ipl-logo

Analysis Of Seven Sins Of The Change Australia Day Movement By Andrew Bolt

613 Words3 Pages

In the Herald Sun, Andrew Bolt’s article ‘Seven Sins of the Change Australia Day Movement’, posted in the 27th of January 2017, asserts the negative and “sin” like properties of changing the date of Australia Day. The “change the Australia Day movement” has ignited a vehement debate that has divided Australians for years, and will most likely continue to. The procedural format clearly and concisely retorts that changing the date will not “heal wounds” and we, as a county, should be instead focused on fixing the issues within the indigenous culture. Bolt ignites the debate very early in his article by affirming that changing the date inevitably “solves nothing”. A strong authoritative tone is taken in the first argument when Bolt uses an …show more content…

Adamantly arguing his point, Bolts tone changes from one of authority to a more conversational tone. This is most likely adopted to make the readers feel included and as if Bolt is just conversing with them, and they are the primary focus of the article. Information in the form of facts is used to strongly back Bolts argument, noting the “brutal” fact is, that due to colonisation Indigenous children apart of the Stolen generation now live a “richer” and more “fulfilled life”. Moreover, positioning the reader to feel confronted by this argument and challenging a popular sense of history. The latter point continues on from the second argument, illustrating how by changing the date we encourage a false sense of “division” in our country. The integration of an anecdote - from an Indigenous frontbencher, is a tactic to undermine Linda Burneys claims by unveiling that she was has a strong Scottish ancestry. Following on to establish that “more that half of Aboriginal married non- Aboriginals”. This forces the reader to break the historical stigma that this debate is between Aboriginals and white people, but there is in fact, more at

Show More
Related

The Eatock V. Bolt: FCA 1103 Case

330 Words | 2 Pages

The Eatock v Bolt (2011) FCA 1103 case is a striking example of how unregulated Media power can undermine and humiliate the interests of the vulnerable. It was alleged that Mr Andrew Bolt, Australian journalist and right-wing political commentator, racially vilified Mrs Pat Eatock and various other members of the Indigenous community. Bolt’s comments were reportedly insensitive to the “light-skinned” Aboriginals of Australia, in which he vilified unlawfully under Section18C (1) through “insulting, humiliating, offensive” commentary. At the conclusion of the case it was found that Bolt did indeed breech the provisions of Section18C. But it was the nature of his punishment which reignited the flame to the Section18 debate.

Read More

Analysis Of The Article 'Invasion Of Australia Day' By Peter Moore

862 Words | 4 Pages

In recent years, the issue of Australia Day marking the ‘invasion’ of ‘white man’ has sparked controversy between the Indigenous and non-indigenous populations of Australia. In his article titled “January 26th is the birth of modern Australia – deal with it”, Peter Moore advocates that the date of Australia Day should not be changed and he provides humour and solidarity for those who share his perspective. He does this through heavy use of attacks and generalisations with an informal, aggressive tone. Conversely, Natalie Cromb, with her article titled ‘Australia Day/ Invasion Day debate: #ChangeTheDate – but not right now”, criticizes the idea of the date changing at present time as she attempts to rally supportive readers to stand up to the

Read More

Analysis Of Verna St. Denis Article On Aboriginal Injustice

1393 Words | 6 Pages

Denis, 2011, p. 306-307). To further explain her thesis, she claims that multiculturalism is used by the government of Canada as a method of colonizing Aboriginal people and diverting the issue of recognition and retribution for the Aboriginal people (St. Denis, 2011). St. Denis proposed at a provincial social science curriculum discussion that Aboriginal studies should be considered a separate course in the Canadian curriculum as opposed to being combined with social studies and history (St. Denis, 2011). The suggestion that was made was interjected by the comment, “Aboriginal people are not the only people here” (St. Denis, 2011, p.306). Although the comment may hold truth, the author uses that remark to further provide evidence that multiculturalism is used as a form of colonialism (St. Denis,

Read More

Analysis Of Dick Smith's Truth Of Australian Day

926 Words | 4 Pages

Smith continues his pattern of strong emotive language whilst depicting the poor and inhumane treatment of the Aboriginals and how in accordance to the newly aquatinted British laws and customs, they were “for the most part, invisible and discounted”. Statements such as these are used to position the reader to feel sympathy towards the Aboriginals as they come to terms with the full extend of the hardship and discord faced by them. Moreover, adding to the understanding of how tirelessly throughout history and continuing today, they have fought to obtain rights equal to those of a white Australian. Smith then continues by appealing to the readers sense of sustainability. By recounting how the Aboriginals “nurtured” and “preserved” Australia and how the life of modern Australian isn’t sustainable, and how we, should seek guidance and assistance from the Aboriginals.

Read More

Jasper Jones Quotes

929 Words | 4 Pages

The history of Aboriginal alienation was an important context that assisted Silvey in the making of his novel, and furthermore establishing a successful play. The year 2009 was an influential year for Aboriginal’s rights. After twenty years of negotiation, the United Nations

Read More

For Australia's Sake By Henry E. Boote

509 Words | 3 Pages

Boote argues that such an action would not help the men on the front, expressing his concern that it would instead ‘paralyse and pauperise’ the land that these men were sacrificing their lives for. The document is clearly a piece of propaganda. It features emotive language, calling upon the patriotism of Australian people in order to prevent the referendum being a success. Phrases such as ‘Keep Australia White’ and ‘Do not vote to ruin the country’ make the author’s standing on the potential policy changes clear.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Scott Sawyer's Argument Against Racism

734 Words | 3 Pages

Scott Sawyer’s opinion piece published in the Gladstone Observer on the 25th of January 2014, employs an informal tone to argue against the unnecessary racism often exhibited on Australia Day. The piece follows a train of thought as it transitions from an impartial positive tone to stern and disgusted. The article “Ditch the racism and enjoy Australia Day as it should be” states it’s contention in it’s title, clearly and concisely, continuing on to position the Australian population to agree to it’s contention using rhetorical questions, emotive and inclusive language and appeal to patriotism. The article displays a cartoon image of a cave man looking puzzled at a stone wheel, contemplating its existence and use. The image acts as a metaphor

Read More

Change The Date Of Australia Day By Peter Moore

956 Words | 4 Pages

Change the date of Australia Day issue – Language Analysis Controversy surrounds the issue of whether Australia Day’s date should be changed to a day with historical value that also includes Indigenous people. As Australia day is on the 26th of January, it is associated with the day that Captain Cook landed in 1788, which to those of Indigenous origin, can be known as Invasion Day. Two articles published on the 26th of January 2017, with opposing views ‘January 26th is the birth of modern Australia – deal with it’ written by Peter Moore and ‘Australia Day/Invasion Day debate: #ChangeTheDate – But not right now’ by Natalie Cromb, express their views on the date of Australia Day potentially being changed. In Peter Moore’s opinion piece, published

Read More

Racism Is Destroying The Australian Dream Speech Analysis

652 Words | 3 Pages

This article discusses the speech given by an Indigenous journalist, Stan Grant who participated in a debate where he spoke for the motion “Racism is destroying the Australian Dream’’. Hence, the main points of this article are mostly evidence given by Grant in his debate to support his idea that the Australian Dream is indeed rooted in racism. One of the main points is that the indigenous Australians are often excluded and disregarded as non-Australians simply due to their race and skin colour. Grant pointed out the incident where AFL player Adam Goodes was publicly jeered and told that he did not belong to his country as he was not an Australian despite the fact that Australia indeed is the land of his ancestors.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Australia Day

978 Words | 4 Pages

As patriotic Australians we pride ourselves to be a nation that accepts and respects the beliefs of all cultures, but on this historical day majority of Australians tend to forget the true meaning behind the celebration. If you ask today’s society, what they did this Australia day mass numbers would respond with “binged on alcohol” and “indulged in a barbecue.” Consequently, this day cannot be called a national celebration when some of our fellow Australians are grieving while others are out celebrating an occasion they know little about. Giving due regard to the indigenous people and their mostly negative perspective on this issue should be a priority. A new date, not the 26th of January should be established, as rather than unite, it seems to divide Australians into different viewpoints.

Read More

Essay On Australia Day

820 Words | 4 Pages

Should Australia change the date of Australia Day? Some of you may be wondering why this is such a controversial issue and some of you might already know. If you don’t know why I’ll tell you. The date that we celebrate Australia Day is not the date we became our own country, you may be thinking “so what?” well I’ll tell you, the day we are celebrating is the day Great Britain invaded Australia and the start of when they tortured and killed thousands of the Australian indigenous people, there are multiple dates available that were important to Australia or represent Australia and this date has no monument recognizing the day

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Australia Day

258 Words | 2 Pages

The date of Australia day has been a large community discussion for many Australians. This day is a happy and positive day for many Australians and very important to some people. This is because it brings different people from different cultures that exist in our country together to celebrate the history that Australia has made. On both sides of this argument, if you want Australia Day to change, or stay the same, there is good evidence for this argument. Australia Day should most definitely stay the same for the following reasons.

Read More

Persuasive Essay: The Legend Of Anzac Day

1194 Words | 5 Pages

They see it as the first time that Australians were recognised as Australians and not people who were fighting on behalf of Britain Promotion These remarks were speedily rejected by the then Prime Minister Julia Gillard, who reported that she totally couldn't help contradicting the commission. Her encounters of going to sunrise administrations in Melbourne, she stated, indicated it was regularly kids who persuaded their folks to come. "When you can see that sort of excitement … I figure we can state as a country it's an essential piece of our national personality." My last point is Anzac day is relevant to modern society because we need to remember the people that sacrifice their lives to Australia and fight for their

Read More

Speech On Changing The Date Of Australia Day

993 Words | 4 Pages

Changing the date of Australia day is more than just a secondary issue for our nation. The week leading up to January 26th, and the week that follows, are essentially the only times of the year when the topic is actually prevalent within Australian news, which is a huge issue – this has led to a lack of understanding – and blatant ignorance – with non-indigenous people in regard to Indigenous Australians culture. The argument most Australians hold for not wanting to change the date is the fact that ‘changing the date won’t change the history behind it’ when that’s not at all the outcome that those who want to change the date are striving for. My name is Shehara Bradley, and I am here to inform you all of how important it is to change the day our nation celebrates Australia day, because change is more than necessary in order for all Australians to move forward. The media often trivialises this and misrepresents the history behind January 26th controlling the narrative that changing the date will ultimately make little to no difference, and therefore positioning their audience to believe the same.

Read More

Aboriginal Identity Essay

1190 Words | 5 Pages

Abstract Being an aborigine in a white dominated society is a complicated identity. Australia, one of the white governed nations, also owns many aboriginal tribes. They lived harmonious lives in the early period. But European colonization has made a profound effect on the lives of Aboriginals in Australia, which led to the total demolition of their native culture, identity and history. As a result the new generation Aboriginals have lost their Aboriginal heritage and have been accepted neither by Aboriginals nor by whites.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Seven Sins Of The Change Australia Day Movement By Andrew Bolt

Related Topics

Open Document