ipl-logo

Analysis Of A War Of Choice By Richard N. Haass

1428 Words6 Pages

Two wars, both alike in dignity, In fair Iraq where we lay our scene. “A War of Necessity, War of Choice” was written by Richard N. Haass from 2005 to 2008 and reviewed the Gulf War in 1991 and the Iraq War in 2003 (Council on Foreign Relations). He reviews these two wars to understand a critical pivot in American foreign policy—the decision to choose a war of choice rather than a war of Necessity. So, the natural question is, why did Haass write about this? Although some may say Haass wrote this for self-centered reasons [as he was a participant in strategies and planning of a vastly unpopular war], the seemingly evident reason is to ensure future presidents are not able to make another mistake that the Bush administration made as well …show more content…

When discussing the differences between the two wars, he lets the reader know the differences early on, which helps the reader understand precisely what the wars are and are not (Haass, 7). When Haass dissects a war of choice, he masterfully explains the headspaces that many actors were in. His explanation of the legal and international ramifications and their effects on foreign policy are also done with great skill, specifically in sections explaining how the United Nations and the United States population react and can influence wars of choice. However, Haass fails to explain how a war of choice occurs and why they are wrong. He explains that going outside of core issues can lead to corruption, not necessarily why wars of choice are …show more content…

Having an in-depth analysis of the conditions of both wars and a description of said wars preceding an actual analysis of the wars allows Haass better to facilitate a discussion on the differences between the wars. Writing them individually also allows him to address better the environment surrounding each idea. Despite this excellent framework, Haass fails to capitalize on it, often failing to go into depth about crucial aspects of his argument. He explains and elaborates on the decision-making surrounding each type of conflict but never extricates this onto the world surrounding the decision and thus fails to teach the reader about conflicts outside the Two wars primarily mentioned in the book. To correct these issues, Haass could have analyzed the two wars in a vacuum and then related individual aspects to historical or contemporary examples to better influence policy

Show More
Related

Summary Of The Wednesday Wars By Gary D. Schmidt

322 Words | 2 Pages

I read the book called the Wednesday wars by Gary D. Schmidt. The book is about a boy named Holling Hoodhood who is in seventh grade and his teacher, Mrs. Baker. The story takes place mainly in school or at Holling’s home. The first main event is when Holling finds out he is the only one that doesn't leave school early on Wednesdays because of Hebrew school or catechism. Also, when Holling let the rats go, it caused a lot of trouble through the story.

Read More

Summary Of The Wednesday Wars By Gary D. Schmidt

171 Words | 1 Pages

The book that is going to discussed in this essay is The Wednesday Wars by Gary D. Schmidt. It is about a boy named Holling and his teacher named Mrs. Baker. This is going on during The Vietnam war. Holling thinks that Mrs. Baker is a mean teacher, but he has to stay with her every wednesday, because he is Presbyterian and everyone in his class goes to Catholic or Hebrew school. Here is the two questions will be discussed in the essay are How do the plays Holling reads with Mrs. Baker mirror events in the book?

Read More

Summary Of The Tuesday Wars By Gary Dd

216 Words | 1 Pages

The difference between two things are often blurred by way we interpret them. In The Wednesday Wars by Gary D. Schmidt, the lead character, Holling is witnessing the truth behind people's true emotions. Holling was publicly embarrassed when pictures of him were plastered throughout the school displaying the bright yellow tights he wore in the Shakespeare play. Everywhere he looked he observed student faces manifesting haunting and unpleasant smirks, mocking him without mercy or end. Holling felt like he was engulfed in a bottomless pit of misery and shame.

Read More

Review Of Why They Fought By James M. Mcpherson

1025 Words | 5 Pages

James M. McPherson is the Author of the Book entitled What They Fought 1861-1865 For, in his introduction McPherson explains that he “…carved from research for a larger book tentatively entitled Why They Fought.” (McPherson, 1994) This is a book that elucidates the attitude of the soldiers that fought during the Civil War, it discusses their Honor and courage, masculinity, discipline, religion, their fear, pain, and death among others. In his synopsis, McPherson says that his book “…gives voice to the very men who risked their lives in this struggle and places them in the great and terrible choir of a country dived against itself.” (McPherson, 1994)

Read More

Summary Of The Wednesday Wars By Gary D. Schmidt

154 Words | 1 Pages

Not letting your child go to college is not letting them have a chance to have a life. This relates to a girl named Heather and her father in the The Wednesday Wars by Gary D. Schmidt. Heather was in a business with her father that she was forced to work in. When her family and her were sitting at the dinner table, she was talking about how she was going to college and her dad interrupted her saying that she’s not going to college and she is perfectly fine in the business that she is in not going anywhere. I don’t think that Heather’s dad has good attitude towards her.

Read More

How Did Dwight D Eisenhower Use Pathos In The Cold War

830 Words | 4 Pages

He emphasizes that warfare is not in the future of the United States and that it only wants peace for itself and all other countries. The audience will sway more with Eisenhower’s thesis because they were provided with valid statements that left an impact on viewpoints towards

Read More

Review Of Ernst Junger's All Quiet On The Western Front

1331 Words | 6 Pages

Ernst Junger’s account of World War I subtly produces a mood of remorse among his audience through his formation of description. Most of his book contains lucid images, lacking any symbolic language. His pragmatic diction and syntax structure a story almost devoid of emotion. Junger punctuates his writing with frequent fragments and brusque sentences that highlight the vicious reality of war (47). As he recounts the deaths of his fellow soldiers with a chilling tone, he appears to be unfazed by the brutalities around him (52).

Read More

Analysis Of Howard Zinn's The Myth Of A Good War

321 Words | 2 Pages

In Howard Zinn’s speech, “The Myth of a Good War” (or “Three Holy Wars”), he talks about the misleading air surround three very brutal and devastating wars that shaped our country. As his title implies, he talks about the mythical concept of a “good” war – as designed by our government. Peter Stearns’ article, “Why Study History?” , describes the value placed in the study of history. Stearns points out the relevance of history in relation to our identity, both individually and as a whole nation.

Read More

The Soldier In Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

990 Words | 4 Pages

The war forces people into situations where the pressure is too much and the environment forces a change on how one views himself. Curt Lemon and Norman Bowker held themselves to standards that they couldn’t reach. They let the war determine how they live and who they would become. The war causes the human spirit to change so vastly that it leads to a demise, so quick and drastic, that it is hard to

Read More

My Brother Sam Is Dead By Mr Collier

707 Words | 3 Pages

The point is further established when Colonel Read states, “War is never fair. Who chooses which men get killed and which ones don’t?” (Collier and Collier 200). Warfare comes at a cost, and one never knows who will pay it. By the same token, the authors stress that as long as the fighting goes on only unfair consequences will

Read More

Summary Of A New Moral Compact?

1298 Words | 6 Pages

In the essay “A New Moral Compact,” David W. Barno formally uses effective rhetorical techniques to successfully argue that a draft lottery system is essential for the United States’ involvement in armed foreign conflict to subside. The first way Barno creates an effective argument is by his technique of consistently using the literary device of comparison to identify the similar, yet different, nature of the participation in the Afghan and Iraqi conflicts to the Vietnam War. Within the first sentence of the essay, Barno informs the reader of the United States entering “its second decade of armed conflict,” which translates into eleven years of continuous strife that the nation has endured throughout Afghanistan and Iraq (15). This specific information is significant as the author later uses it for an effective comparison with the ten-year Vietnam War.

Read More

Summary Of The Best War Ever Sparknotes

756 Words | 4 Pages

This war was greater for the American society than it was for their soldiers. While many of the soldiers lost their mind, American saw great economic growth and overcame the Great Depression. Finally, in the last chapter, Adams talks about the knowledge of postwar history. Although evil groups, such as Nazism, had been overcome, many problems remained in the home front that and some still exist

Read More

World War I: Heart Of The Progressive Era

326 Words | 2 Pages

Due to Woodrow Wilson’s intelligent manipulation, propaganda, and an organized selection of words, going to war seemed as easy as promised. To Wilson, war was a successful way to spread Democracy and

Read More

Analysis Of The Wars By Timothy Findley

1906 Words | 8 Pages

War, something that sounds so cliché yet endeavours a greater meaning; a meaning of finding your true self within yourself, and seeing your natural, brave or mediocre side. The concept of bravery and heroic men is often the label associated with war; however, in Timothy Findley’s The Wars, it is in fact the exact opposite. The Wars is an anachronistic example of what one goes through both physically and mentally. Findley accurately portrays the protagonist, Robert Ross, as a naïve nineteen year old who wishes to escape his excruciating feelings of reality for being held accountable for Rowena’s death by enlisting into war, as well as to adhere to societal norms. Robert is an incompetent young boy that achieves most of his knowledge of war from

Read More

Sherman's Involvement In The Vietnam War

1210 Words | 5 Pages

Whether it be the involvement of the U.S. in the Vietnam War or the decision to drop the nuclear bombs on the Japanese islands of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, wherever conflict arises, controversy is not far behind. It is easy to view military actions as great triumphs, but one must ask if they adhere to our values as human beings. General William T. Sherman’s destruction of the South in his march to the sea was not only unnecessary in terms of the outcome of the war, but the extent of its brutality was inhumane and negatively impacted the cause for peace between the North and the South during and after the war. Sherman’s obliteration of the South in his march to the sea was uncalled for and against the very purpose of the war.

Read More

More about Analysis Of A War Of Choice By Richard N. Haass

Related Topics

Open Document