BLUF: The use of enhanced interrogation techniques presents a severe threat to United States national security due to the unreliable information collected from interviews and the potential for terrorist organizations to use such techniques within their recruitment propaganda. United States government officials must continue the ban of enhanced interrogation techniques to preserve the trust of the Iraqi and Afghanistan people during counter-insurgency efforts, and develop alternative strategies for
Enhanced interrogation did not always exist. The CIA founded the Psychological Ethics and National Security (PENS) after the terrorist strikes on America on September 11, 2001. This event pushed the government to develop a task force, which included mostly psychologists. The group was to be used to get detainees to reveal their information and to use that to protect American national security. However, when the knowledge of enhanced interrogation became known to the people, criticism followed. To
be used by the United states in interrogation include, but are not limited to: kicking, punching, tear gas, death threats, mock executions, forced standing, and food and sleep deprivation. In the article I chose for this essay, “The Illusions of Truth Seeking”, Michael Welch discusses and analyzes the perils of the use of torture for interrogation during the American war on terror. During this period, towards
Prisoners of War Issue In war, every act that is committed may be questionable. Was it necessary to kill that person? Do we need to drop this bomb? Should we have tortured that prisoner? Although the military personnel may question or be questioned about their decisions, they are likely saving lives while doing these tasks. This may not seem like the most appropriate option, but in times of hardship and war, it looks as if it is the only way to save the people whom the men are fighting for. In turn
"Enhanced Interrogation" is a term that was introduced by the George W. Bush administration. This type of investigation includes physically forcible interventions, such as waterboarding, sleep deprivation, facial slapping, forced standing for days and so on. Torture has been an argument for a long time to fight terrorism, but it is a bigger issue, especially after the incident of September 11, 2001. And still, it is not over that we should use "Enhanced Interrogation" or not. The techniques that
interrogating techniques, targeted strikes or the use of drones, privacy and civil liberties, and the rights of prisoners or suspected extremist. It is hard not to find a moral issue with some of these topics. While these topics have ethical issues that need to be explored, interrogation techniques seem to be one of the important ones. Interrogation techniques include rectal infusion, waterboarding, nudity and sexual humiliation. Government officials have become defensive about the technique
of obtaining information about upcoming terror attacks. Some proof about that is the capture of Hassan Ghul, who was interrogated and apparently gave info on Osama Bin Laden’s courier, but they had a breakthrough leading to him even before the interrogation even began. I will show you why it is an ineffective method of gaining information and why it will be beneficial that the Obama Administration has banned this practice (From what I am Aware of from research.) From the first article, it seems
Enhanced Interrogation: CIA Agents Are Justified The average American makes hundreds of decisions on a daily basis; however, though they make these hundreds of decisions, very few of the choices have to do with the good of the country or saving lives. This is not the case for CIA agents. Just as the average everyday person makes decisions on a daily basis, so do these agents. The difference is that these agents are not trying to decide what sort of laundry detergent to use, or what time they
finding out information that could be used to save innocent lives and most kidnapping cases. John W. Schiemann, author of the study on torture and a political scientist at Fairleigh Dickinson University, found that information gained from torture techniques when they are employed, they are found to generate even small amounts of valuable information within the practice. ("Interrogational Torture” Effective or Purely Sadistic?" 1). One of the reasons why torture is listed in a grey area is because of
Enhanced Interrogation Techniques, or EIT’s related to gathering and using information has been a controversial subject in military practice and the criminal justice field. More recently, the media has shed light on some of the gruesome CIA practices of systematic torture on suspects since the release of information on The War on Terror and Guantanamo Bay detainees. Specifically, the debate focuses on whether these enhanced interrogations yield accurate information and its legality based on human
dealing with detainees and prisoners. It has been declared by many officials involved with interrogation “that systematic abuse was designed to break the will of detainees until they confessed” (Egendorf 95). For years, enhanced interrogation has been hidden, proclaimed immoral, justified, and used by many governments to obtain information from the enemy. The politics and history behind enhanced interrogation
To compare utilitarianism to enhanced interrogations and find out if they are ethical or not, one must apply the 4 steps of utilitarianism. First, one must identify all the options (Banks, 2013). An example of this would be “one has the option of interrogating a suspected terrorist in an enhanced manner or to just ask questions in a calm fashion.” Second, one must identify all affected by the decision including individuals, organizations, and the community (Banks, 2013). An example of this would
but I feel as if it still goes on; more often than we’d like to think secretly. It is also a bit disturbing how our President agrees with such heinous actions. I also find it disturbing how the CIA director Mike Pompeo used the term “enhanced interrogation techniques” as a way to avoid the word torture. Sure, torture is effective at times, but how does that make us as a society any better than those who we are claiming to be terrorists?
Countries around the world use such techniques to protect and defend their country. Keeping our people safe is one of the biggest advantages to advanced techniques. Although some people think that interrogation is cruel, it saves lives, helps and protects our country, and serves justice where it is needed. Interrogation saves millions of lives and gets valuable information, We have learned of and captured terrorists who were planning to attack because of interrogation. The C.I.A found the Al Qaeda group
Do you know torture even in 2016 is still practiced by 81 governments as an interrogation technique and also in other ways. When 9/11 happened and the United States detained people to find the person behind those attacks, all of those people had one thing in common they're religion. All of the detainees in Guantanamo bay detention camp were all Muslim. At the time of 13th February 2004 775 detainees were present. 99% of whom were innocent men. Who just like you and I were living a normal life but
There are many interpretations of what torture is and how something can be classified as torture. In “Believe Me It’s Torture” Christopher Hitchens talks about the United States and its various uses of interrogation tactics to get Important information from suspected terrorists. In the article the author often brings up the waterboarding tactic that is often used and how there is a large controversy over whether it is in fact torture or if it is just simply harmless. The article states, “waterboarding
identify individuals that have been presumed as terrorists. Few confirmed terrorists actually come out of this process of identifying suspected terrorists, yet they all still have to go through hours of interrogation and torment. For example, in the two and a half years following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, U.S. intelligence agencies arrested more than five thousand suspected terrorists. There was sufficient hard evidence to bring formal charges against only three of these suspects
For example, an article called Torture Report: Former CIA Directors Say Interrogation Program 'Saved Thousands of Lives' says that, "The CIA never would have focused on the individual who turned out to be bin Laden’s personal courier without the detention and interrogation program, So the bottom line is this: The interrogation program formed an essential part of the foundation from which the CIA and the U.S. military mounted the bin Laden operation
Through the United States Senate report on torture, I was able to find out which torture techniques the United States used while torturing. These techniques included rectal feeding and rehydration, confinement in a box, the use of cold water,
There are several reasons why people will try to get information from you. There are also several ways to do so, including the use of torture. Ultimately, it is up to the military and government on how we should perceive it and how far torturing should go. Because terrorism has changed the world of war, everyone should have an understanding of how torturing terrorists help the military discover future threats and how it keeps the United States as safe as possible. Terrorism has changed the world