More handpicked essays just for you.
Merit and Demerit of Totalitarianism
Merit and Demerit of Totalitarianism
Merit and Demerit of Totalitarianism
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
In George Orwell's novel, 1984, Julia and Winston have different views on life under the totalitarian regime of Oceania. These different views have caused different, but similar, actions throughout the whole book. Winston believes that the party is cruel and inhumane, while Julia doesn’t like the rules and just wants to break them. Even though Winston and Julia both ended up in jail, they had different perspectives on The Party. Winston hated the party.
" Nevertheless, even with fear from both, they continued writing knowing the consequences of what could happen without agreeing with the opposite force in the case of Orwell, communist Russia, and Winston Big Brother, proving that their desire to express themselves is even more powerful than the terror that death might bring them. Then, during chapter two of the book, we were presented with an outside situation in Winston's life. Winston shares his perspective on two coworkers in the ministry of truth, O'Brien and Julia. O'Brien gets introduced further at the end of chapter two, but Julia plays a crucial role in Winston's life. Winston, in the beginning, hated Julia because she formed part of the young anti-sex league.
Breaking his only promise to Julia, never to betray her, was unavoidable. And the brief encounter with Julia when he is released, she gave him what she had gotten from him, bitter
In 1984, Winston and Julia fear their relationship may be discovered. Winston even has the concern early in their relationship, that Julia is working for the “Thought Police.” He mentions this to Julia and she is appalled by this thought. Winston then gives the reasoning, “But from your general appearance-merely because you’re young and fresh and
As the novel progresses Winston's desire of a revolution and hatred of the government is altered and dwarfed by love for Julia. “I want to truly feel what it means to be human, to be loved and love someone. To grow old with them and share my life with them” (Orwell 128). Winston being a single middle aged man who hasn’t truly felt a feeling like this, longs for a special someone to call his own and diverts his attention towards Julia. She is the only thing that matters to him, and Winston desires to spend the rest of his life with her.
Julia pushes Winston; she initiates their meeting and encourages him to rebel. Some could say that without he woman both men would not have gone through with their plans. Violence
In Oceania, the Party works to make sure love between partners is eliminated, for the individual can only truly love Big Brother. Winston, looking for a way to rebel, finds Julia, who is just as rebellious as he is. The secret of their affair is against the law not only because they are having sex, but also because both are willing to commit thought-crime. (pattern 16)
It is questionable whether this has also caused them to become arrogant and leads to their failures in their quests, but this imperfectness has definitely caused them to become memorable as they become closer to real human beings rather than the perfect traditional heroes. Winston’s rebellion only exists in his mind rather than his action, but he does have a strong sense of superiority over others. The fact that he calls Julia “a rebel from the waist downwards” shows the flaws in Winston’s personality, we can see his lack of respect to female, and it seems like their relationship is more likely to be a minor fight back to the party rather than something out of romantic love. Winston also stated that “She knew when to cheer and when to boo, and that was all one needed” suggesting that they lack real communication as well. All Winston wants Julia for is the sexual relationship they can have and the fact that she is someone that can listen even though she does not understand or have an interest in it.
Once Julia has given Winston the note that says ‘I love you’ on it, they begin meeting each other in private, but Winston is not sexually attracted to Julia like she is to him; “Their embrace had been a battle, the climax a victory. It was a blow against the part. It was a political act” (Orwell, 104). In 1984 relationships are forbidden, unless to only reproduce children for the party, making Winston and Julia’s relationship extremely
After Winston is taken by the thought police into the Ministry of Love, he is completely brainwashed, Orwell says “He loved Big Brother” (298). His internal struggle with Julia is also finished, as they both admit they are no longer in love with each other. Julia says to Winston, “‘And after that, you don’t feel the same toward the other person any longer’” and Winston replies, “‘No,’... ‘you don’t feel the same any longer”’(292). Without his rebellious thoughts and Julia there to encourage them, Winston’s internal battle is finally finished.
George Orwell’s novel, 1984 illustrates the power that love can have on an individual throughout the book. In the beginning of the book 1984, Winston struggles with conforming to the government and does everything in his power to protect his thoughts from the Party. The knowledge that he holds could get him vaporized in no time. Winston is looking for an outlet for his rebellion and turns to the idea of an underground organization whose specific purpose is to cause the downfall of the government. During the process of his private search, a love interest emerges into Winston’s life.
“A hero is an ordinary individual who finds the strength to persevere and endure in spite of overwhelming obstacles” ( Christopher Reeve). This passage from a speech given by Christopher Reeve perfectly displays what society thinks a hero should be. However not all protagonist show the same traits; some do not even seem like heroes or good guys, they seem more like villains than heroes. This makes the reader support the antagonist because they seem more of a hero than the protagonist. This happens during The Nether.
Julia wasn’t much interested in reading, and Winston was surprised to discover that “the difference between truth and falsehood did not seem important to” (193) Julia. While Winston was greatly concerned about the party’s manipulation of truth, Julia was more interested in freedom of individuality. The clever thing was to break the rules and stay alive, whether it was a love affair, swearing, wearing makeup or obtaining luxuries on the black market. She took great pride in her ability to bring real sugar, real milk, and real coffee to her meetings with Winston (177). Julia’s desires to bring these prohibited items to their meetings, as well as her disinterest in exposing the part indicate that she rebels simply to undermine the party in her own small ways and gain individual freedom.
George Orwell’s novel 1984 presents us two characters who are entirely different, but still complement each other entirely, the protagonist Winston and his love-interest Julia. Julia’s optimistic character highlights Winston’s fatalistic one. Winston believes he and Julia are compatible and can relate to each other because they share the same believes. They both detest Big Brother and want to rebel against the Party. While this is true, their similarities seem to end there.
Winston falls in love with a black haired girl, Julia. This is in itself an act of rebellion on the part of both of them. A description of their love making follows, and these passages alone contain a lyrical, sensuous quality utterly lacking elsewhere in the book. Winston and Julia, already rebels, now become more active in their plot against the party. They contact O’Brien whom they believe to be a fellow rebel.
