ipl-logo

'A Historical Lens Revealed In Joanna Murray-Smith's Berlin'

709 Words3 Pages

Joanna Murray-Smith’s romantic thriller ‘Berlin’ deconstructs the multifaceted generational war between the Germans and the Jews through her exploration of alternate views. Murray-Smiths presentation of Charlotte and Tom through a historical lens dissects the dynamics of their dual relationships. Murray- Smith reinforces Charlotte and Tom’s dual identities through her use of phrasing, “terrible and strange”, to denote their relationship as German and Jew, and “beautiful and interesting” to reference the interconnection they formed as simply man and woman. The contrasting imagery elucidates Murray- Smith’s critique of how the constraints of the past signifies that Charlotte and Tom’s relationship can only exist in the metaphysical reality due to the generational barriers enforced by society. …show more content…

Smiths accentuation of the lexeme “you’re” creates a subtle shift from individual to collective identity, which allows her to deconstruct the complexity of their relationship and the enduring weight of the holocaust,which shapes their interactions, as it is a constant reminder of their generational aversions toward eachother. Through Charlotte’s plea with Tom, “we need to be here” Smith encapsulates the ongoing battle between preservation of the present and remembrance of the past. This declaration reflects their struggle to reconcile personal agency with historical responsibility, highlighting the constant negotiation between their individual desires and collective obligations to their predecessors. Smith’s juxtaposing dual characterisations of Tom and Charlotte critiques the suffocating nature of generational trauma, revealing how it shapes and constrains future

Show More
Related
1375 Words | 6 Pages

Felicia Carmelly, currently age 87, is one of the few Holocaust survivors who remains alive today. Her story is riveting and immensely detailed; consequently, it deserves to be remembered for eternity. Being generally knowledgable about the Holocaust is one perspective, however, reading and understanding Felicia’s point of view is much different. The thoroughly haunting events that transpired in Transnistria, orchestrated through the eyes of Carmelly herself, were heart-wrenching to say the least. Before the Holocaust began, Felicia was living a very structured and fairly pampered lifestyle in Dorna, Romania, as an only child.

Read More
952 Words | 4 Pages

‘Compare how Iain Sinclair’s adaptation of Joanna Murray-Smith’s Berlin endorses, marginalises or challenges the concept that commemorating the past places an unreasonable burden on those in the present.’ Joanna Murray-Smith’s play, Berlin challenges the concept that commemorating the past, places an unreasonable burden on those in the present. Dissimilarly, Iain Sinclair’s adaptation endorses this concept. The presentation of the abiding concept of anger is encapsulated by the characters in Berlin, which explores the effects of commemorating past trauma.

Read More
577 Words | 3 Pages

In Livia Bitton-Jackson’s memoir I Have Lived a Thousand Years, Bitton-Jackson recounts her experience of surviving the Holocaust through the character of Elli Friedman. Elli is a blossoming, intelligent adolescent girl who lives a normal life until the events of the Holocaust take place. Even a broken relationship with her mother does not stop Elli from giving up. This illuminates aspects of Elli’s admirable personality, such as wisdom beyond her years and her strong ambitious attitude. Elli’s young spirit still fights keep her mother alive in the camps despite her mother’s animosity.

Read More
716 Words | 3 Pages

What does a girl ripped from her home and placed into seclusion and a boy seperated from most of his family and faced with death every day have in common? The answer lies not with their experiences, but within the emotional effects of the aftermath of their traumatic experiences. Jeanne Houston writes about her life in a Japanese-American in her autobiography Farewell to Manzanar, and Elie Wiesel shares his story of the Jewish concentration camps in his autobiography Night. Both of these intimate books reveal truly horrific events and details about the crimes against humanity that went on during WWII, although one author clearly had experienced more appalling episodes. While both Jeannie and Elie suffered heavily and lost family connections

Read More
947 Words | 4 Pages

‘Night’ is a memoir written by Elie Wiesel that explores the horrors of the Holocaust from the author's experiences. ‘First they Killed My father’ was written by Loung Ung, a woman who experienced the Cambodian genocide as a child. Both narrators from each memoir place a larger emphasis on their fathers, two key figures in each story who experienced the genocide with the narrators, and helped them with their development and struggles throughout the genocide. Particularly, the fathers helped the narrator by providing emotional and physical strength, support, and guidance to survive the genocides. The essay aims to explore the roles that the fathers play in ‘Night’ and ‘First They Killed My Father’, and how they are crucial to each of the narrators'

Read More
1426 Words | 6 Pages

Many people don’t like to think about it, but it is an important event to remember so that we don’t let it happen again. Two pieces of literature that explore the idea of wanting to remember the holocaust to not repeat it are Maus by Art Spiegelman and Often a Minute by Magdalena Klein. These texts describe events and feelings surrounding the holocaust and help support the idea of teaching about it to stop it from happening again. Another theme these passages present is persevering even when times are tough. The ideas, scenes, stanzas, tone, and sentences presented in these two compositions

Read More
347 Words | 2 Pages

demonstrating the severe feelings of disillusionment felt by those in concentration camps, and highlighting the erosion of faith. The narrative techniques employed in this passage play a crucial role in shaping the memoirs story by using vivid and disturbing imagery which engulfs the reader in the

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

What can a person do if their language is tainted with malevolent intentions towards others, how about after sixty millions of their own people are inhumanly slaughtered with little to no respect? Nothing can ease a person’s trauma and torment, attempting to explain an event of such horrific context is extremely for a survivor of said event. However, another problem arises, how one thoroughly explains an event that they desperately do not want to relive. Many Holocaust survivors, who are literary geniuses, use a variety of methods in order to express their opinions and experiences to the reader. Elie Wiesel’s use of repetition, Art Spiegelman’s use of a bizarre genre to create symbolism while explaining euphemisms, and many survivors opening up to the younger generation at Holocaust themed museums.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

There was a constant feeling of fear that ran through his body. It felt as if one was scared of heights and was looking down from the empire state building. Overall this story showcases the darkness of the holocaust. The memoir lets readers feel appreciative of the present and the opportunities they are free to take. It explains to individuals not to repeat the past while showing the trauma that the generation had to

Read More
1626 Words | 7 Pages

By using such heavy emotions, both authors were able to articulate their experiences with the Holocaust and those around them. The two authors also successfully managed to capture an audience that appeals outside of the works timeframe. With an event as memorable as the Holocaust, it’s not difficult to focus plenty of attention on the event, but both authors managed to appeal to people who could not possibly have any real insight on the happenings of the Holocaust. The

Read More
637 Words | 3 Pages

Wiesel informs how remembering the Holocaust is the key to preventing mass genocides like it in the future. This central idea is shared among other peoples accounts like “Night” by Ellie Wiesel, Arrival at Auschwitz testimonies, and President Biden's Holocaust Remembrance Speech. The memoir

Read More
1884 Words | 8 Pages

The devastation of many souls: The Holocaust vs. The Trail of Tears Maggie Helms English II Ms. Autumn Farless, Ed. S. Maggie Helms English II Ms. Autumn Farless, Ed. S. The devastation of many souls: The Holocaust vs. The Trail of Tears

Read More
614 Words | 3 Pages

The first thing that Nazi guards did at the concentration camps was take away the identities of these poor, innocent people. During the Holocaust, Jews were mistreated by physical abuse and starvation. Through Eliezer’s harrowing journey, Weisel highlights the degrading effects of dehumanization on both victims and perpetrators, underscoring the importance of empathy, dignity, and resistance in the face of

Read More
2082 Words | 9 Pages

Amidst the corridor of history, there exists a chapter so chillingly vivid that it grasps the narrator’s soul and refuses to release its strenuous hold on his heart: the Holocaust. Ellie’s memoir Night recounts the darkest time in his life, how as a 15 year old boy he and the Jewish people endured the hardships of the Holocaust. Wiesel was a Romanian-born Jew, his hometown of Sighet was controlled by the Hungarians for a majority of the Second World War. By May of 1944, all Sighet Jews were forced into cattle wagons and transported to Auschwitz against their will. Wiesel’s story breaks through the curtain of silence as the world retreats from the deliberate extermination of 6 million Jews, providing a graphic and unvarnished portrayal of his

Read More
1001 Words | 5 Pages

Many actions played out during the Holocaust and World War II were not humane, and still remind us like a scream behind closed doors: hidden but still heard. While hearing the horrid stories and seeing the ghoulish photos of times not to be forgotten, we see the tragedy that is the mistreatment of human lives. Our identities are lost little by little, but those victims had theirs ripped from their bodies. After losing everything and then becoming a nearly empty vessel, it is amazing that we attempt to comprehend the cruelty of the Holocaust. The loss of identity and self might have started with Adolf Hitler’s reign, for the Holocaust legacies, but we are all losing bits of ourselves constantly.

Read More

More about 'A Historical Lens Revealed In Joanna Murray-Smith's Berlin'

Open Document