ipl-logo

A Battle Between A Samurai And A Knight Analysis

448 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Simularities knights and samurai conclusion

Who Would Win in a Battle Between a Samurai and a Knight?
Although knights and Samurai have a lot of superior advantages, I believe that the knights have more, and that they will win in a hand to hand combat battle. They have better armor, trained from a young age, and have great weapons. The first way that knights have an advantage is that they have better armor. In document D, written by Terry Bennett, it states that knights wore complete suits of metal armor on their whole body. This supports my claim because armor decided the outcome of most of the battles in the middle ages, and they could reflect the blade from the samurai. Another piece of evidence that supports the claim is in document D written by Terry Bennett, it says that they made Samurai wear more armor due to their extra advantage of sharp armor so they could pounce their enemies. Shortly Thereafter,
The second way that Knights would have an advantage in battle is that they trained being a knight at such a young age. In document C2, written by PBS, It states” ...A future knight’s training began at the age of four or five with learning how to ride a pony. This teaches them at a young age how small responsibilities will impact you in life after all. It …show more content…

In document C2, written by PBS, it says “... This included practice with blunted (less sharp) or wooden swords…”. This gives them more training with these weapons, and helps then exceed their high standards to be able to master weapons being a knight. It also says in the Warriors video by the History Channel, it states,”The weapons are sharper than the Samurai’s armor…”. This will help the knights decapitate and cut through their armor, causing the samurai to get new armor. Lastly, Document D written by Terry Bennett, says that the knights had made guns, and that the samurai were forced to wear armor to stop bullet penetration, but it was too heavy to wear on the

Show More
Related
601 Words | 3 Pages

The similarities between the samurai and the knight were greater than the differences. This can be shown by looking at three areas social status, honor and death, and traning and armor. The first area of important differences was social status different it was that because there was a social pyramid were the samurai class was divided up, and the knight was divided up. For the order in japan there was emperor, the shogun, daimyo, the samurai

Read More
344 Words | 2 Pages

There were many similarities and differences between Samurai and Knights, but I believe that the differences are greater than the similarities, in other other words I believe that there are more similarities than differences. The Samurai were honorable warriors in Japan that were loyal to his Daimyos. The Knights were honorable warriors in Europe who were loyal to his lord. I’m going to analyze documents related to social position, training and armor, and their beliefs. To better determine if the differences are greater than the similarities.

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

Knights and samurai are very similar. They were warriors during the age of feudalism who protected and were loyal to their lord. But while they are incredibly similar, who would win in a battle? However despite these similarities, in a one, in a one one one fight, the advantage would go to the samurai since their armor, code, and training are superior to that of the knights.

Read More
436 Words | 2 Pages

Throughout the years, both Japan and Europe turned into a Chaotic mess, around the same time. In the late 400’s the Roman empire had fallen, leaving Divided and weekend kingdoms. On the other side of the world, Japan was having some similar issues. The Japanese emperors and the Imperial Court we're both challenged by the rise of Clans. Despite religion, Samurai and knights are more similar than different.

Read More
687 Words | 3 Pages

Tokugawa Japan + Medieval Europe Medieval Europe and Tokugawa Japan lived in seclusion to each other, and yet there were many uncanny similarities between Tokugawa Japan and Medieval Europe. In Medieval Europe there were many key features of the social system that were introduced at the time. The social system of Medieval Europe was called Feudalism. Feudalism puts the King in charge of everything and everyone, with barons and nobles underneath him. The nobles provide loyalty and knights to the king in return for land to control.

Read More
508 Words | 3 Pages

Samurais and knights have many differences, but also share many traits. One difference is that Samurais have better armor than the knights due. This armor allows the samurais to use their right arm while the knight's arms are enclosed in their armor. As stated in document D, “Samurai did not wear armor on their right arm so they can easily draw their bow.” Another difference that they have with their armor is in Document D it states, “The knights’ armors weighed about 40 to 60 pounds (heavier than the samurai's armor)”

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

All of this leads to an impact on military, feudalistic society and Japan’s history. To commence, Samurai’s are important in Japanese history because they helped start feudalism and the Shogun’s rule. It all started when the central government had no authority over the large landowners. The Daimyo refused to pay their taxes, so when the Jurisdiction came to collect, the daimyo had this huge army of Samurais.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

Samurai and Knights: Were the Similarities Greater Than the Differences? Japan and Europe had unique lifestyles, one part being its military. It consisted of archers, who wielded bows and skilled swordsmen, called samurai. In Europe however, their military consisted of archers and swordsmen called knights. These two military figures share many similarities between each other, outweighing the differences.

Read More
1403 Words | 6 Pages

Japan’s rich history of power, wealth, and influence had many remarkable eras. One of the more notable periods in Japanese history was that of the Tokugawa Period (1600-1868). The Tokugawa Period was talked about in Musui’s Story, an autobiographical book, written by Kokichi Katsu. (Katsu ix) Katsu wrote Musui’s Story for three main reasons: to share how he had transformed from a low-ranking samurai to a well-known hero, to show his sense of self, and to serve as a cautionary tale for his descendants.

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

From the Kamakura Period of the late twelfth century to the Meiji Restoration in the nineteenth century, the samurai have held prominent positions as noble warriors in Japanese society. They have come to be famous in modern, Western pop culture as the fierce, stoic guards of feudal Japan, but their practices and rituals extended beyond wielding katanas and donning impressive armor. Samurai practices were rich and complex, with strict codes, ritual suicide, and a history of influencing culture and politics (“Samurai”). Samurai code was influenced by traditional Japanese culture, Zen Buddhism, and Confucianism. Bushido, or “Way of the Warrior,” was the code of conduct the samurai class were expected to uphold.

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Warriors would balance the spear on the atlatl, and double the amount of momentum behind their swing rather than if they were just using their arms. Early conquistadors and European fighters recorded the spears were powerful enough to pierce through their chain mail armor. Lances were only made a greater weapon once horses were introduced to the Americas, and became a notable weapon amongst horseback

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

what really fascinates me is that the samurai weren’t a rare elite force; however, they were an entire social class and they were about 10 percent of Japan’s population at that time. What really grabbed my attention is the way the dress up, they were stylish and at their time they were rock stars in their style of clothing. The samurai dressed up to move with speed, to have freedom of movement and travel. The weapons were unique

Read More
528 Words | 3 Pages

Many similarities and differences stood beside the Samurai and the Knights, but was there more similarities than differences between them? Samurai and Knights were both powerful warriors back then. The Samurai had lived in Feudal Japan, and knights had lived in different parts of Europe. They both had different culture ideas, and of course different language, and yet also they both had similarities of them both. These are Social positions, Military training and armor, and Code of Honor.

Read More
431 Words | 2 Pages

Many people always wonder who would win in a one on one battle. A samurai or a knight? Although many people support the samurai’s side, I support the knight side for various reasons. While knights and samurai have many similarities, in a one on one battle, the advantage would go to the knights and this can be seen through weapons, armor, and training. The most significant way a knight has an advantage is through armor.

Read More
712 Words | 3 Pages

But also change within the military occurred with the replacement of Samurai authority. Trying to be equal competitors in world power as their Western neighbors. Japan had gotten imperialist ideas from 1853 when the U.S. black ships steamed

Read More

More about A Battle Between A Samurai And A Knight Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document