ipl-logo

Timothy Evans Arguments Against Capital Punishment

1009 Words5 Pages

One of the most cogent arguments against Capital Punishment is the fact that innocent people have been killed due to flaws in the justice system. Witnesses, prosecutors and jurors can all make mistakes, which could cost an innocent persons life, and these mistakes cannot be put right. In 1979, a total of 69 people have been released from death row in the US after evidence of their innocence had emerged. A historic example of this would be the Timothy Evans case in 1950 which was one of the most dreadful miscarriages of justice ever in the British legal system. Timothy Evans was wrongly convicted with the murder of his wife and daughter, and was therefore executed for a crime he had not committed and was further given a royal pardon in 1966.
An argument against this view would be that Capital Punishment saves more lives than it takes. Recent studies show that for every inmate put to death, 3 to 18 murders are prevented. However if the justice system did not have the death penalty, there would be far higher death rates of innocent people than there are currently.
Personally I think the argument that more lives are saved …show more content…

I don 't think it should be abolished simply because innocent people have been executed. There are many more innocent people that would be killed due to there being no capital punishment. As well as this capital punishment works as a deterrent and makes people think twice about comitting as they are aware of the consequences. A crucial reason why I think capital punishment shouldn 't be abolished is the fact that it leaves the majority of society happy. Some critics of my viewpoint might point out that capital punishment goes against our human rights. However this is a weak argument because if someone takes away someones rights, they should therefore also have their rights removed, as they have violated their victim 's rights and the rights of the family of the

Show More
Related

The Rescue Defence Of Capital Punishment By Steve Aspenson

744 Words | 3 Pages

Capital punishment has long been a heavily debated issue. In his article, “The Rescue Defence of Capital Punishment,” author Steve Aspenson make a moral argument in favor of capital punishment on the grounds that that is the only way to bring about justice and “rescue” murder victims. Aspenson argues as follows: 1. We have a general, prima facie duty to rescue victims from increasing harm. 2.

Read More

Jeffrey Reiman's Arguments Against Capital Punishment

1646 Words | 7 Pages

Support for capital punishment requires valuing retribution over rehabilitation. Those who favor capital punishment value highly the closure it provides to the families of the victims, and they believe that it deters would be murderers from killing. Retribution, closure and deterrence are the main reasons in favor of the death penalty. Opponents of capital punishment generally believe that it is hypocritical and immoral for the state

Read More

Isaiah Mccoy's Argumentative Essay On Death Penalty

756 Words | 4 Pages

Believe it or not, innocent people do end up on death row, even with all the safeguards that are applied. For example, in the CNN article “Death Penalty: Why America needs a rethink,” it mentions a study that showed that “more than 4 percent of inmates sentenced to death in the United States are probably innocent”(Holloway 2). This information goes to show just how weak the United State’s justice system is. Even after 400 years, they still haven't been able to decide whether a human is innocent or guilty. Now, we come to the point that death row isn't the worst thing that could happen to an inmate.

Read More

Mr. Van Den Haag's New Argument Against The Death Penalty

953 Words | 4 Pages

There was a case in 1993, were Westley Allan Dodd, a child rapist and murderer demanded to be killed, hanged publically and the community did what he was asking for. They put a rope around his throat, tied his hands together, and hanged him in front of a crow of cheering people. Later one many experts said that Dodd was a psychopath that wanted to be remember, he manipulated the community to complied his desire. Equally important we have all the cases in which innocent people have been misjudged. It’s horrible that good people had to be in prison, but it’s even worse that this people are sentenced to die.

Read More

Furman Vs Georgia

877 Words | 4 Pages

The Death Penalty: Is it Right? In 1972, the Supreme Court was evaluating a criminal case, Furman v. Georgia. In this case the defendant, William Henry Furman, was burglarizing a house when he was discovered by someone. In attempt to flee, he tripped and accidently set off the gun, killing the person that discovered him.

Read More

Green's Argument In Favor Of The Death Penalty

511 Words | 3 Pages

6 in 10 americans favor the death penalty for convicted murderers. There is no question that killing another person is the most heinous crime that one can commit. Yes, most prisoners convicted in death row are murders but there has been cases where someone innocent has been wrongly executed. For example, of this failure is the case of Roosevelt Green, who was executed in Georgia for the kidnapping and murder of a young woman. According to author David Bruck, "Green swore that his companion shot her . . .

Read More

Essay On Texas Death Penalty

950 Words | 4 Pages

The death penalty should continue to be legal because it is inexpensive. The death penalty makes for a good way for people to get the justice they deserve. In Texas the death penalty being legal makes sure that the people that commit heinous crimes pay. Texas does not suffer from political doubt, and certain cases are a no other answer that the death penalty. It cost the Texas Department of Criminal Justice $83 to execute a prisoner by lethal injection alone.

Read More

The Facts: 13 Reasons To Oppose The Death Penalty

808 Words | 4 Pages

According to the Death Penalty Information Center Website, as of July 1, 2017, there were 2,817 prisoners on Death Row in the United States. Some people believe that the death penalty is a good way to deal with violent criminals who have taken lives. However, others say the death penalty is unnecessary, such as in the article “The Facts: 13 Reasons to Oppose the Death Penalty” and how there is an alternative to help and make those people lives get better. I believe we should get rid of the death penalty because The death penalty puts innocent lives at risk, Race, and place determine who lives and who dies, and No civilians job description should include killing another person.

Read More

Abolitionists Arguments Against The Death Penalty

975 Words | 4 Pages

These mistakes are not repairable as death is final and several cases have been re-examined where DNA that exonerates someone was not involved in court proceedings due to the time-period resulting in the execution of an innocent. They respond with the notion that the death penalty detracts from the sympathy of people for the pain and suffering of the families of the victims of crime and shifts the sympathy to the offender instead. Some human rights groups speak against the execution of an individual on death row gaining that individual a following in the media for sympathy with their impending death for the heinous acts they committed. They say that it is insulting to the victims’ families and makes a mockery of the heinous acts that were committed. Finally, abolitionists contend that capital punishment does not bring the victim back to life.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment

873 Words | 4 Pages

Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is a legal process in which a person is put to death as a punishment for a crime by the government of a nation. The United States is in the minority group of nations that uses the death penalty. There are thirty-three states that allow capital punishment and seventeen states that abolished it (Death Penalty Information Center). The morality of the death penalty has been debated for many years. Some people want capital punishment to be abolished due to how it can cost a lot more than life imprisonment without parole, how they think it is immoral to kill, and how innocent people can be put to death.

Read More

Capital Punishment In The Uk Essay

744 Words | 3 Pages

Although some people might say that Capital Punishment is good for the protection of society, there have been incidents where innocent people have been mistakenly convicted and executed. This proves the point that Capital Punishment is an inhumane and barbaric process that can still be unsafe. Since the reinstatement of the Death Penalty, more than 150 men and women have been released nationally, meaning that there are big chances that uninvolved suspects of various crimes can be wrongly killed due to the fact that the police can have wrong judgements. In July 1998 Derek William Bentley had been granted a pardon after have being put to death. He was hanged at the age of 19 (had the mental age of 11) for a murder committed by a 16 year old friend, Christopher Craig.

Read More

Why Is Capital Punishment Controversial

873 Words | 4 Pages

In addition, anyone who kills deserves to die too so as to have a test of their own cruelty. Moreover, they argue that, capital punishment will help to get rid of repeat murders and also to prevent foreseeable killings or massacre. However, there are many studies done on capital punishment, and none has proven with numbers that executing criminals helps deter crimes (Garland 134). Furthermore there is no justification at all, as to why a crime should be paid with another crime. The main purpose of a punishment is to change the criminals, but capital punishment does not do that.

Read More

Essay On Political Ideologies

1364 Words | 6 Pages

I agree that the death penalty is inhumane and should be abolished; no one deserves to be killed, even those who have killed. However, I also feel that the death penalty solves nothing because all the government or state does is end the person’s life. This means they don’t get to learn from what they have done; they don’t receive punishment. It is better that the prisoner be sentenced to life so that they could ‘feel’ dead, but still have to live in a confined space for the rest of their lives, thinking about what got them there in the first place. That to me, is a real death penalty.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Death Penalty In The United States

1227 Words | 5 Pages

There is a lot of emotion that comes with the death penalty. But when emotion is not involved there is only one way it should be handled United States being one of the more advanced countries, why do we still practice capital punishment? Some people say it is the best option to get those criminals off the streets to prevent them from harming others. The death penalty should be outlawed because innocent people could be put to death, it does not deter crime,

Read More

Should Death Penalty Be Abolished?

1320 Words | 6 Pages

The major reason why the death penalty should be abolished is that the cost of the death penalty is too much and the USA is in debt to many other countries. What this means is that the death penalty should be abolished and also the cost death penalty is more than the cost of maximum sentence life in prison. According to J. Marceau and H. Whitson, “The Cost of Colorado’s Death penalty,” 3 Univ. of Denver Criminal Law Review “A new study of the cost of the death penalty in Colorado revealed that capital proceedings require six times more days in court and

Read More

More about Timothy Evans Arguments Against Capital Punishment

Related Topics

Open Document