ipl-logo

Enhanced Interrogation Techniques Pros And Cons

957 Words4 Pages

BLUF: The use of enhanced interrogation techniques presents a severe threat to United States national security due to the unreliable information collected from interviews and the potential for terrorist organizations to use such techniques within their recruitment propaganda. United States government officials must continue the ban of enhanced interrogation techniques to preserve the trust of the Iraqi and Afghanistan people during counter-insurgency efforts, and develop alternative strategies for human intelligence.

During the War on Terror, the United States committed acts of torture, referred to as enhanced interrogation techniques, to at least 39 detainees. In fact, nearly all states between 1981 and 2010 engaged in counter-insurgency efforts have committed some form of torture. The prevalent use of torture in such settings conveys a common …show more content…

In its effort to combat terrorism, the United States produced more terrorists and terrorist sympathizers using enhanced interrogation techniques, straining the relationship with the local Iraqi and Afghanistan populace. Indeed, images of United States soldiers torturing detainees served as a powerful recruitment tool for Sunni jihadists who were able to persuade local nationals to support their crusade. Furthermore, the United States’ use of enhanced interrogation techniques proved to be ineffective as the information collected from interrogations was inadequate to combat the terrorist threat. Based on the available literature regarding the use of United States enhanced interrogation, three recommendations are provided.

• Preserve Executive Order 13491 - Ensuring Lawful Interrogations to promote the United States’ commitment to human rights. It is imperative that the United States act as an exemplar of liberty to the local Iraqi and Afghanistan people if it expects to prevail against the insurgent

Show More
Related

Rhetorical Analysis Of Torture Myth '

1050 Words | 5 Pages

Applebaum has plenty of evidence to back up her claim that physical torture is not effective, and there are many other ways to obtain information. While the fear-encouraging and questioning elements are potent to many who are afraid of terror committed against them, but when the overwhelming sentiment of Levin’s argument is being compared to the logic and ethical points of Applebaum it is clear to see the superiority of her argument. Although Levin would advocate for physical torture in extreme situations, one must expect extreme consequences. Physical torture is rarely effective, violates rights, and damages a whole nation’s credibility. This is why physical torture should not be

Read More

Enhanced Interrogation: George W. Bush Administration

776 Words | 4 Pages

"Enhanced Interrogation" is a term that was introduced by the George W. Bush administration. This type of investigation includes physically forcible interventions, such as waterboarding, sleep deprivation, facial slapping, forced standing for days and so on. Torture has been an argument for a long time to fight terrorism, but it is a bigger issue, especially after the incident of September 11, 2001. And still, it is not over that we should use "Enhanced Interrogation" or not. The techniques that are utilized in this type of investigation they are unethically and morally wrong, but they work.

Read More

Article Summary: The Case For Torture By Michael Levin

421 Words | 2 Pages

Many believe that being interrogated by American intelligence should not be a pleasant experience for enemy combatants such as terrorists. Levin presents torture as the only method to safeguard civilians,but this is a violation against human rights and inhumane. Although

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Guantanamo Bay

982 Words | 4 Pages

Lawful interrogations are being made to detainees to know their intentions. Edwin Meese III comments, “We have learned a great deal from them during long-term, lawful interrogations.” This shows that the interrogations worked. Without these interrogations, the United States wouldn’t be aware of the intentions of the terrorists and it wouldn’t be possible to defeat the enemy. Guantanamo Bay is the safest interrogation center for detainees.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Isolationists

679 Words | 3 Pages

A question has risen up about whether or not psychologists should be involved in interrogations of suspected terrorists. This question didn’t come out of nowhere but came when psychologists were involved in the interrogations of suspected terrorists at Guantanoma, Abu Ghraib, and psychologists that participated in the CIA and Pentagon’s harsh interrogation programs. These programs involved “torture” and interrogation techniques, which were only not called torture due to the government saying health providers, were overseeing what was being done. Many wonder if this constitutes a violation of APA policy and ethics, or if this makes sure interrogations are legal, ethical, safe, and effective.

Read More

Is Torture A Justified Means To Prevent Terrorism

1685 Words | 7 Pages

Rules of War: Torture a Justified Means to Prevent Terrorism? Is torture a good means of preventing terrorism? No, I believe it is not a way to prevent terrorism as it is a very barbaric and ancient method of obtaining information about upcoming terror attacks. Some proof about that is the capture of Hassan Ghul, who was interrogated and apparently gave info on Osama Bin Laden’s courier, but they had a breakthrough leading to him even before the interrogation even began. I will show you why it is an ineffective method of gaining information and why it will be beneficial that the Obama Administration has banned this practice (From what I am Aware of from research.)

Read More

Enhanced Interrogation Analysis

649 Words | 3 Pages

For many years, the US Government has used basic interrogation techniques in order to force information out of prisoners and terrorists. However, after the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, the US Government initiated what they called “Enhanced Interrogation”. They initiated this process with the goal in mind to get more information out of terrorists or potential terrorists for the prevention of future attacks. No matter how controversial the methods, the CIA’s new methods may have good intentions, but proved ineffective when it mattered most. One method of interrogation used that most people are familiar with is a technique called “waterboarding”.

Read More

Examples Of American Exceptionalism

1429 Words | 6 Pages

Regarding tortures conducted by American military in Iraq, Ignatieff (Ibid, p.24) indicates the U.S.’s self-contradiction by stating “a country that thinks it is too virtuous, too exceptional, to pay respect to the Geneva Conventions and begins to write its own rules about detention, interrogation, and special status can end up violating every value it holds dear”. Hancock (2007, p.53) also wrote that, while human rights violations in friendly countries are overlooked “as counter terrorism, cultural diversity, necessary acts of self-defense, unproved allegations, tragic mistakes or as regrettable exceptions to an otherwise improving trend” and those acts in “states of peripheral concern to Washington policymakers” are simply ignored even if those are severe, those in enemy counties are “selectively highlighted…as proof of evil and repressive regimes”. Thus, the U.S. has created its own standards distinctively applied to itself and its allies, and its enemies (Hoffmann, 2005; Ignatieff, 2005; Hancock, 2007), and the language of human rights has utilized as technique to legitimize the standards and foreign policies based on those standards (Hancock,

Read More

Guantanamo Bay Breaches

2855 Words | 12 Pages

Reports from the Red Cross, other organisations and released prisoners show that detainees are often subject to violent interrogation and torture, whereas the United States administration argues that the activities they are conducting are legal and do not breach any human rights. (Ratner, M. and Ray, E. 2004). Presidents George W Bush and Barack Obama have often defended accusations and reports claiming that inhuman techniques have

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Torture

844 Words | 4 Pages

Mr. President, you said that torture “works” and that you would “allow” waterboarding as a form of interrogation methods towards individuals who are considered “terrorists.” According to various definitions, torture is applied to a prisoner or detained individual to obtain a confession or admission of a crime, or simply to impose pain and suffering as a punishment. I would like to say that any form of torture is immoral for any individual to have to go through, especially within interrogation. In the Eighth amendment of the United States Constitution it states that “cruel and unusual punishment shall not be inflicted…” Above all, it is a deliberate and intentional method to break someone either physically and psychologically in order to obtain information.

Read More

Examples Of Utilitarianism

800 Words | 4 Pages

To compare utilitarianism to enhanced interrogations and find out if they are ethical or not, one must apply the 4 steps of utilitarianism. First, one must identify all the options (Banks, 2013). An example of this would be “one has the option of interrogating a suspected terrorist in an enhanced manner or to just ask questions in a calm fashion.” Second, one must identify all affected by the decision including individuals, organizations, and the community (Banks, 2013). An example of this would be “Those likely to be affected by the decision are the suspected terrorists or detainees, their friends and family, the military, and the whole country.”

Read More

Soft Power In Foreign Policy

1703 Words | 7 Pages

This report surly damages the image of the United States abroad but many other governments have to explain their role in the program. The important outcome is, that other countries will not take the United States seriously if they will use the argument of protection of human rights anymore. The racial issues in Ferguson and other cities damaged the image but the torture report is another level. Even though the practices are despicable, I can see one positive aspect of this report.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Interrogation

809 Words | 4 Pages

Interrogation saves millions of lives and gets valuable information, We have learned of and captured terrorists who were planning to attack because of interrogation. The C.I.A found the Al Qaeda group (9/11) using such techniques. This provided how they set up their operations,what was happening next and the training manual

Read More

Purpose Of Interrogation Analysis

1498 Words | 6 Pages

Interrogation is a controversial topic that can be extremely helpful or hurtful to a whole country and its people. Each country has a different way of handling their citizens and problems. Meaning different ways of forming and maintaining their communities and when and how they use interrogation. This raises the question, How does the effectiveness of interrogation differ in the U.S.A. compared

Read More

Arguments Against Foreign Terrorism

715 Words | 3 Pages

Enhanced interrogation techniques have been used on terrorist since 2002 when the George W. Bush administration issued the torture memos. Foreign terrorism has been a big problem sociologically, psychologically and has affected stakeholders while benefiting terrorist groups. Foreign terrorism has been a big problem sociologically in today 's world. Human society is becoming more lenient towards terrorism. Terrorism is very awful and these criminal should be treated different than an American citizen.

Read More

More about Enhanced Interrogation Techniques Pros And Cons

Related Topics

Open Document