ipl-logo

Alex Murdaugh: The Plea Of Insanity

1104 Words5 Pages

Plea of Insanity
The plea of insanity is a defense in which the defendant cannot be held criminally responsible for a crime due to them not being in a stable mindset. In the ongoing trial of Alex Murdaugh, the question of whether or not he should claim insanity is still up for debate. But many things must still be considered before saying that he should not. Before the murder trial most people knew Alex Murdaugh as a thief and drug addict, but that is only half of the story. Along with the drugs and embezzlement, Alex was a man who was also struggling mentally. That being considered in regards to the ongoing trial, Alex Murdaugh should plea not guilty by reason of insanity due to his situational stress and drug use, his unstable suicidal urges, …show more content…

At times throughout the trial, Alex has been seen displaying seemingly no reaction to the deaths of his wife and son, but at other times, he is seen visibly distraught and sobbing. This has been noted and used by many as “evidence” that he is aware of his actions and is trying to fake his way through the court, but in reality, it is a sign of dissociation. According to the account of Marian Proctor, as quoted by the New York Times, “We never talked about finding the person who could have done it,”(Bogel-Burroughs), and “He said that his No. 1 goal was clearing Paul’s name, and I thought that was so strange because my No. 1 goal was to find out who killed my sister and Paul”(Bogel-Burroughs). This testimony accurately depicts the effects of dissociation. While Alex Murdaugh was very emotional while being tried for the murders of his wife and son, his reactions were out of character for him because he is attempting to avoid the reality of the deaths of his family. This can be used to explain why he had chosen to focus on clearing Paul’s name rather than finding the …show more content…

Alex Murdaugh, despite being a thief and drug addict, was also a man struggling with his own issues and complications. At the time of the murders, Alex was going through a mental breakdown due to his addiction to opioids, his lack of a job, and his stress from the constant slander his family received as a result of his financial crimes. Therefore, by all means, Alex’s plea of insanity is the only plea that fits the case and his specific state of mind.
Works Cited

Bogel-burroughs, Nicholas. “Murdaugh 'Never Talked' with Relative about Finding His Family's Killer.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 14 Feb. 2023, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/14/us/alex-murdaugh-wife-sister-proctor.html.
Kamin, Katie. “Alex Murdaugh's 19 Indictments and 99 Financial Charges Explained.” Https://Www.live5news.Com, 17 Jan. 2023, https://www.live5news.com/2023/01/17/alex-murdaughs-19-indictments-99-financial-charges-explained/.
Melendez, Pilar. “'I Was in the Throes of Withdrawal': Alex Murdaugh Speaks out about Botched Attempted Suicide Plot.” The Daily Beast, The Daily Beast Company, 13 Dec. 2021,

Show More
Related
398 Words | 2 Pages

The prosecution is charging the defendant Alex palmer with first degree murder of Jes Markson. Critical aspects of four witness testimonies will be analyzed and discussed. Furthermore, the prosecution will explain the importance of each testimony and how the testimony helps link the Defendant Alex Palmer to the crime. The first witness Detective Dana Brown should state that she has been working for the Hollywood police department for eighteen years, seven of which have been as a detective. Disclosure of this information to the jury will help establish her credibility.

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

According to medical experts, who examined Morgan on three separate occasions, Morgan was declared legally insane at the time of the murder based on the M’Naughten standard. The experts reached their opinion utilizing Morgan’s history, various psychiatric tests along with the medically accepted technique of hypnosis. The expert testimony was presented to the trial judge in the jury’s absence as well as during the penalty phase of the trial. The appellant does not deny killing the victim; the issue being decided was his sanity at the time of the murder and the exclusion of medical

Read More
2496 Words | 10 Pages

In fact, on the day of the murder, prosecutors say Murdaugh’s law office confronted him about misusing funds from the firm.” After this, the Murdaugh name was practically drug through the mud. People now hear the Murdaugh name and think of such a disgraceful family. Shortly after Alex’s family was murdered, he

Read More
681 Words | 3 Pages

Then “the defense argued that the authorities conducted a shoddy investigation” because they failed to gather possible fingerprints and DNA samples from Paul and Maggie's clothing. Ending Alex Murdaughs wild case “Murdaugh is punished with the maximum two consecutive life sentences for the

Read More
961 Words | 4 Pages

He was extremely wealthy and operated a law firm. This law firm had been owned by generations of the Murdaugh Family. Alex had a wife and two sons whom he appeared to love dearly. Little did anyone know the secrets the family had hidden. In 2021, Alex had frantically called the police because someone had shot his youngest son, Paul, and his wife, Maggie, killing them.

Read More
956 Words | 4 Pages

To emphasize, Alex struggled with his addiction for many years and he hid it from everyone. Gloria, the family maid, found the drugs under the bed and informed Paul. Paul confronted his father about it only to receive backlash. This could have been another trigger that set off the killing of Maggie and Paul. Harpootlian says, ‘When PMPED went public with embezzlement accusations, the story from Alex’s team gelled: Alex suffered from 20 years of opioid addiction and blew “most” of his millions on “checks written to drug dealers’’ (Westfall,49).

Read More
950 Words | 4 Pages

At the 2002 trial, Yates pleaded not guilty, by using the insanity defense. The insanity defense argues that an individual should not be found guilty of a crime if they have a persistent psychiatric disease at the time the crime was committed. It was proved that Yates could tell right from wrong, so she did not meet the definition of the insanity in Texas (Walsh). The jury deliberated for almost four hours, and finally found Yates guilty. The jury rejected her insanity defense, and Yates was sentenced to life in prison.

Read More
737 Words | 3 Pages

Drunk mom, dad leaving at such a young age, some of his siblings killing themselves and on top of all that getting abused a lot by his mom and the nuns that hit him when he was in catholic school. Well who was this this very ungood, bad childhood and different and that is Perry Smith. My client’s case is about 2 men Perry & Dick and they're doing is very shocking,that was Perry has killed a family of 4 the Clutter family & each were shot with a gun besides that Mr.Clutter had his throat slit. Previously,Dick was gonna kill them all but something suddenly happened and that was in Perry’s mind. They are not guilty at all but the fact that they will be charged with insanity because yes there has been something going on in Perry’s mind like something

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

Like Alex is trying to help Katie but Katie thinks that she doesn’t deserve his affection because she is a person who still has a lot of issues to work through. But since Alex worked as in the Criminal Investigation Division. “He’d been with Criminal Investigation Division, or CID,” (Page 16) He had prior knowledge as to what to expect of victims and how they would react after being out of an abusive

Read More
1445 Words | 6 Pages

The court dismisses the plea quickly because “the justice system ignores psychosocial complexities and histories in favor of black and white definitions of right and wrong” (Myers). The justice system in this time very rarely accepted pleas of insanity or mental illness. Capote wrote that “after an hour’s conversation with the defendants, the doctor rule[d] out that neither man

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

He pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, but his plea was later rejected (Murdock & Navasky). Insanity is most well-known as a criminal defense plea, but is also considered to be a lack of mental stability. Many people may not know that there are different types of tests to evaluate the credibility of the defense plea. The insanity defense plea originated in England because of the case

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

He also is not guilty because he cannot tell the difference between fantasy and reality, and he cannot control his own morals. So, why not give this man a second chance? Everyone deserves

Read More
1042 Words | 5 Pages

Insanity is not a valid defense for one main reason. You are either crazy or you are not. In the end, Mack Herring was acquitted for murder. He felt as if he was pressured into doing it and he also thought he was helping her by committing the crime.

Read More
2103 Words | 9 Pages

The crew of thugs had been begging for a violent death like that: shot down, no mercy “(Patterson 193) meaning that in one sense Alex agrees with Taylor that they had it coming. Then almost immediately after Alex contradicts himself by thinking “ In my book and the blind eyes of justice, the fact that a man had it coming doesn’t make killing him right “ (Patterson 194). This shows Alex’s true opinion in that he believes that killing a man who was clueless doesn’t make it right. It also shows he thinks everyone is innocent until proven guilty just like most cops are caught not and that he believes only courts can issue punishment not some group of vigilante

Read More
786 Words | 4 Pages

From the beginning of the story it is clear that there is a lack of an authority figure in Alex’s life. His parents seem to be emotionally absent, they do not question their sons lack of school attendants, nor do they question where he is and wants he is doing late at night. Alex had a very relaxed upbringing and was allowed to do whatever, whenever with no consequences. The “Droog" gang members also had a negative impact on Alex’s decision making and problem solving abilities. Growing up with this lack of authority and the inability to differ between right and wrong is the ideal environment for the makings of a psychopath.

Read More

More about Alex Murdaugh: The Plea Of Insanity

Related Topics

Open Document