ipl-logo

Analyzing Nicolas Malebranche's Occasionalism

988 Words4 Pages

Marc Wilk Dr. Kaufman PHIL3010 November 30, 2014 Short Paper: Malebranche’s Occasionalism Nicolas Malebranche (1638-1715) was a French philosopher and also a devout Christian. In order to incorporate his Christian beliefs into philosophy, he established his own doctrine of occasionalism. That is, there is only one true cause for every effect; the true cause being God. All other natural causes are just occasional causes. Malebranche gives many different arguments in favor of his idea. Most importantly, the argument from ‘no necessary connection’ which states, “there are no necessary connections between events involving only creatures. Therefore, there are no true causes in events involving only creatures.” He uses this argument heavily in favor …show more content…

There are three aspects of occasionalism that all correlate. First, the negative aspect, which infers that all creatures (living things, humans) have no true causal powers. Second, the positive aspect, which infers that God is the true cause of every effect. Third, the lawfulness aspect, which infers that God does it all but only in accordance to His laws that He has established. For example, when you accidently stub your toe into a wall you feel pain. For Malebranche, this pain is just the result of one of God’s occasions. Additionally, the physical pain that you experience, acts as an occasion for God to cause the mental pain. A better example might be a soccer ball hitting another soccer ball. The impact that soccer ball number one has on soccer ball number two is an occasion for God to move the soccer ball. In both examples, God is the sole cause of the …show more content…

The formal argument goes as stated above, “there are no necessary connections between events involving only creatures. Therefore, there are no true causes in events involving only creatures.” Although I believe it should be stated as, 1. For every cause, there is an effect. 2. The mind perceives a necessary connection between every cause and effect. 3. This necessary connection is only held true by an infinite, all power, all good being. 4. Therefore, God is the only true cause for every effect, leaving all creatures (humans),

Show More
Related

Fahrenheit 451 By Ray Bradbury: Chapter Analysis

655 Words | 3 Pages

(SIP-A) The logical fallacy it uses is false cause. (STEWE-1) False cause occurs when one thing is incorrectly seen as the cause of another thing. This usually happens as a presumption that a relation between two events is evidence for a cause-effect between those events.

Read More

The Kansas-Nebraska Bill During The Revolutionary War

2217 Words | 9 Pages

Otherwise, there would be no argument to cause the

Read More

Sacrifice In Homer's Odyssey

507 Words | 3 Pages

All their afflictions come from us, we hear. And what of their own failings?” (page 2). The gods, although they are powerful, cannot prevent every wrongful decision made by man, yet men do not blame themselves but turn to supernatural causes

Read More

William Craig Cosmological Argument

1022 Words | 5 Pages

Craig validates that his argument, “the universe has a cause of its existence”, is true by assuming the initial premise that everything that

Read More

Problem Of Evil Swinburne Analysis

1054 Words | 5 Pages

Daniel Ertel Professor Hunt Phil 1010-01 October 1st, 2016 Is Gods Existence compatible with the existence of evil? One of the most dated arguments on the topic of God’s existence is whether its’ existence is compatible with the existence of evil. In his dissertation, “The Problem of Evil,” by Richard Swinburne, he attempts to demonstrate how evil can coexist in a world created by an omnipotent (all-powerful) and benevolent being. In his first objection, he argues that there is an omnipotent and omnibenevolent God in a universe that contains coexisting forces.

Read More

Saint Thomas Aquinas Argument For The Existence Of God

871 Words | 4 Pages

The objection addressed the validity of the argument which had the premise 1, nothing is the efficient cause of itself except God and premise 2, a chain of causes cannot be infinite. The argument thus concludes there must be a first cause. This conclusion agrees with my thesis that Saint Thomas Aquinas’s argument formulated in the second way leads to a valid argument, which concludes that there must be a first cause and that God

Read More

Essay On The Key Arguments For The Existence Of God

492 Words | 2 Pages

Fong-Wei Ting Mr. Mahoney Apologetics November 24 2014 Key Arguments for and against the existence of God God is defined as the perfect and all-powerful spirit or being that is worshiped especially by the Christian, Jews and Muslims as the One who created and rules the universe.1 There are many people who do not believe in a God, and with a lack of faith, they argue against the existence of God and are proving something that is completely false or unrelated. There are a large number of reasons proving God to be real. This essay is to prove the existence of God, and within this essay are twelve reasons that prove God does exist.

Read More

Thomas Aquinas First Cause Argument Analysis

1797 Words | 8 Pages

So the first cause argument proves that God does not exist assuming the first cause argument is sound then there must be some other cause because it is not God. In summary the notion of omnipotent is a miss-name because it implies the potency, power, causality when in fact all that it does is imply logical entailment, it implies that if it wills something you can deduce from the statement that something exists, you do not need a causal step, it is a logical deduction and therefore the first cause argument argues from causes in the world

Read More

Macbeth Superstition Essay

2463 Words | 10 Pages

Although some may be quick to dismiss people’s beliefs in supernatural causation, they hold great significance

Read More

Boethius Boethius Free Will

1532 Words | 7 Pages

In Christian tradition, the existence of God is central to the religion and the practices and beliefs associated with it. In this tradition, God can be conceived of as an all powerful, immortal and transcendent being who governs and creates the world as it is known. During the Medieval Era Christianity dominated Europe, leading to an extensive amount of philosophical and scholarly works related to God and how to properly conceive of him. As a result, many philosophical topics and theories were brought under examination in an attempt to combine them with Christian ideologies and conceptions of God and the world. One of the many topics brought under consideration was free will.

Read More

Summary Of Aristotle's 'Argument Of Parmenides'

2363 Words | 10 Pages

Remember that for Aristotle meant something different than what we intend when we say cause. We are referring to an action or event that occurred prior to another. For Aristotle, causes meant explanation. This explanation works fine for a man made article, so how does he explain cause in nature?

Read More

Difference Between Christianity And Naturalism

981 Words | 4 Pages

Instead the belief revolves around the idea that natural causes are sufficient to explain everything that exists in the

Read More

Thomas Aquinas Cosmological Argument

1784 Words | 8 Pages

The objection against premise three states: “There can be an infinite series of numbers; why can’t there be an infinite series of past causes (PowerPoint 384)?” Thomas Aquinas is a famous philosopher who is well known for his theological writings. Here, Aquinas steps in to defend this premise saying that “if there were an infinite regress of causes, we could not have gotten to the present moment because we would have had to go through an infinite series to get here, and it is impossible to go through an infinite series (PowerPoint, 384).” William Lane Craig then comes in and discusses the claim of premise three and Aquinas’ defence and states that, “the idea of an actual infinite number of anything leads to contradictions. Both Thomas Aquinas and William Lane Craig’s defence claims help show that premise three is true, proving that the first half of the first cause argument is a sound

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Problem Of Evil

877 Words | 4 Pages

On the other hand, theists like Swinburne, believe that evil is necessary for important reasons such as that it helps us grow and improve. In this paper I will argue that the theist is right, because the good of the evil in this specific case on problems beyond one’s control, outweighs the bad that comes from it. I will begin by stating the objection the anti-theodicist gives for why it is wrong that there is a problem of evil. (<--fix) Regarding passive evil not caused by human action, the anti-theodicist claims that there is an issue with a creator, God, allowing a world to exist where evil things happen, which are not caused by human beings (180-181).

Read More

God's Not Dead Analysis

915 Words | 4 Pages

In his first-cause argument, he states that everything we are able to observe has a cause and that nothing can cause itself. In order for something to cause itself, it would have to exist prior to itself, which is impossible. Nor can something be caused by an infinite regress of causes. (Vaughn, Lewis. Pg.

Read More

More about Analyzing Nicolas Malebranche's Occasionalism

Related Topics

Open Document