ipl-logo

A Critical Analysis Of Disconnected Urbanism By Paul Goldberger

1064 Words5 Pages
One of the most significant advances in technology in recent times has been the invention of the cell phone. Cell phones have become a massive part of the world that people live in today. The ability to communicate with anybody in any part of the world whenever possible has been a substantial improvement to the way individuals live. Technology has allowed people to connect in more ways than ever before, but it is currently disconnecting people from the world right in front of them. Paul Goldberger’s essay “Disconnected Urbanism” incorporates multiple persuasive methods to be successful in effectively convincing its audience that cell phones have taken people away from the places around them. One effective technique Goldberger implements is his use of ethos. “Disconnected Urbanism” was originally published in Metropolis magazine ( ). The subscribers to this magazine are typically members of the “architecture and design industry” ( ). In the world of architecture, Paul Goldberger is known for being a Pulitzer Prize winning critic ( ). As a result, Goldberger appeals to the readers of the magazine by being an award-winning author that they can believe. Goldberger also incorporates a critical yet rational tone into his essay. By not being overly-emotional, he sounds more logical and reasonable, he is building his credibility, and the readers are more likely to be persuaded by is argument. In his essay, he acknowledges the opposing viewpoint that geographical locations
Show More
Related
309 Words | 2 Pages

In Goldberger’s article, Disconnected Urbanism, he does not say much about the advantages of a cell phone and I do not believe he should have. If in fact he had mentioned some of the positive points of a cell phone, the article would not persuade the reader as strongly. He claims that the cell phone takes away from a person's experiences because it allows them to be in more than one place at a time. To truly experience something, you need to have all of your attention on it. The cell phone draws your attention away.

Read More
400 Words | 2 Pages

By analyzing her retirement speech, it is apparent that Connie Parkinson uses many effective techniques to build her argument that cellular devices are a hindrance to interpersonal relationships. Once of the most prevalent strategies that she utilizes in persuading her audience is the use of personal anecdotes and stories to connect with her listeners over their shared experiences with cell phones. Another method Parkinson applies is her continuous use of rhetorical questions that compel her audience to ponder the inquiries she has raised. A third way the speaker tries to convince her audience on the negative effects cell phones have on interpersonal relationships is through her use of humor and informal language throughout her speech,

Read More
324 Words | 2 Pages

“Technology Taking Over?”, by Yzzy Gonzalez speaks on how we are transitioning into a technology dependent society. One example Gonzalez uses to fortify her argument is the idea that people become obsessed with using rapid, and more efficient devices to proceed with their daily lives. For reference, she mentions mobile banking and its effects on how people spend their money. For perspective, mobile banking allows for people to transfer money with convenience, which in turn abolishes the need to drive to an ATM. Moreover, Gonzalez utilizes her own morning routine and provides the reader with rhetorical questions—encouraging them to reflect upon their own morning routine, as well as the similarities that could be present.

Read More
629 Words | 3 Pages

Debra Marquart has written a memoir titled The Horizontal World to emit readers of her love for the upper Midwest. Marquart uses diction and contrast to characterize the Midwest. In doing so, Marquart hopes to show the importance of this region to those who already have a generalized opinion of the Midwest. In the passage, Marquart uses concrete diction when describing how people such as those who visit view the upper Midwest.

Read More
191 Words | 1 Pages

Over time, gadgets and gizmos have taken attention from many Americans. Maggie Jackson gives prominence to this point in “Distracted: The Erosion of Attention and the Coming Dark Age.” According to Jackson, technology has become too advanced for attention’s sake. In her essay, Jackson states that “we are nurturing a culture of social diffusion, intellectual fragmentation & sensory detachment. In this new world, something is amiss.

Read More
1073 Words | 5 Pages

Sometimes people use television to forget about a hard time at work, others using phones in public, causing lack of communication with people nearby. “Little by little, technology has become an integral part of the way that people communicate with one another and has increasingly taken the place of face-to-face communication. Due to the rapid expansion of technology, many individuals fear that people may be too immersed in this digital world and not present enough in the real world,”. People, especially in the United States, spend so much time on the internet they get separated from their real life and don't know what’s going on around them. Not only does Technology take away from everyone's real life, but it also distances people from family and friends.

Read More
1556 Words | 7 Pages

In Nicholas Carr’s article, “How Smartphones Hijack Our Minds” (November 10, 2017) Carr discusses the implications of allowing our smartphones to have such a huge effect on our lives. Smartphones serve many purposes, and have created massive societal effects throughout the world despite being introduced roughly only two decades ago. One can converse with anyone in the world at any given moment, they can watch any television show they want, and they can receive alerts so they no longer have to put effort into remembering things themselves. However, with so much control over people’s own lives, one begins to wonder about the negative consequences of the smartphones themselves.

Read More
666 Words | 3 Pages

The grid system does improve the efficiency of modern living. However, one may feel lost in the lack of character on the streets because every intersection shares a similar image; the uniform placement of the traffic light, the same width of the crossroad and the similar corner stores appear twice in the neighborhood. Yet there are moments in New York that breaks down the grid system and reveal the unique characters of the city like the anticipation of the Trevi fountain view.

Read More
1021 Words | 5 Pages

Rem Koolhaas, observes and begins his retroactive manifesto, a scripted chronology of the stages of Manhattanism, its changing’s and lasting legacies; especially the culture of congestion. Manhattans own metropolitan urbanism and revolutionary lifestyle. Through his optimistic narrative “Delirious New York” he documents the repeated elements and themes in New York’s development and decline that make it a theatre of progress and the capital of timeless crisis. This focuses in particular on the skyscraper as a product of the physical manifestation of Manhattanism on the grid, along with the relationship between this density-focused architecture and the culture of congestion.

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

This writing by Berman was particularly interesting in all the quotes from opposing viewpoints of writers who weren 't necessarily designers, but of observers of urban development captured in a time that’s hard to relate to if not for these other pieces of work. The quote in the beginning by Rem Koolhaas described a city of wonder and technology advancing so fast it seemed magical. That last quote from the Great Gatsby I had not realized had so much context to what we’re studying. A city described in ashes, where ashes begets more ashes through undying advancement and rebirth. New York described as a city never really having an identity that’s solid, instead melts into ashes swept into the air and made again and

Read More
910 Words | 4 Pages

In fact, people are still able to bond using technology, it can help people to keep in touch, and it can be used to help people cherish what is important to them. As long as humans do not abuse it, electronics can simply be used as a new way to interact with one another. Unlike the outcomes of “The Veldt” and “The Pedestrian”, technology does not have to consume or ruin lives. People should encourage one another to use the modern items at their disposal without uninformed cynics claiming that they are living life

Read More
1410 Words | 6 Pages

Nowadays, technology devices become plays an important role in our daily lives, especially in adolescents’ categories. While there is a very clear argument for how the technology is effected on us and causing social isolation as we know, but in another way is also the argument that these technologies are helping us to become more social in our society. This is very probably because we have a good and perfect ability to communicate with each other. Despite long distances. We all know that the goal of technology is to make our lives easier and more efficient.

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

The beauty of the landscape—where sand, water, reeds, birds, buildings, and people all somehow flowed together—has never left me. I’m trying to discover—invent, I suppose—an architecture, and forms of urban planning, that do something of same thing in a contemporary way.” Before moving to London to attend the Architectural

Read More
824 Words | 4 Pages

Disconnected With more than five billion people in the world now owning some kind of mobile phone, it’s hard to imagine a world without these devices. Without your smartphone who would tend to your crops on Hay Day? Who would take care of your Snapstreaks while you’re gone?

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

According to Lindsey Craig in her article “Technology -- we all love it and we all use it, but how is it affecting us?” she stated that “Technology is making us more alone, because instead of interacting with our friends in person, we are dependent on using our phones or tablets. We start to compare

Read More

More about A Critical Analysis Of Disconnected Urbanism By Paul Goldberger

Related Topics

Open Document