ipl-logo

A Review Of Are Organizations Religious Exemptions Democratically Defensible By Stephanie Collins

1731 Words7 Pages

Title: Review of "Are Organizations’ Religious Exemptions Democratically Defensible?” by Stephanie Collins INTRODUCTION This review examines the article titled "Are Organizations’ Religious Exemptions Democratically Defensible" by Stephanie Collins. The article was published in Daedalus, Vol. 149, No. 3, Religion & Democracy (Summer 2020), pp. 105-118 (14 pages). Stephanie explores the topic of religious exemptions for organizations and their compatibility with democratic societies. The author investigates four arguments for granting such exemptions and evaluates their validity. The article's primary objective is to critically analyse the various strategies proposed to justify religious exemptions for organizations. The author challenges …show more content…

This test acknowledges the temporal dimension of organizational abilities and emphasizes the potential moral duties of individual members to influence the organization's ability to abide by the law. The article highlights that the granting of religious exemptions should be limited and infrequent. While some cases may initially justify religious exemptions based on an organization's procedures or foundational goals, the author argues that such exemptions are likely to be temporary. Organizations often possess the long-term capacity to abide by the law, and members may have moral obligations to foster this ability within the organization. Overall, the article provides a comprehensive framework for analysing religious exemptions within organizational contexts, challenging traditional perspectives and offering a nuanced understanding of the complex considerations involved. It emphasizes the importance of balancing individual claims and responsibilities while cautioning against the broad application of religious exemptions, particularly when they conflict with fundamental principles of equality and non-discrimination. …show more content…

The author's use of evidence and logical reasoning is commendable, contributing to a well-supported argument. The article also sheds light on the moral considerations surrounding religious exemptions, emphasizing the need to balance the rights of individuals affected by discrimination. However, the critique of the article reveals several areas that could be improved. Engaging with alternative viewpoints and addressing potential criticisms would have added depth and strengthened the overall argument. Additionally, a more comprehensive analysis of the practical implications, comparative perspectives, temporal dimension, and intersectionality of religious exemptions would have enriched the article's analysis. Despite these limitations, the article makes valuable contributions to the discourse on religious exemptions in organizational settings. It highlights the need to carefully consider the justifications and implications of religious exemptions while balancing the rights and protections of all individuals involved. The article serves as a starting point for further exploration and dialogue on this complex and contentious

Show More
Related
1552 Words | 7 Pages

v. Hialeah. Unlike in the Smith case, the court does not use Santeria’s status as a minority religion to argue its practices as unworthy of First Amendment protection. In fact instead, the court states firmly that religious beliefs, and thus the practices required to fulfill them, “need not be acceptable, logical, consistent, or comprehensible to other in order to merit First Amendment protection.” (Kennedy 531). This is due, in part, to the Court’s ability to understand the Santeria through a Christian lens.

Read More
924 Words | 4 Pages

This statement is key because it displays how religious principals and characteristics promotes the protection for property, reputation, and life. Furthermore, without religion and its obligated principals, people will most likely abandon oaths, which are significant requirements in the justice system. Moreover, Washington wanted to express that if the people have integrity, honor, and commitment then they will be able to understand the meaning of respecting the laws and justice system. Also, how religion and its principles lead to the concept of morality and cannot be sustained without

Read More
2028 Words | 9 Pages

“Faith and the Presidency: From George Washington to George W. Bush” was written by Gary Scott Smith, the book goes in depth about how presidencies brought religion to America and its government. This book was written to be read by students and scholars looking to further their knowledge about the presidents’ religious views and how they used their views in office. Gary Scott Smith is currently the chair and professor of history at Grove City College, were he graduated from in 1972 with a bachelor’s in art in Psychology. He also has his master’s in art in American History from John Hopkins which he received in 1979. In 1981 he received his Ph. D in American History from John Hopkins as well (Faculty, par.1).

Read More
1264 Words | 6 Pages

Despite the incorporation, this Court has approved those earlier rulings. The establishment of religion clause prevents that state or federal government from forcing one religion to worship. The clause means neither government can create laws which support one religion, all religions, or favor one religion over another. No person can be reprimanded for supporting one religion or church attendance. No tax can be imposed to aid any religious institution or organization.

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

One’s jobs are chosen, their schedule is chosen, and it is an absolute moral sin to expect otherwise. Even while committing these “sins of preference”, Equality doesn’t stop talking about how he is doing something that he sees as morally wrong. “We knew this well, in the years of our childhood, but our curse

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is a federal law that prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of religion, sex, sexual orientation, or national origin. It forbids discrimination in any aspect of employment, including hiring and firing, compensation, promotion, and benefits. However, there are exceptions to this law, mainly in the form of bona fide occupational qualifications, otherwise known as BFOQ’s. Title VII permits an employer to discriminate on the basis of “religion, sex, or national origin in those instances where religion, sex, or national origin is a bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of the particular business or enterprise.”

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

When it comes to different issues regarding religious organizations and the law the government has made different decisions regarding each depending on what was needed and did not infringe with the first amendment. As the authors conclude that, “The principle of free exercise of religion is not restricted to individuals. Properly understood, it also extends to religious organizations and entities” (Pg. 247). This is indeed what occurs when issues regarding religious property disputes, tax exemptions, the funding religious charities, labor and employment arise and need governmental assistance in order to be

Read More
1400 Words | 6 Pages

Court has used a three-part test to decide whether such aid violate the establishment clause. -Have a clear secular, nonreligious

Read More
1958 Words | 8 Pages

In particular, resolution of the question of whether facial neutrality will be dispositive under Smith will be of considerable significance. More importantly, though, Hialeah will now call on the Court to decide whether disadvantaging minority religious practices, like Santeria, is, in fact, an "unavoidable consequence" of democratic government. Hialeah, in other words, involves nothing short of the fate of free exercise” . The case advanced the development of the First Amendment, Free Clause. City Attorneys when addressing this case to the city council clearly stated “we cannot stop them from opening a church a church.

Read More
980 Words | 4 Pages

Secular governing, also known as the separation of church and state, has not been around for a long period of time. Since before the United States was founded, there have been many radical changes in the general consensus on whether or not a government should encourage or even force a religion on its people. With Puritanism, Deism, and Transcendentalism, it is easy to see a change in attitudes as the years went by. The canonical literature created by some of the celebrated writers in the United States shows a progression over time in regards to different beliefs and their views on secular governments.

Read More
727 Words | 3 Pages

One of the main reasons why America was established is the pursuit of religious freedom, as every American citizen is given the freedom to practice any or no religion and the right to freedom of speech and expression. Although the pursuit of religious freedom is still true today, discrimination continues in American society. After terrorist attacks on September 11th, 2001, discrimination against Muslims religion have increased, which illustrates an incompatibility of multiple cultures and religions in the United

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Under the constitution, customers do not have the right to force a business to provide a service that would violate the owner’s religion—unless

Read More
570 Words | 3 Pages

" Some legislative actions associated to religion has been acknowledged legitimate by the Supreme Court. For example, implementing

Read More
832 Words | 4 Pages

Comedian, George Carlin once said “I'm completely in favor of the separation of Church and State. These two institutions screw us up enough on their own, so both of them together is certain death.” In most cases religion in general is seen as prosperous and helpful, yet there are some extreme cases where religion is used to hurt people. One example of a church using their religion as a harmful hate mechanism is the Westboro Baptist Church. The church is known for their hate filled posters, songs and speeches.

Read More
948 Words | 4 Pages

“Religious liberty might be supposed to mean that everybody is free to discuss religion. In practice, it means that hardly anybody is allowed to mention it.” ― G.K. Chesterton Many occasions in the United States history have shown that religion has caused many controversial questions. These questions have brought the American Justice System to a running halt, leading society to begin to ponder about the importance of freedom of religion, true meanings of the free exercise and establishment clause, and if there should be limitations imposed on the free exercise of one’s religious beliefs.

Read More

More about A Review Of Are Organizations Religious Exemptions Democratically Defensible By Stephanie Collins

Open Document