ipl-logo

Analysis Of The Gary Dotson Case

601 Words3 Pages

Forensic science has contributed to wrongful convictions and the correction of wrongful conviction by bringing to surface the issue of how involved flawed forensics has made an impact. In Gary Dotson case, false claims were made involving the forensics that was used throughout the case, in such cases as blood comparison and analysis of hairs. The correction to the field of forensics associated with allowing wrongful convictions to be overturned because it reveals the flaws in forensics that previous cases used to implement and by demonstrating how certain types of forensics are unreliable and invalid (Garrett, 2011). There are a few cases that the forensics completed mislead the jury because they were not showing the truth but rather flaws. …show more content…

There was an analysis of hairs and blood comparison conducted this was done before DNA testing was established. The analysis presented two techniques used to examine the innocence of Gary and this individual provided inaccurate information regarding the case’s specific evidence. The method of hair comparison that was used is unreliable because multiple people can have the same hair type leaving room for error and inconclusive evidence. Serology is a reliable method of analysis given that the same person will always have the same blood type. Serology, is ABO testing, which was the most common method that was used by forensic analysts because it is both credible and valid. Not every method used in forensics is entirely accurate; the idea is to reduce error, and in Gary Dotson case the analysts made loads of mistakes, which in turn means bad science. The analyst made the claim that contamination must have created another blood type. Flawed forensics convicted Gary for a crime, and real science has demonstrated that an individual can be wrongfully convicted but be given freedom (Garrett, 2011). Dotson was convicted of rape in 1979 and sentenced to twenty-five to fifty years in prison. Later, DNA testing results provided Dotson his freedom when he was exonerated in 1989 (Garrett,

Show More
Related
1139 Words | 5 Pages

This represented the power and position of forensic pathology in the criminal justice system, which the Crown and defence rely on, but can end in incarcerations of innocent individuals, as shown in John’s case. In this investigation, rather than having evidence presented by a forensic pathologist, Dr. Dietrich was a clinical pathologist who was trained to determine causes of disease in living patients and not to perform post-mortem examinations to identify the causes of death. John’s trial was proceeded by an unqualified pathologist without training in the area required to provide medical evidence in criminal trials, which lead to misdiagnoses and John’s wrongful conviction. As well, rather than approaching evidence with an open mind “without preconceptions or presumptions about abuse”, Dr. Dietrich had initially believed Maxine’s death was a homicide, therefore demonstrating his bias and lean towards evidence supporting his view instead of the truthful information

Read More
690 Words | 3 Pages

However, the way the glass evidence at the crime scene was documented, collected, and preserved absolutely would have had an impact on the examination results at the lab. The glass evidence was mishandled as it was reportedly transferred from an envelope to a plastic bag during the investigation, which could have resulted in further loss or contamination of the evidence. Overall, the mishandling of significant evidence compromised the reliability and admissibility in court. Again, this example of mishandling of evidence posed as another contention point within the case and resulted in much

Read More
1477 Words | 6 Pages

The Ethics of Fred Zain Fred Zain was a forensic lab technician that worked for both the states of West Virginia and Texas. A man who did a job he was severely under qualified for, for ten years, and who was thought to be a start asset in his line of work. Fred Zain had testified in countless cases, presenting himself well and appeared to know his trade so well that no one in the courtroom questioned the lab results obtained by Zain. It is very well known that his actions in court are viewed as unethical by today’s standards. In his time of employment, Fred Zain acquired a lengthy rap sheet of tampering and falsifying evidence, false convictions.

Read More
231 Words | 1 Pages

On September 5th at 9:15PM a car was discovered burning in the 400 block of Xenia St. SE. A body was later found in the burning vehicle. The vehicle was later determined to be registered to my 21 year old son Malik Thomas. Due to the condition of the body I was asked to submit a DNA sample. Someone attempted to obliterate Malik 's existence.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

In his interview with Ana Swanson, a writer for the Washington Post, Adam Benforado, a law professor at Drexel University describes a case he studied that was a wrong verdict. Benforado explains that there was a rape case in 1979 and the victim was brought in to identify her attacker out of five men. The victim had previously been given pictures of these five men to identify and she could not. In the lineup, she picked John Jerome White as her attacker and he was immediately sentenced to prison for decades. Swanson continues writing that the DNA from the case was tested a couple of years later and White was not the rapist.

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

The Lindbergh Kidnapping Crime has always been a part of the world we live in. Whether it be theft, murder, or kidnapping, it has been and always will be a huge factor in society. With crime, comes forensics; the “behind the scenes” work in all cases. Forensics is described as “relating to the use of scientific knowledge or methods in solving crimes or relating to, used in, or suitable to a court of law” (Crime Museum 1). Dubbed as “The Crime of the Century”, The Lindbergh kidnapping has affected the criminal justice system in more areas than one.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

This paper is to serve as an in depth analysis of all aspects of the physical evidence found at the scene, and later at O.J.’s house. The origin of the evidence, relation to the crime scene, connection to O.J., and the legalities of the collection and handling of said evidence will all be examined. A sample of blood was discovered on a pair of O.J. Simpson's socks that were found in his bedroom; after a DNA analysis was conducted, the blood was identified it as Nicole Brown's. Although this seems like substantial evidence, the handling of the evidence comes into

Read More
1502 Words | 7 Pages

On the other hand, discrepancies or weaknesses in the forensic analysis may raise reasonable doubt and favor the defendant (Bolton-King, 2016). Conclusion: Reliability and validity are critical considerations in forensic firearm examination, influencing the accuracy and credibility of forensic evidence presented in legal proceedings. Despite its importance, the field of forensic firearm identification has faced criticism regarding its scientific foundation. Skeptics argue that traditional methods lack the rigor and standardization necessary to be considered truly scientific. However, dismissing forensic firearm examination entirely would not only disregard its historical significance but also deprive the legal system of a valuable tool in investigating firearm-related crimes.

Read More
143 Words | 1 Pages

Historically, forensic science and miscarriages of justice were never closely examined. However, forensic science has been pointed to as a contributor to miscarriages of justice since as long ago as the Dreyfus case. The Dryfus case or the “Dryfus affair” was a political scandal that divided France until it was resolved in 1906. It started with the treason conviction of Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a young French artillery officer of Alsatian and Jewish descent. Sentenced to imprisonment for sharing French military secrets to the German Embassy in Paris.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

Science has come a long way over the years. It has helped countless every day struggles and cure diseases most commonly found. What you don’t hear about however is the advancement of forensic science. Forensic science has helped solve countless cases of murder, rape, and sexual assault. In the case of John Joubert, it helped solve the murders of three young boys with one small piece of evidence that linked him directly to the crime.

Read More
562 Words | 3 Pages

Television shows involving murder cases and crime such as Bones, Criminal Minds, and NCIS have tricked viewers into believing this forensic science is a simple process. Misrepresentation of forensic science in mainstream crime shows lead audiences to believe technology has the ability to report one accurate consensus within minutes when provided with a dental imprint. In reality, receiving an accurate consensus when examining a dental impression on human skin is rare. The Stinson case sparked media interest, leading consumers to this assumption. However, bite mark analysis has never been error rate tested, meaning the validity of this science has not yet been determined.

Read More
296 Words | 2 Pages

Destiny Johnson LSTD 502 Criminal Law January 10, 2016 A. Research Paper Topic: Wrongful Convictions B. Law abiding citizens should not be wrongfully convicted of a crime that they did not commit. Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) was first used to aid a criminal investigation by Professor Jeffreys in 1986 for rapes/murders that occurred in the United Kingdom. The first DNA exoneration took place in 1989. Prior to DNA testing there were hundreds of wrongful convictions.

Read More
2071 Words | 9 Pages

If a forensic analyst holds biases, either knowingly or unknowingly, it can influence various results such as influence DNA mixture interpretations, fingerprint comparisons, toxicology, and other forensic science judgements (Dror et al. 1). By understanding

Read More
1150 Words | 5 Pages

In a murder case where an 18-year-old, Sarah Johnson was sentenced to life in prison for committing a first degree murder for both her and dad. The case reopened when a retired crime lab technician Michael Howard “testified that whoever shot Diane and Alan Johnson at close range on September 2, 2003, would have been hit by a "rain" of blood spatter” (http://www.cnn.com/2005/LAW/03/03/johnson/index.html?eref=sitesearch). Howard came up with his theories proving that, Sarah was not even close in committing those murders and it is a wrongful conviction. Based on blood spatter, Howard disclosed that the shooting which took place was at a very close range and blood would have been all over the assailant, where as there was no blood pattern found on Sarah’s clothes. In fact, the pajama pant, Sarah was wearing on the day of shooting had no trace of her parent’s DNA or blood.

Read More
2155 Words | 9 Pages

But in the shoes of the convicted, this matter means years of their life gone, these convictions on their permanent record and the constant judgement that follows. This is where the world of forensics is supposed to help out, an infallible titan in the world of uncertainty, but does it really? In fact, in my eyes forensics in most cases forensics makes most cases worse, ranging from unreliable testimonies, evidence that is incorrectly used to convict a person, and more. Of course people do believe this is fake because they sit down and turn on their t.v’s or open a book and dwell in the world of imagination where forensic is perfect. In a great world it would be, but there are various faults to it and there needs to be change in the way people gather and present evidence.

Read More

More about Analysis Of The Gary Dotson Case

Related Topics

Open Document