ipl-logo

Animal Welfare Debate

781 Words4 Pages

Animal Welfare means the state of the animal, Animal Rights however is rights believed to belong to animals to live free from use in medical research, hunting, and other services to humans. Many people debate wether or not these two are the same, in the two articles I have read, I was showed the differences and similarities of the two. In the first article I read, “The Farm Animal Welfare Debate” by
F. Bailey Norwood and Jayson L. Lusk, it was stated that many of the livestock industry has tended to focus less on the things that actually happen on the farm and focus more on two red herrings. One of the two red herrings being dismissing animal rights arguments with the fact that their ultimate goal is not to improve animal welfare but to …show more content…

It is argued that the current livestock management is based on science, while the animal advocacy is based on emotion. Many of the industries, like The Untied Egg Produces, (UEP) also argue that they are based on sound sciences while others, like The Humane Society of United States, is not. The UEP is based on information given by an independent scientific committee, this committee recently made many recommendations based on scientific evidence that would improve animal welfare. The Humane Society did many studies proving that the the ideas UEP had were, good but showed no difference in the animals welfare. For example increasing space per hen from 48 to 67 square inches and the elimination of forced molting. It was proven that the animals showed no difference when in a cage barley bigger than their body size, and a cage much …show more content…

There are studies showing that many laboratories in fact do not harm the animals intentionally. It has just been believed for so long many people refuse to see any different. In both of these articles there are many facts about animals. How they live, how they're treated, the rights that they have as animals. Both articles are talking about the same things, animals being safe. Even though they are debating about basically the same thing, there are many differences between animal rights and animal welfare. Animal welfare is a specific animals state of being, the animals safety. Animal rights are the rights of a specific animal. The right that the animal has as a living creature, and the right that animal has to not be used as an experiment, or not to be hunted to its death in its

Show More
Related

Norcross Argument Essay: Don T Eat Factory Farm Animals

654 Words | 3 Pages

The theory or idea that animal has rights comes from the rights that are traditionally moral and politically correct rights is a virtue from the type of culture that we are. Animal liberation comes from the utilitarian tradition that comes from ethics and mortality as coming about as a result of pleasure and/or pain, as someone’s overall well-being. When animals are caged harvest, this diminishes their well-being, which gives us the mortality that we address their decreased well-being and prescribes to us to liberate

Read More

A Student Shany Sun's Argument In Favor Of Animal Testing

1004 Words | 5 Pages

After Sun reassures readers that the animals are completely safe and pain-free, she is able to reinforce how animal testing is beneficial through sound research. “The truth behind animal testing,” explains how specific discoveries such as insulin, blood transfusions, penicillin, so on and so forth have been unearthed because of animal testing. Today, many people can relate to these medical advances because they are so commonly used in hospitals and the medical field. Sun’s research even introduces multiple cases where animal testing was successful. One such case included Charles Chamberland who was able to find a vaccine for both cholera and anthrax through animal experimentation with little harm to the chickens he was testing.

Read More

Jeremy Rifkin A Change Of Heart About Animals

862 Words | 4 Pages

Many Americans blindly believe that animals deserve the same rights as humans, but little do they know about the differences between the welfare of animals and the rights of animals. In the article A Change of Heart about Animals, Jeremy Rifkin cleverly uses certain negative words in order to convince the readers that animals need to be given same rights as humans, and if not more. Research has shown that non-human animals have the ability to “feel pain, suffer and experience stress, affection, excitement and even love” (Rifkin 33). Animals may be able to feel emotions, however this does not necessarily mean that they are able to understand what having rights mean. While humans must accept their moral responsibility to properly care for animals,

Read More

Animal Testing Is Bad Science By Noah Berlatsky

1092 Words | 5 Pages

He also includes in this article that animal tests are unreliable and can be more risky for humans because so many side effects are different between animal and human trials. Towards the end of his article he describes how animals are especially harmful to animals and if there is no physical harm. He wrote, “animals in laboratories typically display behavior indicating extreme psychological distress” (Berlatsky). The results of the distressed animals are inaccurate and can cause more harm to both humans and animals all while not helping further medical

Read More

Tom Regan Animal Rights Analysis

206 Words | 1 Pages

Peter Singer, in his “Equality for Animals” and Tom Regan in his “The Case for Animal Rights,” both form strong arguments on the rights towards animals and the complete elimination on using animals as a means of resources. (Regan, 893) Although both conclude with the fact that animals deserve respect and should not be looked at merely as property, they approach this view differently. The main difference found in their arguments is Regan’s description of inherit value, and Singer’s referral to Utilitarianism. Singer focuses more on the expansion of Utilitarianism claiming that this maximum happiness should include the lives of animals as well.

Read More

Machan's Arguments Against Animal Rights

1408 Words | 6 Pages

One topic that many scholars are debating right now is the topic of animal rights. The questions are, on what basis are rights given, and do animals possess rights? Two prominent scholars, Tom Regan and Tibor Machan, each give compelling arguments about animal rights, Regan for them and Machan against them. Machan makes the sharp statement, “Animals have no rights need no liberation” (Machan, p. 480). This statement was made in direct opposition to Regan who says, “Reason compels us to recognize the equal inherent value of these animals and, with this, their equal right to be treated with respect” (Regan, p. 477).

Read More

Animal Welfare Act Pros And Cons

146 Words | 1 Pages

The Animal Welfare Act of 1966, was signed into law by President Lyndon B. Johnson, and it’s the only Federal law in the United States that regulated treatment and care of animals in research. Animals like rats, mice, birds and other cold-blooded animals are excluded from this law. Dogs, cats, guinea pig, and warm-blooded animals are well protected under this law. Question is why, are the laboratory experiment animals are not protected and treated well. Should we continue experimenting new drug on these animals and make our life easy on their pain or should we for better meant for our society practice and observe new drug on these animals.

Read More

Anti Animal Testing Satire

1277 Words | 6 Pages

Studies show that with all of the animal experimentation that has been done, most of them were inhumane, unreliable and had violated the Animal Welfare Act of 1966. This act ensures that animal care for research is a main priority. It is also required to have appropriate veterinary care, housing, feeding, handling, sanitation, ventilation, and sheltering. For some, animal experimentation is “supposed” to help human beings use certain products for their own benefit. What people do not realize is that these animals have rights and that their rights are being more than violated.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Animal Welfare

920 Words | 4 Pages

The Five Freedoms forms the multidisciplinary tools to measure animal welfare (A.J.F. Webster, 2001). However, the Five Freedoms are not implemented in all

Read More

Hyperbole For Animal Rights

1300 Words | 6 Pages

Animal rights organisations have made animals right a controversial issue rather than a habit that is swept under the rug. The roles of organisations are important because they give voice that there is an issue we either don’t know about or are ignoring. PETA does a great job at stirring controversy and awareness with its risky publicity stunts. To think about this issue in simper terms you can split the fight into two parts. In this case the general public could be viewed as he conformists because they are influenced by media and other propaganda to use animals as products.

Read More

Analysis Of Francione's Argument For Animal Rights

1030 Words | 5 Pages

Furthermore, animals have different demands, wants and needs compared to humans as they are different species that live under different conditions, where humans do not know what the animals want as there is no communication between the animals and humans. Therefore, each species should have a different type of lifestyle and different rights, so the authors argument towards animals and humans having similar rights is irrational. In addition, the authors are against the property of animals by humans yet have six dogs as pets which make them hypocritical since these pets are considered their property. They cannot set an example towards the issue they are discussing, which is the rights of animals not to be property, when they are going against their own argument by having six animals as their

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Animal Welfare

224 Words | 1 Pages

In recent years, there has been a growing awareness and interest about animal welfare in food production. A nationwide Survey had confirmed consumers recognized that farm animals were being treated poorly in factory farms. The majority of the public desired strict laws concerning the treatment of animals to be passed.

Read More

Methylmercury: The Ethics Of Shark Fin Soup

756 Words | 4 Pages

Therefore, rather than basing rights off of those traits make it a vulnerability discourse. There are two main animal equality arguments, Peter Singer’s Utilitarian theory, and Tom Regan’s moral recognition theory. Singer argues, “human preference for humans rests on an unsupportable biological distinction vis-a`-vis all other animals”. While Tom Regan states, “that all beings who are ‘‘subjects-of-a-life” should receive the moral recognition and legal protection that rights afford”. The problem with the

Read More

Animal Bill Of Animal Rights

1023 Words | 5 Pages

Animals are loved one way or another by most human beings. Whether it is loving them because they are a source of food or adoring them because they consider them family. As a result of this, many people start to contradict one another saying animals should not have rights while others say they should. Animal Activists are exacting that animals should have rights that protect them from discrimination, abuse, and neglect that are mostly targeted towards home animals. In the end there is a difference between how you treat a domestic animal and a farm animal.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Animal Testing

1067 Words | 5 Pages

Supporters also claim that animals are treated with the utmost respect. The Animal Welfare Act was a

Read More

More about Animal Welfare Debate

Related Topics

Open Document