ipl-logo

Prisoners Of War Essay

1041 Words5 Pages

Prisoners of War Issue In war, every act that is committed may be questionable. Was it necessary to kill that person? Do we need to drop this bomb? Should we have tortured that prisoner? Although the military personnel may question or be questioned about their decisions, they are likely saving lives while doing these tasks. This may not seem like the most appropriate option, but in times of hardship and war, it looks as if it is the only way to save the people whom the men are fighting for. In turn, taking the enemy captive for questioning may also be necessary—to find a bomb they may have placed or to find the mastermind behind their operation.
A prisoner of war is defined as “any person captured or interned by a belligerent power during war.” The term used loosely can also apply to civilians or others associated with the military, not necessarily just the members of the armed forces. The term “prisoners of war” dates back to 1660, proving that prisoners of war are not a new thing that is coming about. For instance, in World War II (1939-1945), the Japanese captured over 140,000 prisoners and treated them very cruelly (Gibson). The Japanese paid no respect to the Geneva Conventions and treated prisoners however they needed to get the information they wanted. The Geneva Conventions of …show more content…

It takes the torturers to the low level of terrorists, weakens international law, and the anti-American sentiment could be amplified if conversation about the torture got out (Messerli). Other problems with the torture is that prisoners may give false information just to avoid torture and punishment or that an innocent person may be accused and tortured falsely. Terrorists may also choose death or suicide before giving in to becoming a prisoner of war. Therefore, the valuable information that they could have shared may never be

Show More
Related
1694 Words | 7 Pages

Alan Dershowitz begins his article “ Should the Ticking Bomb Terrorist Be Tortured” by questioning whether one person can be tortured to save the lives of many others. Dershowitz displays both sides of the argument before shifting the question. Dershowitz asserts that the question is not if torture should be used on a ticking bomb terrorist, rather the question is whether the torture is done openly under a legal framework or secretly and illegally. He then simplifies the conflict to the prioritization of values. While the argument that Dershowitz constructs seems to leave very little room for disagreement, there are ways in which to collapse his entire premise.

Read More
994 Words | 4 Pages

Furthermore, one must keep in mind the term “civilians”. While torture and abuse are in and of themselves truly unethical, it is made even more so by the fact that these actions were taken against civilians, who by rights had little to no actual influence upon the fighting itself, and could hardly have been found guilty of anything occuring there. This simply seeks to enforce how easily the process of dehumanization can cause people to perform heinous and cruel acts upon other, at times even innocent

Read More
1299 Words | 6 Pages

Furthermore, Skeptics may say they volunteered to eliminate hundreds of lives. To demonstrate, it says “Many children occupy command positions in their armed group/military and are responsible for planning or ordering the commission of war crimes and human rights abuses.” ( Dave, 2016). Although children volunteered or were told to hold these positions they had no choice. If they would’ve had said no they could’ve been killed or tortured to death.

Read More
651 Words | 3 Pages

Ethical Dilemma: Discovered by Unarmed Combatants During Operation Red Wing, a reconnaissance mission partaken by a group of U.S. Navy Seal Team 10, Lieutenant Michael P. Murphy and his team were spotted by three civilians. LT Murphy was immediately asked the most discomforting question of a young Leader’s career, “what do we do?” Considering the question in accordance with similar events and laws concerning the Law of Warfare, I often ask myself what I would do if I was behind enemy lines and my positioned was uncovered by unarmed civilians. I would allow the civilians to go free and immediately attempt to return to my operational outpost because killing innocent people is against the law, unethical, and counterproductive to the overall goal within the Global War on Terrorism.

Read More
764 Words | 4 Pages

Child soldiers are captured by abuse, and life threatening situations. These situations can lead to a high population of death and withdrawals of fear. Child soldiers are forced into these situations with the threat of death due to denying serving. Life threatening situations are everyday events that happen while you are a child soldier and cause effects on children that should not be acceptable in everyday life. History has proven that the use of child soldiers should be banned internationally because soldiers are around drugs and drug abuse.

Read More
596 Words | 3 Pages

However, since the War Crimes Act of 1996 this law has enforced breaches of the Geneva Conventions to be processed according to policy. Risk are inherent among soldiers in the military, therefore understanding what soldiers represent should empower them to uphold the standards, live the Army Values

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

Although torturing is considered wrong by many people today, I agree with Michael Levin that torture should be an option in certain situations because it could save the lives of American people. Levin says in his article “Torturing a terrorist unconstitutional? Probably. But millions of lives surely outweigh constitutionality (Levin 605).”

Read More
1032 Words | 5 Pages

2016). Using this ethical framework to argue against torture, one needs to consider the violation of the terrorist’s rights. Utilitarians argue that under a scenario where thousands of people are in danger, the well-being of the larger community is more important than neglecting the rights of a single individual (Krauthammer 2005). The simple idea of taking away a person’s autonomy for the sake of others violates rights ethics. To comprehend the violation upon the victim’s rights, it is important to understand how torture feels, “Brian describes his body as having become an object… pain is the central reality; it dominates experience and expression (Wisnewski 2010, 81).”

Read More
1107 Words | 5 Pages

World war 2 was the war that changed many views on the economy: during world war 2, women finally had the chance to work in jobs that were not previously opened to them. This war was a turning point for The United States; World War 2 was the war that opened many opportunities, not only for women but for people of color too. World war 2 was the war that changed many views on the economy. On December 7th, 1941, Pearl Harbor was attacked by the Japanese, thus causing the United States to take action and declare war.

Read More
1742 Words | 7 Pages

Rules: With regard to international armed conflicts, the four Geneva Conventions (GC I to IV) and Additional Protocol I and II contain various provisions specifically dealing with both of Prisoners of War, Civilians protection to prevent any kind of violations that may happen toward them. The Forth Geneva convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War has set rules governing the issue of civilians who found themselves under enemy’s possession. Article 5 of the 4th GC has identified who are protected persons with putting conditions to be considered as protected with the privileges of having the statue of protected persons at article 27 of the same convention. Third Geneva Convention in particular has recognized group of rights with regarded to POWs such as the right to be humanely treated at article 13, correspondence at article 71, the right to gain a sufficient food in quantity and quality at article 26 and the right to not be subjected to torture and question at article 17 where every prisoner of war “when questioned on the subject, is bound to give only his surname, first names and rank, date of birth, and army, regimental, personal or serial number, or failing this, equivalent information” Moreover, the use of weapons and means that have indiscriminate effects such as poisonous gas and bombs which also would aggravate the suffering recognized as prohibited to use due to the amount of damage it causes upon civilians as well as the environment

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

During Book 4 of Plato’s Republic, the focus of the discussion taking place revolves around Socrates’ hypothetical perfect city and its contents. The use of the hypothetical city aids the discussion in allowing for application of virtue, ideas, and their definitions to society before extending the argument to the individual. After having debated justice, defined the good, and outlined the education of the guardian class, it is time to circle back to Justice. Upon laying the foundation of this hypothetical city, it was time to look for the virtue within it. However, Socrates and his argumentative opposition still lacked an agreed upon definition of justice, and the ones utilized previously in discussion stemmed mostly from the ideas of what

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

The first scene that these quandaries come to light is where General Geoffrey D. Miller, a specialist in interrogations, was sent to Abu Ghraib to help guards extract more information from the prisoners. The guards at the facility had been trained for years to follow every order they had been given, but this would mark the first time that the United States Army’s orders had directly conflicted with their personal convictions. This fact was stated by the soldiers themselves in the the interviews conducted afterwards. This type of obedience can be explained by Erich Fromm in his article, “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem”. Fromm states that there are two types of Obedience one that is submissive to an institution or power, and another which an affirmation of your own personal beliefs (Fromm 124).

Read More
753 Words | 4 Pages

Torture and its small chance of success 1. Torture is justifiable but only in the most extreme cases. Michael Levin has strong argument supporting this. He sees the need to use torture as a balance between saving innocent lives and what you have to do to be able to save them. It’s a way to prevent disasters and saving valuable lives even if it means hurting the ones who endangered others.

Read More
170 Words | 1 Pages

Kill or be killed is the position our soldiers are unfortunately put into. It appears that there are few rules in war time and the lines get blurred. President Truman made a hard decision to drop the bomb. His decision was not only to target non-combatants.

Read More
1881 Words | 8 Pages

Soldiers train rigorously, preparing for the departure of war. They sacrifice all that they have to fight for their country. As they return after the war, they are left with painful experiences and traumatizing memories, suffering from their inevitable conditions. However, the spouse, families and children back at home are suffering even more than soldiers.

Read More

More about Prisoners Of War Essay

Related Topics

Open Document