ipl-logo

Arguments Against Jury Nullification

631 Words3 Pages

Jury nullification is a finding by a trial jury in contradiction to the jury's belief about the facts of the case, which occurs during a trial when jurors acquit a defendant, even though the jurors may believe the defendant to be guilty of the charges. (Legal IQ, 2017) Jurors have an obligation to follow the law, as interpreted by the trial judge when rendering a verdict; therefore, judges instruct jurors in this obligation. (Hall, 2014) However, “a defendant has no right to insist that a jury is instructed that it has the authority to nullify the law” (Hall, 2014, p. 577). A jury nullification takes place when a jury decides on a verdict of “not guilty” even if they believe that the defendant is guilty of the charge. (Find Law, 2017) Jury nullification happens civilly and criminally; therefore, in a criminal trial, a jury nullifies by acquitting a defendant, even though jurors may believe that the defendant committed the offense; nevertheless, they do not believe he or she shall be punished for the crime. Jurisdictions with double jeopardy rules convictions can be overturned on appeal; however, an acquittal cannot be overturned. (Legal IQ, 2017)

According to the U.S. Supreme Court, a jury nullification is legal whether or not juries need to be instructed on this right is a different matter. (Find Law, 2017) …show more content…

Jury Nullification Arguments by Criminal Defense Counsel. Retrieved November 8, 2017, from https://www.dcbar.org/bar-resources/legal-ethics/opinions/opinion320.cfm

Find Law (2017). Jury Nullification. Retrieved November 8, 2017, from http://criminal.findlaw.com/criminal-procedure/jury-nullification.html

Hall, D. E. (2014). Criminal Law and Procedure, 7th Edition: Cengage Learning. p. 577. Retrieved November 8, 2017, from https://www.betheluniversityonline.net/cps/default.aspx?SectionID=5980&tabid=

Legal IQ (2017). What is Jury Nullification? Retrieved November 8, 2017, from

Show More
Related

Examples Of Westlaw Research Authority

363 Words | 2 Pages

Prosecutorial misconduct (Westlaw Research Skills Three). iii. Legal issue: Is the prosecutor able to use improper comments that can sway the court against the person on trial? (Westlaw Research Skills Three). iv.

Read More

Jury System DBQ Essay

515 Words | 3 Pages

Jurors should not know anything about a specific case and not follow public affairs and read the news (Doc F). When a person is selected to be part of a jury, they have to say an oath stating that they will not use their emotions to determine the verdict of a trial. If a juror is caught using their emotions, they will be fined for a crime called perjury. Since there are twelve people in a jury, there is a variation of opinions when the jury decides a verdict. But, a judge is more professional and knows how to only use the evidence provided and be less biased.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Horney's Trial

591 Words | 3 Pages

Ironically that's all they argued, they didn’t bother to use the 8th amendment as a defense. The benefits of being able to nullify a verdict as a jury is being able to provide a different socio-economic perspective. A judge works with crime everyday, most likely not living in the ghetto where some jurors may live. Juror’s with different perspectives of a crime can cause more linancy and sympathy towards a defendant.

Read More

Hurst's Sixth Amendment Essay

1820 Words | 8 Pages

Our rejection of simple-majority jury decisions, I believe, was deeply-rooted. In the 1700’s, Sir William Blackstone made his opinion clear that a jury trial was the most “transcendent privilege” any person can hope for. 3 Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England 379 (1768). That no state can take away your property or liberty without the “unanimous consent of twelve of his neighbors and equals,” was a great comfort to Blackstone, as it should be to all of us. Id. John Adams believed that a unanimous jury is the thing that “preserves the rights of mankind.”

Read More

Judge Dbq Essay

776 Words | 4 Pages

A jury is not trained to decide someone’s fate, which is why a judge, as a trained lawyer, should choose the

Read More

Jury Duty Dbq Essay

1285 Words | 6 Pages

Like the Electoral College, several of the plans made by the Founding Fathers have lost some of their practicality. What worked in the past does not always work in the future, and this is the case for the jury system. The sole reason it was created was to ensure that each citizen was guaranteed a fair trial, which was a main concern due to Britain’s monarchy. In modern times, however, the judicial branch of the United States could easily give every citizen a fair trial with only a judge presiding over the case. It is clear that bench trials are superior to trials by jury because the citizens on juries are unqualified or biased, its benefits do not outweigh its burdens, and its claim to encourage civic duty is false.

Read More

Jury System Dbq

842 Words | 4 Pages

Another reason citizens question juries is that they have bias from personal experience or the media. The defendant and the prosecution criticize the jury system because the actual jurors may not understand the situation from any point of view because they come from different lifestyles (Doc E). The American jury system is not a good idea anymore because juries are not experts in law, they have bias, and are not “a jury of peers”. Because jurors are not experts in law, they are subject to be

Read More

Arguments Against Majority Verdicts

1037 Words | 5 Pages

“Other arguments against majority verdicts include that they compromise the criminal standard of proof of "beyond a reasonable doubt", given that at least one juror has a doubt; create a greater risk of convicting the innocent, leading to miscarriages of justice; and reduce public confidence in jury verdicts” (SMH 2005). However, a number of positives that occur after and during the trial largely outweigh the few issues that arise. There are far less hung juries. More than 80 cases resulted in hung juries during 2005. Majority verdicts as opposed to unanimous verdicts to better keep the integrity of the trial by helping prevent juror bribery or intimidation; it may also help stop rogue or stealth jurors (LY Lawyers 2017).

Read More

Essay On 7th Amendment

867 Words | 4 Pages

The clear distinction between a jury and a judge is among the key specifications of the seventh amendment. This distinction in the law is termed as functions. According to the amendment, the judge is designated to try the law whereas the jury can try according to facts. This distinguishing between the law and fact is important as it gives the legitimacy to the decree of juries. At the same time, the amendment prevents from violation of the justified legal anticipations of the

Read More

12 Angry Men Rhetorical Analysis

1186 Words | 5 Pages

Twelve Angry Men is in many ways a love letter to the American legal justice system. We find here eleven men, swayed to conclusions by prejudices, past experience, and short-sightedness, challenged by one man who holds himself and his peers to a higher standard of justice, demanding that this marginalized member of society be given his due process. We see the jurors struggle between the two, seemingly conflicting, purposes of a jury, to punish the guilty and to protect the innocent. It proves, however, that the logic of the American trial-by-jury system does work.

Read More

Should Citizens Be Required To Serve On A Juror Essay

647 Words | 3 Pages

However they are wrong because some people will not take it serious as it need to be. Citizens should not be required to serve on jury because bias jurors. For example, in the play “Twelve Angry Men” during the deliberation of the verdict some of the jurors showed bias toward the young man on trial because of where he was from. “We 're not here to go into the reasons why slums are

Read More

Examples Of Jury Nullification

457 Words | 2 Pages

Jury nullification occurs when a jury returns a verdict of "Not Guilty" despite its belief that the defendant is guilty of the violation charged, according to Doug Linder. The jury will nullify a law because it believes that it wrongly applies to the particular defendant. Is this right or wrong? Should a jury have the right to override the law? Juries have the power to nullify a law, but do they have the right to?

Read More

Arguments Against Jury Nullification

656 Words | 3 Pages

Police officers, too, “take into consideration factors such as whether” the behavior of the accused “was merely a technical violation or whether other circumstances not formally recognized by the law justified or excused a defendant’s actions.” When police officers so use their judgement to apply and interpret the law, it is not considered anarchy or lead “to the end of the rule of law.” When prosecutors consider factors that are not relevant to a strict application of the law to decide whether or not to file charges, they are using their judgement. This happens almost every day, and this has not led to the end of governmental power. Thus, jury nullification has an inherent purpose: “to weed out inappropriate prosecutions where police and prosecutors failed to do

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Jury Duty

577 Words | 3 Pages

I think that I would like to be on a jury and experience what is required of a juror, I think everyone should be a member of the jury at least once in their lifetime. Having to experience the juries’ duties on a civil or criminal case, in some instance would be hard. Especially in a murder case involving children or battered women. When the judge gives you direction to please disregard that statement. How can you disregard information that you have heard?

Read More

Trial By Jury Advantages And Disadvantages

1472 Words | 6 Pages

Moreover, the ability to make objective judgments could be enhanced, for instance by questioning witnesses (Joyce, 2013). In conclusion, the judge should be able to overturn acquittal when jury nullifies, in order to ensure that the innocent is not convicted and the guilty is not acquitted (Hostettler,

Read More

More about Arguments Against Jury Nullification

Related Topics

Open Document