ipl-logo

Comparison Of Monarchy And Democracy In Ancient Greece

903 Words4 Pages

Introduction
Monarchy, aristocracy, tyranny, oligarchy and democracy were all forms of government found at different times and in different city-states in Ancient Greece. Elements of more than one of these forms also co-existed, however, and the modern connotations of labels such as these are not necessarily the same as those that prevailed in Ancient Greece.
In this paper I firstly describe these various forms of government and provide examples of their use in Ancient Greece. I then compare and contrast the models.
Monarchy
Monarchy may be defined as: “a government having a hereditary chief of state with life tenure and powers varying from nominal to absolute” (Merriam Webster, n.d.).
Monarchy was common amongst Greek city-states in Greece …show more content…

The word “aristocracy” is a concatenation of “kratos”, meaning rule, and ‘aristoi”, meaning the best (Brouwers, 2015).
Athens was governed by aristocracy from the 8th to the 6th centuries B.C: “political power was in the hands of several large aristocratic families or clans (genei) which controlled large areas of Attica, the territory around Athens” (Athenian Agora Excavations, n.d., first paragraph).
Tyranny
Tyranny may be defined as: “a government in which absolute power is vested in a single ruler” (Merriam Webster, n.d.). The modern connotation of the word tends to involve oppression, but this was not necessarily the case in Ancient Greece – some tyrants were seen as benevolent (Cartwright, 2013).
The fundamental difference between monarchy and tyranny was heredity. Monarchs were rulers by birthright, whereas tyrants assumed power by other means, often including force.
Athenian examples of tyrants included Cylon in the 7th century BC and Peisistratus (Pisistratus) in the 5th (Gill, n.d.). Dionysius I and II in the 4th and 3rd centuries BC were tyrants of Syracuse (Encyclopædia Britannica, …show more content…

Discussion
Some of these forms of governance had common features. For example, bloodline was crucial to monarchy and also to forms of aristocracy and oligarchy in which powerful families ruled. Tyranny and oligarchy both at times featured the forceful usurping of rule.
Some of them also co-existed in that governance embodied elements of more than one form. For example, Sparta had dual monarchs but also a direct democratic Assembly of Spartan citizens whose powers were limited because their agenda was set and decisions subject to veto by executive bodies, the most influential of which (the Gerousia) was populated by senior aristocrats (Brand, n.d.). Similarly, Macedonian governance also featured an Assembly – albeit weak - as well as monarchy. More importantly, the monarchs generally required aristocratic support in order to rule effectively (Martin,

Show More
Related
1072 Words | 5 Pages

In mid-6th c. BCE Athens, just five years after the government of Solon (594), the Athenians found themselves encompassed by dissension and internal disorder. Athens created the first democracy-based government, although their government became more of a republic with democratic attributes. They, the electors, were unable to elect an Archon for five years due to their dissent with the former principles ran by the State. All people within Athens viewed these principles with contempt, those in the elite[upper] class were ‘estranged because of the abolition of debts,’ while the poor people wanted the distribution of all land and property. Both parties were unhappy with the changes made by Solon’s reforms and so many refused to vote for any new

Read More
1120 Words | 5 Pages

Also in both the senate and the aristocracy, only a few are in power in comparison to the house of representatives. In the past the ones who were part of the senate where the rich and the educated just like in Aristocracy, only the rich and educated were allowed to be part of the government. The form of monarchy in our government can be related to the executive branch or the president. A monarchy is a government ruled by a single person. The executive branch is the governing body that makes decisions and enforces the law.

Read More
504 Words | 3 Pages

Unlike the Romans, Athenians had a strict but fair schedule that allowed them to enjoy citizenship equally. Equally, hard workers have brought Athens power just as much as hereditary leaders. According to Document B all citizens should be allowed to speak their opinion and have a share in election because of the hard work they do to make the city powerful. Athenians allowed poor and common men to win a position in government which was a transition from the wealthy having power to everyone having power.

Read More
276 Words | 2 Pages

The Government of Athens wasn’t known to be the best one. Compared to Oligarchy, the Athenian democracy is a poor form of government. Athenian democracy is considered weak and is run by weak-minded people. Mostly lethargic and incompetent people are brought to the power saying that they all have equal rights. It becomes an issue in democracy when we need someone strong willed to lead the rest of the people in the society.

Read More
1489 Words | 6 Pages

Every portion of the government directly represented its people - from the Council of 500 to the Ecclesia and the Court and Jury System - and citizens were payed and thus incentivized to participate in the system. They did their best to make an equitable system with the allocation of members through the 10 tribe system, the potential for scrutinization for any member of the government, and the randomization of jury members for trials. The Greeks were a tier above their Roman counterparts when it came to

Read More
983 Words | 4 Pages

Before in an oligarchy or in a monarchy one person or group made the decisions about everything. This is a very basic similarity though, as the groups in each democracy do completely different things. The current American Democracy split up their responsibilities into three separate branches. These checks and balances are called; judiciary, legislative and executive. The leader of the country or president as we call him is contained in the executive branch.

Read More
1015 Words | 5 Pages

The second generation of citizens tended to be against tyranny as it was considered to jeopardise all of their freedom. Thirdly, tyrants were people who took control without the permission of the city states people and often a tyrant was someone or a group of people that was set up by an outside populous that is trying to control them and how much power they have. Subsequently, Persia was considered to be a tyrant over all the Greek city-states that had been colonised into the Persian Empire, in the early 5th century, as they treated the Greeks like slaves and the Greeks believed in “freedom for all”. Also, the placement of the thirty tyrants, who were more than happy to at least 1500 men, in Athens by Sparta was proven to be a very repressive ruling, specifically designed to keep Athens

Read More
711 Words | 3 Pages

As various studies suggested, ancient Athens pursued permissiveness and democracy, which its form of government was the antecedent of nowadays 'rule by the people '. After toppling the dictator Hippias in 510 BC, Athenian demos not only took power, but also introduced electoral system that "with no single ruler. A public assembly of male citizens met 40 times a year to vote on state decisions. The agenda was set and decrees carried out by a 500 strong council, chosen by lot to serve one year each"(Finley, 1983). In my view, the authority was no longer centralized in the hands of one administrator, more ordinary people got a say in running the

Read More
301 Words | 2 Pages

The dynastic ruler that I will be focusing on is Maximillian I and the family that came from him. It was the beginning of the early modern period that the use of a monarchy had begun to come into practice. There was always

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

Comparing the structures and the backgrounds of ancient Greek political structures many common ways were identified. Cartledge (2011) describes about 1,500 poleis during the fourth century in Greece were different forms of government were practiced. Some poleis practiced the democratic structure; others were oligarchies and some monarchies. All though, had common ground and that was that the richest ruled or influenced the poor majority. The wealthy families ruled in the oligarchies and the monarchies and their children inherited the power and so on.

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

Forms of Government in Ancient Greece Poleis University of The People Greek city-states ruled their populace through different governmental systems. Each polis was unique in its form of government and the latter, the type of the government, had undergone quite a few changes over time. Aristotle categorized types of government in Ancient Greece into monarchies, oligarchies, tyrannies, and democracies(Carr, 2017). Monarchies, a ruling system in which total power rests with one person or a family, were the norm in the early ages of Greek, about 2000 BC and after, which is an era known as the Bronze Age(ContessaD, 2012). This form of government was represented either by kingdoms or empires.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

This means that the country is governed by the same royal family due to their lineage. Monarchy is found throughout Ancient Greece wether it be in Sparta 's two kings, Athens kings, or even in Macedonia with King Phillip II and Alexander the great. Monarchy within the Ancient Greek states was both obsolete and tested. Within the Spartan culture, kings were able to be balanced out by Ephors, which were elite members voted in by Spartan citizens.

Read More
643 Words | 3 Pages

The Greeks displayed their humanistic values through government by they utilizing an effective system of self governing. This system was a direct democracy, defined as “government by the people” or “rule of the majority.” In the Athenian Democracy, the Assembly was the regular

Read More
298 Words | 2 Pages

Democracy, a form of government, allows the people in their own nationality to vote for people in order for them to become representatives as a result to vote on new laws that would affect their own nationality. One of the many states of Greece, ancient Athens was indeed not truly democratic as a result of not inclusive, other than male citizens, to gain authority in ancient Athens, ¨Demokratia was ruled by male citizens only, excluding women, free foreigners(Metics) and slaves.¨(Document D), therefore ruling Athens was only accessible to male citizen since since women, free foreigners(Metics), and slaves were not allowed to rule as a result of not being male citizens. One of the many states of Greece, ancient Athens, was indeed not truly democratic as a result of not even using the essentials of democracy that is used today, “Thus, by our standards, it was oligarchy, not democracy.¨(Document D), therefore ancient Athens was not using democracy as their form of government, they were using oligarchy,another form of government in which a small group of people has power and control, as their form of government instead of democracy.

Read More
1275 Words | 6 Pages

A political regime may also be known as a form of government, a state system, or a political system. The term political regime may also sometimes refer to a specific ruler or set of rulers within a political system. There are many different types of political regimes in the modern world, and many more have existed historically. These range from the directly democratic political regime of anarchism to totalitarian regimes such as Military Dictatorship or

Read More

More about Comparison Of Monarchy And Democracy In Ancient Greece

Related Topics

Open Document