phone calls. Furthermore, other companies are observing their employees as they work by hiding recording cameras and spying on them secretly. Meanwhile, there is also a distinct paranoia around drugs. Multiple companies have introduced a regulatory system called TAD or tobacco, alcohol, and drugs which forbid their employees from consuming any of those substances at any given time, including in their homes; infact, these companies enforce

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

Joseph, This is a great question. The main issue presented with digital evidence and the Fourth Amendment are the limitations presented during the investigation of criminal cases. The Fourth Amendment protects the privacy of every citizen in the country, which makes law enforcement 's job of enforcing the law a complicated process. Also, the amendment states that only due to a reasonable cause, a search and seizure shall be performed, and most of the times after obtaining a warrant.

Read More
295 Words | 2 Pages

The Fourth Amendment states, "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized" (Administrative Office, n.d.) The key to this is unreasonable searches and seizures. I am using a government-owned device and if my employer believes I have something to hide that could be hurtful or harmful, he should be allowed to search my device without waiting for a warrant. The only time it would be infringing on my rights protected by the Fourth Amendment is if he is being unreasonable and only checking whenever he felt like being nosey.

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

Examples of these include the Apple vs. FBI case and the Hillary Clinton email sever scandal. Both of these stories covered by the news are only touching the surface of what is to come, the court interpretation of the 4th amendment search and seizure in criminal cases has the potential to redefine the unstated but implied right to privacy. I would like to be a part of this expanding debate and help protect the privacy of others while also taking down those who represent a clear and present danger to

Read More
1289 Words | 6 Pages

Sexual harassment and sexual assault are very serious issues happening today in the workplace. Women or men have suffered from unsolicited sexual behaviors that are typically provoked by someone “higher” in position. “Sexual harassment especially has been a fixture in the workplace since women began to work outside their homes” (Fitzgerald, 1993). It is solely the responsibility of the employer to ensure that all employees within are aware and are very cautions of laws, misconduct, and liabilities. Employers must enforce the Policy Prohibiting Discrimination and further extend those laws and guidelines to their employees.

Read More
1512 Words | 7 Pages

The organization I chose to observe, and interview three people at is called Shorty’s Lunch, my family’s business. It is a small restaurant located in Washington, PA that has been around for over eighty years. The people I chose to observe, and interview were; Steve the owner, Leslie the head waitress, and John the general manager. Steve the owner of the restaurant has worked there since he was around sixteen years old.

Read More

More about Workplace Monitoring Case Summary

Related Topics

Open Document