ipl-logo

Abu Ghraib Prison Case Study

1108 Words5 Pages

The torture of prisoners in Abu Ghraib prison; a case study in State crime

Introduction:
Abu Ghraib prison was a U.S. Army detention centre for captured Iraqis from 2003 to 2006.
This is an international problem. Guantanamo Bay another prison where the use of torture is apparent and unlike the Abu Ghraib prison it is still in use today.
The main focus of this essay will be on why it is a state crime but other areas will also be covered to answer the question effectively.

Why is it a state crime?
For a crime to be seen as a state crime it needs to fall under at least one of these three definitions (Green and Ward, 2004; Michalowski, 2010):
1. Crime as law violation - Article 84 of the Fourth Geneva Convention prohibits housing prisoners …show more content…

This is because the information of the abuses happening at Abu Ghraib prison was initially ignored by the US government. When the evidence was irrefutable, the government finally reacted stating that it was an isolated incident. This was disregarded by civil society movements such as the Red Cross as they had been providing information of the abuse a year before the scandal broke. Rumsfeld the secretary of defence mentioned that it was not ‘torture’ but ‘abuse. This shows how the US government would have ignored the whole thing had the information not been released to the public and caused public …show more content…

Staub’s ‘cultural self-concept’ [1989, p. 54] evidenced most strongly in countries such as Nazi Germany, modern Turkey, and Cambodia and Argentina in the 1970s)
• the clear designation of an enemy within the dominant ideology (e.g. Jews in Nazi Germany, ‘subversives’ in Argentina, Kurdish militants in Turkey – see Staub, 1989, p .62).

Most of the soldiers believed that they had done absolutely nothing wrong this can be seen in the documentary "The Ghosts of Abu Ghraib". The soldier took pictures of the stripped prisoners and still to this day believes that there was nothing wrong with it. “As White House counsel, Gonzales advised President Bush in a 2002 memo that the Geneva Conventions did not apply to the treatment of enemy prisoners in the so-called 'war on terror.'” Bush said ‘This is no time for Congress to abandon practices that have a proven track record of keeping America safe’ (Associated Press, 2008). President agreed with the US of torture to ‘keep America

Show More
Related

Summary Of Should The Ticking Bomb Prisoner By Alan Dershowitz

1694 Words | 7 Pages

Many have said that they would want nonlethal torture to be used in such cases but “did not want torture to be officially recognized by our legal system.” Similar statements have posited that while “torture might be necessary in a given situation it could never be right.” This approach, that of keeping torture off-the-books, is in direct conflict with the necessity for accountability and transparency in a democracy. A democracy cannot work if the public is kept in the dark. The public must know what is going on in order to approve or disapprove.

Read More

Summary Of Torture's Terrible Toll By John Mccain

848 Words | 4 Pages

In " Torture's Terrible Toll", an essay written by John McCain, the topic of torture is highly discouraged. McCain feels very strongly that it should not be allowed except in only a very high risk and time sensitive situation. McCain makes six claims throughout the rest of the essay. They are that the abuse of prisoners harms the war effort, that prisoner abuse has a terrible toll and threatens our moral standings, that mistreatment of prisoner harms us more than our enemies, that we shouldn't have to compromise our values to get information, that torture is torture whether physical or mental, and that we should not compromise our values and lose the sense of honor that we hold. Basically, he is saying that the United States should show that they are different from other nations.

Read More

Summary Of The Shock Doctrine By Naomi Klein

312 Words | 2 Pages

“... their memories fractured, their trust betrayed.” (P 54) In part one of The Shock Doctrine, by Naomi Klein, Klein talks about the rehabilitation failure of Guantanamo Bay and the tactics it used. The authoritative figures who facilitate Guantanamo Bay are convinced by their belief that they are right and whomever is in their custody is wrong, that they use unethical methods to treat the imprisoned. This is backed by Hassan Mustafa Osama Nasr on page 52, “They began to punch me in the stomach and all over my body.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Stanford Prison Experiment And Philip Zimbardo

751 Words | 4 Pages

Neither one of the circumstances was ethical at any point and had been publicized by the media for its explicit type of interrogation methods as well as sadistic behavior. In particular, Phil Zimbardo has argued that the study shows that strong situational forces can override individual differences in personality and moral values. In Abu Ghraib, soldiers were inserted into the role of prison guards and began to sadistically torment prisoners there and at other detention sites in Afghanistan and Iraq. Many of the specific acts of humiliation were similar to those that transpired in the Stanford Prison Experiment, according to Zimbardo. This theory has been challenged by allegations by Seymour Hersh, in the New Yorker, that these soldiers were in fact acting under direct orders of their superiors as part of a top secret Pentagon intelligence gathering program authorized by Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld.

Read More

Enhanced Interrogation Techniques Pros And Cons

957 Words | 4 Pages

BLUF: The use of enhanced interrogation techniques presents a severe threat to United States national security due to the unreliable information collected from interviews and the potential for terrorist organizations to use such techniques within their recruitment propaganda. United States government officials must continue the ban of enhanced interrogation techniques to preserve the trust of the Iraqi and Afghanistan people during counter-insurgency efforts, and develop alternative strategies for human intelligence. During the War on Terror, the United States committed acts of torture, referred to as enhanced interrogation techniques, to at least 39 detainees. In fact, nearly all states between 1981 and 2010 engaged in counter-insurgency efforts have committed some form of torture.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography On Torture

962 Words | 4 Pages

"Erroneous Assumptions: Popular Belief in the Effectiveness of Torture Interrogation." Peace & Conflict 13.4 (2007): 429-435. Academic Search Complete. Web. 14 Feb. 2016.

Read More

Guantanamo Double Standards

1682 Words | 7 Pages

Guantanamo Bay: The Double Standard That is America “Human rights are the soul of our foreign policy, because human rights are the very soul of our sense of nationhood”. Jimmy Carter. If we analyze Jimmy Carters Quote then we can see that he is 100 percent correct. Human rights are the soul of our foreign policy, whether it’s intervening in Myanmar or in Syria when Bashar Al-Assad used chemical weapons on the Syrian rebel groups. When we look further we see the US only does this because it is what we stand for as a country, duo process, equal rights, and religious freedom.

Read More

How Does George Orwell Use Torture In 1984

501 Words | 3 Pages

This is similar to our CIA society today, For torture to happened it can not happen on U.S soil. It must happen some place else.

Read More

Analysis Of Ghosts Of Abu Ghraib By Rory Kennedy

717 Words | 3 Pages

The United States invasion of Iraq in 2003 was dubbed Operation Iraqi Freedom by US Forces, but it seemed like freedom was the last thing on their minds. Abu Ghraib prison was an occupied Iraqi prison where the US Army held mass incarcerations and sponsored inmate torture. 2007 marked the year that a documentary titled “Ghosts of Abu Ghraib” was produced by HBO and directed by Rory Kennedy. This documentary showed the abuses and injustices inured to the Iraqi prisoners at the hands of the United States Soldiers. Although the guards at Abu Ghraib Prison Complex had personal reservations against the treatment of the prisoners, they were manipulated into authoritarianism by their overzealous obedience.

Read More

The Negative Effects Of Gentrification

157 Words | 1 Pages

Gentrification is a fast growing process in most cities today. Displacement through gentrification has many side effects for low-income families. Gentrification is a major problem; it is the displacement of people of lower socioeconomic status and replacing them with people of higher economic status, raising the property rates on these gentrified properties so that the lower classes can no longer afford to live there and further creating social inequality among the citizens of our community. We take broken parts of town and convert them into lavish attractions for visitors and natives. These so-called broken parts of town have residents who can no longer afford to live in these parts.

Read More

Habeas Corpus Essay

1524 Words | 7 Pages

On September 20th, 2001 nine days after the Twin Towers President George W. Bush announced to all Americans that the nation has begun the war on terror. With any war there will be casualties as well as prisoners captured who have essential information to saving lives. Some of the prisoners caught were considered extremely dangerous and sent to Guantanamo Bay. At one point in the war on terror Guantanamo Bay held some of the worlds highest-ranking criminals in the world. Many people questioned the government’s legitimacy of holding these prisoners and believed they should be given the right to a fair trial.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Torture

956 Words | 4 Pages

How can a country maintain their dignity and respect if they contradict themselves by allowing torture while fighting against terrorism? Torture needs to be banned if the U.S wants to remain the great country that it is consequently it needs to lead by example. No one can predict if by refraining from the use of torture, others will too, but what is for sure is that by engrossing it others will follow. Sodomizing with blunt objects, threatening sexual abuse against family members, waterboarding, these are a few of the things that detainees had to endure. Just the thought of someone having to go through that pain is enough to reject torture but having to tolerate images put out for the world to see is unbelievable and that is something that some had to go through, making it impossible

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Guantanamo Bay

617 Words | 3 Pages

Xanthe Gutierrez-Mizula Mrs. Lehman US History 26 May 2017 Guantanamo Bay Detention Facility Guantanamo Bay is a detention camp that is supposed to hold only the most dangerous people. In 2002 after the 9/11 terrorist attack, George Bush opened the facility to interrogate suspected terrorists to ensure the countries safety. Unfortunately, at this point in society the United States arrests people and takes them here without any court hearing or trial and supposedly even tortures them (Nolen 1). Guantanamo Bay, (also known as GITMO) can be seen as a violation of many human rights.

Read More

Ethical Theory Of Immanuel Kant's Categorical Imperative

890 Words | 4 Pages

In 2003 the US military relied on the confession taken from Sheikh al-Libi in which it was claimed that Iraq supplied both chemical and biological weapons to Al Qaeda. This testimony was used in the month leading up to the invasion of Iraq. Later al-Libi retracted his statement saying that he did so in order to make the torture stop. This is a clear example of the ineffectiveness of torture and the bad consequences it can often produce. The CIA had forgotten its own conclusion, sent to congress in 1989, that ‘inhumane physical or psychological techniques are counterproductive because they do not produce intelligence and will probably result in false answers.’

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Torture

2162 Words | 9 Pages

Torture can be initiated through causing some form of mental anguish or physical pain, usually in order to gain information from the person being tortured. Torture is usually punishment for a serious crime,but is usually for the purpose of extracting a confession from an accused person. Many wonder nowadays should torture still be used in this day and age. Torture has been around since the times of the Ancient Greeks and is still around today, notoriously used in criminal organizations but also utilized by various governments when dealing with terrorist. Once the torture of Jews at the hands of the Nazis in World War II became knowledge to the public.

Read More

More about Abu Ghraib Prison Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document